VGYL and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

VGYL and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2017] AATA 1551 (22 September 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2016/5730

Re:VGYL

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndBYQZ

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Miss E A Shanahan, Member

Date:22 September 2017

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT 1st Tier), that between 23 March 2015 and 12 May 2015, VGYL had sole care of his daughters by virtue of Special Circumstances.

The reviewable decision of the AAT 1st Tier in relation to the percentage of care is set aside and the Tribunal determines that from 13 May 2015 the percentage of care provided by VGYL is 37 per cent and the percentage of care provided by BYQZ is 63 per cent. 

[sgd]........................................................................

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

CHILD SUPPORT – Family Court Orders – father actual care 100 per cent for a period of 50 days – mother being investigated for child assault – charges dropped – Special Circumstances found – Federal Circuit Court percentage care orders reinstated – decision in relation to percentage of care thereafter set aside

Legislation

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)
Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth)

A New Tax System (Family Assistance) Act 1999 (Cth)

Cases

Re Parent A and Child Support Registrar and Another (2013) 137 ALD 426
Polec v Staker [2011] FMCAFAM 959

P v Child Support Registrar [2014] FCAFC 98

Secondary Materials

Child Support Guide

REASONS FOR DECISION

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

22 September 2017

  1. On 26 October 2016 VGYL lodged an application for review by the General and Other Divisions of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT General Division). The reviewable decision in this case is that of the Social Security and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT 1st Tier) dated 13 January 2016.  The application to the AAT General Division related only to that part of the AAT 1st Tier decision concerning the percentage of care between VGYL and BYQZ. VGYL accepted and agreed with the AAT 1st Tier decision relating to the 50 day period in which he had been found, by virtue of special circumstances, to have provided 100 per cent of care for his two daughters. 

  2. VGYL was informed by the Child Support Registrar (CSR) or their delegate that in order for the percentage of care to be changed to reflect the delegate’s decisions that from 7 October 2016 he had 36 per cent (and later 39 per cent) of the care of the children and BYQZ had 64 per cent (later 61 per cent), the determination of the AAT 1st Tier must first be revoked.

  3. At the hearing on 4 July 2017 VGYL was self-represented. Ms Belinda Lewis, Senior Government Lawyer of the Department of Human Services (the Department), appeared for the Registrar. Both parents gave evidence, BYQZ by telephone. The Respondent had filed documents in accordance with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read VGYL and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 1551
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) of a decision by the Child Support Registrar (CSR) regarding the percentage of care of two daughters. The applicant, VGYL, sought to challenge the CSR's determination of care percentages, which had been based on Federal Circuit Court consent orders made in October 2014. These orders stipulated a complex care arrangement, with the children otherwise residing with the mother, BYQZ, and the father, VGYL, having care for specific weekends and holidays.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine the correct assessment of actual care percentages for the children, particularly during a period between March and May 2015 when VGYL had sole care. This involved considering whether the existing care arrangement, as established by the Federal Circuit Court orders, accurately reflected the actual care provided, or if special circumstances warranted a departure from the initial percentage assignments. The Tribunal also had to consider the definition of "care arrangement" under the A New Tax System (Family Assistance) Act 1999 and how actual care is worked out under section 54A of the relevant Act.

The Tribunal accepted that the Federal Circuit Court consent orders established a pattern of care. It acknowledged that while the CSR had initially assigned 32% care to VGYL and 68% to BYQZ, a subsequent determination that special circumstances existed for the period of 23 March 2015 to 12 May 2015 was correctly made. Based on the evidence, the Tribunal found that VGYL had 100% actual care of the children during this specific period. The Tribunal also noted that the concept of care is broader than a simple time-based calculation and can allow for flexibility depending on the facts.

