VQLM and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

VQLM and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2018] AATA 3540 (5 September 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/0895

Re:VQLM   

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member C Edwardes

Date:                     5 September 2018

Place:Perth

The decision under review is affirmed.

.............[sgd]...........................................................

Member C Edwardes

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP – whether applicant of good character – meaning of good character – criminal behaviour – serious offences – applicant’s evidence not credible - character references not reliable – no independent evidence to test the veracity of claims in character references - applicant found not to be of good character at time of application for citizenship – decision under review is affirmed

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) – s 21(1) – s 21(2) – s21(2)(h) – s 24(1), s 24(1A), s 52(1)(b)
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) –– s 43(1)(a)

CASES

Ahori and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] AATA 601
Irving v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1996) 139 ALR 84
Kakar v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2002] AATA 132
Karatunov and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2017] AATA 132
Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
XFKR and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2017] AATA 2385

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Department of Immigration and Border Protection, Citizenship Policy, at 1 June 2016, Chapter 11

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member C Edwardes

5 September 2018

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application for the review of a decision made on 6 February 2018 (PT2 5-15)(R1) to refuse the Applicant’s application for Australian citizenship under section 24(1) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) (the Citizenship Act). The decision to refuse the Applicant’s citizenship application was made on the basis that the Applicant was not of good character at the time of the Minister’s decision.

  2. The Application for review is made in accordance with section 52(1)(b) of the Citizenship Act, which allows applications to be made to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) for review of a decision made under section 24 of the Citizenship Act.

    BACKGROUND

  3. The Applicant is a 31 year old citizen of Sri Lanka who arrived in Australia on 2 November 2006 as the holder of a Temporary Tourist visa subclass TR 676 visa.

  4. On 31 January 2007 he was granted permanent residency as a holder of a Protection visa subclass XA866.  On 10 September 2012 the Applicant applied for Australian citizenship.

  5. This application was rejected on the 11 December 2012 as a result of the Applicant having pending criminal charges.

  6. The Applicant made another application for citizenship on the 17 November 2015.

  7. On 6 February 2018 the Minister’s delegate refused this application and stated:

    Your Police Check Results Report indicates that you have been convicted of the following offences:

·           19/12/2013

Perth District Court

Grievous Bodily Harm

(Suspended Imprisonment Order - 18 Months Concurrent, Suspended 18 Months from 19/12/2013)

·           19/12/2013

Perth District Court

Unlawful Wounding

(Suspended Imprisonment Order -…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read VQLM and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 3540
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) reviewed a decision by the Minister for Home Affairs to refuse citizenship to the applicant, VQLM. The central dispute concerned whether the applicant was of "good character" as required by section 21(2)(h) of the *Citizenship Act 1948* (Cth) at the time of his application. The applicant presented character references, but the Tribunal also considered his criminal history, including convictions for destroying property, grievous bodily harm, and unlawful wounding.

The Tribunal was required to determine if the applicant met the good character requirement for citizenship, specifically assessing the weight of his criminal convictions against the character references provided. The legal issue revolved around the interpretation and application of the "good character" criterion in the context of past serious criminal behaviour and the applicant's own characterisation of his actions.

The Tribunal reasoned that the applicant's criminal convictions, particularly those for grievous bodily harm and unlawful wounding arising from an unprovoked attack, were extremely serious. It found that the applicant's attempts to downplay the severity of these offences in his submissions indicated a lack of genuine remorse, which is a key component of good character. Furthermore, the Tribunal considered that insufficient time had passed since the applicant's offending for him to demonstrate enduring moral qualities. The Tribunal also viewed the conviction for destroying property in a domestic context as serious, noting the government's strong stance against domestic violence. Ultimately, the Tribunal concluded that the applicant's past behaviour demonstrated a disregard for the law and a propensity for violence, and therefore he failed to meet the good character test.

