Vringo Infrastructure Inc v ZTE (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Vringo Infrastructure Inc v ZTE (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 3) [2014] FCA 983

Citation: Vringo Infrastructure Inc v ZTE (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 3) [2014] FCA 983
Parties: VRINGO INFRASTRUCTURE, INC. v ZTE (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD (ACN 110 578 428)
File number(s): NSD 1010 of 2013
Judge(s): YATES J
Date of judgment: 1 September 2014
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – confidentiality regime between the parties – application to extend confidentiality regime to include in-house counsel – whether confidentiality regime should be extended – factors relevant to whether persons should be included in confidentiality regime – balance between risk of inadvertent or accidental disclosure and need for ability to seek appropriate advice and provide informed instructions.
Cases cited: AstraZeneca AB v Medis Pharma Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 549
Date of hearing: 1 September 2014
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 26
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms C L Cochrane
Solicitor for the Applicant: Allens Linklaters
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr N R Murray
Solicitor for the Respondent: Davies Collison Cave Law

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1010 of 2013

BETWEEN:

VRINGO INFRASTRUCTURE, INC.
Applicant

AND:

ZTE (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD (ACN 110 578 428)
Respondent

JUDGE:

YATES J

DATE OF ORDER:

1 SEPTEMBER 2014

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Nothing in this Order will operate as a waiver of any right of a party to this Proceeding (Party) pursuant to statute or any regulation (including any right under the rules of this Court) or the common law, including without limitation any claim of privilege.

Suppression and Non-Publication Order

2.Pursuant to section 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), and on the basis that this Order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, this Order applies to any document:

(a)disclosed by or on behalf of a Party (Discloser) to another Party (Disclosee), or a person who receives the document on behalf of the Disclosee, in relation to this Proceeding, and

(b)which the Court has ordered, on the application of the Discloser, is subject to this Order,

until further Order.

Interim Suppression and Non-Publication Order

3.Pursuant to section 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), and on the basis that this Order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, this Order applies to any document:

(a)   disclosed by or on behalf of the Discloser, and

(b)   which the Parties have agreed in writing is confidential and subject to this Order,

until such time as a Party seeks in the Proceeding to tender or read the document or otherwise rely in Court upon the contents thereof or information contained therein or information derived or notes taken or reports or other documents generated therefrom, including copies of such documents, at which time the Discloser must satisfy the Court that an order in accordance with paragraph 2 of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vringo Infrastructure Inc v ZTE (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 983
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Vringo Infrastructure Inc v ZTE (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 3) involved a dispute regarding the extension of a confidentiality regime between the parties to include an in-house counsel, Jason Charkow. The applicant, Vringo Infrastructure Inc, sued the respondent, ZTE (Australia) Pty Ltd, for alleged infringement of certain patent claims. The court had to determine whether Mr Charkow should be included in the confidentiality regime that had been agreed upon by the parties, which prescribed in detail how confidential documents and information were to be treated by the parties and those to whom access was permitted.

The court found that Mr Charkow was an experienced litigator who had previously participated in such confidentiality regimes and there was no reason to doubt that he would be acutely aware of the obligations placed on recipients of protected information. The court further found that Mr Charkow's exclusion from the confidentiality regime would result in significant prejudice to the applicant, without any real corresponding benefit to the respondent so far as concerns the protection of confidential information.

The court ordered that Mr Charkow be included as a permitted recipient of documents and information within the confidentiality regime. The order included provisions for the handling, keeping, and storage of the confidential material, as well as the obligations of the parties to maintain the confidentiality of the material. The order also included provisions for the retrieval and deletion of the confidential material after the final determination of the proceeding.

This case highlights the importance of carefully considering the inclusion of in-house counsel in a confidentiality regime and the balance between the risk of inadvertent disclosure and the need for the ability to seek appropriate advice and provide informed instructions.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Nothing in this Order will operate as a waiver of any right of a party to this Proceeding (Party) pursuant to statute or any regulation (including any right under the rules of this Court) or the common law, including without limitation any claim of privilege.

