Victor Charles Ndubueze v AWX Labour Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read
[2024] FWC 2874

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.365—General protections

Victor Charles Ndubueze
v

AWX Labour Pty Ltd

(C2024/5836)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT MILLHOUSE

MELBOURNE, 16 OCTOBER 2024

Application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal

  1. Mr Victor Charles Ndubueze made a general protections application involving dismissal pursuant to s 365 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (Act) on 20 August 2024. The application has been made against AWX Labour Pty Ltd, a labour hire company.

  1. Section 365(1) of the Act prescribes that a general protections application involving dismissal must be made within 21 days after the dismissal took effect or within such further period as the Commission allows under s 366(2). As the Form F8 application records Mr Ndubueze’s contention that he was dismissed by the respondent with effect on 31 May 2024, the Commission raised a concern with the parties that the application was filed outside the 21-day statutory timeframe.

  1. In its Form F8A response to the application, the respondent objects to Mr Ndubueze’s application because it contends that Mr Ndubueze was not dismissed by it. Rather, the respondent contends that Mr Ndubueze is an ongoing casual on hire/assignment employee.

  1. For the reasons that follow, I am not satisfied that there are exceptional circumstances. Accordingly, the discretion to extend the time in which the application may be made is not enlivened.

Relevant factual findings

  1. Mr Ndubueze commenced employment with the respondent on 11 April 2024.[1] While Mr Ndubueze contests that he digitally signed the offer of employment produced by the respondent,[2] the respondent says that Mr Ndubueze was employed by it on a casual on-hire/assignment basis to perform work for the respondent’s clients as required from time to time.[3] Notwithstanding, Mr Ndubueze accepts that he signed a five page employment offer from the respondent which was provided to him in hard copy in the respondent’s offices on 11 April 2024.

  1. Mr Ndubueze contends in his application that he was dismissed with effect on 31 May 2024.[4] However, the submissions and evidence relied upon by Mr Ndubueze demonstrates that he was offered and accepted a shift by the respondent on 18 July 2024.[5] In the proceeding before me, Mr Ndubueze submitted that he was instead dismissed by the respondent on 18 July 2024 upon the conclusion of his shift that day, noting that no further shifts have been offered to him.

  1. The respondent rejects the contention that Mr Ndubueze has been dismissed by it at all.

  1. As explained to the parties, noting the dispute as to whether Mr Ndubueze was dismissed or not, I will proceed on the assumption – without deciding – that Mr Ndubueze was dismissed by the respondent on 18 July 2024 as he contends, solely for the purposes of considering whether to grant a further period having regard to the matters in s 366(2) of the Act.

  1. Having regard to Mr Ndubueze’s contended date of dismissal of 18 July 2024, for the application to have been within time it must have been filed by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Victor Charles Ndubueze v AWX Labour Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FWC 2874
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Victor Charles Ndubueze filed an application against AWX Labour Pty Ltd, a labour hire company, claiming dismissal in contravention of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The application was made beyond the 21-day statutory timeframe prescribed by s 365(1) of the Act, raising concerns about its timeliness. AWX Labour objected to the application, asserting that Mr Ndubueze had not been dismissed but remained an ongoing casual employee. The central legal issue was whether the Fair Work Commission had the discretion to extend the time for filing the application due to alleged exceptional circumstances under s 366(2) of the Act.

The Deputy President, Millhouse, evaluated the application against the statutory criteria for exceptional circumstances, which include the reason for the delay, any actions taken by the applicant to dispute the dismissal, prejudice to the employer, the merits of the application, and fairness between the applicant and others in similar positions. Mr Ndubueze argued that he delayed filing his application while trying to resolve a non-payment issue and awaiting a response to his discrimination concerns. However, the Deputy President found that these reasons did not constitute acceptable or reasonable explanations for the delay. Furthermore, Mr Ndubueze did not take any positive steps to dispute his alleged dismissal prior to filing the application. The merits of the substantive application were considered neutral due to the contested facts and lack of evidence. The Deputy President concluded that the circumstances did not amount to exceptional circumstances, thereby denying the application for an extension of time. Consequently, the application was dismissed.