The Tribunal affirmed the Minister's decision to refuse citizenship.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issue for review by this Tribunal is whether the Applicant was, as of the 6 February 2018, a good character for the purpose of satisfying section 21(2)(h) of the Citizenship Act. EVIDENCE The matter was heard in Perth on 17 August 2018. The Applicant appeared in person. An interpreter was present to assist the Applicant. The Respondent was represented by Mr Burgess of Sparke Helmore. The Tribunal received the following evidence:·Exhibit A1 – Applicant’s submissions dated 20 June 2018.·Exhibit A2 – Character reference dated 19 June 2018.·Exhibit A3 – Character reference dated 20 June 2018.·Exhibit A4 – Character reference (undated)·Exhibit A5 – Character reference dated 17 April 2018.·Exhibit A6 – Untitled Photo·Exhibit R1 – T documents (T1-T14 pp 1-140).·Exhibit R2 – Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SOFIC) dated 27 July 2018.·Exhibit R3 – Hearing Certificate (Dated 1 May 2018) The Tribunal has reviewed all of the material before it. The Tribunal is satisfied that all relevant evidence was before it and that both parties were provided an opportunity to address the evidence, either orally or in writing. Relevant aspects of the evidence and material before the Tribunal will be analysed and referred to below. The Respondent states in respect to the criminal record of the Applicant the following:4 On 28 October 2009 the applicant was convicted of “destroy or damage property” for which he was fined $400 and ordered to pay Court costs of $76 and compensation of $200. In his submissions, the applicant explains that the conviction arose from an incident of a domestic nature, namely that the applicant:… and the complainant were in an intimate personal relationship… [the applicant] attached so much of importance to the relationship, that he was upset that the victim did not respond to his calls, that he went to her residence to persuade her to continue their relationship. When she did not respond to the doorbell, in an act of desperation he attempted to push open the door which resulted in damage to the door frame… When his then girlfriend attempted to end the relationship, he was overcome by emotional upheaval and this led to his acting in an inappropriate manner.5 On 10 September 2012 the applicant lodged an application for conferral of Australian citizenship and this was refused on 11 December 2012 because he had pending criminal court proceedings.6 On 19 December 2013 the applicant was sentenced to 18 months imprisonment for grievous bodily harm (GBH) and 8 months imprisonment for unlawful wounding. Both sentences of imprisonment were suspended for 18 months. These charges arose out of the applicant’s involvement in an unprovoked attack on two men at their homes on 19 August 2011. The Sentencing Remarks of DCJ Eaton reveal that the applicant attended the house of the two men accompanied by three other accomplices with the intent to assault the two men. After arriving at the house, one of his co-offenders struck each of the victims in the back of the head with a weight barbell, causing serious depression fractures of the men’s skulls. Although the applicant was not the offender who wielded the barbell, the Sentencing Judge noted found he was present standing over the victim at the time. The serious nature of the applicant’s offending behaviour is further demonstrated in the sentencing remarks of Eaton DCJ who noted:Both complainants suffered serious injuries. Those suffered by Mr [redacted] were the more serious. Neither suffered a permanent injury, in that each has fully recovered. Neither is left with a permanent disability. In each case however the blow to the head could have led to far more serious, even tragic, consequences for the victims. Apart from the fact that a weapon was employed and that the attacks were on that afternoon completely unprovoked, it does seem to me that the fact that all four acted in concert adds to the seriousness of what happened”. (R2 2-3)

