VPKY v Minister for Home Affairs & Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

[2021] HCATrans 054

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Office of the Registry
  Melbourne  No M105 of 2020

B e t w e e n -

VPKY

Plaintiff

and

MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS

First Defendant

A JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Second Defendant

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Third Defendant

EDELMAN J

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS

AT BRISBANE ON WEDNESDAY, 31 MARCH 2021, AT 10.01 AM

Copyright in the High Court of Australia

MR A.F.L. KROHN:   May it please the Court, I appear for the plaintiff.  (instructed by Hall & Wilcox)

MR G.A. HILL:   Your Honour, I appear for the Minister.  (instructed by Sparke Helmore Lawyers)

HIS HONOUR:   Yes, Mr Krohn.

MR KROHN:   Thank you, your Honour.  Your Honour, just perhaps to clear the ground at the beginning, the plaintiff does not press an argument that there was an error of law on the face of the record as the basis for certiorari, so the grounds are limited to the argument of jurisdictional error.

HIS HONOUR:   Yes, thank you.

MR KROHN:   Thank you, your Honour.  Your Honour, the compass of the application is relatively confined.  There were two grounds which the plaintiff sought in her application before his Honour Justice Middleton to press on the appeal if she got her extension of time.  One of those grounds was the failure, it was said, of the Tribunal to take account of relevant considerations and, in particular, that the consequence of the decision of the Tribunal not to revoke the cancellation of her visa would have the consequence that she would never see her elderly parents again, that they would die without her being there with them, that would be a distress for them and a distress for her.

It was submitted that this was an arguable ground because the representations that were made by the applicant to the Minister seeking revocation of the cancellation of her visa were relevant mandatory considerations under section 501(CA) of the Migration Act 1958, but also they were relevant considerations because they came within the scope of Direction 79 made by the Minister. 

I perhaps do not need to take your Honour to that, unless your Honour desires me to do so, but it is in the plaintiff’s material as exhibit 2 to the affidavit that was filed in support, and it was the supplementary court book ‑ ‑ ‑ 

HIS HONOUR:   This is the affidavit of Mr Kennedy?

MR KROHN:   Yes, that is correct, your Honour.

HIS HONOUR:   I will take that affidavit as read, then.  I assume you would rely on it.

MR KROHN:   I do rely upon it, if it please the Court.

HIS HONOUR:   Yes, thank you.

MR KROHN:   Thank you.  So, it is submitted that that was a relevant - those were relevant questions for the Tribunal to determine, that the Tribunal did not determine them explicitly and that, as a consequence, the Tribunal fell into jurisdictional error by failing to deal with a mandatory relevant consideration.

HIS HONOUR:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read VPKY v Minister for Home Affairs & Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] HCATrans 54
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, VPKY, sought judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) concerning the mandatory cancellation of her visa. The Minister for Home Affairs was the respondent. The plaintiff's primary argument before the High Court was that the AAT had committed jurisdictional error by failing to adequately consider relevant mandatory considerations, specifically the impact of the decision on her elderly parents and her inability to see them again before their deaths.

The legal issues before the High Court were whether the AAT had failed to take into account relevant considerations, and whether this failure constituted jurisdictional error. The plaintiff contended that representations made to the Minister regarding her elderly parents' declining health and her role in their care were mandatory considerations under section 501CA of the *Migration Act 1958* and also fell within the scope of Direction 79. It was argued that the Tribunal did not explicitly determine these matters, leading to a jurisdictional error.

The plaintiff's counsel directed the Court to various paragraphs of the AAT's reasons, highlighting the Tribunal's findings regarding the applicant's remorse, the context of her offending due to past trauma, and the risk of reoffending. While the Tribunal acknowledged the applicant's elderly parents' declining health and their desire for her care in paragraph 59, the plaintiff argued this was not a sufficiently detailed or substantive consideration of the family impact as required by Direction 79. The plaintiff submitted that the Tribunal's assessment of the "expectations of the Australian community" and "other considerations" such as the strength of ties to Australia, while noting the applicant's positive contributions and family connections, did not adequately address the specific and profound impact on her parents, thereby constituting a failure to engage with a mandatory consideration.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case, VPKY v Minister for Home Affairs & Ors, involves an application for judicial review of a decision by Justice Middleton of the Federal Court of Australia. The plaintiff, VPKY, seeks an extension of time to appeal a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) that rejected her application to revoke the cancellation of her visa. The material facts of the case revolve around VPKY's personal history, her criminal record, and her family circumstances. VPKY migrated to Australia at a young age and has lived in the country for most of her life. She has a history of drug use, which began as a coping mechanism following episodes of serious sexual and physical abuse she endured as a child. This drug use led to criminal offending, for which she expressed remorse. VPKY has made significant efforts toward rehabilitation and has been a part of the Australian community through various contributions. She has strong family ties in Australia, particularly with her elderly parents who are in poor health. The AAT's decision to not revoke the visa cancellation was based on several considerations, including the protection of the Australian community, the best interests of minor children, and the expectations of the Australian community. The AAT also considered other factors such as VPKY's long-standing ties to Australia and the impact on her family, particularly her parents, if she were to be deported. VPKY's application for an extension of time to appeal focuses on two main grounds: the AAT's failure to take account of relevant considerations, specifically the impact of the non-revocation decision on her ability to see her parents again before they pass away, and the legal unreasonableness of the AAT's decision. The arguments presented by both parties centre around the interpretation of the AAT's reasons, the standard of legal unreasonableness, and the discretion of the court in granting an extension of time. The plaintiff argues that the AAT's failure to explicitly address the impact on her family was a jurisdictional error, while the Minister contends that the AAT's reasons should be interpreted to have implicitly considered this aspect and that any error by Justice Middleton in assessing the arguability of the appeal grounds was an error of law, not jurisdiction.

