W. Neudorff GmbH KG v Colin Leslie Young

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

ABSTRACT OF DECISION

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Application  :          No. 689399 in the name of Colin Leslie Young

Title:          Stomach-action molluscicides

Action:          Opposition by W.Neudorff GmbH KG to amendments under section 104, and the final determination of an opposition under section 59

Decision:          Issued  02 May 2005.

Abstract

The amendments are allowable.

The amendments do not overcome the deficiencies noted in the original opposition.  Claims still lack novelty and inventive step.

The applicant given a further opportunity to propose amendments.

PATENTS ACT 1990

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Re:Patent Application No. 689399 by Colin Leslie Young, and opposition by W.Neudorff GmbH KG to amendments under section 104, and an opposition under section 59

BACKGROUND

  1. Patent application number 689399 in the name of Colin Leslie Young was opposed by W.Neudorff GmbH KG and Arthur Yates & Co Ltd. I issued a decision in the opposition on 23 November 2001 (see [2001] APO 68), finding that the opposition succeeded on the grounds of novelty, inventive step and section 40. I allowed Professor Young 8 weeks to propose amendments to overcome these deficiencies.

  2. Amendment of the specification was opposed by Neudorff.  Evidence in relation to that opposition has been served.  During the evidence stages, Professor Young proposed further amendment to the specification.  The Commissioner directed that the opposition and all evidence filed was to be treated as an opposition to the later amendment without the need to file separate documentation.

  3. The present matter is an opposition to both requests to amend.  The matter was heard in Canberra on 3 February 2005.  A final determination of the original opposition was also heard at the same time.  Professor Young did not attend the hearing.  Neudorff was represented by Mr Ray Evans, patent attorney of Phillips Ormonde & Fitzpatrick.  Dr George Puritch attended the hearing.

    THE SPECIFICATION

  4. The specification relates to compositions for controlling molluscs, particularly slugs and snails.  The invention is said to relate to the use of a metal chelate, in which the chelating ligand is a complexone.  These compounds are stated to act as stomach-action poisons.  The preferred metal is iron, and the preferred forms of the complexone include EDTA.  The prime focus of the specification is the compound Fe(III)EDTA.

  5. The specification as accepted has two independent claims:

    1.  A stomach-action molluscicide including a metal complexone and a suitable non-liquid carrier therefor, wherein the molluscicide has a pH above about 7.

    26.  A metal complexone when used as a stomach-action molluscicide, wherein the pH of the molluscicide is above about 7.

    The amendments

  6. The specification following the first amendment also has two independent claims:

    1.  A stomach-action molluscicide including a metal complexone and a suitable non-liquid carrier therefore, wherein the molluscicide has a pH above about 7, with the proviso that when the metal complexone is only [FeEDTA]-Na+, bone meal is not present in an amount of 84.4% by weight or greater of the dry components of the molluscicide.

    26.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read W. Neudorff GmbH KG v Colin Leslie Young and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] APO 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of patent application number 689399, the applicant Colin Leslie Young sought protection for compositions designed to control molluscs, specifically slugs and snails, using stomach-action molluscicides. W. Neudorff GmbH KG, opposed these amendments, arguing that they failed to address the deficiencies identified in the original opposition. The opposition also extended to the final determination of the original opposition.

The key legal issues centred on whether the proposed amendments were allowable under the relevant provisions of the Patents Act 1990, and whether these amendments successfully overcame the objections regarding novelty, inventive step, clarity, and fair basis. Specifically, Neudorff argued that the amendments claimed matter not in substance disclosed, failed to fall within the scope of the original claims, lacked clarity, and did not provide a fair basis for the claims.

The court found that the amendments were allowable as they did not claim any new matter not in substance disclosed in the original specification. The insertion of a method for determining the pH of the molluscicidal compositions addressed the concerns regarding clarity and fair basis. However, the amendments did not overcome the deficiencies regarding novelty and inventive step. The court determined that the proviso inserted into the claims did not sufficiently exclude the prior art, as the Puritch patent still disclosed compositions that fell within the scope of the amended claims. The court also found that the inventive step issue remained unresolved, as the amended claims still included compositions that were obvious in light of the prior art.

As a result, the court allowed the applicant a further opportunity to propose amendments to overcome the remaining deficiencies. The court emphasised the importance of resolving these issues to avoid protracted proceedings and to ensure the expeditious resolution of the application's status. Costs were awarded to Neudorff in relation to the final determination, but not for the opposition to the amendments.

In conclusion, while the amendments were found allowable, they did not resolve the underlying issues of novelty and inventive step. The applicant was granted a final opportunity to address these issues, with a clear directive to resolve them to prevent further delays.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established