Suppression and Non-Publication Order

2. Pursuant to section 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), and on the basis that this Order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, this Order applies to any document:

(a) disclosed by or on behalf of a Party (Discloser) to another Party (Disclosee), or a person who receives the document on behalf of the Disclosee, in relation to this Proceeding, and

(b) which the Court has ordered, on the application of the Discloser, is subject to this Order,

until further Order.

Interim Suppression and Non-Publication Order

3. Pursuant to section 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), and on the basis that this Order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, this Order applies to any document:

(a) disclosed by or on behalf of the Discloser, and

(b) which the Parties have agreed in writing is confidential and subject to this Order,

until such time as a Party seeks in the Proceeding to tender or read the document or otherwise rely in Court upon the contents thereof or information contained therein or information derived or notes taken or reports or other documents generated therefrom, including copies of such documents, at which time the Discloser must satisfy the Court that an order in accordance with paragraph 2 of this Order should be made in relation to the document.

4. In this Order, a document that falls within paragraphs 2 or 3 will be referred to as a Discloser Confidential Document.

Discloser Confidential Material

5. Each Discloser Confidential Document, the contents thereof and information contained therein or information derived or notes taken or reports or other documents generated therefrom, including copies of such documents as may be made by the persons referred to below (Discloser Confidential Information) will be confidential in this Proceeding, and they and all and any information contained in them:

(a) may only be disclosed to:

(i) external solicitors and patent attorneys for the Disclosee;

(ii) external counsel for the Disclosee;

(iii) paralegals, litigation support personnel, computer services personnel, secretarial staff and other administrative staff employed or engaged by those persons named in sub-paragraphs 3(a)(i) - (ii) (inclusive);

(iv) subject further to paragraph 8 of this Order, in relation to any Discloser Confidential Document where the Applicant is the Disclosee:

A. Mr Jason Charkow, Senior Intellectual Property Counsel; and

B. Dr Saswat Misra, Intellectual Property Counsel,

(Disclosee Representatives);

(i) subject further to paragraph 8 of this Order, any independent expert nominated on behalf of the Disclosee (Disclosee Expert);

(ii) subject further to paragraph 7 of this Order, employees of third party legal process outsourcing providers retained by or on behalf of the Disclosee in relation to this Proceeding (Disclosee LPOs); and

(iii) such other persons as to whom the Discloser consents in writing (provided that the Discloser must not unreasonably withhold consent) or the Court may order,

(collectively, Disclosee Disclosure Persons);

(b) will not be open to public inspection, disclosed in open Court or, subject to paragraphs 13 and 14 of this Order, disclosed in the open part of any Court transcript; and

(c) may be used only for the purposes of this Proceeding.

6. External solicitors for the Disclosee and any Disclosee Expert to whom any Discloser Confidential Documents or Discloser Confidential Information (hereafter, collectively referred to as Discloser Confidential Material) is disclosed under this Order will be bound by this Order.

7. Discloser Confidential Material may only be disclosed to Disclosee LPOs where such persons and their employer have, prior to disclosure, each signed a confidentiality undertaking to maintain the confidentiality of the Discloser Confidential Material in the form set out in the Schedule to this Order (Confidentiality Undertaking). The Disclosee will at all times be responsible for ensuring the confidentiality of any Discloser Confidential Material disclosed to Disclosee LPOs.

8. Discloser Confidential Material may only be disclosed to Disclosee Representatives or Disclosee Experts where such persons have, prior to disclosure, each signed a Confidentiality Undertaking.

9. Discloser Confidential Material will be used, handled, kept and stored by the Disclosee Disclosure Persons subject to the following directions:

(a) Discloser Confidential Material will be used, handled, kept and stored in such a manner as will at all times preserve its confidentiality;

(b) no copies of Discloser Confidential Material will be made by any Disclosee Disclosure Persons except as may be reasonably required for the purpose of this Proceeding;

(c) subject to sub‑paragraph (b) above, any copies of Discloser Confidential Material made by or on behalf of any of the Disclosee Disclosure Persons will be subject to the provisions of this Order relating to Discloser Confidential Material (as if such copies were Discloser Confidential Material); and

(d) no Discloser Confidential Material will, without the prior written consent of the Discloser, be disclosed to or inspected by any persons other than the Disclosee Disclosure Persons.

