Franciscus Van Den Heuvel v Tom Tucker
[2000] SADC 131
His Honour Judge Taylor
Civil
On the weekend commencing Friday, 9th June 1995 a number of people travelled from Adelaide to Coober Pedy to play in a tournament of the game of ‘eight ball’.
Five of them travelled in one car, the car being a 1977 Valiant Chrysler station wagon, rear drive and automatic, with the automatic lever on the steering wheel.
The five sat in the same positions for the journey to Coober Pedy and return.
Frank Van Den Heuvel (the plaintiff) was the captain of the team and he had provided the car, having borrowed it from his brother.
The driving to and from Coober Pedy was shared by the plaintiff and Tom Tucker, (the defendant), and those two sat alternately driving or in the seat next to the driver.
The other three sat in the back seat, Steve Nikolavcic sat behind the front passenger, Frank Deeble was in the rear centre seat and Jason Tucker (son of the defendant) sat behind the driver.
The plaintiff drove the car from Adelaide to Woomera and the plaintiff requested that the defendant then drive the car to Coober Pedy.
The section between Adelaide to Woomera is approximately 534 kilometres and the section from Woomera to Coober Pedy is approximately 266 kilometres.
Whilst the defendant was driving the car on the section from Woomera to Coober Pedy, when about 80 kilometres before Coober Pedy, they saw a car by the side of the road and it was the car of John Stam - another car going to the Coober Pedy competition. This car was broken down and it is generally agreed that they would tow it to Coober Pedy. The car was a Holden Statesman and apparently a tow rope was obtained from the plaintiff’s car. Frank Deeble left the car at that incident after a dispute over warm beer.
The tow then commenced with the distance between the two cars being between nine to twelve feet, varying with different witnesses.
The defendant says that the Chrysler did not have enough power to tow fast as he had to have his foot to the floor to make any headway.
Stam complains that the tow was too fast at around 110 kilometres per hour.
The defendant disputes this.
In the event, they all arrived at Coober Pedy without incident at about 7.00 - 7.30pm that Friday night.
The method of driving from Adelaide to Coober Pedy, that is, the driving of the plaintiff, taken from the following passages of the transcript pages 8, 9 and 10.
EVIDENCE OF FRANCISCUS VAN DEN HEUVEL
“Q.... When you drove up did you average an approximate speed, or did you drive at any set parameters of speed.
A. Once I got to the open road, I was sitting just under 100.
Q. Just under 100 km/h.
A. Yes.
Q...... The state limit is 110 km/h, could you explain why you drove at 10 km/h under the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Van Den Heuvel v Tucker No. DCCIV-98-763 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] SADC 131
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that there was no evidence to support the plaintiff’s claim that the defendant drove at an excessive speed. The court accepted the evidence of the defendant and his passenger that the car was travelling at a speed of between 110 and 120 kilometres per hour, and that any increase in speed was unconscious. The evidence of the other passengers was inconsistent and unreliable. The court found that the defendant was not negligent in relation to his speed and that he was a candid and credible witness.
The court considered the evidence of three expert witnesses on the mechanics of the accident and the defendant’s reaction time. The court found that the accident was caused by the failure of the left-hand rear axle, which was an extremely rare event. The court accepted the evidence of the defendant’s expert that the failure of the axle occurred instantaneously and that the defendant could not have done anything to prevent the accident. The court found that the accident was an inevitable accident and that the defendant was not negligent.
Accordingly, the court dismissed the plaintiff’s claim.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.