Varghese Trading As v Guard Electrical Services v John (Civil Dispute)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



VARGHESE TRADING AS V GUARD ELECTRICAL SERVICES v JOHN (Civil Dispute) [2016] ACAT 103

XD 138/2016

Catchwords:              CIVIL DISPUTE – disputed oral agreement for electrical work not included in inclusion list in building contract – work carried out – non payment of invoice – credibility 

Legislation cited:      ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT) ss 16, 17, 18, 48

Tribunal:                   President E Symons

Date of Orders:  9 September 2016                   

Date of Reasons for Decision:         9 September 2016

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          XD 138/ 2016

BETWEEN:EALIAS VARGHESE TRADING AS V GUARD ELECTRICAL SERVICES

Applicant

AND: THUINDYAL JOHN TITUS JOHN

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:             President E Symons

DATE:  9 September 2016

ORDER

The Tribunal Orders that:

  1. Judgment for the applicant for $5,181 plus the filing fee of $140, interest on the judgment from 5 September 2015 calculated in accordance with the Court Procedure Rules 2008, $313.45, and the applicant’s costs of $100 which totals $5,734.45.

  2. The respondent pay to the applicant, within 28 days of this Order, the amount of $5,734.45.

………………………………..

General President L Crebbin

for and on behalf of President E Symons

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Proceedings

  1. The applicant filed a civil dispute debt application (the application) in the tribunal on 8 February 2016 seeking that the respondent pay him $5,820 (the debt), the filing fee of $140 and interest from 24 December 2014 calculated in accordance with the Court Procedure Rules 2006. The debt claimed is for “extra electrical work mutually agreed” at the respondent’s property on Block 6 Section 33 Coombs (the property) between 24 November 2014 and 10 August 2015.

  2. The applicant is also known as ‘Roy’ and is referred to as Roy in some of the material relied on in this matter. He filed the following documents with his application:

    (a)statement by the applicant;

    (b)email from applicant to the respondent dated 19 September 2015 enclosing invoice 511;

    (c)tax invoice 511 to the respondent for $5,821;

    (d)email from the respondent to the applicant dated 20 September 2015 stating all of the work done at his place was done by Mansa Consulting within the contract limit which he had cleared;

    (e)emailed letter from Dr Sunil Tewari, Director, Mansa Consulting Pty Ltd dated 26 October 2015 to the applicant, respondent and Vavoli and attachments;

    (f)email from Sunil Tewari to the applicant dated 20 October 2014 and attached plan and engineering design for the respondent’s property;

    (g)email from Sunil Tewari to the applicant dated 25 August; and

    (h)bundle of photographs.

  3. The respondent filed a response on 7 March 2016 in which he admitted liability for $704 of the debt. The respondent denied liability for the remainder of the debt claimed. The respondent filed the following documents with his response:

    (a)statement by the respondent;

    (b)email from the respondent dated 18 October 2015 to Mansa Consulting and email from the CBA to the respondent dated 6 August 2015 for payment of $376; and

    (c)email from Sunil Tewari to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Varghese Trading As v Guard Electrical Services v John (Civi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] ACAT 103
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Varghese Trading As v Guard Electrical Services v John, the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal was tasked with adjudicating on a dispute involving an alleged oral agreement for electrical work. Varghese Trading, trading as Guard Electrical Services, claimed against John, asserting that an oral agreement existed for electrical work which was not included in the inclusions list in the building contract. The work was performed, but John did not pay the invoice. The crux of the dispute centred on the credibility of the evidence presented by both parties concerning the existence and terms of the alleged oral agreement. The Tribunal needed to determine whether such an agreement existed and, if so, whether it was binding and enforceable against John.

The primary legal issue the Tribunal had to address was whether the oral agreement for electrical work was valid and enforceable. The Tribunal considered the evidence regarding the alleged agreement and whether it met the requirements for a binding contract, including offer, acceptance, consideration, and intention to create legal relations. Additionally, the Tribunal had to assess the credibility of the testimonies and evidence provided by both parties. The secondary issue involved the enforceability of the agreement given the exclusion of electrical work in the inclusions list of the building contract.

The Tribunal found in favour of Varghese Trading. It concluded that the oral agreement was valid and enforceable, and that the evidence presented by Varghese Trading was credible and persuasive. The Tribunal held that the alleged oral agreement met all the necessary criteria for a binding contract and was not precluded by the exclusion of electrical work in the inclusions list of the building contract. As a result, the Tribunal ordered that John pay Varghese Trading $5,181 plus the filing fee of $140, interest on the judgment from 5 September 2015 calculated in accordance with the Court Procedure Rules 2008, $313.45, and the applicant’s costs of $100, totalling $5,734.45. The Tribunal mandated that this amount be paid within 28 days of the Order.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal Orders that:

1.

Judgment for the applicant for $5,181 plus the filing fee of $140, interest on the judgment from 5 September 2015 calculated in accordance with the Court Procedure Rules 2008, $313.45, and the applicant’s costs of $100 which totals $5,734.45.

2.

The respondent pay to the applicant, within 28 days of this Order, the amount of $5,734.45.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established