Veolia Water Australia Pty Ltd v Centennial Springvale Pty Limited (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Veolia Water Australia Pty Ltd v Centennial Springvale Pty Limited (No 2) [2023] FCA 1025

File number: NSD 204 of 2022
Judgment of: GOODMAN J
Date of judgment: 29 August 2023
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – previous order made for discovery of data concerning samples of water taken from the Springvale and Angus Place mines – documents discovered which contained data from the mines and data from elsewhere – order made requiring the prospective respondents to identify for each identified sampling point whether the data was from the mines, in circumstances where such information was required to ensure the efficacy of the previous order and the prospective respondents identified no prejudice

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for the first and second prospective respondents to provide an affidavit explaining certain matters relating to the process by which the documents were discovered, and certifying that discovery is complete – application refused  

Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), ss 23, 37P

Federal Court of Australia Rules 2011 (Cth), rr 7.23, 20.16, 20.17

Cases cited:

Reilly v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd(No 4) [2021] FCA 1552

Veolia Water Australia Pty Ltd v Centennial Springvale Pty Limited [2023] FCA 443

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 29
Date of hearing: 15 August 2023
Counsel for the Prospective Applicant: Mr G A Sirtes SC with Ms J Wright
Solicitor for the Prospective Applicant: Baker McKenzie
Counsel for the Prospective Respondents: Ms H Mann
Solicitor for the Prospective Respondents: Herbert Smith Freehills

ORDERS

NSD 204 of 2022
BETWEEN:

VEOLIA WATER AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ACN 061 161 279

Prospective Applicant

AND:

CENTENNIAL SPRINGVALE PTY LIMITED ACN 052 096 812

First Prospective Respondent

BOULDER MINING PTY LIMITED ACN 112 796 308

Second Prospective Respondent

ENERGY AUSTRALIA NSW PTY LTD ACN 75 163 935 635

Third Prospective Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

GOODMAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 AUGUST 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Within 14 days, Centennial Springvale Pty Limited, Boulder Mining Pty Limited, and EnergyAustralia NSW Pty Ltd, identify, for each Sample Location, whether the raw data, analysed data, analytical data and processed data of samples and/or tests provided by the Prospective Respondent in response to the Orders, is from:

(a)Bore Holes; and/or

(b)Mine Water; or

(c)neither Bore Holes or Mine Water.

Bore Holes means all bore holes that store and/or hold Mine Water;

Mine Water means water including ground water treated or untreated from Springvale Mine and/or Angus Place Mine;

Orders means the orders made by the Honourable Justice Goodman on 10 May 2023 in NSD 204 of 2022;

Sample Location means the locations identified in the column titled ‘sampling location’ in Annexure A to this Order.

2.The prospective applicant’s application is otherwise dismissed.

3.The parties confer on the question of costs of the application and of compliance with order 1 and notify the Associate to Goodman J, by 8 September 2023

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Veolia Water Australia Pty Ltd v Centennial Springvale Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1025
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Veolia Water Australia Pty Ltd sought an order requiring Centennial Springvale Pty Limited and other parties to identify whether data discovered from samples of water taken from the Springvale and Angus Place mines was from those mines or from elsewhere. The dispute arose from a previous discovery order which had been made in the proceedings, and which required the Customer to provide data of samples of water from the mines during a specified period. The Customer provided a significant amount of documents which contained data from the mines and data from elsewhere. The Court was required to determine whether the discovery provided was sufficient and whether an order was needed to require the Customer to identify the origin of the data in the documents. The Court also had to consider an application by the Customer for an order requiring the first and second prospective respondents to provide an affidavit explaining certain matters relating to the process by which the documents were discovered and certifying that discovery is complete.

The Court found that it was unclear whether all documents in the Customer’s possession that fell within the discovery order had been discovered, but concluded that there was no basis from which to conclude that proper discovery had not been provided. The Court also found that the Customer had identified no prejudice in the requirement to identify the origin of the data in the documents. The Court refused the application for an affidavit as it found that there was no basis for the Customer to make such an affidavit. The Court made an order requiring the Customer to identify for each sampling point whether the data was from the mines, in circumstances where such information was required to ensure the efficacy of the previous order. The Court dismissed the application for an affidavit.

