-
R v Clark
[2023] SASCA 15
Citation 1
…constitute a refusal. It is a question of fact to be inferred from all the circumstances, and in this context the remarks of Geoffrey Lane J in R v Clark (1969) 53 Cr App Rep 438 at 442; [1969] 2 All ER 1008 at 1010, dealing it is true with different words in an English Act of Parliament but one that was enacted in…
-
DPP v Piscopo
[2011] VSCA 275
Citation 2
…[17] [2011] VSCA 275, paragraph 38, citing, note 4, “ DPP v Foster [1999] 2 VR 643, 652 [29] (Winneke P, with whom Batt JA agreed ‘in all respects’ and with whom Ormiston JA agreed, with one reservation)”.…
-
Mastwyk v DPP
[2010] VSCA 111
Citation 3
…necessary to meet the purposes of the section and the Act. [26] [24] Hrysikos v Mansfield [2002] VSCA 175, paragraph 3, approved in Mastwyk v DPP (2010) 27 VR 92, per Nettle JA at paragraphs 39-41 and Redlich JA, paragraphs, 60-65. [25] Mastwyk v DPP (2010) 27 VR 92, per Redlich JA, paragraphs 66, 75. [26] DPP (20…
-
Hrysikos v Mansfield
[2002] VSCA 175
Citation 4
…triction on individual liberty that goes beyond what is necessary to meet the purposes of the section and the Act. [26] [24] Hrysikos v Mansfield [2002] VSCA 175, paragraph 3, approved in Mastwyk v DPP (2010) 27 VR 92, per Nettle JA at paragraphs 39-41 and Redlich JA, paragraphs, 60-65. [25] Mastwyk v DPP (2010) 2…
-
Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority
[1998] HCA 53
Citation 5
…[12] (1998) 194 CLR 355.…
-
Simic v The Queen
[1980] HCA 25
Citation 6
(Para 1)
…ength of the Prosecution evidence before the Court supporting the charges, her prior good character has limited probative value. [1] In Simic v R (1980) 144 CLR 319 at paragraph 24, the High Court stated that “it is obvious that whether evidence of good character will be of any avail to an accused person depends on t…
-
Ball v Chargelegue
[2016] VSC 294
Citation 7
…ons, 27 December 2016 at page 2, citing DPP v Serbest [2012] VSC 35; Sanzaro v County Court [2004] VSC 30 per Nettle J at para 73; Ball v Chargelegue [2016] VSC 294; DPP v Vaa [2004] VSC 444, para 10..…
-
Director of Public Prosecutions v Kaba
[2014] VSC 52
Citation 8
…“lawfulness” beyond reasonable doubt, the charge must be dismissed as it is no offence to refuse an unlawful requirement. Bell J in DPP v Kaba [2014] VSC 52 states at [481-2] “Any violation of a Charter right should be regarded as serious .”[35] [35] Ibid.…
-
Halley v Kershaw
[2013] VSC 439
Citation 9
…ith s 3 RSA definition of `drive’. The definition of `in charge’ is contained in s 3AA RSA (also see Halley v Kershaw [2013] VSC 439 [4] to [7], [26] to [33]. [41] & [46] re discussion of what is in charge.” The pleaded offences are one of ‘driving’ rather than one of `in charge’ – the evidence reveal that the pr…
-
Director of Public Prosecutions v Skafidiotis
[2013] VSC 258
Citation 10
…40] Reddy v Ross [1973] VR 462; Hrysikos v Mansfield (2002) 5 VR 485. [41] Hrysikos v Mansfield (2002) 5 VR 485. See also DPP v Skafidiotis [2013] VSC 258, paragraph 24.…
-
Director of Public Prosecutions v Blango
[2012] VSC 384
Citation 11
…sal to undergo the test.[6]” [43] Connellan et al, Road Safety Law In Victoria 2015, p.226, citing Bearsdley v Hower (1993) 19 MVR 15; DPP v Blango [2012] VSC 384. [44] [2012] VSC 384, at paragraph 8.…
-
DPP v Serbest
[2012] VSC 35
Citation 12
…[6] Defence submissions, 27 December 2016 at page 2, citing DPP v Serbest [2012] VSC 35; Sanzaro v County Court [2004] VSC 30 per Nettle J at para 73; Ball v Chargelegue [2016] VSC 294; DPP v Vaa [2004] VSC 444, para 10..…
-
Sanzaro v County Court of Victoria
[2004] VSC 444
Citation 13
…age 2, citing DPP v Serbest [2012] VSC 35; Sanzaro v County Court [2004] VSC 30 per Nettle J at para 73; Ball v Chargelegue [2016] VSC 294; DPP v Vaa [2004] VSC 444, para 10..…
-
R v Gemmill
[2004] VSC 30
Citation 14
…[6] Defence submissions, 27 December 2016 at page 2, citing DPP v Serbest [2012] VSC 35; Sanzaro v County Court [2004] VSC 30 per Nettle J at para 73; Ball v Chargelegue [2016] VSC 294; DPP v Vaa [2004] VSC 444, para 10..…