Vokalek v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Criminal)

VOKALEK v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

[2008] SASC 256

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Gray

19 September 2008

CRIMINAL LAW - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - OFFENCES AGAINST DECENCY AND MORALITY - OBSCENE, INDECENT OR OBJECTIONABLE PUBLICATIONS OR REPRESENTATIONS - PUBLICATION, DISTRIBUTION, DELIVERY, ETC

Defendant placed an order in the United States of America for two DVDs containing pornographic material - defendant charged with two counts of importing a prohibited import contrary to section 233(1)(b) of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth) - following a trial before a Magistrate, first count was dismissed - defendant was convicted on the second count - defendant appealed against the conviction on the second count and the Commonwealth appealed against the dismissal of the first count.

The defendant's appeal against the conviction on the second count - whether the DVD the subject of the second count offended against the standards of morality, decency and propriety, generally accepted by reasonable adults, to the extent that the DVD should not be imported - whether the use to which the DVD is intended to be put is a relevant consideration in determining whether it offends against these standards - whether the Magistrate had failed to articulate in her reasons why the DVD the subject of the second count offended the currently accepted standards – whether the Magistrate erred in ruling that evidence from two expert witnesses was inadmissible on the topic of the prevailing community standards of decency.

Held – dismissing the appeal and affirming the conviction on the second count – Magistrate did not err in finding that the DVD the subject of the second count offended against the standards of morality, decency and propriety, generally accepted by reasonable adults, to the extent that the DVD should not be imported – the use to which the DVD is intended to be put is not a relevant consideration for this offence, as when the DVD was imported it was imported on an unrestricted basis – the Magistrate did not err in identifying the need to determine community standards and concluding that those standards were the contemporary standards of decency currently accepted by the Australian community, being the average man or woman of that community – the Magistrate did not err in ruling that the expert evidence was inadmissible – the law leaves the assessment of the relevant publications and whether the publications breach contemporary standards to the finder of fact, in this case the Magistrate.

The Commonwealth’s cross-appeal against the dismissal of the first count – whether the Magistrate applied the wrong test in reaching her conclusion that it had not been proved beyond reasonable doubt that the majority of reasonable adults would take the view that a DVD such as the DVD the subject of the first count would not be tolerated.

Held – allowing the cross-appeal and imposing a conviction on the first count – Magistrate applied the wrong test - Magistrate erred in proceeding on the basis that the DVD…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vokalek v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] SASC 256
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Vokalek v Commonwealth of Australia involved the defendant who ordered two DVDs containing pornographic material from the United States. He was charged with two counts of importing a prohibited import under section 233(1)(b) of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth). Following a trial before a Magistrate, the first count was dismissed, but the defendant was convicted on the second count. Both parties appealed against the outcomes. The defendant challenged the conviction on the second count, while the Commonwealth appealed against the dismissal of the first count.

The legal issues the court needed to decide included whether the DVD in question offended the standards of morality, decency and propriety generally accepted by reasonable adults, and if the intended use of the DVD was a relevant consideration for this offence. The court also needed to determine whether the Magistrate had correctly articulated why the DVD offended accepted standards and if she erred in ruling that expert evidence on community standards of decency was inadmissible.

The court held that the Magistrate did not err in finding that the DVD in question offended against the standards of morality, decency and propriety, generally accepted by reasonable adults, to the extent that it should not be imported. The use of the DVD was not a relevant consideration as it was imported on an unrestricted basis. The court also found that the Magistrate correctly ruled that expert evidence was inadmissible as the assessment of relevant publications and whether they breach contemporary standards is left to the finder of fact. Regarding the cross-appeal, the court held that the Magistrate applied the wrong test in reaching her conclusion that it had not been proven beyond reasonable doubt that a DVD such as the one in question would not be tolerated. The court allowed the cross-appeal and imposed a conviction on the first count.

The court dismissed the defendant's appeal and affirmed the conviction on the second count. It allowed the Commonwealth's cross-appeal and imposed a conviction on the first count. The order of the Magistrate dismissing the first count was set aside, and an order was made convicting the defendant on the first count. The defendant's conviction on the second count remained, and the matter was remitted to the Chief Magistrate for sentence.

