VHX (a pseudonym) v JZT (a pseudonym) and State Trustees Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S EAPCI 2024 0004
VHX (A PSEUDONYM) Applicant
v
JZT (A PSEUDONYM) First Respondent
STATE TRUSTEES LTD Second Respondent

---

JUDGES: BEACH and LYONS JJA
WHERE HELD: Melbourne
DATE OF HEARING: 11 October 2024
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 16 October 2024
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2024] VSCA 238
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: [2023] VSC 683 (Quigley J)

---

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Guardianship and administration – Application for leave to appeal from decision refusing leave to appeal from VCAT – Whether primary judge erred in refusing recusal application – Whether primary judge biased – Whether primary judge misconstrued provision of Guardianship and Administration Act 2019 – Whether primary judge erred in refusing applicant leave to appeal – Whether primary judge denied represented person her human rights – Asserted errors not reasonably arguable – Proposed appeal having no prospects of success – Application for leave to appeal refused.

Guardianship and Administration Act 2019, ss 8, 9 and 30.

---

Counsel

Applicant: In person
First Respondent: No appearance
Second Respondent: Mr P Over

Solicitors

Applicant:
First Respondent: Hartleys Lawyers
Second Respondent: Legal Branch, STL Ltd

BEACH JA
LYONS JA:

  1. The applicant, VHX,[1] and the first respondent, JZT, are sons of RP. Pursuant to an order, first made in January 2018 in the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (‘VCAT’ or ‘the Tribunal’), the second respondent, State Trustees Ltd, is the administrator for RP in accordance with the provisions of the Guardianship and Administration Act 2019 (‘the GA Act’). That order has been the subject of various applications and reviews in VCAT, as well as proceedings brought in the Supreme Court by the applicant to challenge decisions of the Tribunal with which he was dissatisfied.

    [1]Pursuant to orders made in the Trial Division on 24 October 2023, the applicant, the first respondent and their mother were referred to by the pseudonyms VHX, JZT and RP respectively. For convenience, we will adopt the pseudonyms ordered by the Trial Division (noting that on some occasions in that Court, pseudonyms have been confused and RP has been incorrectly referred to as JZT, although no party sought to take any point in relation to these misidentifications).

  2. In the present proceeding in this Court, the applicant seeks leave to appeal from orders made by Quigley J in the Trial Division, on 23 November 2023,[2] refusing him leave to appeal from orders made by Senior Member B Hoysted in VCAT, on 5 April 2023, which orders continued the appointment of the second respondent as administrator for RP.[3] For the reasons that follow, the application for leave to appeal must be refused.

    [2]VHX v JZT [2023] VSC 683 (‘Quigley J Reasons’).

    [3]NJA (Guardianship) [2023] VCAT 572 (‘VCAT Reasons’). ‘NJA’ was the pseudonym used by the Tribunal when it referred to RP.

    Background

  3. The primary judge described the background to this matter as ‘a tale of unhappiness and family dysfunction, with long held and deep-seated resentments evident in the expression and behaviour of [the applicant],…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read VHX (a pseudonym) v JZT (a pseudonym) and State Trustees Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] VSCA 238
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In VHX (a pseudonym) v JZT (a pseudonym) and State Trustees Ltd, the applicant, VHX, sought leave to appeal against the decisions made by the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) and the Trial Division of the Supreme Court of Victoria. The applicant contested the orders continuing the appointment of JZT as the administrator for RP, who is under guardianship. The applicant argued that VCAT and the Trial Division had erred in their decisions and that the administration of RP’s estate was not in her best interests.

The primary legal issues revolved around whether the primary judge in the Trial Division erred in refusing the recusal application and whether the judge was biased. Additionally, the applicant contested the interpretation of a provision in the Guardianship and Administration Act 2019 and questioned whether the primary judge had misconstrued the Act. The applicant also argued that the primary judge had denied RP her human rights by not allowing the appeal. The court needed to determine if these asserted errors were reasonably arguable and if the proposed appeal had any prospects of success.

The court examined the arguments put forward by the applicant and found that the alleged errors were not reasonably arguable. The court held that the primary judge had not erred in refusing the recusal application or in their interpretation of the Guardianship and Administration Act 2019. The court concluded that the primary judge had not denied RP her human rights and that the proposed appeal had no prospects of success. Therefore, the application for leave to appeal was refused.

The court's final orders confirmed the refusal of the applicant's leave to appeal against the decisions of VCAT and the Trial Division. The administration of RP's estate continued under the second respondent, JZT. The court emphasized the importance of maintaining the status quo in such sensitive matters until a valid and successful appeal could be mounted.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the present proceeding in this Court, the applicant seeks leave to appeal from orders made by Quigley J in the Trial Division, on 23 November 2023,[2] refusing him leave to appeal from orders made by Senior Member B Hoysted in VCAT, on 5 April 2023, which orders continued the appointment of the second respondent as administrator for RP.[3] For the reasons that follow, the application for leave to appeal must be refused.[2]VHX v JZT [2023] VSC 683 (‘Quigley J Reasons’).[3]NJA (Guardianship) [2023] VCAT 572 (‘VCAT Reasons’). ‘NJA’ was the pseudonym used by the Tribunal when it referred to RP.Background The primary judge described the background to this matter as ‘a tale of unhappiness and family dysfunction, with long held and deep-seated resentments evident in the expression and behaviour of [the applicant], coupled with distrust and resort to conspiracy as justification for any adverse decisions made in respect of the management of [RP’s] legal and financial affairs’.[4][4]Quigley J Reasons, [2]. The genesis of the various proceedings between the parties was an application made by the applicant, in November 2017, for orders appointing him as the guardian and administrator of RP. The application was contested by the first respondent as well as another of RP’s sons and RP’s then estranged husband, who is now deceased. In resisting the applicant’s application, they contended that RP required an independent guardian and administrator. The Tribunal heard the applicant’s application on 15 January 2018 and was satisfied that RP had a disability and needed an independent guardian and administrator. Instead of appointing the applicant to those roles, the Tribunal appointed the Public Advocate as RP’s guardian, and the second respondent as administrator of her estate. The guardianship order is no longer in force and, as we have said, the second respondent remains administrator of RP’s estate. In its January 2018 order appointing the second respondent as administrator, the Tribunal directed that the order would continue to have effect ‘until further order of the Tribunal’. Following that order, various orders have been made by the Tribunal relating to the administration order.[5] It is not necessary to set out the detail of those orders or the detail of an earlier application for leave to appeal brought by the applicant in the Trial Division in 2022. For present purposes, it is sufficient to turn directly to the hearing at VCAT which gave rise to the orders of 5 April 2023 about which the applicant makes complaint.[5]Orders were made in the Tribunal on 21 May 2020, 10 March 2021 and 31 May 2021. Pursuant to orders previously made, VCAT commenced a reassessment of RP’s administration order on 16 May 2022. The reassessment was required to be adjourned pending the outcome of the applicant’s earlier Trial Division proceeding. The reassessment hearing continued in September 2022, and was finalised on 5 April 2023. During the reassessment hearing, the Tribunal heard from the applicant, a witness who gave evidence on behalf of the first respondent, and two witnesses from the second respondent. While RP attended the hearing, and attempts were made by the Tribunal to communicate with her, she was not relevantly responsive in any way.[6] At the reassessment hearing, the applicant asserted that, in the words of s 8(1)(b) of the GA Act, it was RP’s ‘will and preferences’ that he be appointed as her administrator.[7][6]VCAT Reasons, [12], [22].[7]Ibid [23].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.