The Tribunal's decision affirmed that VGYL had 100% care of the children from 23 March 2015 to 13 May 2015. It was further ordered that from 13 May 2015 onwards, the parties complied with the Federal Circuit Court orders, and the weekend care arrangements would recommence on 22 May 2015.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

At the hearing on 4 July 2017 VGYL was self-represented. Ms Belinda Lewis, Senior Government Lawyer of the Department of Human Services (the Department), appeared for the Registrar. Both parents gave evidence, BYQZ by telephone. The Respondent had filed documents in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 and both parents provided Statements of Facts, Issues and Contentions, as did the Respondent.BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION VGYL and BYQZ are respectively the father and mother of two daughters, born in March 2010 and in July 2011 respectively. A child support system was first registered with the Department on 12 August 2014. A Parenting Plan dated 2 October 2014 was subsequently confirmed by Consent Orders made in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia (FCC) on 29 October 2014. As a result of the latter, the Child Support Division of the Department determined that VGYL had 32 per cent of the care of the daughters and BYQZ had 68 per cent of the care of the daughters. The Minutes of Consent Orders presented to the FCC on 29 October 2014 were seven pages long and had been altered. Several paragraphs had been crossed out and hand-written changes were made throughout the document. This appears to be the copy of the Orders provided to the CSR, although in the actual decision of the FCC, Judge Burchardt had directed that the Applicant file a clean, certified, electronic copy of the Minute in Word Format to.... his chambers. This so called clean copy was provided to the CSR and the Tribunal as an attachment to VGYL’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 25 April 2017. On 20 March 2015, VGYL reported to police that BYQZ had assaulted their eldest daughter. The details of this assault are not relevant given the nature of the application. However, the report prompted an investigation by the police; who, on VGYL’s behalf, supported an Interim Intervention Order. After further investigation, the assault charges were dropped on 1 May 2015. This was because the investigating officer, Leading Senior Constable Sam Island advised on 29 April 2015 that he had, with great reluctance, recommended withdrawal of the Intervention Order application. On 25 May 2015 an officer of the Department decided that the original 32 per cent to VGYL and 68 per cent to BYQZ care assignments remained unchanged for the interim period between 23 March 2015 and 12 May 2015. VGYL contacted the CSR indicating that no consideration had been given to the 100 per cent care he had provided during the period subject to Special Circumstances. The CSR considered his complaint as a new application rather than an objection and on 16 July 2015, confirmed that the care remained at the 32 to 68 per cent ratio. On 11 August 2015 VGYL lodged a formal objection to the decision of 25 May 2015. A determination was made on 16 October 2015 that Special Circumstances did exist. As a result VGYL had 100 per cent care of both children from 23 March 2015 to 30 April 2015 but determined that from 1 May to 12 May 2015 the percentage of care had reverted to the 32 to 68 per cent ratio, the 68 per cent percentage of care being provided by BYQZ.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

