Victorian Producers' Co-operative Co Ltd v Kenneth

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Victorian Producers’ Co-Operative Co Ltd v Kenneth [1999] FCA 1488

BANKRUPTCY – whether transfer of property, being live stock, under a mortgage of live stock is void against the trustee – whether value of forbearance to recover indebtedness of debtors is less than the market value of the live stock transferred under the mortgage

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) ss 120, 139ZQ and 139ZS

Halse v Norton (1997) 76 FCR 389 – cited
Ogilvie v Adams (1981) VR 1041 – distinguished
Sutherland v Brien [1999] NSWSC 155 - considered

VICTORIAN PRODUCERS’ CO-OPERATIVE COMPANY LIMITED V KENNETH AND OTHERS
VG 7754 OF 1998

JUDGE:        MERKEL J
PLACE:        MELBOURNE
DATE:          29 OCTOBER 1999

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VG 7754 OF 1998

IN THE MATTER OF the bankrupt estate of Robert William Heather and Martha Faye Heather

BETWEEN:

VICTORIAN PRODUCERS' CO-OPERATIVE COMPANY LIMITED (ACN 004 059 607)
Applicant

AND:

PHILIP KENNETH AGGS in his capacity as Trustee of the bankrupt estate of Robert William Heather and
Martha Faye Heather
First Respondent

GEORGE LIONEL CADDY in his capacity as Official Receiver for the Bankruptcy District of the Australian Capital Territory
Second Respondent

PHILIP KENNETH AGGS in his capacity as Trustee of the bankrupt estate of Robert William Heather and
Martha Faye Heather
Cross-Claimant

VICTORIAN PRODUCERS' CO-OPERATIVE COMPANY LIMITED (CAN 004 059 607)
Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

MERKEL J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 OCTOBER 1999

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.   The Application dated 1 October 1998 be dismissed.

2.   A declaration be made that the transfer of property made under the mortgage granted by RW and MF Heather to the applicant dated 14 November 1995 is void against the first respondent.

3.   The applicant pay to the first respondent the sum of $34,725.39.

4.   The applicant pay the respondents’ taxed costs of the Application and the Cross Claim dated 12 February 1999.

5.   Reserve liberty to apply in respect of interest.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VG 7754 OF 1998

IN THE MATTER OF the bankrupt estate of Robert William Heather and
Martha Faye Heather

BETWEEN:

VICTORIAN PRODUCERS' CO-OPERATIVE COMPANY LIMITED (ACN 004 059 607)
Applicant

AND:

PHILIP KENNETH AGGS in his capacity as Trustee of the bankrupt estate of Robert William Heather and
Martha Faye Heather
First Respondent

GEORGE LIONEL CADDY in his capacity as Official Receiver for the Bankruptcy District of the Australian Capital Territory
Second Respondent

PHILIP KENNETH AGGS in his capacity as Trustee of the bankrupt estate of Robert William Heather and
Martha Faye Heather
Cross-Claimant

VICTORIAN PRODUCERS' CO-OPERATIVE COMPANY LIMITED (ACN 004 059 607)
Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

MERKEL J

DATE:

29 OCTOBER 1999

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. The present matter relates to a dispute concerning a mortgage of live stock granted by Robert William Heather and Martha Faye Heather (“the debtors”) to Victorian Producers Co-operative Company Limited (“the Co-operative”)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Victorian Producers' Co-operative Co Ltd v Kenneth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] FCA 1488
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Victorian Producers' Co-operative Co Ltd v Kenneth, the central dispute involved a mortgage of livestock granted by Robert William Heather and Martha Faye Heather to the Victorian Producers Co-operative Company Limited on 14 November 1995. The first respondent, the trustee, and the second respondent, the official receiver, sought to declare the mortgage void against the trustee, contending that the value of the consideration given by the Co-operative was less than the market value of the livestock. The dispute was heard and determined by the relevant Australian court.

