Vesuvius Australia Pty Ltd v V & M Davidovic Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Vesuvius Australia Pty Ltd v V & M Davidovic Pty Ltd [2011] NSWSC 539
Hearing dates:3 June 2011
Decision date: 09 June 2011
Jurisdiction:Equity Division
Before: Biscoe AJ
Decision:

(1) Defence to summary judgment claim struck out, judgment accordingly.

(2) Appeal allowed against refusal of primary judge to grant summary judgment.

(3) Appeal dismissed against primary judge refusal to allow plaintiff to re-open first judgment;

(4) Other orders as set out at [ 56 ] of this judgment.

Catchwords: SUMMARY JUDGMENT: - STRIKE OUT OF DEFENCE-set off defence to summary judgment claim struck out because of defendant's failure to comply with Court's directions and orders-appeal allowed from decision not to grant summary judgment in respect of part of plaintiff's claim where set-off was the only triable issue-set-off for damages for misleading or deceptive conduct or unconscionable conduct is not available against a claim for release of plaintiff's security deposit under a deed of options for lease which provided for return of the deposit if the lease does not proceed-the lease did not proceed.
Legislation Cited: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 rr 13.1 49.41
Civil Procedure Act 2005 ss 61, 94
Cases Cited: Cookson Plibrico Pty Ltd v V & M Davidovic Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 1171
Hans Pet Constructions Pty Ltd v Cassar [2009] NSWCA 230
Lean v Tumut River Orchard Management Ltd [2003] FCA 269
Re Dalco; Ex parte Dalco v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (1986) 67 ALR 605
Smith (Administrator of Cosslett (Contractors) Ltd) v Bridgend County Borough Council [2002] 1 AC 336
Tony Lee Motors Ltd v M S MacDonald & Son (1974) Ltd [1981] 2 NZLR 281
Vesuvius Australia Pty Ltd (formerly known as Cookson Plibrico Pty Ltd) v V & M Davidovic Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] NSWSC 48
Texts Cited: Meagher, Gummow and Lehane's Equity Doctrines and Remedies, 4th ed (2002) LexisNexis Butterworths
P W Young, C Croft, M Smith, On Equity (2009) Lawbook Co
R Derham, The Law of Set-Off, 4th ed (2003) Oxford University Press
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Vesuvius Australia Pty Ltd (Plaintiff/First Cross Defendant)
V & M Davidovic Pty Ltd (First Defendant/Cross Claimant)
Paul Armitage (Second Cross Defendant)
Representation: Mr B Coles QC with Mr P Russell (Plaintiff/First Cross-Defendant)
Mr M Davidovic in person (Director of the First Defendant/Cross Claimant)
Pikes Lawyers (Plaintiff/First Cross-Defendant)
File Number(s):2010/0084991

Judgment

OVERVIEW

  1. The plaintiff sues the defendant for the release of a security deposit paid under a Deed of Options for Lease, and for damages for breach of the deed. Clause 13 of the deed requires the defendant, as landlord, to immediately allow the refund of the security deposit to the plaintiff, as tenant, if the lease is not to proceed. The lease is not to proceed.

  1. The defendant cross-claims against the plaintiff for damages for misleading and deceptive conduct and unconscionable conduct relating to the subject of the deed. In its defence to the plaintiff's claim the defendant pleads that it is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vesuvius Australia Pty Ltd v V & M Davidovic Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NSWSC 539
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal was heard by Beech-Jones J at first instance. The plaintiff, Vesuvius Australia Pty Ltd, sought summary judgment on its claims concerning the release of a security deposit, but not on its claim for damages. The defendant, V & M Davidovic Pty Ltd, argued that it had a set-off defence, which the primary judge found to be arguable. The plaintiff then sought to re-open the first judgment and obtain the same summary relief, but this was also dismissed with costs. The plaintiff now appeals against both judgments. Additionally, the plaintiff has moved for the further amended defence and further amended cross-claim to be struck out or dismissed due to the defendant's failure to comply with directions and orders.

The legal issues before the court were whether the set-off defence was arguable and whether the defendant's failure to comply with directions and orders warranted the striking out or dismissal of its defence and cross-claim. The court found that the set-off defence was arguable, and therefore, the plaintiff was not entitled to summary judgment on the claims concerning the release of the security deposit. However, the court also found that the defendant's failure to comply with directions and orders warranted the striking out or dismissal of its defence and cross-claim.

In light of the defendant's failure to comply with directions and orders, the court allowed the appeal and ordered that the further amended defence and further amended cross-claim be struck out or dismissed. The court found that the set-off for damages for misleading or deceptive conduct or unconscionable conduct was not available against a claim for release of the plaintiff's security deposit under a deed of options for lease which provided for the return of the deposit if the lease did not proceed. Since the lease did not proceed, the defendant's set-off defence was not available.

The court ordered that the further amended defence and further amended cross-claim be struck out or dismissed. The court also ordered that the defendant pay the plaintiff's costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In 2010 the plaintiff moved for summary judgment on its claims concerning the release of the security deposit ( the summary judgment claims ), but not on its claim for damages. The motion was dismissed with costs because it was held that the defendant had an arguable defence of set-off ( the first judgment ). The plaintiff moved for leave to re-open the first judgment and, consequently, for the same summary relief. That motion was also dismissed with costs ( the second judgment ). The plaintiff now appeals against both judgments. The appeals have been overtaken by the plaintiff's further motion before me for the further amended defence and further amended cross-claim to be struck out or dismissed. That motion is grounded in the fact that the defendant has since February/March 2011 been in breach of directions or orders: (a) in relation to service of its evidence; (b) to inform the plaintiff of the basis on which an undertaking as to damages that it gave to the Court can be satisfied; and (c) to provide security for the plaintiff's costs of the defendant's cross-claim against the plaintiff. The service directions were made so that the substantive hearing would not be delayed. The service directions were aimed at a prompt hearing of the substantive matter and the undertaking, which the primary judge required. These directions influenced the primary judge when declining to grant summary judgment. The defendant company did not have legal representation at the hearing before me but was represented by a director, Mr M Davidovic. The instructions of the defendant's former solicitors had been withdrawn. I have decided that: By a notice of motion filed on 10 August 2010 and its amended notice of motion filed 24 September 2010, the plaintiff sought, by way of summary relief pursuant to r 13.1 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 ( UCPR ) that the Court below make the orders claimed in paragraphs 2, 3 and 4 of the plaintiff's amended statement of claim ( the summary relief claims ), namely: In its amended statement of claim the plaintiff also claimed damages. Summary judgment was not sought in relation to that claim. On 11 November 2011 Hallen AsJ delivered judgment and concluded that the defendant's set-off deference was arguable and should proceed to trial: Cookson Plibrico Pty Ltd v V & M Davidovic Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 1171. An order giving effect to that judgment by formally dismissing the plaintiff's notice of motion filed on 10 August 2010 was not made until 15 March 2011. In the first judgment at [80] - [82] the primary judge concluded by saying: On 9 December 2010, the primary judge gave effect to [82] of the first judgment by directing the defendant to serve on or before 8 February 2011 all affidavits and expert reports on which it intended to rely in relation to the plaintiff's claim and the defendant's cross-claim. On 18 November 2010 the plaintiff filed a notice of motion for orders that the first judgment be re-opened and for summary judgment on the summary judgment claims.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.