Vellaisamy (Migration) [2023] AATA 2690 (17 July 2023)
DECISION RECORD
DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division
APPLICANT: Mr Rameshkumar Vellaisamy
CASE NUMBER: 2102935
HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S): BCC2019/376676
MEMBER:Peter Ranson
DATE:17 July 2023
PLACE OF DECISION: Brisbane
DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the visa applicant a Business Skills (Provisional) (Class EB) visa.
Statement made on 17 July 2023 at 9:54am
CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – Subclass 188 (Business Innovation and Investment (Provisional)) visa – Subclass 188 – Business Innovation stream – ownership interest for the two fiscal years nominated was for less than the required time – turnover shown in the application was less than required – Ministerial intervention referral – decision under review affirmed
LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958, ss 65, 359, 351
Migration Regulations 1994, Schedule 2, cl 188.225
STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS
APPLICATION FOR REVIEW
Mr Rameshkumar Vellaisamy (known as Ramesh) came to Australia from India after spending time in Singapore where he learned the supermarket trade and he says became very good at it. He had followed his cousin to Singapore and then to Australia where they established an Asian grocery business called Sri Murugan Trading. Ramesh had an ownership interest in that business until a dispute arose between him and his cousin after which he was ousted from it.
Ramesh was invited by the government of Victoria to apply for the visa on 10 December 2018, and on 7 February 2019 he applied for a Class EB Subclass 188 (Business Innovation and Investment (Provisional)) visa. The criteria for the grant of a Subclass 188 visa are set out in Part 188 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). The primary criteria must be satisfied by at least one applicant. Ramesh is the primary and only visa applicant.
The primary criteria include common criteria, and criteria set out in streams. In this case, Ramesh applied for the visa in the Business Innovation stream. On 19 February 2021, a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs refused to grant him a Business Skills (Provisional) (Class EB) visa under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). He then applied for review of that decision.
Clause188.225 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations requires an applicant to have held an ownership interest in one or more established main business with an annual turnover of at least $500,000 for at least two of the four fiscal years immediately before the time of application. The delegate refused to grant the visa on the basis Ramesh did not satisfy this requirement because his ownership interest in the nominated main business, Sri Murugan Trading, was less than required both in terms of percentage and duration for the turnover achieved.
Ramesh became emotional at the hearing and said he did not know about the requirements of the regulations even though his application was lodged by Mr Santhosh Bisam of Aspire Global (AUS) Pty Ltd.[1] Ramesh believes he was not well advised by that migration agent who he says advised him…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Vellaisamy (Migration) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] AATA 2690
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Ramesh had a sufficient ownership interest in an established main business for at least two of the four fiscal years preceding his invitation to apply for the visa, and whether that business achieved an annual turnover of at least $500,000 in each of those years. The Tribunal also had to consider the nature of Ramesh's interest in the business and identify the specific business to which the definition of "main business" applied, distinguishing between a business and the legal entity that operates it.
The Tribunal found that Ramesh was a director and shareholder of SRI Murugan Trading Pty Ltd from 30 August 2018 to 6 December 2021. However, the visa application required proof of ownership interest for at least two of the four fiscal years immediately before the invitation to apply. The Tribunal noted that case law establishes a business is an enterprise, not a legal entity, and that an Australian Business Number attaches to an entity, not a business. Ramesh claimed he worked in businesses in India and Singapore prior to moving to Australia but stated he did not have an ownership interest in those businesses, thus they could not be relied upon for his application. The Tribunal placed no weight on the allegations of fraud made in correspondence, as no evidence was provided to support them and Ramesh had already disclosed his departure from SRI Murugan Trading Pty Ltd.
The Tribunal concluded that the decision under review should be affirmed and recommended Ministerial Intervention.
Background
Background to the litigation
Ramesh claimed to have worked for his cousin, Mr Kalai Ramalingam, in an Asian supermarket business in India and then Singapore for five years until they moved to Australia. He started in February 2012 as a team member in the business in India and became the manager of the Singapore business in March 2015 until they left for Australia in February 2017. However, Ramesh asserted that he did not have an ownership interest in these businesses, and therefore, they cannot count towards his visa application. After arriving in Australia, Ramesh became a director and shareholder of SRI Murugan Trading Pty Ltd, which operated an Asian supermarket in Australia. His involvement in the company was from 30 August 2018 to 6 December 2021. The Tribunal considered whether Ramesh’s ownership interest in this business met the main business definition for at least two of the four fiscal years immediately before the time of invitation to apply for the visa and whether the annual turnover of the business met the required threshold of at least $500,000 in the relevant years.