Confidentiality - General

10. No affidavit filed in this Proceeding by or on behalf of the Disclosee, may contain any Discloser Confidential Material, save in an annexure to such an affidavit marked ‘Confidential’ and such annexures will be confidential to the relevant parties, and will not be used, inspected or disclosed except as provided in this Order.

11. No written submissions filed in this Proceeding by or on behalf of the Disclosee, may contain any Discloser Confidential Material, save in an annexure to such submissions marked ‘Confidential’ and such annexures will be confidential to the relevant parties, and will not be used, inspected or disclosed except as provided in this Order.

12. Nothing in this Order will prevent disclosure of any Discloser Confidential Material to:

(a) any judge, employee or other personnel of this Court; or

(b) any person associated with recording transcript at any hearing in this Proceeding,

for the purposes of this Proceeding.

13. Nothing in this Order will prevent the Disclosee from disclosing Discloser Confidential Material at any interlocutory or final hearing in this Proceeding, provided that any oral disclosure is made in closed Court.

14. Where Discloser Confidential Material is orally disclosed in any interlocutory or final hearing in this Proceeding, the transcript of that portion of the hearing will be confidential, with access thereto limited to the persons who have liberty to view such material under this Order.

15. Subject to paragraphs 16 and 17 of this Order, within 28 days after the final determination of this Proceeding, or any appeal therefrom or on the expiry of any applicable appeal period (whichever is the later) (Final Determination) the Disclosee's solicitors will take all necessary steps to retrieve from any Disclosee Expert, Disclosee Representatives and Disclosee Service Provider, in the case of Discloser Confidential Material all Confidential Material disclosed to or in the possession, custody or control of such persons.

16. Within 28 days of Final Determination the Disclosee's solicitors will take all necessary steps to ensure that any Disclosee Expert or Disclosee Service Provider has permanently deleted all Discloser Confidential Material which has been stored electronically by such persons.

17. Within 45 days of Final Determination the Disclosee's solicitors will certify to the Discloser's solicitors that they have carried out the steps set out in paragraphs 12 and 13.

18. Subject to paragraph 1, nothing in this Order will prevent disclosure of any Confidential Material beyond the terms of this Order if the Discloser consents in writing to such disclosure, or if the Court orders such disclosure.

19. Subject to paragraph 1, no obligation of confidentiality shall exist, or continue to exist as the case may be, in respect of any material that:

(a) becomes publicly available or public knowledge otherwise than through the default of any person under an obligation of confidence;

(b) appears in any patent or other printed and published document otherwise than through the default of any person under an obligation of confidence;

(c) is subsequently received from a third party not under any obligation of confidentiality;

(d) the parties to this Proceeding agree, or the Court determines, is public knowledge; or

(e) in relation to which, the Discloser has, by notice in writing, notified the Disclosee that the relevant material is no longer subject to these Orders.

20. No admission

Subject to paragraphs 2, 3 and 19, a designation of, or failure to designate, material as Discloser Confidential Material, or its treatment in conformity with, or failure to treat in conformity with, such designation, will not be construed as an admission or agreement by any Party that the designated material does or does not constitute or contain any Discloser Confidential Material.

21. The provisions of this Order will continue after the final determination of this Proceeding and this Court will retain jurisdiction to deal with any issues relating to this Order including without limitation, its enforcement.