The primary legal issues the court needed to resolve were whether the transfer of livestock under the mortgage was void against the trustee because the value of the consideration given by the Co-operative was less than the market value of the livestock, and if so, whether the trustee was required to compensate the Co-operative under s 120(4) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966. The consideration given by the Co-operative was its agreement to forbear from immediately suing the debtors and to continue providing credit, which the court found to have value, albeit potentially less than the market value of the livestock. The court examined the nature of the forbearance and the credit arrangement between the parties to determine the actual value of the consideration provided.

The court concluded that the consideration given by the Co-operative for the mortgage was its agreement to forbear from taking steps to recover the debtors' indebtedness and to continue providing credit. Although this forbearance had value, the court determined that its value was less than the market value of the livestock. Consequently, the transfer of property under the mortgage was void against the trustee. The court further found that the trustee was not required to pay the Co-operative under s 120(4) because the total amount advanced by the Co-operative in reliance on the mortgage was $6,438.48. Therefore, the trustee was entitled to a declaration that the transfer of property under the mortgage was void, and the net indebtedness of the Co-operative to the trustee was $34,725.39. The court ordered that the application be dismissed and that the Co-operative pay the trustee's and the official receiver's costs.

In summary, the court held that the mortgage was void against the trustee, and the Co-operative was required to compensate the trustee for the net indebtedness. The decision provided clarity on the application of s 120 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 in the context of a mortgage of livestock and the valuation of forbearance as consideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Application dated 1 October 1998 be dismissed.

2. A declaration be made that the transfer of property made under the mortgage granted by RW and MF Heather to the applicant dated 14 November 1995 is void against the first respondent.

