Vintage Developments Pty Limited v GHD Pty Limited (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Vintage Developments Pty Limited v GHD Pty Limited (No 4) [2007] FCA 73

VINTAGE DEVELOPMENTS PTY LIMITED (ACN 067 567 006) AND ERROL INVESTMENTS PTY LIMITED (ACN 001 183 277) v GHD PTY LIMITED (ACN 008 488 373), HUNTER VALLEY ESTATES PTY LTD (ACN 010 857 717) AND GRANT HEATON JOHNSTON
NSD 1262 OF 2005

BENNETT J
7 MARCH 2007
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1262 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

VINTAGE DEVELOPMENTS PTY LIMITED
(ACN 067 567 006)
First Applicant

ERROL INVESTMENTS PTY LIMITED (ACN 001 183 277)
Second Applicant

AND:

GHD PTY LIMITED (ACN 008 488 373)
First Respondent / Cross–Claimant

HUNTER VALLEY ESTATES PTY LTD (ACN 010 857 717)
Second Respondent / Cross–Respondent

GRANT HEATON JOHNSTON
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

BENNETT J

DATE OF ORDER:

7 MARCH 2007

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicants pay the second respondent’s costs of the notice of motion dated 11 September 2006.

2.The applicants pay the third respondent’s costs of the notice of motion dated 11 September 2006 up to and including 15 September 2006 and 50% of the third respondent’s costs of the notice of motion thereafter. 

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1262 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

VINTAGE DEVELOPMENTS PTY LIMITED
(ACN 067 567 006)
First Applicant

ERROL INVESTMENTS PTY LIMITED (ACN 001 183 277)
Second Applicant

AND:

GHD PTY LIMITED (ACN 008 488 373)
First Respondent / Cross–Claimant

HUNTER VALLEY ESTATES PTY LTD (ACN 010 857 717)
Second Respondent / Cross–Respondent

GRANT HEATON JOHNSTON
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

BENNETT J

DATE:

7 MARCH 2007

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The applicants (together ‘Vintage’) moved the Court for leave to amend their application and statement of claim to clarify the capacity in which the second applicant, Errol Investments Pty Ltd, brings these proceedings.  Their application was partially successful: Vintage Developments Pty Limited v GHD Pty Limited (No 2) [2006] FCA 1437 (‘Vintage (No 2)’).  Vintage and the second (‘Hunter Valley’) and third (‘Mr Johnston’) respondents disagree as to who should pay the costs of Vintage’s motion for leave to amend the pleadings.  Vintage accepts that, as the party seeking leave to amend, it is appropriate that it bear some liability for costs.  Vintage also acknowledges that it is liable to pay costs incurred prior to 15 September 2006, further to an agreement between the parties.  Vintage’s submission is that it should only be liable thereafter to pay 75% of Hunter Valley’s costs and 50% of Mr Johnston’s costs.  

  2. In the ordinary course, an applicant for leave to amend is liable for the costs of amendment.  Whether or not Hunter Valley or Mr Johnston’s costs should be reduced depends on whether their conduct in contesting the amendments was reasonable. 

    Vintage (No 2)

  3. Two sets of amendments were the subject of argument in Vintage (No 2).

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vintage Developments Pty Limited v GHD Pty Limited (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 73
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Vintage Developments Pty Limited brought a case against GHD Pty Limited, and Mr Johnston. The dispute centred on the costs associated with Vintage's amendments to its application and statement of claim, as well as the costs incurred by the parties during the proceedings. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate costs to be borne by the parties, particularly Vintage’s liability for Mr Johnston’s costs in Vintage (No 2).

The central legal issues revolved around the allocation of costs between Vintage and Mr Johnston, as well as between Vintage and Hunter Valley. The court had to decide whether Vintage’s motion to amend its application and statement of claim was reasonable and whether Hunter Valley and Mr Johnston had acted unreasonably in contesting the amendments. Additionally, the court had to assess whether Vintage should be liable for the costs incurred by Mr Johnston after the specified date of 15 September 2006.