Decision

Reasons for decision

Given the above findings so far, the Tribunal therefore supports the view of the Minister, that the Applicant fails the character test pursuant to section 21(2)(h) of the Citizenship Act.Was the Applicant of good character at the time of the Minister’s decision of his citizenship application: Applicant’s offences The Tribunal will now assess the Applicant’s character at the time of the Minister’s decision in light of Applicant’s specific convictions. The Applicant has three criminal convictions arising out of two incidents: ·Destroy or Damage Property. ·Unlawful wounding·Grievous Bodily Harm The Tribunal considers each of the Applicant’s offences in a very serious light.Destroy or Damage to Property This is an offence that arose as a result of the Applicant breaking down his ex-girlfriend’s the door. The Tribunal notes at the time of this incident the Applicant described his relationship with his girlfriend as “intimate.” (A1 1) The Tribunal notes that the Applicant appears to be down-playing what actually happened in relation to his “Destroy or Damage Property” conviction. He states that “it was not his intention to intimidate her [his ex-girlfriend], or cause damage to her property.” (A1 2) It is the Tribunal’s opinion however, that the Applicant would have indeed intimidated his ex-girlfriend, and did indeed cause damage to her property. The Tribunal considers the Applicant’s acts as serious acts. The Tribunal considers that such charges and convictions are not reflective of behaviour that a law abiding citizen would undertake. Unlawful Wounding and Grievous Bodily Harm The Tribunal notes that this behaviour involved violence and harm to a victim. The Tribunal notes the court transcript relating to the Applicant’s convictions in 2013 that the nature of the offences by the four men, of which the Applicant was one, involved serious criminal activity involving a knife, a metal bar, head wounds and kicking. All of the above activities occurred without evidence of provocation. (T4 22-3)(R1) The Tribunal notes evidence in the transcript relevant to the Applicant’s 2013 conviction that all four men went to the house on that afternoon with the specific intent of inflicting harm. (T4 18-34)(R1) His Honour DCJ Eaton made the following sentencing remarks:All counsel concede that, having regard to the seriousness of the offending, sentences of imprisonment are appropriate (T4 22)(R1) The Tribunal considers that whilst the Applicant received a suspended custodial sentence for his conduct, a suspended sentence of 18 months is a significant amount of time, and reflects the seriousness in which the court viewed the Applicant’s criminal behaviour.Was the Applicant of good character at the time of his application: character references The Tribunal notes that the Applicant has a permanent protection visa in Australia. The Tribunal notes the character references provided on behalf of the Applicant. In summary, the character references describe the Applicant as:·being distressed by his past mistakes;·a person that looks after his parents and siblings in Sri Lanka;·a person who plans to get married and settle down in Perth;·a valued and hard-working employee who has taken on the role of a supervisor.·a community volunteer and a person of good character.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The issue for determination by the Tribunal is whether the Applicant was of good character at the time of his application.Was the Applicant of good character at the time of his application: General considerations The Tribunal will assess the Applicant’s character at the time of the Minister’s decision in light of general considerations relevant to the Applicant. The Respondent contends:(R2 6-7)23 The applicant’s offences weigh against his being of good character.24 The applicant’s convictions for GBH [grievous bodily harm] and unlawful wounding are extremely serious and this is reflected by the comments of the Sentencing Judge in finding that a term of imprisonment, to be suspended was warranted for each of the applicant’s convictions.25 In the applicant’s submissions to this Tribunal dated 20 June 2018, the applicant has attempted to downplay the seriousness of these offences. In particular the applicant states that he “acknowledges that the charges against them were serious and is very remorseful in respect of his involvement, however minor” (emphasis added). The applicant also makes a submission that the sentencing remarks “clearly demonstrate that his role in the incident was significantly minor…” (emphasis added). The Minister contends that the applicant’s attempt to downplay these serious crimes (for which he received sentences of imprisonment) demonstrate that the applicant is not truly remorseful for his actions that led to the serious injury of the two victims of his assault. (original emphasis)26 The Minister also contends that insufficient time has passed since the applicant’s criminal behaviour for the Tribunal to find that he is now of enduring moral qualities, such that a finding of good character could be made, in circumstances where he was sentenced to terms of imprisonment less than two years before lodging his application for citizenship.27 Having regard to the “Characteristics of Good Character” at page 147 of the Policy, it is clear that the applicant falls short of the required standard of character. In particular, the applicant’s past behaviour demonstrates that:• He does not respect and abide by the law in Australia;• He is violent… and has caused harm to others through his conduct; and• He has been associated with others who are involved in anti-social or criminal behaviour, or others who do not uphold and obey the laws of Australia.28 Likewise, the applicant’s conviction for ‘destroy or damage property’ should be viewed as serious in circumstances where the complainant was in a domestic relationship with the applicant and he broke down her door when she refused to speak with him.…30 Similarly, SM Tavoularis recently made similar findings regarding the seriousness of such offending in Karatunov and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2017] AATA 132 where he noted that:The Commonwealth government takes a very serious stance on domestic violence. Numerous and costly measures are currently being taken to address domestic violence in Australia. Further, in a media release issued in September 2015, Prime Minister Turnbull and a number of other government Ministers expressed the view that domestic and family violence has a devastating impact on the Australian community; that domestic, family or sexual violence is unacceptable in any circumstances, and that the issue must be elevated to our national consciousness. I find this material a persuasive statement of the government’s view on domestic violence.31 The Minister contends that the applicant’s very serious and recent convictions for serious acts of violence weigh heavily against a finding that the applicant is, at this point in time, a person of good character for the purposes of s 21(2)(h) of the Act.