BYQZ gave evidence by telephone. She confirmed that she suffered from a mental health disorder which had been diagnosed by a general practitioner and a psychologist as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), the Category 1A stressor being required to found such a diagnosis being identified as the “marital problems”. BYQZ said that while she ran a cleaning business, she was not able to work as most of her time had been taken up with litigation. BYQZ agreed that VGYL had the children solely in his care between 22 March 2015 and 12 May 2015; and when asked by Ms Lewis what action she had taken to re-establish her care of the children, she answered she had got a solicitor. She agreed after some delay, that from 13 May 2015 onwards, she and VGYL had complied with the Court Orders. DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE BYQZ provided a report from her psychologist and it appears that Dr Bell, clinical psychologist, is treating her for depression and anxiety. He has been treating her for five years and attributes her poor mental health to what he described as an invalidating and abusive marital relationship. He has quoted, at some length, a statement given by BYQZ to a court-appointed family counsellor; and it is within this quoted document that she claims that she has PTSD. This letter was written in BYQZ’s appeal for waiver of part or all of her accrued Centrelink debts. RELEVANT LEGISLATION Section 54A of the Act relates to the working out of actual care and extent of care of a child and provides:54A Working out actual care, and extent of care, of a child(1)The actual care of a child that a person has had, or is likely to have, during a care period may be worked out based on the number of nights that the Registrar is satisfied that the child was, or is likely to be, in the care of the person during the care period.(2)The extent of care of a child that a person should have had, or is to have, under a care arrangement during a care period may be worked out based on the number of nights that the child should have been, or is to be, in the care of the person during the care period under the care arrangement.(3)For the purposes of this section, a child cannot be in the care of more than one person at the same time.(4)This section does not limit section 50, 51, 52 or 54.Section 3 of the A New Tax System (Family Assistance) Act 1999 (the Family Assistance Act) defines care arrangement in relation to a child:3 Definitions(1)In this Act, unless the contrary intention appears:...care arrangement in relation to a child means:(a)a written agreement between the parents of the child, or between a parent of the child and another person who cares for the child, that relates to the care of the child; or(b)a parenting plan for the child; or(c)any of the following orders relating to the child:(i)a family violence order within the meaning of section 4 of the Family Law Act 1975;(ii)a parenting order within the meaning of section 64B of that Act;(iii)a State child order registered in accordance with section 70D of that Act;(iv)an overseas child order registered in accordance with section 70G of that Act.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Lewis made no contentions as to what was the correct and preferable decision in the matter. Ms Lewis did, however, refer to various authorities, in particular, Re Parent A and Child Support Registrar and Another (2013) 137 ALD 426, in which the concept of a pattern of care was considered and that the Tribunal should allow some flexibility depending on the facts and circumstances of each case. Similarly, in P v Child Support Registrar [2014] FCAFC 98 and Polec v Staker [2011] FMCAFAM 959 the Court had addressed the concept of care and determined that it is broader than simply the provision of accommodation on any given night and that the percentage of care does not necessarily have to be determined by a reference to a time based calculation.TRIBUNAL’S DELIBERATIONS AND DECISION Based on the evidence the Tribunal accepts that a pattern of care as required by s 50(1) of the Act was agreed to by the parties on 4 October 2014, reduced to a Draft Consent Order presented to the FCC on 29 October 2014, and adopted by the Court subject to a clean and clearer Minute being filed with the Court within seven days. The provisions of this Consent Order were complex and detailed. The order provided that the first three out of every four weekends were spent with the father VGYL, he taking the children from 5.30pm on a Friday to 7.45am on a Monday morning, except when the Monday was a public holiday, at which time the change-over was to occur at 7.45am on the Tuesday. The Court also made Orders that each parent had half of the school holidays, with 2015 and the odd numbered years thereafter to be with one parent for the initial period of the holidays; and the even years with the other parent. Christmases were also to rotate, as was Boxing Day. Special provision was made for the Catholic celebration of Easter for VGYL and the Greek Orthodox Easter for BYQZ, where these events did not fall on the same weekend. Provision was also made with respect to the children’s birthdays, Father’s Day and Mother’s Day. The children were otherwise to reside with their mother. The initial percentages of care assigned by the CSR were 32 per cent for VGYL and 68 per cent for BYQZ. The events leading to VGYL having total care of the children for 50 days has been documented earlier in this decision. The CSR decided that Special Circumstances existed during this period. This decision was affirmed by the AAT 1st Tier, and is not the subject of VGYL’s application to the AAT General Division. However, this Tribunal finds that that decision was correctly made and that VGYL had actual care at 100 per cent from 23 March 2015 to 13 May 2015. On 12 May 2015 Judge Burchardt of the FCC endorsed Consent Orders that the children return to BYQZ at 7.45am on 13 May 2015; that both parties attend family therapy and share the cost equally; that BYQZ was thereby restrained from physically punishing or chastising the children, and that she at all times advise VGYL of her correct address and any change of address. Otherwise the weekend care time of the Orders of 29 October 2014 would recommence on 22 May 2015.