22. There will be liberty to apply on 3 days’ written notice.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Save for one matter, the parties have reached agreement on the form of order that should be made with respect to the preservation of the confidentiality of information that will be disclosed compulsorily or advanced as evidence in the proceeding. The matter in dispute is whether one of the applicant’s employees, Jason Charkow, should be a recipient of documents and information to be disclosed by the respondent as part of the confidentiality regime that has been otherwise agreed.Background There is no dispute between the parties concerning the relevant facts. The facts are disclosed in correspondence between the parties on this question. The correspondence was tendered by the applicant without objection. The applicant sues the respondent for alleged infringement of certain claims of Patent No. 2005212893 and certain claims of Patent No. 773182. The preparation of the applicant’s case will involve a consideration of confidential technical information relevant to the accused products supplied by the respondent. A certain part of that information is held by the respondent and is required to be disclosed under orders for discovery that were made after a contested interlocutory hearing on 25 February 2014. I have been informed that the discovery that has been ordered includes some 300 primary technical documents emanating from the respondent. These documents will be included in the confidentiality regime that has been agreed between the parties. The agreed confidentiality regime is complex. It prescribes in considerable detail how a document defined as a Discloser Confidential Document and derivative matter defined as Discloser Confidential Information are to be treated by the parties and those to whom access is permitted, as well as how this material is to be used by the parties in the proceeding. The regime includes the giving of a written undertaking to the Court by those having access to the material as recipients. The undertaking includes an obligation to keep the material confidential, subject to limited disclosure to certain persons on certain conditions. The undertaking includes an obligation not to copy the material except to the extent reasonably required for the purposes of the proceeding. This is part of a more generally expressed obligation to use the material only for the purpose of the proceeding. The undertaking includes obligations to deliver up the material or delete it, when stored in electronic form, at the conclusion of the hearing. Other limitations and obligations will be apparent from the form of the general order and attached form of undertaking that prefaces these reasons. As I have noted, Mr Charkow is an employee of the applicant. He holds the position of Senior Intellectual Property Counsel. Mr Charkow is a member of the New York Bar. He was admitted to practice in 2002. Prior to joining the applicant, Mr Charkow was in private practice with two large firms operating internationally. He is an experienced litigator and has been included in numerous confidentiality regimes in proceedings conducted in the United States of America. The parties are also engaged in a parallel patent infringement proceeding in the United Kingdom. Mr Charkow is included in the confidentiality regime in force in that proceeding. It has not been suggested that Mr Charkow has not complied with the obligations of confidentiality imposed on him in either that proceeding or the other proceedings to which I have referred.The competing positions

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondent submitted that the non-inclusion of Mr Charkow in the confidentiality regime would not prohibit Dr Misra communicating with Mr Charkow on technical matters that are already public knowledge. In this connection, the respondent referred to the fact that the applicant had already formed the view that the accused products infringe certain claims of the respective patents and that, based on his own analysis of the technical information in the discovered documents, Dr Misra would be able to confirm or correct that view in communications with Mr Charkow, without disclosing the confidential technical information itself.Consideration I am not persuaded that the inclusion of Mr Charkow as a permitted recipient of documents and information within the confidentiality regime will lead to any significantly increased risk of inadvertent disclosure of confidential information. The confidentiality regime is very prescriptive. There is no dispute about the fact that Mr Charkow is an experienced litigator who has previously participated in such regimes. There is no reason to doubt that, as an experienced litigator, Mr Charkow will be acutely aware of the particular requirements that the regime places on recipients of protected information. There is no reason to doubt that Mr Charkow will be also acutely aware that information emanating from the respondent as a result of its disclosure obligations in this proceeding, can only be used for the purpose of this proceeding. I have no reason to doubt that Mr Charkow will bring that awareness to bear when dealing with information – and, in particular, the respondent’s confidential technical information – received pursuant to the regime. His training and practical experience as a lawyer will equip him to do so. It is not suggested that Mr Charkow has any involvement in the commercial or technical aspects of the applicant’s business, beyond his role as legal adviser on intellectual property matters. He does, however, have primary responsibility for the day-to-day conduct of this proceeding on behalf of the applicant. I am persuaded that, in undertaking that role, it is highly likely that he will not be in a position to seek appropriate advice or provide informed instructions unless he has appropriate access to such technical information as he might require, including from the respondent’s discovered documents, as well as the freedom to discuss such information with Dr Misra and the applicant’s external advisers. I do not accept that his role can be adequately performed in the way suggested by the respondent, with Mr Charkow simply being the recipient of publicly-known information or the beneficiary of conclusions reached by Dr Misra. In my view, the exclusion of Mr Charkow from more informed knowledge would be an unwarranted fetter on the applicant’s ability to conduct this proceeding. This exclusion would result in significant prejudice to the applicant, without any real corresponding benefit to the respondent so far as concerns the protection of confidential information, bearing in mind the strict limitations placed upon the recipients of documents and information by the confidentiality regime itself.