Vecchio and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

Vecchio and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 4565 (8 December 2021)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2020/3764

Re:Daniel Vecchio

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Emeritus Professor P A Fairall, Senior Member

Date:8 December 2021 

Place:Sydney

The decision under review is set aside and remitted to the Secretary pursuant to subsection 43(1)(c) with a recommendation to conduct a plan review, taking into account the Tribunal’s findings.

...................................[SGD].....................................

Emeritus Professor P A Fairall, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – whether claimed supports are reasonable and necessary - whether supports are in accordance with NDIS rules and guidelines - decision under review set aside and remitted with directions

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 2A, 42D, 43

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) ss 4, 33, 34

CASES

Holland and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 92

Vecchio and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 3510

QDKH and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 922

QDKH, by his litigation representative BGJF v National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] FCAFC 189

SECONDARY MATERIALS

National Disability Insurance Scheme – Operational Guidelines – Planning Pt 3, cl 7

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 rr 5

REASONS FOR DECISION

Emeritus Professor P A Fairall, Senior Member

8 December 2021 

  1. The National Disability Insurance Scheme (‘the NDIS’) has been in operation for less than ten years. It is landmark social legislation dedicated to the idea that people with disability have the right to realise their potential for physical, social, emotional and intellectual development.[1] This is the first of a series of general principles guiding actions set out in section 4 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (‘the Act’). Other important principles in section 4 of particular relevance to the present case include:

    (2)  People with disability should be supported to participate in and contribute to social and economic life to the extent of their ability…

    (4)  People with disability should be supported to exercise choice, including in relation to taking reasonable risks, in the pursuit of their goals and the planning and delivery of their supports…

    (5)  People with disability should be supported to receive reasonable and necessary supports, including early intervention supports…

    (11)  Reasonable and necessary supports for people with disability should:

    (a)  support people with disability to pursue their goals and maximise their independence; and

    (b)  support people with disability to live independently and to be included in the community as fully participating citizens; and

    (c)  develop and support the capacity of people with disability to undertake activities that enable them to participate in the community and in employment.

    [1] The Act, section 4(1).

  2. The NDIS is administered by the National Disability Insurance Agency (‘the NDIA’) established under the Act.

    THE APPLICANT

  3. Mr Daniel Vecchio (‘the applicant’) is profoundly deaf. He had a left ear Cochlear implant when he was 21. He is the youngest of three brothers, one of whom is also deaf.[2] He…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vecchio and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 4565
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) considered an application for review concerning a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) delegate not to approve an external CCTV system (ESS) as part of the applicant's 2020 National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) plan. The applicant also sought approval for a recommended visual alert system (IVAS). The proceedings were conducted via videoconference with the assistance of Auslan interpreters and a captioner.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the claimed supports, specifically the ESS, were reasonable and necessary in accordance with section 34 of the NDIS Act and Part 5 of the NDIS Rules. The Tribunal also had to determine if it had jurisdiction to consider the inclusion of these supports in the applicant's current 2021 plan, despite the original decision relating to the 2020 plan. The Tribunal noted that the applicant's circumstances had changed significantly with the birth of his second child, and that the funding in the 2020 and 2021 plans remained largely unchanged.

The Tribunal reasoned that the ESS, while providing security benefits, did not meet the "reasonable and necessary" criteria under the NDIS Act and Rules for the applicant's current plan. The applicant, who is deaf, argued that the ESS was essential for his safety due to his inability to hear external sounds and the layout of his home, particularly in light of his young dependents and the neighbourhood's crime rate. However, the Tribunal found that the ESS did not satisfy the specific requirements for funding under the NDIS.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the NDIA's decision of 14 May 2020 and remitted the matter to the Secretary for reconsideration. The Tribunal recommended that a plan review be conducted, taking into account the finding that the ESS system did not meet the "reasonable and necessary" criteria under the applicant's current plan.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In summary, the Tribunal has before it an application for review relating to a decision by the respondent’s delegate not to approve as part of the 2020 plan the external CCTV system (‘the ESS decision’). The Tribunal is also asked to approve the specific IVAS recommended by Ms Vernon. HEARING AND EVIDENCE The proceedings were conducted by videoconference on 16 and 17 September 2021. The applicant was represented by Ms Jade Girvan, of Coda Auslan Services. The respondent was represented by Ms Sarah Varney. The hearing was conducted with the assistance of three Auslan interpreters and a captioner, who did an exceptional job over the two-day hearing. The respondent filed a Statement of Issues dated 16 April 2021, prepared for the purposes of alternative dispute resolution in accordance with Division 3 of Part IV of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (‘the AAT Act’). The respondent also filed a Statement of Facts Issues and Contentions (RSFIC), dated 11 August 2021. The respondent also filed a Tender Bundle in two parts (pages 1-209; 210-641), and a Supplementary Tender Bundle (1-85). The applicant filed both the ESS Report and the IVAS Report.[31][31] H16/210; H17/246 The applicant called Ms Vernon as an expert witness. The respondent called the following witnesses: (a) Ms Judith Davidson, the occupational therapist engaged by the NDIA to conduct an assessment. She provided a written report dated 24 March 2021; (b) Mr Daniel Lewkovitz, the managing director of a security company ‘Calamity Monitoring’. He provided a written report dated 10 August 2021;[32](c) Mr Andrew Willis, CEO, Word of Mouth Technology, and Australian distributor of Bellman products. He provided a written report dated 23 July 2021.[33][32] H30/481.[33] H24/375. I note that Ms Vernon and Ms Davidson are both hearing impaired. THE SCOPE OF REVIEW The present application for review on its face concerns the internal review decision of 14 May 2020 which affirmed an earlier decision to not include the ESS as part of the applicant’s 2020 Plan issued on 3 February 2020.[34] There was no suggestion by the respondent that the application was invalid because the 2020 Plan had been replaced by the current 2021 Plan. For the reasons given by Deputy President Constance in Holland and National Disability Insurance Agency (Holland) [2021] AATA 92, at [41], I am satisfied that the Tribunal has jurisdiction to consider whether the desired supports should be included in the applicant’s current (2021) plan.[34] I note the email dated 20 November 2020 from the Director of the Administrative Appeals Branch of the Reviews and Complaints Division of the NDIA to the applicant’s representative stating that the NDIA “will consider both the ESS and the IVAS as part of the AAT application”. This is important because the applicant’s circumstances have changed significantly with the birth of his second child. I also note that in terms of the approved funding, there was no significant change in the Plan between 2020 and 2021.[35][35] The 2020 Plan provides total funding of $31,156.81, made up of $21,347.22 for core supports, and $9,809.59 for capacity building supports: T7/87-88. The 2021 Plan provides total funding of $31,185.67, made up of $21,345.22 for core supports, and $9,840.45 for capacity building supports: R23/651. The plans are subject to automatic review after 12 months.POST HEARING DEVELOPMENTS(a) QDKH, by his litigation representative BGJF v National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] FCAFC 189 (18 October 2021)