The court ruled that Vintage's liability for Mr Johnston’s costs should be reduced as most of his submissions were related to matters previously raised in Vintage (No 1). Vintage had sought a reduction of 50%, which the court found to be reasonable. Consequently, Vintage was ordered to pay 50% of Mr Johnston’s costs incurred after 15 September 2006. Regarding Hunter Valley, the court found that there was no justification for reducing their liability to 75% of the costs incurred after 15 September 2006. The court also noted that the relevance of the documents sought by Hunter Valley's notice to produce was a matter for taxation.

The final orders of the court required Vintage to pay the costs associated with the notice of motion dated 11 September 2006 for both the second and third respondents. Furthermore, Vintage was to cover the third respondent's costs of the notice of motion up until 15 September 2006 and 50% of the costs incurred thereafter.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicants pay the second respondent’s costs of the notice of motion dated 11 September 2006.

2. The applicants pay the third respondent’s costs of the notice of motion dated 11 September 2006 up to and including 15 September 2006 and 50% of the third respondent’s costs of the notice of motion thereafter.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BENNETT J (dissent)
Vintage’s liability to pay Mr Johnston’s costs of Vintage (No 2) should be reduced. As the majority of his submissions concerned matters raised in Vintage (No 1), it is appropriate that those costs are reduced. Vintage has sought a reduction of 50%. In the circumstances, that in reasonable.Conclusion No reduction in the costs payable to Hunter Valley is justified. Vintage is to pay 50% of Mr Johnston’s costs incurred after 15 September 2006.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by:

One further matter was the subject of extensive submissions. Mr Johnston had been joined to these proceedings pursuant to leave granted by the Court on 11 May 2006 (Vintage Developments Pty Limited v GHD Pty Limited [2006] FCA 531 (‘Vintage (No 1)’). In Vintage (No 2), Mr Johnston submitted that Vintage’s motion was the first time Vintage had applied to the Court for an order to amend the application and statement of claim in a way that pleaded a case against him. It was said to follow, despite the decision in Vintage (No 1) where similar arguments were canvassed and rejected, that the proposed second further amended statement of claim disclosed a new (and statute barred) cause of action against Mr Johnston. That submission was not adopted by Hunter Valley and I rejected it (Vintage (No 2) at [32]). An appeal by Mr Johnston from the decision in Vintage (No 1), after the publication of reasons in Vintage (No 2), was dismissed by the Full Court: Johnston v Vintage Developments Pty Limited [2006] FCAFC 171. Consideration It is necessary to consider the position of Hunter Valley and Mr Johnston separately. Hunter Valley Vintage submits that it should only be liable to pay 75% of Hunter Valley’s costs incurred after 15 September 2006 because:·Vintage was granted leave to make the first set of amendments and successfully defended Hunter Valley’s submission as to the date on which the amendments should take effect; ·Hunter Valley put itself to unnecessary expense in seeking irrelevant information by its notice to produce dated 26 September 2006. That information, if relevant at all, related only to an application for security for costs not the subject of the hearing. Vintage’s evidence on its motion to amend was voluminous. The amendments were sought as a matter of urgency to give effect to a transaction involving Errol Investments, which transaction was unrelated to these proceedings. The amendments were to correct mistakes or omissions in the pleadings and to give effect to Vintage’s own commercial arrangements. There can be no doubt that, subject to an unreasonable position taken by Hunter Valley, Vintage is liable for the costs of amendment. The position taken by Hunter Valley in contesting the amendments was not unreasonable. It was common ground that the limitation period had expired and arguable that the amendments should take effect on the date of filing the amended documents. Moreover, Hunter Valley was successful in contesting the second set of amendments. There is no justification for reducing payment of Hunter Valley’s costs to 75% of costs incurred after 15 September 2006. Whether the documents sought by Hunter Valley’s notice to produce dated 26 September 2006 are relevant to Vintage’s motion for leave to amend is a matter to be determined, if necessary, by a taxing officer. Mr Johnston Vintage submits that, in correspondence between the parties, Mr Johnston also sought irrelevant information and that his costs should be reduced for that reason. As with Hunter Valley, that is a matter for taxation.