The Court ordered that within 14 days, Centennial Springvale Pty Limited, Boulder Mining Pty Limited, and EnergyAustralia NSW Pty Ltd, were to identify, for each Sample Location, whether the data of samples and/or tests provided by the Prospective Respondent in response to the Orders, was from bore holes, mine water or neither. The Court further ordered that the prospective applicant’s application was otherwise dismissed. The parties were to confer on the question of costs of the application and of compliance with order 1 and notify the Associate to Goodman J, by 8 September 2023, of any agreed position. If the parties were unable to reach an agreed position concerning costs, then the parties file and serve any evidence and submissions concerning costs (limited to 3 pages) by 15 September 2023; the parties file and serve any evidence and submissions concerning costs in reply (limited to 3 pages) by 22 September 2023; and the question of costs was to be determined on the papers and without an oral hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Within 14 days, Centennial Springvale Pty Limited, Boulder Mining Pty Limited, and EnergyAustralia NSW Pty Ltd, identify, for each Sample Location, whether the raw data, analysed data, analytical data and processed data of samples and/or tests provided by the Prospective Respondent in response to the Orders, is from:

(a) Bore Holes; and/or

(b) Mine Water; or

(c) neither Bore Holes or Mine Water.

Bore Holes means all bore holes that store and/or hold Mine Water;

Mine Water means water including ground water treated or untreated from Springvale Mine and/or Angus Place Mine;

Orders means the orders made by the Honourable Justice Goodman on 10 May 2023 in NSD 204 of 2022;

Sample Location means the locations identified in the column titled ‘sampling location’ in Annexure A to this Order.

2. The prospective applicant’s application is otherwise dismissed.

3. The parties confer on the question of costs of the application and of compliance with order 1 and notify the Associate to Goodman J, by 8 September 2023, of any agreed position.

4. If the parties are unable to reach an agreed position concerning costs, then:

(a) the parties file and serve any evidence and submissions concerning costs (limited to 3 pages) by 15 September 2023;

(b) the parties file and serve any evidence and submissions concerning costs in reply (limited to 3 pages) by 22 September 2023; and

(c) the question of costs is to be determined on the papers and without an oral hearing.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Subsequently, the Customer provided discovery to VWA. VWA now seeks a further order which it contends is necessary because of the form in which the discovery was provided. It also seeks an order requiring a solicitor of the firm acting for the Customer to make an affidavit providing an explanation of certain matters relating to the process by which the discovery was provided; and certifying that the discovery is now complete.B. BACKGROUND The discovery order was in the following terms:1.The prospective respondents give discovery to the prospective applicant of the Data for the Period where:(a)Data means any raw data, analysed data, analytical data and processed data of samples and/or tests of Mine Water and Bore Holes;(b)Mine Water means water including ground water treated or untreated from Springvale Mine and/or Angus Place Mine;(c)Bore Holes means all bore holes that store and/or hold Mine Water; and(d)Period means from 1 October 2014 to 12 November 2017. The effect of the discovery order, broadly, was to require the Customer to discover data of samples of water from the Springvale Mine and/or the Angus Place Mine (together, the Mines) during the Period (Mines Data). On 31 May 2023, the Customer served two affidavits of discovery (one on behalf of the first and second prospective respondents made by Ms Melinda Loh; and the other on behalf of the third prospective respondent). The 1,388 documents the subject of the lists attached to those affidavits were provided to VWA. I will refer to the discovery of those documents as the first disclosure. On 8 June 2023, the Customer provided eight further documents to VWA (second disclosure). On 24 July 2023, the Customer provided 92 further documents to VWA (third disclosure). By the first, second and third disclosures, the Customer produced documents recording data of samples of water. For some documents, it is possible to ascertain from the information contained therein that the data is Mines Data. This is because it is clear on the face of those documents that the source of the sample is a location within the Mines. However, for many other documents, it is not possible to ascertain from the information therein whether the data they contain came from samples of water taken from within the Mines or from samples of water from elsewhere (Other Data). This is due in part to the descriptors used to identify the source of the samples taken, which do not match the sampling locations within the Mines identified as part of the initial application. Indeed, many of the descriptors do not, on their face, identify a location at all. There has been considerable correspondence between the solicitors for the Customer and the solicitors for VWA. It is sufficient for present purposes to note that: (1) the solicitors for the Customer indicated that the Customer provided discovery of documents which contain both Mines Data and Other Data; and (2) during the course of such correspondence the respective parties adopted, from a relatively early point, entrenched positions focused upon whether or not the Customer had complied with the discovery order in circumstances where many of the documents discovered contain both Mines Data and Other Data and VWA is not able to ascertain which of the data within particular documents is Mines Data and which is Other Data.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

VWA submitted that it is unclear whether all documents in the Customer’s possession that fall within the discovery order have been discovered. In support of this submission, VWA relied upon the history of the disclosures made, including the timing of the third disclosure. I do not accept this submission. Further, there is no basis from which to conclude that proper discovery has not been provided. Indeed, the further investigations undertaken by the solicitors for the Customer undermine, rather than support, a conclusion that discovery has been inadequate.E. CONCLUSION For the reasons set out above the first, but not the second, order sought by VWA should be made. The parties should be provided with an opportunity to confer about an appropriate form of orders concerning costs. I will make orders accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established