Vorrasi v Adelaide City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Land and Valuation Division)

VORRASI v ADELAIDE CITY COUNCIL

[2010] SASC 25

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Bleby

16 February 2010

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING - DEVELOPMENT CONTROL - MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION OF CONSENT AUTHORITY - GENERALLY - CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING SCHEMES

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING - DEVELOPMENT CONTROL - MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION OF CONSENT AUTHORITY - CONSIDERATION OF PARTICULAR PLANNING MATTERS - HERITAGE

Appeal from the Environment Resources and Development Court – development application to install PVC blinds around an outdoor dining area of a cafe – subject land designated as a Local heritage place – whether Commissioner properly carried out an assessment against all relevant principles of Development Plan – failure to provide reasons for departing from uncontradicted expert evidence as to effect of development on heritage value – whether Commissioner misdirected himself as to heritage value – whether particular principles of development control misapplied – whether reversible nature of development considered – relevance of effect on townscape – appeal allowed.

Local Government Act 1999 (SA) Div 6, Ch 11; Development Act 1993 (SA) s 33, referred to.
City of Mitcham v Freckman (1999) 74 SASR 56, considered.

WORDS AND PHRASES CONSIDERED/DEFINED

"heritage value"

VORRASI v ADELAIDE CITY COUNCIL
[2010] SASC 25

Land and Valuation Division

BLEBY J.

Introduction

  1. This is a case about the installation of three clear PVC blinds around the outdoor dining area of a King William Street cafe. It comes by way of appeal from the Environment Resources and Development Court (“the ERDC”) which confirmed a decision of the Adelaide City Council to refuse an application by the appellant for development approval to install the blinds on a portion of the verandah of the building housing the cafe.

  2. The Baretto Courte Caffe, previously known as the Court Cafe, is a King William Street landmark well-known to those who frequent the heritage court buildings facing King William Street, and particularly the Adelaide Magistrates Court and the Coroner’s Court.

  3. The premises form part of a two storey building between 302-306 King William Street, Adelaide, which has been designated as a Local heritage place (City Significance) in the Adelaide (City) Development Plan. The building is a two storey Victorian Terrace originally of four shops and associated first floor dwellings. It is in a conspicuous location on the eastern side of King William Street opposite the State heritage buildings presently occupied by the Supreme Court. It is immediately south of the Adelaide Magistrates Court and Coroner’s Court, and on its southern boundary adjoins the Crown and Sceptre Hotel, another State heritage place. A little further south on the corner of King William Street and Carrington Street is the former Kings Hall, designated as a Local heritage place (Townscape). The building is constructed of stone with rendered surrounds to openings and quoins.

  4. The first floor is described in the Council’s information sheet as follows:

    The exterior of the first floor is intact although neglected. The façade of this section…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vorrasi v Adelaide City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] SASC 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Vorrasi v Adelaide City Council, the appellant sought to appeal a decision made by the Adelaide City Council regarding a development application for the installation of PVC blinds around an outdoor dining area of a café. The subject land was designated as a Local heritage place, and the appellant contested the Commissioner's assessment of the application against relevant principles of the Development Plan. The appellant argued that the Commissioner did not consider all relevant planning matters, did not provide reasons for departing from uncontradicted expert evidence, and misdirected himself regarding the heritage value. The appellant further contended that particular principles of development control were misapplied and that the reversible nature of the development and its effect on the townscape were not adequately considered.

The court addressed several key legal issues, including whether the Commissioner properly assessed the development application against all relevant principles of the Development Plan, whether the Commissioner failed to provide reasons for departing from uncontradicted expert evidence regarding the effect of the development on the heritage value, whether the Commissioner misdirected himself as to the heritage value, and whether particular principles of development control were misapplied. Additionally, the court examined whether the reversible nature of the development and its effect on the townscape were appropriately considered. The court found that the Commissioner's focus on heritage issues, while significant, did not exclude consideration of other relevant objectives and principles of the Development Plan. The Commissioner's reasons for dismissing the appeal were reviewed, and it was concluded that the appeal must be allowed, setting aside the decision of the Environment Resources and Development Court.

