Volley Investments Pty Ltd v Coles Myer Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT :   THE FULL COURT (WA)

CITATION:   VOLLEY INVESTMENTS PTY LTD -v- COLES MYER LTD [2005] WASCA 52

CORAM:   MURRAY J

BARKER J

HEARD:   16 SEPTEMBER 2004

DELIVERED          :   16 SEPTEMBER 2004

PUBLISHED           :  24 MARCH 2005

FILE NO/S:   FUL 2 of 2004

BETWEEN:   VOLLEY INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 055 797 085)

Applicant

AND

COLES MYER LTD (ACN 004 089 936)
Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :  SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram  :MASTER SANDERSON

Citation  :COLES MYER LTD -v- VOLLEY INVESTMENTS PTY LTD [2003] WASC 254

File No  :CIV 2029 of 2003

Catchwords:

Landlord and tenant - Collapse of ceiling in shopping centre - Lessor had arranged for a competent contractor to carry out work on the roof - Cause of collapse unknown - Whether collapse constituted a breach by the lessor of the covenant of quiet enjoyment in the lease

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)

Result:

Leave to appeal granted
Appeal allowed
Leave to defend granted
Respondent to pay applicant's costs of appeal to be taxed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Mr G H Murphy

Respondent:     Mr I R Freeman

Solicitors:

Applicant:     Srdarov Richards Burton

Respondent:     Phillips Fox

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Aussie Traveller Pty Ltd v Marklea Pty Ltd [1998] 1 Qd R 1

Harrison, Ainslie & Co v Lord Muncaster [1891] 2 QB 680

JC Berndt Pty Ltd v Walsh [1969] SASR 34

Case(s) also cited:

Briggs v Glentham Property Ltd (1992) 8 WAR 339

Fancourt v Mercantile Credits Ltd (1983) 154 CLR 87

Hunt v Knabe (No 2) (1992) 8 WAR 96

Malzy v Eichholz [1916] 2 KB 308

Sanderson v Mayor of Berwick‑upon‑Tweed (1884) 13 QBD 547

  1. JUDGMENT OF THE COURT:    The respondent operates a supermarket at the Phoenix Shopping Centre in Spearwood.  The applicant owns the shopping centre and leased the supermarket premises to the respondent.

  2. The lease contains a covenant by the applicant for the quiet enjoyment of the leased premises in the usual form, as follows:

    "11.04Quiet Enjoyment:  On the Lessee paying the rent herein provided and observing and performing all the covenants terms and conditions on the Lessee's part to be observed and performed the Lessee shall and may peaceable possess and enjoy the premises without any interruption or disturbance from the Lessor or any person or persons lawfully claiming by or from or under it subject nevertheless to the terms and conditions of this Lease."

  3. On 22 April 2002 a section of the roof of the shopping centre over the food court, a part of the leased premises, collapsed.  The evidence thus far available does not reveal the cause of the collapse but the respondent asserts that as a result of the collapse the entire shopping centre was closed for a time.  It was unable to resume retail trade for a period, and even then, access to its supermarket was restricted and reduced while repairs were undertaken.  Water damage to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Volley Investments Pty Ltd v Coles Myer Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] WASCA 52
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Volley Investments Pty Ltd v Coles Myer Ltd, the dispute arose from the collapse of a section of the roof at the Phoenix Shopping Centre in Spearwood, which occurred on 22 April 2002. Volley Investments Pty Ltd, the owner and lessor of the shopping centre, leased the premises to Coles Myer Ltd, the operator of a supermarket within the shopping centre. Following the collapse, Coles Myer Ltd claimed damages for breach of the covenant of quiet enjoyment as stipulated in their lease agreement. The specific issue before the court was whether the collapse of the roof constituted a breach by Volley Investments of the covenant to provide quiet enjoyment of the leased premises.

The court was tasked with determining whether the collapse of the roof, which caused significant disruption to Coles Myer Ltd's business operations, amounted to a breach of the covenant of quiet enjoyment. The covenant in question required Volley Investments to ensure that Coles Myer Ltd could peacefully enjoy the leased premises without interruption or disturbance from the lessor or any person lawfully claiming through the lessor. The court had to consider whether the collapse, even though its cause was unknown, could be attributed to Volley Investments, and if so, whether this amounted to a breach of the covenant.

Upon reviewing the evidence and the arguments presented, the court concluded that the Master had erred in holding that the covenant of quiet enjoyment had been breached. The court found that there was no evidence to suggest that the collapse was caused by any action or omission of Volley Investments or their contractor. The court allowed the appeal, set aside the judgment for summary judgment entered by the Master, and granted Volley Investments leave to defend the claim unconditionally. This decision meant that the case would proceed to a full hearing to determine the actual cause of the collapse and the extent of any damages claimed by Coles Myer Ltd.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT: The respondent operates a supermarket at the Phoenix Shopping Centre in Spearwood. The applicant owns the shopping centre and leased the supermarket premises to the respondent. The lease contains a covenant by the applicant for the quiet enjoyment of the leased premises in the usual form, as follows:"11.04Quiet Enjoyment: On the Lessee paying the rent herein provided and observing and performing all the covenants terms and conditions on the Lessee's part to be observed and performed the Lessee shall and may peaceable possess and enjoy the premises without any interruption or disturbance from the Lessor or any person or persons lawfully claiming by or from or under it subject nevertheless to the terms and conditions of this Lease." On 22 April 2002 a section of the roof of the shopping centre over the food court, a part of the leased premises, collapsed. The evidence thus far available does not reveal the cause of the collapse but the respondent asserts that as a result of the collapse the entire shopping centre was closed for a time. It was unable to resume retail trade for a period, and even then, access to its supermarket was restricted and reduced while repairs were undertaken. Water damage to the premises and the respondent's fixtures and fittings occurred. The respondent sued for damages, relevantly for present purposes, for breach of the covenant of quiet enjoyment. The statement of claim does not plead the cause of the collapse of the roof. It pleads merely, and there is affidavit evidence to support the pleading, that immediately prior to the collapse of the roof, as part of the refurbishment of the shopping centre, the applicant accepted a tender from a building company and entered into a building works contract, one component of which was to replace the glass in the skylights in the food court area of the shopping centre. In the statement of claim that work is described as "the installation of skylights in the roof of the food court area". That work was apparently completed in the late afternoon of 21 April 2002. It was probably in the early hours of 22 April 2002 that this section of the roof collapsed. The statement of claim does not plead that the collapse was caused by anything done or omitted by the applicant's contractor in the course of carrying out work authorised under its contract. The applicant having entered an appearance in the action, the respondent as plaintiff, made an application for summary judgment on the ground that the applicant had no defence to the claim except as to damages, pursuant to the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA) O 14 r 1. The application was supported by affidavit verifying the facts in the way required by O 14 r 2. The application was heard by a Master who entered judgment for the respondent for damages to be assessed. The applicant sought leave to appeal from that interlocutory order, contending that the Master erred in holding that upon the evidence available the covenant for quiet enjoyment had been breached. The grounds were expressed in the form of argument. They need not be repeated here. In substance they invite the conclusion that the Master erred in the meaning or effect he gave to the relevant covenant and in respect of the question whether the respondent brought itself within it. We granted leave to appeal, allowed the appeal, set aside the judgment of the Master and granted the applicant leave to defend unconditionally. These are our reasons for those orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established