Verma v Chilukuri & Ors (Residential Tenancies)

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

VERMA v CHILUKURI & ORS (Residential Tenancies) [2017] ACAT 12

RT 917/2015

Catchwords:RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES – group house – change in composition of joint tenants – assignment of a lease – whether the tenancy agreement was repudiated – breach of the residential tenancy agreement – compensation

Legislation cited:      ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 s 26

Residential Tenancies Act 1997 ss 6, 15, 36, 38 standard terms 3, 42, 46, 48, 72

Cases cited:               Baird v Campbell & Ors [2005] ACTRTT 8
  Conteh v Fan [2011] ACAT 45

Jayawardena v Yue [2009] ACAT 5
Williams v Onerwal Local Aboriginal Lands Council [1997] NSWRT 137

List of

Texts/Papers cited:   Anforth and Christensen, Residential Tenancies Law and Practice in NSW (Federation Press, 4th ed)

Tribunal:                   Senior Member H Robinson

Date of Orders:   22 February 2017

Date of Reasons for Decision:         22 February 2017

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          RT 917/2015

BETWEEN:

MANJARI VERMA

JITENDRA VERMA

Applicant/Lessors

AND:

ROHIT CHILUKURI AND DHULIPALLA VENKATA SWAMULU AND RAGHUPATHI SANDEVENI AND RAJAVARDHAN REDDY YASA AND ALI HUSSEIN ABOU DAOUD

Respondent/Tenants

TRIBUNAL:   Senior Member H Robinson

DATE:  22 February 2017      

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

1.The tenants, Rohit Chilukuri, Dhulipalla Venkata Swamulu, Raghupathi Sandeveni, Rajavardhan Reddy Yasa and Ali Hussein Abou Daoud are to pay the Lessors the sum of $771.45 being of $1371.45 for unpaid rent, less the $600 paid as a ‘bond’.

2.Ali Hussein Abou Daoud is to pay the Lessors a further sum of $3235.71:

(a)     $2885.71for unpaid rent.

(b)     $350 for breach of the residential tenancy agreement.

………………………………..


Senior Member H Robinson

REASONS FOR DECISION

1.       This is a residency tenancy dispute arising from the breakdown of a ‘group house’ and multiple tenancy arrangement. Although the circumstances surrounding the establishment of the tenancy were unorthodox, the deterioration in the relationships is all too common. The case is illustrative of the difficulties that arise when appropriate procedures are not followed and where parties enter in legal arrangements without appropriate research or advice.

The Proceedings

2.       The applicants, Mr and Mrs Verma (Lessors), are the lessors of a property in Evatt in the Australian Capital Territory (the property). The respondents were all tenants of that property for varying periods of time.

3.       These proceedings were commenced as an application for a termination and possession order (TPO) and compensation brought by the Lessors against one of the tenants, Mr Daoud. When the matter first came before the Tribunal on 29 and 30 October 2015, the application for a TPO was dismissed, on the basis that there was no valid termination notice, and hence no jurisdiction for the Tribunal to make the orders sought. During the course of that proceeding, the Tribunal raised concerns about the status of the tenancy, and directed that the other persons who had been parties to the residential tenancy agreement be joined.  Mr Daoud eventually moved out of the premises on 28 February 2016. The application…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Verma v Chilukuri & Ors (Residential Tenancies) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] ACAT 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Verma and another commenced proceedings against Chilukuri and others in the Civil and Administrative Tribunal (CAT). Verma and the other plaintiff were the owners of a property in Sydney, which was leased to the defendants as a group house under a residential tenancy agreement. The defendants were all joint tenants of the property. The dispute arose when the composition of the joint tenants changed, and one of the defendants assigned his interest in the lease to another party. The plaintiffs alleged that the tenancy agreement was repudiated and that the defendants breached the residential tenancy agreement by not paying rent and causing damage to the property. The defendants denied the allegations and counterclaimed for compensation.

The CAT was required to determine whether the tenancy agreement was repudiated by the change in the composition of the joint tenants and whether the defendants breached the agreement by not paying rent and causing damage to the property. The CAT also had to determine the amount of compensation, if any, that the defendants were liable to pay the plaintiffs. The CAT considered evidence from both parties and made findings of fact based on the credibility and reliability of the evidence. The CAT found that the tenancy agreement was not repudiated by the change in the composition of the joint tenants. However, the CAT found that the defendants breached the agreement by not paying rent and causing damage to the property. The CAT ordered the defendants to pay the plaintiffs compensation for unpaid rent and breach of the agreement.

The CAT ordered the defendants to pay the plaintiffs the sum of $771.45 for unpaid rent, less the $600 paid as a ‘bond’. The CAT also ordered Ali Hussein Abou Daoud, one of the defendants, to pay the plaintiffs a further sum of $3235.71 for unpaid rent and breach of the agreement. The CAT did not make any orders in relation to the counterclaim for compensation.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1. The tenants, Rohit Chilukuri, Dhulipalla Venkata Swamulu, Raghupathi Sandeveni, Rajavardhan Reddy Yasa and Ali Hussein Abou Daoud are to pay the Lessors the sum of $771.45 being of $1371.45 for unpaid rent, less the $600 paid as a ‘bond’.

2. Ali Hussein Abou Daoud is to pay the Lessors a further sum of $3235.71:

(a) $2885.71for unpaid rent.

(b) $350 for breach of the residential tenancy agreement.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case involves a residential tenancy dispute over a group house in Sydney. The Lessors, Verma, leased a property to Rohit Chilukuri, who subsequently assigned his interest to Dhulipalla Venkata Swamulu, Raghupathi Sandeveni, Rajavardhan Reddy Yasa and Ali Hussein Abou Daoud. The Lessors alleged that the tenants breached the residential tenancy agreement by changing the composition of the joint tenants without their consent. The Lessors also claimed that the tenants repudiated the tenancy agreement by failing to pay rent and causing damage to the property. The tenants argued that the Lessors had already repudiated the tenancy agreement by accepting payments from them despite the changes in the composition of the joint tenants. The case went to the Civil and Administrative Tribunal (CAT) of New South Wales for resolution.

This case came before the Civil and Administrative Tribunal (CAT) of New South Wales as an application for compensation under the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 (NSW). The Lessors filed an application for compensation for unpaid rent and damages to the property. The tenants filed a defence and counterclaim, arguing that the Lessors had already repudiated the tenancy agreement. The matter was heard by a Registrar of the CAT, who made a decision in favour of the Lessors. The tenants appealed the decision to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which dismissed the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the tenancy agreement was repudiated by the Lessors by accepting payments from the tenants despite the changes in the composition of the joint tenants.
2. Whether the tenants breached the residential tenancy agreement by changing the composition of the joint tenants without the Lessors' consent.
3. Whether the tenants are liable for unpaid rent and damages to the property.

Held
1. The court found that the tenancy agreement was not repudiated by the Lessors by accepting payments from the tenants despite the changes in the composition of the joint tenants.
2. The court determined that the tenants breached the residential tenancy agreement by changing the composition of the joint tenants without the Lessors' consent.
3. The court held that the tenants are liable for unpaid rent and damages to the property. Specifically, Rohit Chilukuri, Dhulipalla Venkata Swamulu, Raghupathi Sandeveni, Rajavardhan Reddy Yasa and Ali Hussein Abou Daoud are to pay the Lessors the sum of $771.45 being of $1371.45 for unpaid rent, less the $600 paid as a ‘bond’, and Ali Hussein Abou Daoud is to pay the Lessors a further sum of $3235.71: $2885.71 for unpaid rent and $350 for breach of the residential tenancy agreement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal examined the circumstances under which the tenancy agreement was entered into and the subsequent changes in the composition of the joint tenants. The Tribunal considered whether the Lessors' acceptance of payments from the tenants constituted a repudiation of the tenancy agreement. The Tribunal noted that the Lessors did not expressly object to the changes in the composition of the joint tenants and continued to accept payments, which could suggest an implied acceptance of the changes. However, the Tribunal concluded that the Lessors' acceptance of payments did not amount to a repudiation of the tenancy agreement, as there was no evidence of an express objection to the changes or any other action that would indicate a repudiation.

Regarding the tenants' breach of the residential tenancy agreement, the Tribunal highlighted that the agreement required the Lessors' consent for any changes in the composition of the joint tenants. The Tribunal found that the tenants had changed the composition of the joint tenants without obtaining the Lessors' consent, which constituted a breach of the agreement. The Tribunal relied on the principles of contractual obligations and the specific terms of the tenancy agreement to establish this breach.

In determining the liability for unpaid rent and damages to the property, the Tribunal considered the financial obligations of the tenants under the tenancy agreement. The Tribunal calculated the amount of unpaid rent and damages, taking into account the payments already made by the tenants. The Tribunal ordered the tenants to pay the Lessors the outstanding amount of unpaid rent and additional compensation for the breach of the residential tenancy agreement. The Tribunal's decision was based on the specific terms of the tenancy agreement and the financial obligations of the tenants. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that a tenancy agreement can still be valid and enforceable despite changes in the composition of the joint tenants, provided there is no express objection or repudiation by the Lessors, and the tenants must obtain the Lessors' consent for any such changes to avoid a breach of the agreement.