'VAN' and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

Administrative

Appeals

Tribunal

 

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 1313

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No VT2002/12

TAXATION APPEALS  DIVISION )
Re ‘VAN’

Applicant

And

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal Mr B. Pascoe, Senior Member

Date16 December 2002

PlaceMelbourne

Decision The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

.........Sgd. Mr B. Pascoe..............

Senior Member

Net proceeds from sale of shares  569,637

Cost base of shares

Exercise price  180,999

Market value of options on acquisition    16,456           197,455

372,182

ithe applicant objected to the notice of assessment for the year ended 30 June 2000 on the grounds that the date of acquisition of the shares was the date of the contract for the acquisition of the options, the shares were held for greater than 12 months prior to their disposal and he was entitled to reduce the capital gain by 50%.

4.      Section 109-10 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (“the 1997 Act”) states:-

“This table sets out some, specific rules for the circumstances in which, and the time at which, you acquire a CGT asset otherwise than as a result of a CGT event happening.

Acquisition rules (no CGT event)

Item     In these circumstances                    You acquire the asset at this time

….

2.A company issues or   when contract is entered into or if

allots equity interests in the               none, when equity interest issued

company to you  or allotted.

…..”

5.      The sole question in dispute was the date when the contract for the acquisition of the 120,666 shares disposed of in the year ended 30 June 2000 was entered into.  For the applicant it was contended that the contract was entered into when the options were acquired in August 1996.  For the respondent it was contended that the contract was entered into when the applicant exercised his options and shares were allotted in December 1999 and March 2000.  The significance is that, if the applicant is correct, he is entitled to a 50% discount on the assessable profit on sale of the shares.

6.      The option certificate issued to the applicant was in the following terms:-

“This is to certify that the abovenamed (hereinafter called the “Option Holder”) is the registered holder of the number of options set out above which expire not later than at 5.00pm on the final day of the Option period and is entitled to subscribe for and be allotted ordinary shares of 10 cents fully paid in the capital of the Company on the terms and conditions set out on the back hereof and the Memorandum and Articles of Association of the Company.  Subject to those terms, the Option can be exercised only by the Option Holder completing and signing a form of application for shares on exercise of the Option and delivering it to the Option Register at any time prior to the expiry of the Option Period accompanied by this Option Certificate and payment of $1.50 in respect of each share”.

7.      The terms and conditions of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 'VAN' and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 1313
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of 'VAN' and Commissioner of Taxation, the Federal Court was tasked with determining whether certain shares acquired under an employee share option scheme resulted in a capital gain that was eligible for a discount. The dispute centred around the appropriate valuation date for these shares for the purposes of capital gains tax. The taxpayer argued that the valuation date should be the date the option was granted, while the Commissioner contended that the valuation date should be when the option was exercised. The case hinged on the interpretation of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 and relevant case law, including Laybuff v Amoco Australia Pty Ltd, Sydney Futures Exchange v Australian Stock Exchange Ltd & Another, Elmslie & others v Federal Commissioner of Taxation, and Brooks and another v Federal Commission of Taxation.

The central legal issue was the date on which the contract for the acquisition of the shares was entered into, which would determine the value of the shares at the time of acquisition. The court had to decide whether the contract was entered into when the option was granted, allowing for a discount on the capital gain, or when the option was exercised, which would not allow for such a discount. This interpretation was critical because it would affect the amount of capital gain subject to taxation and, consequently, the tax liability of the taxpayer.

The court examined the relevant statutory provisions and case law to determine the appropriate valuation date. It concluded that the contract for the acquisition of the shares was entered into when the option was granted, aligning with the decision in Laybuff v Amoco Australia Pty Ltd. The court found that this date was the point at which the shares were effectively acquired for tax purposes. As a result, the shares were valued at the grant date, which allowed for the application of a discount on the capital gain. The decision was affirmed by the Tribunal, which upheld the taxpayer's position on the valuation date for the shares.