Background

Background to the litigation

The defendant in this case ordered two DVDs containing pornographic material from the United States of America. Upon their arrival in Australia, the defendant was charged with two counts of importing a prohibited import under section 233(1)(b) of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth). After a trial before a Magistrate, the first count was dismissed, but the defendant was convicted on the second count. The defendant subsequently appealed against the conviction on the second count, arguing that the DVD in question did not offend against the standards of morality, decency, and propriety generally accepted by reasonable adults, and that the intended use of the DVD should be a relevant consideration in determining whether it breached these standards. Additionally, the defendant contended that the Magistrate had failed to properly articulate in her reasons why the DVD in question breached the accepted standards and had erred in ruling that evidence from two expert witnesses was inadmissible regarding the prevailing community standards of decency.

The Commonwealth, on the other hand, appealed against the dismissal of the first count. The Commonwealth argued that the Magistrate had applied the wrong test in concluding that it had not been proved beyond reasonable doubt that the majority of reasonable adults would find a DVD such as the one in question intolerable. The Commonwealth contended that once imported, the DVD would be available in Australia for unrestricted use without classification and could be disseminated, thereby offending against the standards of morality, decency, and propriety generally accepted by reasonable adults to such an extent that it should not be imported.

The case hinged on whether the DVDs in question breached the contemporary standards of decency accepted by the Australian community. The Magistrate concluded that the relevant standards were those of the average man or woman of the Australian community and ruled that evidence from expert witnesses regarding community standards was inadmissible. The Magistrate's decision to dismiss the first count was based on the premise that the DVD was "for private viewing only." However, the court held that this consideration was misplaced since, once imported, the DVD could be used without restriction and disseminated freely.

The case of Vokalek v Commonwealth of Australia originated in the Magistrates' Court where the defendant was charged with two counts of importing a prohibited import contrary to section 233(1)(b) of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth). Following a trial, the defendant was acquitted on the first count but convicted on the second count. Dissatisfied with the outcome, the defendant appealed against the conviction on the second count, arguing that the DVD in question did not offend against the standards of morality, decency and propriety generally accepted by reasonable adults to the extent that it should not be imported. Additionally, the Commonwealth cross-appealed against the dismissal of the first count, contending that the Magistrate applied the wrong test in her reasoning. Both appeals were subsequently heard by the court, which had to determine whether the Magistrate had erred in her assessment of the community standards and the admissibility of expert evidence on the topic. The court found that the Magistrate did not err in her determination of community standards and the admissibility of expert evidence, leading to the dismissal of the defendant's appeal and the allowance of the Commonwealth's cross-appeal.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Commonwealth submitted that the Magistrate identified the need to determine community standards and after referring to the relevant authorities concluded that those standards were the contemporary standards of decency currently accepted by the Australian community, being the average man or woman of that community. This was sufficient. The Magistrate was not required to go further to identify or detail what knowledge of information she used to determine that standard. In my view the defendant’s complaint should be rejected.Admissibility of Expert Evidence The Magistrate had evidence before her, admitted de bene esse, from two suggested experts – Professor Paul Wilson, Forensic Psychologist and Criminologist and Dr Jody Hanson, Writer, Teacher and Dominatrix. Broadly, the evidence went to the suggested acceptance by the community of DVDs of a similar nature to those the subject of the complaint. It was contended by the defendant that the Magistrate was entitled to have regard to this evidence in determining whether the defendant had breached regulation 4A(1A) when importing the DVDs. The Magistrate considered that evidence led by the defendant about standards of indecency from Professor Wilson and Dr Hansen was inadmissible with reference to the Magistrate’s determination of appropriate community standards. The defendant complained about this ruling and contended on appeal, as he had at trial, that the evidence was admissible. In my earlier discussion, the observations of the High Court in Crowe v Graham, and also of Bray CJ in Romeyko v Samuels, addressing the inadmissibility of expert evidence about contemporary standards and whether any particular publication offends such standards, are set out. These observations directly support the Magistrate’s ruling that the evidence was inadmissible. As Windeyer J observed in Crowe v Graham,[41] whether the goods transgress the standards:… is a question of fact to be decided by the tribunal of fact. It is to be answered by reading the publication. Common sense and a sense of decency must supply the answer. Only within very narrow limits is evidence beyond the publication itself necessary or admissible. Evidence of what has been published in other books or writing is not admissible. … Nor is it to be had by calling witnesses – whether writers, publishers or psychologists – and asking them to give their opinion on the matter. This approach has been frequently applied throughout Australia.[42][41] Crowe v Graham (1967-68) 121 CLR 375 at 395-396.[42] Chance International Pty Ltd v Forbes and Another (1968) 12 FLR 425 at 427; Romeyko v Samuels (1972) 2 SASR 529 at 561, 563, 564 (Bray CJ); Dorf Industries Pty Ltd and Another v Toose and Others (1994) 127 ALR 654 at 670. In Transport Publishing Co Pty Ltd v Literature Board of Review,[43] the High Court criticised the influence of extrinsic evidence on a decision of the Supreme Court of Queensland, which had been heard at first instance by the Literature Board of Review. Dixon CJ, Kitto and Taylor JJ observed:[I]t may be said at once that ordinary human nature, that of people at large, is not a subject of proof by evidence, whether supposedly expert or not.Their Honours went on to observe that it was conceivable that opinion evidence may in some circumstances be given upon the characteristics, responses or behaviour of a special category of persons. However, these comments were made in the context of a consideration of the Objectionable Literature Act 1954 (Q.) That Act required the relevant Board to have regard to “the persons, classes of persons, and age groups to or amongst whom that literature is or is intended to be or is likely to be distributed”. Even in this context, their Honours went on to disapprove of the use of the “extrinsic evidence” in that case. [43] Transport Publishing Co Pty Ltd v Literature Board of Review (1956) 99 CLR 111 at 119.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GRAY J
As earlier observed, it was open to the defendant to have sought the permission of the Commonwealth Attorney-General to the importation. Had that course been followed, then the Attorney-General could have given consideration to the allowing of the importation, subject to conditions. That process may have led to the legal availability of the DVD for private adult viewing only. The defendant chose not to follow that course. Notwithstanding his evidence as to his intended use of the DVD, the DVD was imported into Australia. But for its seizure it would have been unclassified. There was nothing to stop the defendant from changing his mind, forming a different intention, and disseminating the DVD to others.Conclusion The appeal by the defendant is dismissed. The cross-appeal by the Commonwealth is allowed. The order of the Magistrate dismissing the first count is set aside. An order is made convicting the defendant on the first count. The defendant’s conviction on the second count remains. The matter is remitted to the Chief Magistrate for sentence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GRAY J