The court allowed the appeal and set aside the decision of the Environment Resources and Development Court. The court granted development plan consent and development approval for the proposal, subject to specific conditions to ensure the development does not compromise future restoration of the building. These conditions included the removal of the blinds and fittings, the outdoor dining permit not being renewed or being cancelled, or development approval being granted for alterations to the western facade of the building. Other conditions related to the colour of the channels housing the blinds, their maintenance, and making good the verandah and footpath upon removal of the blinds. The court considered whether the matter should be remitted to the Environment Resources and Development Court for determining the appropriate conditions or whether such conditions should be part of any final order made by the court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BLEBY J
It is not difficult to accept that provisions such as paragraphs (a), (b), (d) and (f) may have had some bearing in the decision to designate this building a Local heritage place (City Significance). The clear implication from the designation of a building as a Local heritage place (Townscape) is that its principal reason for designation is to be found in paragraph (d), and for that reason is likely to have applied to any development application relating to its facade a more stringent approach than would apply to a Local heritage place (City Significance), being an approach which requires that the development “positively contribute”[2] to the heritage value of that building. That is not a requirement for development of a Local heritage place (City Significance). [2] Adelaide (City) Development Plan, Principle 140.Conclusion It follows that the appeal must be allowed and the decision of the ERDC set aside. In its place there should be an order allowing the appeal against the decision of the Council and granting Development Plan consent and hence Development Approval for the proposal. However, that will need to be subject to a number of conditions. In order to ensure that the development does not compromise or discourage future restoration of the building, and given the ready reversibility of the development, one of those conditions should be to the effect that the approval remains in place only until:(a)The blinds and fittings the subject of the approval are lawfully removed by the owner or occupier of the premises;(b)The outdoor dining permit issued by the Adelaide City Council in respect of the premises is either not renewed or is cancelled; or(c)Development Approval is granted for any alteration to the western facade of the building, including the verandah, of which the premises forms partwhichever first occurs. There will also no doubt need to be conditions relating to such matters as the colour of the channels housing the blinds, conditions as to their maintenance and as to making good the verandah and footpath upon removal of the blinds, and possibly other matters. I will hear counsel as to whether the matter should be remitted to the ERDC for the purpose of determining the appropriate conditions or whether such conditions should be part of any final order made by me.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BLEBY J

The Commissioner’s reasons for dismissing the appeal are expressed in the following three paragraphs:(1)Whether the proposal diminishes the heritage value of the building is not an issue determined solely by an evaluation against the prevailing character and heritage integrity of its lower or ground level. The integrity of the building as a whole ought to be considered and due recognition be given to those elements that have been restored to heritage value status. Such an approach would be consistent with the Plan’s overall thrust for heritage conservation and enhancement unless, of course, its heritage value was so damaged as to make it fruitless to pursue the aims and objectives of heritage conservation. That is not the case here. To the contrary, restoration work has occurred at the lower level and resources have been expended to prepare a conservation plan to assist in its restoration over time.(2)Taken as a whole the proposal would, because of the appearance of and the distortions created by the PVC material when drawn, alter the appearance of the building in a material way. In my view the alteration would not be consistent with what remains of the original street façade when the building is viewed in its totality. For that reason, it would be in conflict with Council wide Principles 135 and 136, would not pay sufficient respect to those parts of the ground level that have been conserved and may well have the effect of discouraging further restoration in accordance with the Plan’s aims and objectives for heritage and conservation.(3)Within the locality the building sits adjacent to or very near a number of heritage places and within a townscape recognised by the Plan as having particular importance. The townscape within the locality reflects with some accuracy the character sought for the Policy Area as expressed in part in Principle 2. That is to say “imposing buildings along a tree lined boulevard”. The importance of the boulevard townscape is reinforced in Principle 3. The existing townscape is devoid of any feature comparable to the proposal. Although not a decisive factor, and one diminished by the presence of regularly spaced street trees, the blinds when drawn would appear as a foreign element thus placing it at odds with the goal of achieving a visually cohesive townscape.Consideration of the appealA focus that was too narrow? The first argument of the appellant was that the Commissioner, having identified what he described as the “central planning issue” failed to take into account the necessary balancing of pros and cons of the proposal as a whole and other relevant objectives of the Development Plan, such as development that contributes to the vibrancy, activity and desired character of the locality. It was argued that he concentrated almost exclusively on heritage issues. Heritage issues were significant, but they were not considered by the Commissioner to the exclusion of other relevant Objectives and Principles of the Development Plan. The Commissioner noted most of the relevant provisions of the Plan. I have already referred to his identification of the policy tension between creating a welcoming, safe and vibrant kerb-side atmosphere, on the one hand, and provisions that discourage developments that would diminish the value of a building or affect the visually cohesive townscape of other buildings in the street. Towards the end of his reasons he referred particularly to the evidence of the appellant and to aspects of the Zone’s desired character which was not challenged. He noted that the aim of Objectives and Principles to “create active street frontages to encourage adaptive reuse and continuation of heritage places is heavily qualified” by Principles 2 and 3 of the Policy Area, especially in the light of their opening qualification, reinforced by objective 43 and Principles 134-136.