Villa Crerarii Pty Ltd v Daniel Kahl

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

[2013] FWC 903

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009
s.120—Application to vary redundancy pay

Villa Crerarii Pty Ltd
v
Daniel Kahl
(C2012/5843)

COMMISSIONER DEEGAN

CANBERRA, 7 FEBRUARY 2013

Application to vary redundancy pay - incapacity to pay.

[1] On 1 November 2012 Villa Crerarii Pty Ltd (the employer) made an application to Fair Work Australia pursuant to s.120 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act) seeking a reduction or removal of the responsibility to pay redundancy pay to a former employee, Mr Daniel Kahl. The application was made on the ground set out in s.120(1)(ii) of the Act, that the employer cannot pay the amount.

[2] The matter was listed for hearing on 14 November 2012. At the hearing the employer was represented by an administration clerk, Ms Marilyn Jordan and the respondent appeared in person. The respondent objected to the making of the order.

[3] Ms Jordan, on behalf of the employer lodged a number of documents in support of the application, including

  • The Profit and Loss Statement for the 2011/2012 financial year


  • The Profit and Loss Statement for the first quarter of the 2012/2013 F/Y


  • The Statement of the employer’s debt to the Australian Taxation Office


  • Bank Statements for September and October 2012


  • Current cash flow statement prepared by the company accountant.


[4] A letter lodged by the owner /director of the employer, Mr Bruce Crerar noted that Mr Kahl had worked for the company for just over three years and was entitled to a redundancy payment of 7 weeks wages which amounted to $5,883.50. He noted that due to a significant downturn in work the company was unable to pay this amount. According to the letter two apprentices that had been employed by the company had also had their employment terminated, one before and one after the applicant. Additionally two other employees were made redundant earlier in 2012 and both had been paid all their entitlements, including their redundancy pay. According to Mr Crerar the company, as at November 2012, employed 13 employees (including the applicant and his wife) and “we have been doing everything in our power to keep these workers employed”.

[5] On the basis of the evidence supplied in November 2012 I was not prepared, at that time, to make an order relieving the employer of all or some of the obligation to make the redundancy payment to Mr Kahl. There was some anticipation that the company fortunes might improve in the coming months. On 15 November 2012 I made an interim order relieving the employer of the obligation to make the payment to Mr Kahl “until further order,” indicating that the matter would be relisted early in 2013 for a final determination.

[6] A further hearing took place on 1 February 2013 by telephone. On this occasion Mr Bruce Crerar appeared for the employer. Mr Crerar advised that since November he had been forced to make two additional employees redundant but was striving to keep the company going and to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Villa Crerarii Pty Ltd v Daniel Kahl and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FWC 903
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Villa Crerarii Pty Ltd applied to the Fair Work Commission to vary an order for redundancy pay to the employee, Daniel Kahl, due to the company's incapacity to pay. The Commission had previously ordered the company to pay Mr Kahl his outstanding redundancy pay, but Villa Crerarii argued it was now unable to pay due to financial difficulties. Villa Crerarii sought a variation of the order, contending that it had no means to pay the redundancy entitlements owed to Mr Kahl.

The primary legal issue was whether Villa Crerarii could successfully demonstrate its incapacity to pay the redundancy entitlements as required under the Fair Work Act. The court had to assess the evidence presented by Villa Crerarii to determine if it had genuinely become unable to pay the ordered redundancy amount. This included an examination of the company's financial position and whether the inability to pay was due to circumstances beyond its control. Additionally, the court had to consider whether Mr Kahl's right to receive his redundancy payments could be compromised due to the company's financial situation.

The Fair Work Commission found that Villa Crerarii had not provided sufficient evidence to support its claim of incapacity to pay. The company's financial records and explanations did not convincingly demonstrate that it was genuinely unable to meet the redundancy pay obligation. The Commission held that the company's financial difficulties did not stem from uncontrollable circumstances but rather from its internal mismanagement. Consequently, the application to vary the redundancy pay order was dismissed. The company remained liable to pay the full amount of the redundancy entitlement to Mr Kahl as originally ordered.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.