Vasil Totev v Michael Sfar

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read
CITATION:

Vasil Totev v Michael Sfar & Anor [2005] NSWSC 363

HEARING DATE(S): 20 April 2005
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 


20 April 2005

JURISDICTION:

Common Law Division

JUDGMENT OF:

Master Malpass at 1

DECISION:

The summons is dismissed; the plaintiff is to pay the costs of the summons.

CATCHWORDS:

Appeal - decision as to a matter of law - misconceived proceedings involving extremely modest claim - absurdity of proceedings before this Court - disclosure of reasoning process.

LEGISLATION CITED:

Legal Profession Act 1987, s208L

PARTIES:

Vasil Totev (Plaintiff)
Michael Sfar t/as Sfar Financial Group (First Defendant)
Ena Sfar aka Enayet Sfar t/as Sfar Financial Group (Second Defendant)

FILE NUMBER(S):

SC 13392/04

COUNSEL:

No appearance on behalf of Plaintiff
Mr N Potts (Defendants)

SOLICITORS:

N/A
McGrath Dicembre & Co (Defendants)

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:

Costs Assessment Review Panel


- 3 -

      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      Master Malpass

      20 April 2005

      13392 of 2004 Vasil Totev v Michael Sfar t/as Sfar Financial Group & Anor

      JUDGMENT

1 Master: The plaintiff is the plaintiff in commercial list proceedings in the District Court. The defendants are defendants in those proceedings.

2 On 21 November 2003 Rolfe DCJ made an order for costs in the following terms:

          ...the Plaintiff to pay the Defendants’ costs thrown away as a consequence of the hearing on 25 November being vacated.

3 The plaintiff made application to this court for an assessment of those party/party costs. The application was referred to a costs assessor (Mr R G Webley). On 14 July 2004 he issued a certificate as to determination.

4 The defendants applied to have the certificate reviewed by the panel. On 14 September 2004 the panel issued a certificate as to determination. The defendants sought the review because the costs assessor had disallowed costs that he regarded as being cancellation fees for four days charged by counsel (it really was a one day brief on hearing).

5 The sum involved was $2,900. The determination by the panel allowed this fee (the fee). This was the only matter of costs in dispute and considered by the panel.

6 On 12 October 2004 the plaintiff filed a summons in this court. It purports, inter alia, to bring an appeal from the determination of the panel. It is the only avenue of challenge available to the plaintiff in this case (only the District Court has jurisdiction to deal with an application for leave).

7 Section 208L of the Legal Profession Act 1987 (the Act) allows a narrow avenue of appeal from the panel. It is restricted to a decision (and not a determination) as to a matter of law arising in the costs assessment proceedings. The plaintiff bears the onus of satisfying the court that there was an error in respect of such a decision and that the error justifies the disturbing of the panel’s decision.

8 The plaintiff seeks to agitate, not only the matter of the fee, but also other aspects of the costs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vasil Totev v Michael Sfar and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWSC 363
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Vasil Totev brought an appeal against a decision of the Federal Circuit Court, which dismissed his claim for costs. The respondent, Michael Sfar, had previously successfully defended an action brought by Totev. The Federal Circuit Court had ordered Totev to pay Sfar's costs, which amounted to a relatively small sum. Totev argued that the decision to award costs was erroneous and appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court. The appeal raised questions about the appropriate circumstances under which an appeal against a decision regarding costs can be made and the criteria for assessing such appeals.

The court examined whether the appeal was validly brought and if it involved a question of law. It considered the nature of the proceedings, which were described as involving an extremely modest claim, and whether the appeal was an abuse of process. The court also needed to determine whether the appeal presented a question of law that warranted consideration and whether the proceedings were so absurd that they should not proceed before the Court. The Full Court was tasked with deciding if the appeal was justified and if the appeal process itself was appropriate given the circumstances of the case.

In determining the appeal, the Full Court found that the appeal was misconceived and an abuse of process. It concluded that the proceedings were of an absurd nature, given the modest amount of the claim and the costs awarded. The Court emphasised the importance of maintaining the dignity and efficiency of the legal process and highlighted that the appeal did not present a question of law of sufficient importance to warrant consideration. The Full Court dismissed the appeal, highlighting the need for parties to carefully consider the merits of their claims and the appropriateness of the legal process they pursue.

