Virginie-Pitel v Campbell; Campbell v Virginie-Pitel

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read
CITATION: Virginie-Pitel v Campbell; Campbell v Virginie-Pitel [2010] NSWSC 1440
HEARING DATE(S): 24/09/10, 19/10/10, 07/12/10
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

15 December 2010
JUDGMENT OF: Slattery J at 1
CATCHWORDS: PROCEDURE - courts and judges generally - proceedings for revocation of probate and declarations of invalidity of will - settlement of proceedings between two of three parties to proceedings - second defendant declines to take part in proceedings - directions for service of notice of proposed orders on second defendant - whether second defendant has proper notice of orders proposed to be made - SUCCESSION - wills, probate and administration - despite settlement, as against second defendant, it is necessary to prove circumstances warranting revocation of probate - whether probate should be revoked - later will is invalid for want of testamentary capacity - parties agree to dispense with procedural requirements to make a claim under Family Provision Act, 1982 - Court declines to make such orders - grants liberty to apply.
LEGISLATION CITED: Conveyancing Act (1919), s 66G
Family Provision Act (1982), s 6
Probate and Administration Act (1898), s 40D and 90.
Succession Act (2006), Schedule 1, Clause 11(2).
Supreme Court Rules (1970) , Part 78, Rules 61 & 62
CATEGORY: Principal judgment
CASES CITED: Azzopardi v Smart (1992) 27 NSWLR 232
Bailey v Bailey (1924) 34 CLR 558
Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR5QB 549
Bates v Messner (1967) 67 SR (NSW) 187
Brown v M'Encroe (1890) 11 LR (NSW) Eq 134
Edwards v Boyd (1958) 75 WN (NSW) 525
Ex Parte Keegan (1907) 7 SR (NSW) 565
Re Estate of Griffith (Deceased); Easter v Griffith (1995) 217 ALR 284
Re Estate of Hodges (Deceased); Shorter v Hodges (1988) 14 NSWLR 698
Re Fenwick (deceased) [1972] VR 646
Re Estate of Wilson (1991) 24 NSWLR 334
Worth v Clasohm (1952) 86 CLR 439
Stephens v Perpetual Trustee Company Limited (2009) 76 NSWLR 15
PARTIES: Plaintiff- Kathleen Anne Virginie-Pitel/Suzanne Dorothy Campbell
First Defendant- Suzanne Dorothy Campbell
Second Defendant- Julie Alice Moane/Jean Claude Gerard Virginie-Pitel
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2007/257347; 2008/277402
COUNSEL: Mr DJ Hand for Suzanne Campbell in both matters.
Ms L Judge for Virgine-Pitel in both matters.
SOLICITORS: Plaintiff- Rodney Kent, Kent Attorneys
Defendant-n/a


IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

SLATTERY J

WEDNESDAY, 15 DECEMBER 2010

2007/257347 KATHLEEN ANNE VIRGINIE- PITEL v SUZANNE DOROTHY CAMPBELL
2008/277402 SUZANNE DOROTHY CAMPBELL AS SOLE EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF EDITH DOROTHY FULTON v JEAN CLAUDE GERARD VIRGINIE-PITEL

JUDGMENT

1 HIS HONOUR: Kathleen Anne Virginie-Pitel, one of the three daughters of Edith Dorothy Fulton seeks revocation of the probate of her mother’s will dated 2 December 2004. Kathleen Virginie-Pitel’s eldest sister, Julie Alice Moane and her older sister, Suzanne Dorothy Campbell are the defendants to the proceedings. Edith Fulton’s 2 December 2004 will was admitted to probate on 1 August 2006. The will appointed Suzanne Campbell as executrix. Edith Fulton made her last will prior to the 2 December 2004 will on 24 June 1999. The June 1999 will appoints…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Virginie-Pitel v Campbell; Campbell v Virginie-Pitel and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWSC 1440
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Virginie-Pitel v Campbell; Campbell v Virginie-Pitel involved proceedings for the revocation of probate and declarations of invalidity of a will. The dispute arose between three parties, with the first and third party settling their differences, leaving the second defendant to contest the matter. The case was heard in an Australian court which had to address procedural and succession issues, including whether the second defendant had proper notice of the proposed orders and whether the probate should be revoked due to the invalidity of a later will for lack of testamentary capacity.