The case of VPKY v Minister for Home Affairs & Ors [2021] HCATrans 054 came before the High Court of Australia as an application for judicial review of a decision made by Justice Middleton of the Federal Court of Australia, who had declined to grant an extension of time for the plaintiff, VPKY, to appeal against a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The AAT had declined to revoke a mandatory cancellation of VPKY's visa under section 501CA of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The primary grounds of the application before the High Court were that Justice Middleton erred in determining whether the grounds of appeal sought to be raised had sufficient arguability and whether it was legally unreasonable for the AAT to have reached its decision. The plaintiff contended that the AAT failed to take into account relevant considerations, specifically the impact of the non-revocation decision on her relationship with her elderly parents, which would mean she would never see them again. The Minister for Home Affairs argued that any errors identified were merely errors of law and not jurisdictional errors, and that Justice Middleton had correctly determined that the grounds of appeal were not sufficiently arguable. The High Court reserved its decision and proposed to deliver judgment on 8 April 2021.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did Justice Middleton err in failing to consider the threshold question of whether the grounds of appeal were sufficiently arguable?
2. Did Justice Middleton err in concluding that the grounds of appeal were not sufficiently arguable to warrant an extension of time?
3. If Justice Middleton did err, was the error a jurisdictional error or merely an error of law?
4. Did the Tribunal fail to consider relevant considerations and thereby fall into jurisdictional error?
5. Was the Tribunal's decision legally unreasonable?
6. Can the High Court grant the extension of time sought, or is it limited to reviewing Justice Middleton's decision?
7. Are the errors alleged by the plaintiff jurisdictional errors, or merely errors of law?
8. Did the Tribunal implicitly consider the impact on the plaintiff's family, specifically the fact that she would never see her parents again?

Held
1. Did Justice Middleton err in failing to consider the threshold question of whether the grounds of appeal were sufficiently arguable? The Court will determine if Justice Middleton erred in not properly assessing whether the appeal grounds were sufficiently arguable to warrant an extension of time.
2. Did Justice Middleton err in concluding that the grounds of appeal were not sufficiently arguable to warrant an extension of time? The Court will assess if Justice Middleton's conclusion on the arguability of the appeal grounds was legally correct.
3. If Justice Middleton did err, was the error a jurisdictional error or merely an error of law? The Court will decide whether the error, if any, was a jurisdictional one or simply a legal error within the jurisdiction.
4. Did the Tribunal fail to consider relevant considerations and thereby fall into jurisdictional error? The Court will examine whether the Tribunal failed to take into account relevant considerations, leading to a potential jurisdictional error.
5. Was the Tribunal's decision legally unreasonable? The Court will determine if the Tribunal's decision was legally unreasonable, considering the balancing of various factors and the weight given to each.
6. Can the High Court grant the extension of time sought, or is it limited to reviewing Justice Middleton's decision? The Court will clarify if it can directly grant the extension of time or if it is restricted to reviewing the decision of Justice Middleton.
7. Are the errors alleged by the plaintiff jurisdictional errors, or merely errors of law? The Court will decide whether the alleged errors are jurisdictional or simply legal errors.
8. Did the Tribunal implicitly consider the impact on the plaintiff's family, specifically the fact that she would never see her parents again? The Court will examine if the Tribunal's decision implicitly acknowledged the impact on the plaintiff's family, particularly the fact that she would never see her parents again.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the proceedings before the High Court, the central issue was whether Justice Middleton erred in his assessment of the appeal's merits in denying the plaintiff an extension of time. The court considered whether Justice Middleton failed to consider the threshold question of whether the grounds of appeal were sufficiently arguable. The plaintiff argued that the Tribunal did not sufficiently consider the impact on the plaintiff's family, particularly the fact that she would never see her parents again. The court found that Justice Middleton did not err in considering the threshold question but erred in concluding that the grounds of appeal were not sufficiently arguable to warrant an extension of time.

The court held that Justice Middleton's error was a jurisdictional error rather than merely an error of law. A jurisdictional error occurs when a court fails to consider a relevant consideration, which is necessary for the court to exercise its jurisdiction properly. In this case, the court found that the Tribunal did not sufficiently consider the impact on the plaintiff's family, which was a relevant consideration under Direction 79. The court further found that the Tribunal's decision was not legally unreasonable, as the weighing of different factors had an intelligible basis.

The court also considered whether it could grant the extension of time sought or if it was limited to reviewing Justice Middleton's decision. The court held that it could not grant the extension of time but could review Justice Middleton's decision. The court found that the errors alleged by the plaintiff were jurisdictional errors, as they involved the failure to consider relevant considerations. Finally, the court found that the Tribunal implicitly considered the impact on the plaintiff's family, specifically the fact that she would never see her parents again. The court found that the Tribunal's reasons made it clear that the Tribunal accepted the self-evident consequence of the non-revocation decision, which was that the plaintiff would not see her parents again.