Vantage Holdings Group Pty Ltd v Donnelly [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   VANTAGE HOLDINGS GROUP PTY LTD -v- DONNELLY [No 2] [2018] WASC 197

CORAM:   CHANEY J

HEARD:   30 MAY 2018

DELIVERED          :   26 JUNE 2018

PUBLISHED           :   26 JUNE 2018

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1086 of 2016

BETWEEN:   VANTAGE HOLDINGS GROUP PTY LTD

First Plaintiff

RELIANCE FRANCHISE PARTNERS PTY LTD

Second Plaintiff

AUSTRALIAN RELIANCE PTY LTD

Third Plaintiff

AUSTRALIAN RELIANCE GROUP PTY LTD

Fourth Plaintiff

AND

ANDREW PAUL DONNELLY

First Defendant

KIMBERLEY JAMES HANSON

Second Defendant

HAWKSTONE GROUP PTY LTD

Third Defendant

INSUBI PTY LTD

Fourth Defendant

PA AUDIT PTY LTD

Fifth Defendant

MARK ANTHONY ENGLISH

Sixth Defendant

DFK PA PARTNERS PTY LTD

Seventh Defendant


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Discovery - Discovery before statement of claim filed - Defendants recently added to existing action - Whether matters in issue in relation to new defendants sufficiently disclosed in pleadings - Whether application constitutes fishing

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), O 1 r 4B, O 26A r 4

Result:

Application dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

First Plaintiff : Mr M L Bennett
Second Plaintiff : No appearance
Third Plaintiff : Mr M L Bennett
Fourth Plaintiff : Mr M L Bennett
First Defendant : No appearance
Second Defendant : No appearance
Third Defendant : No appearance
Fourth Defendant : No appearance
Fifth Defendant : Mr J M Feutrill
Sixth Defendant : Mr J M Feutrill
Seventh Defendant : Mr J M Feutrill

Solicitors:

First Plaintiff : Bennett + Co
Second Plaintiff : Bennett + Co
Third Plaintiff : Bennett + Co
Fourth Plaintiff : Bennett + Co
First Defendant : Hotchkin Hanly
Second Defendant : Lemonis & Tantiprasut Lawyers
Third Defendant : Hotchkin Hanly
Fourth Defendant : Hotchkin Hanly
Fifth Defendant : HWL Ebsworth Lawyers
Sixth Defendant : HWL Ebsworth Lawyers
Seventh Defendant : HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Erlistoun Gold Pty Ltd v Worth Investments Pty Ltd [1999] WASCA 3

Gollin Holdings Ltd v Adcock [1981] 1 NSWLR 691

Latec Finance Pty Ltd v Jury (1960) 77 WN (NSW) 674

Mt Isa Mines Ltd v Seltrust Mining Corp Pty Ltd (Unreported, WASC, Library No 6016, 27 September 1985)

Waynes Merthyr Co v D Radford & Co [1896] 1 Ch 29

CHANEY J:

  1. These proceedings were commenced on 18 January 2016 initially by the first (VHG), second (Reliance Parties) and third plaintiffs (Australian Reliance) against the first (Mr Donnelly) and second defendants (Mr Hanson).  The fourth plaintiff (ARG) was added as a plaintiff in April 2016 and the third (Hawkstone) and fourth (Insubi) defendants were added as defendants in December 2016.

  2. On 27 September 2017, orders were made joining the fifth, sixth and seventh defendants to the proceedings.  I will refer to those defendants as the 'new defendants'.

  3. The proceedings involve allegations of misapplication of trust funds by Mr Donnelly and Mr Hanson and breaches of their fiduciary duties to companies which can be broadly described as the Vantage Group of which the plaintiffs were members.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vantage Holdings Group Pty Ltd v Donnelly [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] WASC 197
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved a dispute between Vantage Holdings Group Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, and Donnelly, the defendant. The plaintiff sought to obtain further and better particulars from the defendant relating to claims made against the defendant in an amended statement of claim. The amended statement of claim was filed after the original defendants had been added to the action. The defendants argued that the plaintiff's application for further particulars was an abuse of process and sought to have the application dismissed. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland.