The final orders of the Tribunal were that the decision under review was affirmed, meaning that the taxpayer's argument regarding the valuation date for the shares was upheld. The taxpayer was entitled to the discount on the capital gain based on the valuation date being the date of the grant of the option. This decision provided clarity on the interpretation of the relevant tax provisions and the application of the discount to capital gains in the context of employee share option schemes.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns the taxation treatment of a capital gain arising from the acquisition of shares by an individual under an employee share option scheme. The taxpayer, referred to as 'VAN,' acquired shares in his employer company through such a scheme. The central issue in the case is whether the shares were acquired at the date of the grant of the option or at the date of the exercise of the option, which would determine whether the capital gain is subject to a discount under the relevant taxation provisions. The Commissioner of Taxation assessed VAN for tax on the capital gain, treating the acquisition date as the date of the grant of the option. VAN contested this assessment, arguing that the acquisition date was the date of the exercise of the option, which would entitle him to a discount on the capital gain.

The background to the case includes the statutory provisions of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, which outline the taxation of capital gains. The case also refers to previous cases such as Laybuff v Amoco Australia Pty Ltd (1974) 132 CLR 57, Sydney Futures Exchange v Australian Stock Exchange Ltd & Another (1995) 128 ALR 417, and administrative decisions such as Elmslie & others v Federal Commissioner of Taxation 93 ATC 4964 and Brooks and another v Federal Commission of Taxation 2000 ATC 4362, which provide context and precedent for the interpretation of the relevant taxation laws.

The matter came before the tribunal as an appeal against a decision made by the Commissioner of Taxation. The initial decision, which was the subject of the appeal, assessed VAN for tax on the capital gain from the share acquisition under the employee share option scheme. The tribunal reviewed this decision, hearing arguments from both VAN and the Commissioner of Taxation. The tribunal's role was to determine whether the Commissioner's assessment was correct according to law, considering the statutory provisions and relevant case law and administrative decisions.

Key procedural steps in the tribunal's consideration of the case included the submission of written arguments by both parties, the presentation of evidence, and the oral hearing where both parties had the opportunity to present their cases and respond to the arguments of the other side. The tribunal also considered the relevant statutory provisions and precedents in its deliberations.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the shares were acquired at the date of the grant of the option or the date of the exercise of the option for the purposes of determining the capital gain.
2. Whether the capital gain is subject to a discount under the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 based on the acquisition date.
3. Whether the tribunal should affirm or overturn the decision of the Commissioner of Taxation in light of the arguments presented and the applicable law.

Held
1. The court held that the shares were acquired at the date of the grant of the option for the purposes of determining the capital gain.
2. The court held that the capital gain is not subject to a discount under the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 based on the acquisition date.
3. The court held that the tribunal should affirm the decision of the Commissioner of Taxation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal considered the legal principles surrounding the acquisition of shares under employee options and their impact on capital gains tax. In determining the date of acquisition of shares for capital gains tax purposes, the Tribunal relied on the principle that the date of acquisition is when the contract for the purchase of the shares is entered into. This principle was affirmed by the High Court in Laybuff v Amoco Australia Pty Ltd (1974) 132 CLR 57, where it was held that the contract for the purchase of the shares is the key factor. The Tribunal applied this principle to conclude that the shares were acquired at the date of the grant of the option, not the date of exercise.

Regarding the discount available under section 115-205 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, the Tribunal examined the statutory provisions and relevant case law. The Tribunal noted that the discount is not applicable to shares acquired under employee options. It relied on the decisions in Elmslie & others v Federal Commissioner of Taxation 93 ATC 4964 and Brooks and another v Federal Commission of Taxation 2000 ATC 4362, which held that the discount does not apply to such shares. The Tribunal concluded that the capital gain was not subject to a discount.

Finally, the Tribunal reviewed the decision of the Commissioner of Taxation in light of the arguments presented and the applicable law. Given the determinations on the acquisition date and the inapplicability of the discount, the Tribunal affirmed the Commissioner's decision. The binding principle established in this decision is that shares acquired under employee options are treated as acquired at the date of the grant of the option for capital gains tax purposes, and the discount under section 115-205 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 does not apply to such shares.