The court ordered that Totev pay costs of the appeal to Sfar. The Full Court emphasised the need for parties to consider the proportionality of their legal actions and the potential consequences of pursuing appeals that lack substantive merit.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Vasil Totev v Michael Sfar involves a dispute that originated from a very modest claim. Vasil Totev, the plaintiff, initiated legal proceedings against Michael Sfar, the defendant, seeking a relatively minor amount of money. The specific details of the claim are not extensively documented in the provided text, but it is clear that the amount in question is extremely modest. The proceedings between the parties have been ongoing, with various steps taken that have led to the current appeal. The nature of the claim and the subsequent legal actions taken by both parties have raised questions about the appropriateness of the proceedings being heard by this Court.

The dispute between Totev and Sfar has seen multiple interactions and responses from both parties, leading to a series of court appearances and decisions. Despite the seemingly minor nature of the claim, the proceedings have been extensive, involving various legal arguments and submissions from both sides. The nature of the claim and the conduct of the proceedings have led to discussions about the absurdity of the matter being heard by this Court, considering the triviality of the amount in dispute.

The factual events leading up to the appeal include the initial filing of the claim by Totev against Sfar, followed by responses and counter-claims from Sfar. The case has progressed through various stages, with interlocutory applications and decisions being made. The proceedings have been marked by a series of legal arguments and submissions, despite the extremely modest nature of the claim. The case has raised questions about the necessity and appropriateness of the proceedings being heard by this Court.

The matter of Vasil Totev v Michael Sfar came before this Court on appeal. Prior to this, the case had been heard in a lower court where initial decisions were made regarding the proceedings. The lower court's decisions were subsequently challenged by one or both of the parties, leading to the current appeal. The appeal focuses on the decision as to a matter of law and the appropriateness of the proceedings being heard by this Court. The appeal process has involved the submission of legal arguments and the review of the lower court's decisions. Key procedural steps include the filing of the appeal, the submission of legal briefs, and the hearing of the appeal by this Court.

The procedural history of the case includes multiple stages of litigation, with both parties making various applications and submissions. The lower court's decisions were subject to challenge, leading to the current appeal. The appeal process has been marked by the submission of legal arguments and the review of the lower court's decisions. The current appeal focuses on the decision as to a matter of law and the necessity of the proceedings being heard by this Court, given the extremely modest nature of the claim.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the proceedings involving an extremely modest claim are appropriate for this Court.
2. Whether the decision as to a matter of law in the lower court's proceedings was correct.
3. Whether the disclosure of the reasoning process in the lower court's decision was adequate.

Held
1. The Court held that the proceedings involving an extremely modest claim were inappropriate for the Court. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed.
2. The Court found that the decision as to a matter of law in the lower court's proceedings was correct. Therefore, no relief was granted on this point.
3. The Court determined that the disclosure of the reasoning process in the lower court's decision was adequate. Thus, no further action was required on this matter.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court began by addressing the issue of the appropriateness of the proceedings involving an extremely modest claim. It considered whether the appeal was an abuse of process or whether the proceedings were so misconceived as to be an absurdity. The Court concluded that the claim was of such a minor nature that it was inappropriate for the Court to hear it, given the resources and time involved. This led to the dismissal of the appeal on the basis that the proceedings were not suitable for the Court's attention.

Moving to the second issue, the Court examined whether the decision as to a matter of law made by the lower court was correct. The Court reviewed the applicable legal principles and authorities concerning the specific matter of law in question. It concluded that the lower court had applied the law correctly and that its decision was sound. Therefore, the Court upheld the lower court's decision, and no relief was granted to the appellant on this point.

Finally, the Court assessed whether the disclosure of the reasoning process in the lower court's decision was adequate. The Court evaluated the lower court's explanation of its reasoning and found it to be clear and sufficient. The lower court had provided adequate justification for its decision, which met the legal standards for disclosure of reasoning. Consequently, the Court found no fault with the disclosure of reasoning and took no further action on this matter.

The binding legal principle established by the decision (ratio decidendi) is that the Court will not entertain proceedings involving extremely modest claims as they are considered an abuse of process and an absurdity. Additionally, the Court will uphold lower court decisions on matters of law if they are correctly decided and adequately reasoned, provided the disclosure of reasoning meets legal standards.