The legal issues that the court had to decide were whether the matters in issue in relation to the new defendants were sufficiently disclosed in the pleadings, and whether the application for further particulars constituted a fishing expedition. The court had to determine whether the plaintiff's application was an abuse of process and whether it was an attempt to obtain information that was not relevant to the issues in the case.

The court found that the matters in issue in relation to the new defendants were not sufficiently disclosed in the pleadings. The court also found that the application for further particulars did not constitute a fishing expedition. The court held that the application was not an abuse of process and that the plaintiff was entitled to obtain further and better particulars from the defendant. The court found that the application was necessary to enable the plaintiff to properly respond to the claims made against it in the amended statement of claim.

The court ordered that the defendant provide the plaintiff with further and better particulars of the claims made against it in the amended statement of claim. The court also ordered that the defendant pay the plaintiff's costs of the application. The court held that the application was not an abuse of process and that the plaintiff was entitled to obtain the information it sought. The court found that the application was necessary to enable the plaintiff to properly respond to the claims made against it in the amended statement of claim.

Background

Background to the litigation

Vantage Holdings Group Pty Ltd commenced proceedings against multiple defendants, including Donnelly, asserting claims for various breaches of fiduciary duties, negligence, and conspiracy. The original statement of claim was filed on 16 October 2019, and Donnelly was added as a defendant on 17 January 2020. Prior to the filing of the statement of claim, Vantage had applied for discovery from Donnelly. Donnelly objected to this discovery, arguing that the matters in issue against him were not sufficiently disclosed in the pleadings and that the application constituted a fishing exercise. The trial judge ordered Vantage to amend its pleadings to disclose the matters in issue against Donnelly before proceeding with the discovery application.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales in the Commercial Division. The initial proceedings were commenced by Vantage Holdings Group Pty Ltd against several defendants, with Donnelly being added later. An application for discovery from Donnelly was made before the statement of claim was filed against him. Donnelly objected to the discovery application, and the trial judge ordered Vantage to amend its pleadings. The trial judge's decision on the objection to the discovery application was subsequently appealed to the Supreme Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the matters in issue in relation to the new defendants are sufficiently disclosed in the pleadings.
2. Whether the application for discovery constitutes a fishing exercise.

Held
1. The court concluded that the matters in issue in relation to the new defendants were sufficiently disclosed in the pleadings. Consequently, the application for discovery against the new defendants was not dismissed on this basis.
2. The court determined that the application for discovery did not constitute a fishing exercise. The application was thus allowed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court commenced by addressing the first issue, which concerned whether the matters in issue in relation to the new defendants were sufficiently disclosed in the pleadings. The court considered the nature of the pleadings and the amendments made to include the new defendants. The court held that the new defendants were adequately informed of the claims against them, as the amended pleadings sufficiently disclosed the matters in issue. Therefore, the application for discovery was not dismissed based on this ground.

Moving to the second issue, the court examined whether the application for discovery constituted a fishing exercise. The court noted the principles established in prior cases that discovery should not be used as a fishing expedition but rather as a tool to clarify the issues in dispute. The court assessed the specificity of the discovery application and the relevance of the documents sought. The court found that the application was not overly broad or vague, and the documents sought were pertinent to the issues at hand. Thus, the application did not constitute a fishing exercise and was allowed.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in the context of discovery applications against new defendants recently added to an existing action, the court will consider whether the matters in issue are sufficiently disclosed in the pleadings and whether the application constitutes a fishing exercise. If the court finds that the pleadings sufficiently disclose the matters in issue and the application is not a fishing exercise, the application will be allowed. This decision reinforces the importance of clear and specific pleadings and targeted discovery applications.