Decision

Reasons for decision

I therefore set aside, under subsection 43(1)(c) of the AAT Act, the decision of the IRO dated 14 May 2020, and remit the matter to the Secretary for reconsideration, with a recommendation to carry out a Plan Review; taking into account the Tribunal’s finding that, under the applicant’s current plan, the ESS system does not meet the ‘reasonable and necessary’ criteria under section 34 of the NDIS Act, or Part 5 of the NDIS Rules. DECISION The decision under review is set aside and remitted to the Secretary pursuant to subsection 43(1)(c) with a recommendation to conduct a plan review, taking into account the Tribunal’s findings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As noted above, there is no funding provision in the current Plan for the support systems recommended by Ms Vernon. THE RATIONALE FOR THE REQUESTSThe ESS In his initial reaction to the approved 2020 Plan, the applicant explained his concerns about security issues as follows: Due to my hearing disability, I cannot hear the sound of people in the external areas of my home. The layout of my home prevents me from viewing the external areas of my home from inside the house. Without visual notification devices, I have a severe lack of safety in my home. This also results in a lack of independence in my daily life and reduced mental health…The [ESS] will provide me with visual notification and identification of people in the external areas of my home. This will increase my level of safety in my home, independence and mental health. [43][43] T4A/64. He also stated:The [ESS] is ‘solely and directly’ related to my hearing disability, as my primary purpose of the [ESS] is for visual notification. The fact that the general hearing population use [ESS] in their homes for general home security and non-disability related needs is irrelevant in consideration of my circumstances. Due to my hearing disability I cannot hear the sound of a person entering the external areas of my home or breaking into my house. Unlike hearing people, I have a unique need for visual notification, as I cannot rely on sounds to notify me of intruders in my home. Accordingly, my use of the [ESS] is an ‘additional cost solely and directly related to’ my hearing disability, that ‘I would not necessarily otherwise incur’ if I were hearing. This satisfies the requirement in r 5.2(a) Rules… Please note that a video doorbell system is an unsuitable alternative option, as it only provides visual notification of people who are standing outside my front door. This does not meet my need for visual notification of people in the external areas of my home (the front yard and back yard).I have an increased need for the [ESS] due to my circumstances The following circumstances heighten my lack of safety in my home:a) Young DependentsWithout adequate visual notification of intruders in my home, I cannot provide a safe environment for my 2-year-old son and newborn baby. This creates a severe lack of safety for my young children, who depend on me for their safety needs. My children’s lack of safety is compounded by the fact that there are no hearing occupants in the home, as my fiancée is also deaf. b) No adult hearing occupants My fiancé is deaf and shares the same notification needs. There are no hearing occupants in my home who can notify me of intruders in the external areas of my home a) (sic) Neighbourhood crime rate:My home is located in an area that has a high rate of home burglaries and break-ins, particularly it is nearby a train station.b) (sic) Layout of the home My home has a street front and does not have external structures to provide privacy and enclosure, exposing it to possible intruders. Also, the large backyard and layout of the house make it difficult for me to view the external areas of my home from inside my house … How has it affected you?Without the [ESS], I continue to have a severe lack of safety in my home. In particular, I am at high risk of serious injury or death, in circumstances of home invasion or burglary, where: a) I cannot seek timely police assistance or intervention; and b) I cannot protect myself, my loved ones in the home or my valuables. This also results in: a) lack of independence in my daily life. I cannot independently monitor my home security and independently take timely action in response to intruders in my home; and b) reduced mental health. As a result of the lack of my own safety and the safety of my loved ones in my home, I experience anxiety and restless nights. What outcome are you seeking? I am seeking the provisions of the [ESS] as outlined in the CCTV report.[44][44] T1A/64-6.The visual alert system (interior) (IVAS)