| CITATION: | Veterinary Surgeons Board of Queensland v MacIntosh [2010] QCAT 601 |
| PARTIES: | Veterinary Surgeons Board of Queensland |
| v | |
| Alison Mary Hay MacIntosh |
| APPLICATION NUMBER: | VTD001-09 |
| MATTER TYPE: | Occupational Regulation |
| HEARING DATE: | 25, 26 and 27 October 2010 |
| HEARD AT: | Brisbane |
| DECISION OF: | Richard Oliver, Senior Member Dr Ian Wells, Member Dr Russell Duigan, Member |
| DELIVERED ON: | 17 November 2010 |
| DELIVERED AT: | Brisbane |
ORDERS MADE: |
|
| CATCHWORDS : | Professions and trades; Veterinary surgeons – complaints and discipline; whether the respondent’s conduct in using power tools in equine dentistry constituted misconduct in a professional respect; section 22F(f) and (k) of the Veterinary Surgeons Act 1936 (Qld) considered; failure to properly supervise assistant’s work; consideration of “filing or rasping” of teeth within the meaning of section 3(1)(8) of the Veterinary Surgeons Regulation 2008 involved the medical or surgical treatment of horses within the meaning of section 2A(2)(c) of the Veterinary Surgeons Act; sanction imposed reprimand and 3 months suspension of registration. |
APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION (if any):
| APPLICANT: | Vetrinary Surgeons Board of Queensland represented by Ms K. McMillan S.C. of counsel instructed by DLA Phillips Fox |
| RESPONDENT: | Alison Mary Hay MacIntosh represented by Mr G. Long S.C. of counsel and Mr F. Lippett of counsel instructed by Carvosso & Winship |
REASONS FOR DECISION
Dr MacIntosh is a registered veterinary surgeon who graduated from the University of Queensland in 1988. She was registered in Queensland as a veterinary surgeon in 1994 and had been in practice since that time.
Between February 2001 and June 2007 the respondent provided corrective dental treatment to a number of horses. That dental treatment was undertaken by the respondent, on occasions together with her husband Michael Lancaster, who is not a registered veterinary surgeon, working under the respondent’s supervision. Full particulars of the dental treatment undertaken are set out in an agreed statement of facts submitted by the parties[1].
[1] Exhibit 23
In summary the dental treatment administered and the consequences of that treatment are as follows:
a)Zander owned by Ms Grantham: dental treatment between 14 February 2001 and 4 February 2007. The treatment involved the use of a power operated float and the use of a power operated cut off wheel to realign Zander’s incisor teeth. As a consequence of this treatment Zander suffered iatragenic dental trauma and pulp necrosis on teeth 101, 201, 202, 306 and 406. The dental treatment provided and/or supervised and/or allowed by the respondent resulted in pulp exposure and/or thermal pulp necrosis, due to inappropriate use of power tools. Zander was euthanased on 13 May 2009.
b)Silver Smith owned by Mr and Mrs Smith: the respondent undertook incisor realignment of Silver’s upper and lower incisors with power tools including a cut off wheel. Inappropriate use of these power tools resulted…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Veterinary Surgeons Board of Queensland v MacIntosh and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] QCAT 601
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue for determination was whether Mr MacIntosh's use of power tools in equine dentistry constituted misconduct as defined under section 22F(f) and (k) of the Act. This required an examination of the statutory framework governing veterinary practice, particularly the Veterinary Surgeons Regulation 2008. The court also needed to determine whether the activity of "filing or rasping" of teeth fell within the definition of medical or surgical treatment under the Act, and whether Mr MacIntosh's failure to properly supervise his assistant constituted misconduct.
The tribunal found that Mr MacIntosh's use of power tools in equine dentistry did indeed constitute misconduct. The tribunal concluded that the activity of filing or rasping of teeth involved the medical or surgical treatment of horses, and that Mr MacIntosh's failure to properly supervise his assistant contributed to this finding. The tribunal found that the conduct breached the professional standards expected of a registered veterinary surgeon. Consequently, the tribunal imposed a reprimand and a three-month suspension of Mr MacIntosh's registration, effective from 28 October 2010, with certain exceptions for periods necessary to undergo training and courses in compliance with an undertaking given to the Tribunal.
The final orders of the tribunal were that Mr MacIntosh be reprimanded and that his registration as a veterinary surgeon be suspended for a period of three months, starting from 28 October 2010. This suspension was to be subject to certain exceptions to allow Mr MacIntosh to undertake the necessary training and courses in accordance with his undertaking to the Tribunal.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. That the respondent be reprimanded.
1. The respondent’s registration as a veterinary surgeon is suspended for a period of 3 months from 28 October 2010 save for those periods necessary to undergo training and courses in compliance with the respondent’s undertaking given to the Tribunal.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi