Vergara v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Vergara v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 474

File number(s): SYG 2141 of 2020
Judgment of: JUDGE D HUMPHREYS
Date of judgment: 04 April 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Administrative Appeals Tribunal – Student (Temporary) (Class TU) visa– Whether the Tribunal’s finding was irrational, illogical or lacking a material foundation – Whether the Tribunal drew an adverse conclusion due to the applicant’s failure to lodge tax returns – Whether the Tribunal failed in its s 360 obligations – Application for judicial review dismissed – Costs ordered.
Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 360, 425, 499

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) cl 500.212

Cases cited:

Associated Provincial Picture House Limited v Wednesbury Corporation [1949] 1 KB 223

Djokovic v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs

LPDT v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 12

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection  v SZVFW (2018) 264 CLR 541

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Stretton [2016] FCAFC 11

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZMTA (2019) 263 CLR 421

Minister for Immigration arid Citizenship v Li (2013) 297 ALR 225

SZBEL v Minister for Immigration (2006) 228 CR 152

SZDFZ v Minister for Immigration (2008) 168 FCR 1

SZTAP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCAFC 138; (2008) 172 FCR 1

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 64
Date of hearing: 11 March 2025
Place: Parramatta
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr Karp
Solicitor for the Applicants: Mr Revelman (Meridian Legal)
Counsel for the First Respondent: Ms McNeil
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Ms Edmondstone (MinterEllison)
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Submitting appearance,save as to costs

ORDERS

SYG 2141 of 2020

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

JOSE PORFIRIO DELGADO VERGARA

First Applicant

CARMEN CARO PUERTA

Second Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE D HUMPHREYS

DATE OF ORDER:

04 APRIL 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application is dismissed.

2.The First and Second Applicant are to pay the First Respondent’s costs fixed in the sum of $8,371.30.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE D HUMPHREYS

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicants are husband and wife. The application is for review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (as it was then) (“the Tribunal”), dated 10 August 2020, affirming the decision of a delegate of the Minister not to grant the first applicant, Jose Vergara a Student (Temporary)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vergara v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 474
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Vergara v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs is a case involving Mr Vergara, a Peruvian national who applied for a student visa to extend his stay in Australia. The applicant had been in Australia since 2009 on temporary visas and was seeking to extend his stay until September 2022 through further studies. The delegate refused the visa application, and the applicant sought merits review at the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The AAT found that the applicant's familial connections in Australia, including his wife and stepchildren, provided a strong incentive for him to remain in Australia, and that the applicant had not provided a clear career plan or evidence of his entrepreneurial activities in Peru. The applicant sought judicial review of the AAT's decision, arguing that the AAT's finding was irrational, illogical and lacking a material foundation.

The court considered whether the AAT's finding was unreasonable or lacked an evident and intelligible justification. The court noted that the AAT had considered the relevant factors in accordance with Ministerial Direction No 69, and that the applicant had resided in Australia for 10 years at the time of the decision. The court found that the AAT's conclusion that the applicant's familial connections in Australia provided a strong incentive for him to remain in the country was not irrational or illogical, and that the AAT had provided sufficient reasons for its decision. The court also noted that the applicant had not provided sufficient evidence to support his claim to be an independent entrepreneur or to demonstrate the value of his further studies to achieving his career goals.

The court dismissed the application for judicial review and ordered the applicant to pay the respondent's costs. The court found that the AAT's decision was within the range of possible lawful outcomes and that the applicant had not demonstrated that the AAT's finding was unreasonable or lacked an evident and intelligible justification. The court also noted that the applicant had not provided sufficient evidence to support his claims, and that the AAT's decision was based on a thorough consideration of the relevant factors.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out below, the application must be dismissed. BACKGROUND Mr Vergara (“the applicant”) is a national of Peru. The second applicant is also a national of Peru. The applicant arrived in Australia in 2009, listed as a dependant on his wife’s student visa. The applicant remained in Australia until May 2016, at which point the first and second applicants lodged a student visa application with the first applicant in this matter identified as the primary applicant. At the time of this application, the applicant provided Confirmation of Enrolment (COE) in a Certificate III and Certificate IV in Business and Diploma of Leadership and Management, which would extend the Applicant’s stay in Australia until September 2022. On 17 July 2019, the applicants applied for the visa. The first applicant applied for a visa only under the student stream and not the Subclass 500 (Student Guardian) stream. The delegate refused to grant the visa on 20 November 2019, the applicant’s then sought merits review at the Tribunal.ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL DECISION The Tribunal provided the relevant background to the matter at [7]-[15]. In support of his visa application, the applicant provided documents including a written statement from the first applicant and copies of the written statement in the names of each of the other applicants. The file included evidence of the applicant’s marital status, the applicant’s English studies to date and untranslated property registration documents dated January 2016. The delegate in their decision record indicated they had the following concerns: •The applicant has been residing in Australia on temporary visas or associated bridging visas since 2009 and were proposing to extend their stay to a period in excess of 13 years;•The presence of the applicant's wife and stepchildren provided him with significant onshore familial connections;•The applicant failed to provide a clear career plan, evidence to support his claim to be an independent entrepreneur with current projects in Peru, or a clear explanation about the value of the further studies to achieving his career goals.•The applicant's study proposal was primarily for maintaining ongoing residence in Australia, through exchanging the primary role of student with his wife and in turn, including her as a dependant in the current student visa application. Prior to his hearing before the Tribunal the applicant provided documents listed at [12]. The Tribunal gave the applicant time until 3 August 2020 to provide further documentary evidence including the most recent 12 months of account statements of all bank accounts operated by the applicant and his wife in Australia and any Australian Taxation Office (“ATO”) Notice of Assessment showing the applicants' annual income over the 2017, 2018 and 2019 income years. The applicants provided bank records and a brief written submission from their representative stating that the applicants work as sole traders and had not filed an individual tax return, at that time for the three years requested. The representative also noted that the applicant’s accountant advised of the applicants’ intention of lodging their tax returns, with an estimate they may be available by the end of August.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The delegate refused to grant the visa on 20 November 2019, the applicant’s then sought merits review at the Tribunal.ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL DECISION The Tribunal provided the relevant background to the matter at [7]-[15]. In support of his visa application, the applicant provided documents including a written statement from the first applicant and copies of the written statement in the names of each of the other applicants. The file included evidence of the applicant’s marital status, the applicant’s English studies to date and untranslated property registration documents dated January 2016. The delegate in their decision record indicated they had the following concerns: •The applicant has been residing in Australia on temporary visas or associated bridging visas since 2009 and were proposing to extend their stay to a period in excess of 13 years;•The presence of the applicant's wife and stepchildren provided him with significant onshore familial connections;•The applicant failed to provide a clear career plan, evidence to support his claim to be an independent entrepreneur with current projects in Peru, or a clear explanation about the value of the further studies to achieving his career goals.•The applicant's study proposal was primarily for maintaining ongoing residence in Australia, through exchanging the primary role of student with his wife and in turn, including her as a dependant in the current student visa application. Prior to his hearing before the Tribunal the applicant provided documents listed at [12]. The Tribunal gave the applicant time until 3 August 2020 to provide further documentary evidence including the most recent 12 months of account statements of all bank accounts operated by the applicant and his wife in Australia and any Australian Taxation Office (“ATO”) Notice of Assessment showing the applicants' annual income over the 2017, 2018 and 2019 income years. The applicants provided bank records and a brief written submission from their representative stating that the applicants work as sole traders and had not filed an individual tax return, at that time for the three years requested. The representative also noted that the applicant’s accountant advised of the applicants’ intention of lodging their tax returns, with an estimate they may be available by the end of August. In considering whether the first applicant intended genuinely to stay in Australia temporarily, the Tribunal had regard to Ministerial Direction No 69 (Direction 69), ‘Assessing the genuine temporary entrant criterion for Student visa and Student Guardian visa applications’ made under s 499 of the Migration Act 1968 ( Cth) (“the Act”). In accordance with the factors highlighted in Direction 69, the Tribunal considered the following in relation to ‘the relevance of circumstances in the applicant’s home country’. The applicant claimed that he his mother and four siblings currently reside in Peru. Although the Tribunal accepted that these familial connections provided him with an incentive to return to Peru at some stage, the Tribunal noted that the applicant had resided in Australia for 10 years at that point, and was not persuaded these familial connections provided the applicant with a strong incentive to return home. The Tribunal was not persuaded there was any familial factor impacting the applicant at the time which would incentivise him to return to Peru for the foreseeable future ([22],[25]).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Further, to succeed, the applicant would also have to prove the error asserted by ground three was material in light of the decisions in SZMTA and LPDT. It is submitted the error asserted at [28] of the Tribunal decision record does not meet the threshold of materiality. CONSIDERATION In Djokovic v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCAFC 3 at [17] the task of a court conducting judicial review was described in this manner:… An application for judicial review is one in which the judicial branch of government reviews, by reference to legality or lawfulness, the decision or decisions of the executive branch of government, here in the form of a decision of the Minister. The court does not consider the merits or wisdom the decision; nor does it remake the decision. The task of the court is to rule upon the lawfulness or legality of the decision by reference to the complaints made about it. Unreasonableness is where a decision-maker has come to a conclusion so unreasonable that no reasonable decision-maker could have come to it; (see: Minister for Immigration arid Citizenship v Li (2013) 297 ALR 225 (“Li”) at [28] per French CJ), or where a decision has been made that lacks an "evident and intelligible justification"; (see: Li at [76]; Associated Provincial Picture House Limited v Wednesbury Corporation [1949] 1 KB 223 at [234 ]). The test for unreasonableness is "stringent" and only arises in rare cases; (see: Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZVFW (2018) 264 CLR 541 at [11]). Unreasonableness is not a means for challenging a decision on the basis that the court disagrees with the consideration of matters or the evaluative judgments made by the decision maker; (see: Li at [30], [113]). In Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Stretton [2016] FCAFC 11 at [11] Allsop CJ said the following concerning a review of a decision for legal unreasonableness:The task is not definitional but one of characterisation: the decision is to be evaluated, and a conclusion reached as to whether it has the character of being unreasonable, insufficiently lacking rational a foundation, or an evident or intelligible justification, or in being plainly unjust arbitrary capricious or lacking common sense having regard to the terms, scope and purpose of the statutory source of the power, such that it cannot be said to be within the range of possible lawful outcomes as to the exercise of that power. The descriptions of a lack of quality used above are not exhaustive or definitional, they are explanations or explications of legal unreasonableness, of going beyond the source of power.Ground Two Ground two is a complaint that the finding at [34] of the Tribunal decision record was irrational, illogical and lacking a material foundation in critical aspects. That finding noted that the applicant’s wife and two stepchildren were with him in Australia and ‘provides him with a source of support and familial connection that ameliorates what might otherwise be a disincentive from him seeking to maintain residency in Australia’.