The central issue in the Vokalek case was whether the DVDs in question were obscene and hence should not be imported into Australia. The court considered whether the standards of morality, decency, and propriety, generally accepted by reasonable adults, were offended to the extent that the DVDs should not be imported. The court also examined whether the intended use of the DVDs was a relevant consideration in determining whether they offended these standards. The court determined that the intended use of the DVDs was not a relevant consideration because, once imported, they were available for unrestricted use without classification and could be disseminated freely. The court upheld the Magistrate's decision that the DVD in question offended the contemporary standards of decency currently accepted by the Australian community.

The court further assessed whether the Magistrate erred in ruling that evidence from two expert witnesses on prevailing community standards of decency was inadmissible. The court found that the Magistrate did not err in this ruling, aligning with the principle that the assessment of whether publications breach contemporary standards is left to the finder of fact, in this case, the Magistrate. The court supported this finding by referencing the observations of the High Court in Crowe v Graham and Bray CJ in Romeyko v Samuels, which emphasize that the determination of whether goods transgress standards of decency is a question of fact decided by the tribunal of fact.

In considering whether the Magistrate failed to articulate in her reasons why the DVD offended the currently accepted standards, the court dismissed the defendant's argument. The court noted that the Magistrate had identified the need to determine community standards and concluded that those standards were the contemporary standards of decency currently accepted by the Australian community, being the average man or woman of that community. The court held that the Magistrate was not required to further identify or detail what knowledge or information she used to determine that standard.

Regarding the Commonwealth's cross-appeal against the dismissal of the first count, the court found that the Magistrate applied the wrong test. The Magistrate erred in proceeding on the basis that the DVD was "for private viewing only." The court held that once imported, the DVD would be available in Australia for unrestricted use without classification and available for dissemination. Consequently, the DVD offended against the standards of morality, decency, and propriety generally accepted by reasonable adults to such an extent that it should not be imported. The court allowed the cross-appeal and imposed a conviction on the first count.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the assessment of whether a publication offends the standards of morality, decency, and propriety generally accepted by reasonable adults is left to the finder of fact, and expert evidence on prevailing community standards of decency is inadmissible. Furthermore, the intended use of the imported material is not a relevant consideration for the offence of importing obscene material. The court followed established principles from previous cases and did not depart from prior authority in reaching its decision.