3. The applicant pay to the first respondent the sum of $34,725.39.

4. The applicant pay the respondents’ taxed costs of the Application and the Cross Claim dated 12 February 1999.

5. Reserve liberty to apply in respect of interest.

Background

Background to the litigation

The present matter relates to a dispute concerning a mortgage of live stock granted by Robert William Heather and Martha Faye Heather (“the debtors”) to Victorian Producers Co-operative Company Limited (“the Co-operative”) on 14 November 1995. The first respondent (“the trustee”) and the second respondent (“the official receiver”) claim that the mortgage is void against the trustee pursuant to s 120 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (“the Act”) on the ground that the value of the consideration given by the Co-operative for the mortgage was less than the market value of the live stock the subject of the mortgage.Background On or about 1 March 1993 the Co-operative and the debtors entered into an arrangement pursuant to which the Co-operative was to provide credit to the debtors to enable them to purchase live stock for later resale by the Co-operative. The arrangement was that the debtors would obtain live stock from the Co-operative on credit, fatten the stock on their property and, in due course, deliver the live stock to the Co-operative for sale. In the usual course, the debit balance on the debtors’ account with the Co-operative was to be reduced by the Co-operative applying the proceeds of sale in reduction of the debtors’ indebtedness to the Co-operative. Although an application for finance was signed by the debtors the application did not contain details of the terms upon which loans made by the Co-operative were to be repayable. The arrangement between the debtors and the Co-operative resulted in the debtors being indebted to the Co-operative in the sum of $78,878 on 14 November 1995. The Co-operative was concerned that the amount owing had “got a bit high” and requested that the debtors mortgage their live stock to secure their indebtedness, from time to time, to the Co-operative. The debtors agreed to that request and executed the mortgage. Under the mortgage the debtors covenanted to grant, assign, transfer and assure to the Co-operative the live stock of the debtors described in the Schedule (which had a value at the time that approximated the amount of the indebtedness), progeny of that live stock and other live stock acquired by the debtors from time to time. The consideration for the mortgage was stated to be the Co-operative’s agreement, at the request of the debtors, to forebear from immediately suing for the amount of the indebtedness. In the ensuing twelve months the Co-operative, in reliance upon its security under the mortgage, advanced to the debtors further amounts totalling $6,438.48. At the date of the mortgage, as a result of the failure of their timber milling business, the debtors were unable to pay all of their debts as they fell due. The debtors were indebted to Westpac Banking Corporation in an amount in excess of $1 million. After certain demands by the bank for payment had not been complied with by the debtors, the bank proceeded to exercise its rights under the real property mortgages granted to it by the debtors. After the realisation of the securities the debtors remained indebted to the bank in the sum of approximately $680,000. A bankruptcy notice, which was issued on behalf of the bank on 27 February 1997, led to the debtors declaring themselves bankrupt on their own petition on 9 April 1997. Accordingly, the bankruptcy of the debtors commenced on that date.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The trustee has also applied a common sense approach to valuing the other aspect of the consideration given by the Co-operative, being the making of further advances under the credit arrangement. The trustee has conceded, correctly in my view, that it is appropriate to regard the value of the consideration given by the Co-operative as the amount that was, in fact, advanced, in reliance upon the mortgage, as a result of the continuation of the credit arrangement. As the advances totalled the sum of $6,438.48 the total amount the trustee is required to pay to the Co-operative under s 120(4) is the sum of $10,438.48.Conclusion It follows from the foregoing that:· the application of the Co-operative under s 139ZS must fail;· the trustee is entitled to a declaration that the transfer of property under the mortgage is void against the trustee;· the Co-operative is obliged to pay to the trustee the proceeds it received as a result of the sale of live stock pursuant to the mortgage, being the sum of $45,163.87, less the amount the trustee is obliged to pay to the Co-operative under s 120(4), being the sum of $10,438.48. Accordingly, the net indebtedness of the Co-operative to the trustee is the sum of $34,725.39. As the trustee has succeeded in its claims in the proceeding, including the cross-claim, it is appropriate that the Co-operative pay the trustee’s and the official receiver’s taxed costs of and incidental to the proceeding and the cross-claim.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Accordingly, the present proceeding requires determination of the following issues:· whether the transfer of live stock under the mortgage is void against the trustee on the ground that the value of the consideration given by the Co-operative for the transfer was less than the market value of the live stock transferred: see s 120(1)(b);· in the event that the transfer of live stock under the mortgage is void against the trustee whether the trustee is required, under s 120(4), to pay to the Co-operative a sum equal to the value of any consideration that the Co-operative gave for the transfer of property pursuant to the mortgage?The consideration given for the Mortgage It is common ground that s 120 applies to the mortgage in the event that the Court is satisfied that the value of the consideration given by the Co-operative was less than the market value of the live stock mortgaged. The mortgage states that the consideration is the Co-operative’s agreement to “forebear from immediately suing” the debtors in respect of their indebtedness. As was stated at para 84.14 of the Explanatory Memorandum to the Bankruptcy Legislation Amendment Bill 1996, which enacted s 120 in its current form:“Forbearance to sue has always been regarded at law as good consideration. Such forbearance will, under the Act as proposed to be amended by the Bill, have to be looked at in the light of the likely value of the chose in action.” In the present matter the evidence does not establish that the Co-operative was entitled to “immediately” sue the debtors and recover the amount of their indebtedness to it without giving reasonable notice that repayment of their debt is required. Accordingly, the likely value of a forbearance from “immediately” suing is problematic. Counsel for the trustee relied upon Ogilvie v Adams (1981) VR 1041 at 1043 to contend that where a loan of money is made and nothing is said as to repayment the money is repayable without prior demand. In my view that is not the situation in the present case. It was a term of the credit arrangement entered into between the Co-operative and the debtors that, in the usual course, the loans that were made from time to time to enable the purchase of live stock would be repayable out of the proceeds of sale of the live stock after the fattening of that stock on the debtors’ property. In the absence of breach, termination of that arrangement may require reasonable notice. There may be no entitlement to repayment without the giving of that notice. Thus, a forbearance from “immediately suing” the debtors may have little value. It is unnecessary to pursue that matter further as I am satisfied that the consideration actually given by the Co-operative for the mortgage was its agreement to forebear from taking such steps, as were within its power to take, to recover the amount of the debtor’s indebtedness to the Co-operative and to continue to provide credit on the same basis as had previously been provided. Although that consideration has value the issue is whether that value is less than the market value of the live stock the subject of the mortgage.