The final order of the Fair Work Commission was that Mr Ndubueze's general protections application was dismissed, and no extension of time was granted.

Background

Background to the litigation

Victor Charles Ndubueze commenced employment with AWX Labour Pty Ltd on 11 April 2024, as a casual on-hire/assignment employee. The employment involved performing work for AWX Labour's clients as required. Mr Ndubueze contends that he was dismissed by AWX Labour on 31 May 2024, though the respondent denies this and claims his employment status remains active as a casual employee. Mr Ndubueze subsequently submitted that his dismissal occurred on 18 July 2024, after which he was offered and accepted a shift. He alleges that he was dismissed on 18 July 2024 upon the conclusion of his shift that day, with no further shifts offered to him. Mr Ndubueze filed a general protections application involving dismissal on 20 August 2024, outside the statutory 21-day timeframe.

Mr Ndubueze filed a general protections application involving dismissal on 20 August 2024 against AWX Labour Pty Ltd pursuant to s 365 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The application was made outside the 21-day statutory timeframe, leading the Commission to raise a concern with the parties about the timeliness of the application. AWX Labour responded to the application, objecting on the grounds that Mr Ndubueze was not dismissed and his employment status remains active as a casual employee. The matter proceeded to a hearing on 10 October 2024.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is there an acceptable or reasonable explanation for the delay in filing the general protections application involving dismissal?
2. Did Mr Ndubueze take action to dispute the dismissal prior to filing the general protections application?
3. Does the granting of an extension of time cause prejudice to the respondent?
4. Do the merits of Mr Ndubueze's substantive general protections application weigh in favour of granting an extension of time?
5. Is there fairness as between Mr Ndubueze and other persons in a similar position?
6. Are there exceptional circumstances to warrant an extension of time under s 366(2) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)?

Held
1. There is no acceptable or reasonable explanation for the delay in filing the general protections application involving dismissal.
2. Mr Ndubueze did not take action to dispute the dismissal prior to filing the general protections application.
3. The granting of an extension of time does not cause prejudice to the respondent.
4. The merits of Mr Ndubueze's substantive general protections application weigh neutrally in the assessment of whether to grant an extension of time.
5. The factor of fairness as between Mr Ndubueze and other persons in a similar position is neutral in the assessment of whether to grant an extension of time.
6. There are no exceptional circumstances to warrant an extension of time under s 366(2) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The decision revolves around the assessment of whether there are exceptional circumstances under s 366(2) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) to warrant an extension of time for Mr Victor Charles Ndubueze to file his general protections application involving dismissal. The Deputy President, Millhouse, meticulously examined various statutory criteria to determine the existence of exceptional circumstances. The reasoning process began by considering the reason for the delay. Mr Ndubueze argued that he waited for the respondent to resolve his concerns about non-payment and alleged racial discrimination. However, the Deputy President concluded that Mr Ndubueze's actions did not provide an acceptable or reasonable explanation for the delay as he did not actively dispute the dismissal but rather inquired about his employment status and pay concerns. The court considered the action taken by Mr Ndubueze to dispute the dismissal and found that while he made inquiries, he did not take positive steps to contest the dismissal, which weighed against granting an extension of time. The Deputy President then assessed the potential prejudice to the employer, finding none that would support the grant of an extension. The merits of Mr Ndubueze's substantive application were deemed neutral, as the court could not fully assess the merits without proceeding with the substantive application. Lastly, fairness as between Mr Ndubueze and other persons in a similar position was also considered neutral, as no specific material was provided to demonstrate differential treatment. Weighing all these factors, the Deputy President concluded that there were no exceptional circumstances to justify an extension of time, thus dismissing Mr Ndubueze's application.