The matter before the Tribunal pertains to the visa application of Ramesh under the Subclass 188 (Business Innovation and Investment (Provisional)) visa. Ramesh applied to establish himself in Australia through his involvement in an Asian supermarket business conducted by SRI Murugan Trading Pty Ltd, an entity in which he was a director and shareholder from 30 August 2018 to 6 December 2021. The application was referred to the Tribunal following a Ministerial intervention, following an initial decision by the Department of Home Affairs to refuse the visa. The Tribunal was tasked with reviewing the decision and considering whether Ramesh met the eligibility criteria for the visa, particularly in relation to the ownership interest and annual turnover of the nominated business. Prior to the Tribunal hearing, Ramesh had disclosed that he was no longer a shareholder or director of SRI Murugan Trading Pty Ltd and there were allegations of fraud against him from the company, which were not substantiated. Throughout the proceedings, Ramesh maintained his innocence regarding the allegations and provided evidence of his involvement in the Asian supermarket business.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Tribunal considered Ramesh's submissions that he did not have an ownership interest in the businesses in India and Singapore. It is clear that the ownership interest requirement must be satisfied in relation to the business nominated to support the visa application. In this case, the business is an Asian supermarket conducted by SRI Murugan Trading Pty Ltd (ACN 611 918 980). Ramesh was a director and shareholder of this company from 30 August 2018 to 6 December 2021. The Tribunal accepted Ramesh's evidence that he did not have an ownership interest in the businesses in India and Singapore, and thus they cannot be considered in this application. The Tribunal must now consider whether Ramesh had an ownership interest in SRI Murugan Trading Pty Ltd for at least two of the four fiscal years immediately before the invitation to apply for the visa.
The Tribunal found that Ramesh had an ownership interest in SRI Murugan Trading Pty Ltd for at least two of the four fiscal years immediately before the invitation to apply for the visa. This is evidenced by his role as a director and shareholder of the company during the relevant period. The Tribunal applied the legal principle that an ownership interest is a share in the profits and losses of a business, which can be demonstrated by a directorship or shareholding. The Tribunal relied on the evidence provided by Ramesh, including his role in the company and the fact that he was a director and shareholder, to conclude that he had an ownership interest in the business.
The Tribunal also considered the definition of a main business and how it applies to Ramesh's business. The Tribunal noted that a main business is not a legal entity but rather an enterprise or undertaking. It is important to identify the business to which the definition of main business must be applied. In this case, the business is an Asian supermarket conducted by SRI Murugan Trading Pty Ltd. The Tribunal applied the legal principle that a main business is one that is established and has a significant presence in the market. The Tribunal relied on the evidence provided by Ramesh, including the nature of the business and its presence in the market, to conclude that it meets the definition of a main business.
The Tribunal further considered whether the business owned by Ramesh met the annual turnover requirement of at least $500,000 for at least two of the four fiscal years immediately before the invitation to apply for the visa. The Tribunal noted that an Australian Business Number (ABN) attaches to an entity, not to a business. The Tribunal applied the legal principle that the turnover requirement applies to the business, not the entity. The Tribunal relied on the evidence provided by Ramesh, including the turnover of the business, to conclude that it did not meet the annual turnover requirement for at least two of the four fiscal years immediately before the invitation to apply for the visa.
The Tribunal also considered whether one business can be owned by multiple entities and whether multiple businesses can be owned by one entity. The Tribunal noted that the definition of a main business must be applied to the business, not the entity. The Tribunal applied the legal principle that one business can be owned by multiple entities and conversely, multiple businesses can be owned by one entity. The Tribunal relied on the evidence provided by Ramesh, including his role as a director and shareholder of SRI Murugan Trading Pty Ltd, to conclude that the business met the definition of a main business for at least two of the four fiscal years immediately before the invitation to apply for the visa.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the Tribunal concluded the decision under review should be affirmed and recommends Ministerial Intervention. The Tribunal found that Ramesh had an ownership interest in SRI Murugan Trading Pty Ltd for at least two of the four fiscal years immediately before the invitation to apply for the visa. The Tribunal also found that the business met the definition of a main business for at least two of the four fiscal years immediately before the invitation to apply for the visa. However, the business did not meet the annual turnover requirement of at least $500,000 for at least two of the four fiscal years immediately before the invitation to apply for the visa. The Tribunal distinguished prior authority by applying the legal principles that an ownership interest is a share in the profits and losses of a business, which can be demonstrated by a directorship or shareholding, and that a main business is one that is established and has a significant presence in the market. The Tribunal followed prior authority by applying the legal principle that one business can be owned by multiple entities and conversely, multiple businesses can be owned by one entity.