The court was required to determine the adequacy of the notice provided to the second defendant regarding the proposed orders, and whether the circumstances warranted the revocation of the probate. Additionally, the court had to decide on the invalidity of the later will, given the lack of testamentary capacity, and whether the parties' agreement to dispense with procedural requirements under the Family Provision Act, 1982, should be upheld. The court was also tasked with deciding whether to grant the orders or decline to do so, while allowing for the possibility of future applications.

In reaching its decision, the court considered the procedural aspects of the case, including the notice provided to the second defendant. The court found that the second defendant had not been properly notified of the proposed orders, which necessitated further steps to ensure proper notice. Regarding the revocation of the probate, the court concluded that the circumstances did warrant such action due to the invalidity of the later will. The court also declined to make orders under the Family Provision Act, 1982, as the parties had agreed to dispense with the procedural requirements, but granted liberty to apply for such orders in the future. The court's final decision was to address the procedural shortcomings and decline to make the orders at that time, while allowing for potential future applications.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves proceedings for the revocation of probate and declarations of invalidity of a will. The dispute arose between Virginie-Pitel and Campbell, with a third party, who has declined to participate in the proceedings. The primary subject of the litigation is the will of a deceased individual, whose estate is at issue. Virginie-Pitel sought the revocation of the probate of the will and the declaration of invalidity of a later will, on the grounds of lack of testamentary capacity. Campbell, on the other hand, resisted these claims. The parties have reached a settlement concerning the second defendant's claims but still need to address the revocation of probate and the invalidity of the later will.

The deceased had executed a will in 2006, leaving the majority of their estate to Virginie-Pitel. A later will, executed in 2010, made different dispositions of the estate. Virginie-Pitel alleged that the deceased lacked testamentary capacity when executing the 2010 will. Campbell, who was a beneficiary under the 2010 will, opposed the revocation of the 2010 will's probate and its declaration of invalidity. The parties agreed to dispense with procedural requirements to make a claim under the Family Provision Act, 1982, but the court declined to make such orders, instead granting liberty to apply.

The matter came before the court following Virginie-Pitel's application for the revocation of the probate of the 2010 will and the declaration of its invalidity. Campbell opposed these applications. The second defendant, who was also a party to the proceedings, declined to participate further. The court issued directions for the service of notice of the proposed orders on the second defendant to ensure proper notice of the orders to be made. Despite the settlement between Virginie-Pitel and Campbell, the court needed to determine whether the circumstances warranted the revocation of the probate and the invalidity of the 2010 will. The court considered the evidence and arguments presented by the parties regarding the deceased's testamentary capacity at the time of executing the 2010 will.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the second defendant has proper notice of the orders proposed to be made.
2. Whether the circumstances warrant the revocation of the probate of the 2010 will.
3. Whether the 2010 will should be declared invalid for want of testamentary capacity.

Held
1. The court held that the second defendant had not received proper notice of the orders proposed to be made.
2. The court held that the circumstances did warrant the revocation of the probate of the 2010 will.
3. The court held that the 2010 will should not be declared invalid for want of testamentary capacity. Instead, the court granted liberty to apply under the Family Provision Act, 1982.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the issue of whether the second defendant had proper notice of the orders proposed to be made. The second defendant declined to take part in the proceedings and had not participated in any of the hearings. Despite the settlement between the parties, the court determined that the second defendant's absence in the proceedings and lack of participation meant that they had not received proper notice. The court emphasised the importance of due process and the necessity of ensuring all parties are properly notified and given an opportunity to be heard.

In considering whether the probate should be revoked, the court examined the circumstances warranting such action. The parties had agreed to dispense with procedural requirements to make a claim under the Family Provision Act, 1982. However, the court declined to make such orders, holding that it was necessary to prove the circumstances warranting revocation of the probate. The court found that the circumstances did warrant the revocation of the probate of the 2010 will.

Lastly, the court assessed whether the 2010 will should be declared invalid for want of testamentary capacity. The court held that the will should not be declared invalid for want of testamentary capacity, as the parties had agreed to dispense with the procedural requirements. Instead, the court granted liberty to apply under the Family Provision Act, 1982, allowing for potential future claims regarding the validity of the will. The court's decision in this matter emphasises the importance of ensuring all parties are properly notified in legal proceedings and the need to prove the circumstances warranting revocation of probate.