Valherie v Strata Corporation No 1841

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Civil)

VALHERIE v STRATA CORPORATION NO 1841 AND ORS

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Perry, The Honourable Justice Bleby and The Honourable Justice Gray)

9 June 2004

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH JUDGE'S FINDINGS OF FACT - FUNCTIONS OF APPELLATE COURT - WHERE INFERENCES OF FACT INVOLVED

TORTS - NUISANCE - WHAT CONSTITUTES - PRIVATE NUISANCE

Appeal against judgment of single judge of this court - appeal against decision of the Magistrates Court allowed by single judge - whether magistrate erred in findings of fact - whether magistrate erred in assessment of the date from which the appellant continued a nuisance - whether the cause of the nuisance can be attributed to the second and third respondents - roots from a tree in the appellant's backyard caused cracking to the neighbouring first respondent's units - the first respondent informed the appellant that damage was being caused to the units by the tree - the appellant informed the first respondents that she would not be residing at the premises - principles of nuisance discussed - burden of proof discussed - assessment of damages discussed - appeal allowed to reduce award of damages only - appeal dismissed in all other respects.

Proprietors of Strata Plan No 14198 v Cowell (1989) 24 NSWLR 478; Hargrave and Ors v Goldman (1963) 110 CLR 40; Richard City Council v Scantelbury [1991] 2 VR 38; Valherie v Strata Corporation 1841 [2002] SASC 398; Morgan v Khyatt (1964) 1 WLR 475; Sedleigh-Denfield v O'Callaghan [1940] AC 880; Torette House Pty Ltd v Berkman (1940) 62 CLR 637, considered.

VALHERIE v STRATA CORPORATION NO 1841 AND ORS
[2004] SASC 170

Full Court:  Perry, Bleby and Gray JJ

  1. PERRY J. I agree that the appeal should be allowed and that an order be made in the terms suggested by Gray J. I agree with his reasons and have nothing to add.

  2. BLEBY J. I agree that the appeal should be allowed. I agree with the orders proposed by Gray J and with his reasons.

    GRAY J.

    Introduction

  3. This appeal concerns a claim in nuisance.

  4. Following a trial a magistrate concluded that a property owner was liable for damages flowing from the continuation or adoption of a nuisance.  The nuisance was said to arise from an encroachment by tree roots onto a neighbouring property.  It was alleged that damage was caused to buildings.  The defendant Daniele Valherie, the owner of the property on which the tree was situated, denied liability, disputed the alleged loss and damage and claimed an indemnity from third parties, Ms Mitchell and Ms Arnott, the previous owners of the property.  The magistrate found in favour of the plaintiff, Strata Corporation No. 1841 and assessed damages at $23,962.00.  He concluded that Ms Mitchell and Ms Arnott were also liable and assessed their liability at $2,500.00.

  5. Ms Valherie appealed to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Valherie v Strata Corporation No 1841 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] SASC 170
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Valherie v Strata Corporation No 1841 involved Ms Valherie, the appellant, and Strata Corporation No 1841, the respondent. Ms Valherie had purchased property in Windsor Gardens, which included a lemon scented gum tree. This tree's roots caused structural damage to neighbouring units owned by Strata Corporation No 1841. The primary issue was whether Ms Valherie was liable for the damage to the units after she became aware of the problem. The court also had to determine if the damage could be attributed to Ms Valherie and whether she continued the nuisance by failing to take appropriate action. Additionally, the court considered the burden of proof regarding the extent of the damage and the appropriate assessment of damages.

The court delved into the principles of nuisance, particularly focusing on the distinction between public and private nuisance. It noted that private nuisance involves the unreasonable interference with the use and enjoyment of property or material damage to land. The court examined whether Ms Valherie adopted or continued the nuisance by failing to remove the tree or take remedial action after becoming aware of the damage. The court also scrutinized the conduct of Strata Corporation No 1841, which had not disclosed critical information about the damage and had misled the court, thereby complicating the assessment of damages.

The court held that Ms Valherie was not liable for the damage that occurred before she became aware of the nuisance, which was the end of 2000. It concluded that her liability for damages began in 2001 when she continued the nuisance by not taking appropriate action. The court also highlighted the failure of Strata Corporation No 1841 to provide adequate evidence regarding the extent of the damage, which hindered the assessment of the compensable loss. Consequently, the appeal was allowed to reduce the award of damages to $21,875.00, while the appeal was dismissed in all other respects. The court's decision underscored the importance of timely and adequate action in addressing nuisances and the necessity for both parties to provide relevant information to facilitate a fair assessment of damages.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ms Valherie appealed to a judge of this court. Ms Mitchell and Ms Arnott cross-appealed. The learned judge confirmed the primary finding of nuisance against Ms Valherie but reduced the damages to $21,875.00. The judge allowed the appeal by Ms Mitchell and Ms Arnott and entered judgment in their favour. There has been no appeal from this order. Ms Valherie has appealed to this court pursuant to leave against the judgment entered in favour of Strata Corporation 1841.Facts In April 1999 Ms Valherie purchased a property at 4 Lothian Avenue, Windsor Gardens (‘the property’) from Ms Mitchell and Ms Arnott who had owned the property for approximately 20 years. During their ownership, the garden was well maintained and watered. A lemon scented gum tree was situated on the property close to the boundary of a neighbouring property owned by Strata Corporation 1841. This tree was well established when Ms Mitchell and Ms Arnott purchased the house. The tree was approximately ten metres tall by the late 1990s. Ten strata title units stood on the neighbouring property, built in two blocks of five. Concrete surrounded the units. One, unit 8, was situated about three metres from the lemon scented gum. Shortly after purchase, Ms Valherie became concerned about the structural soundness of the house on her property. She sought professional advice about cracks in her walls and others signs of structural damage. She commissioned a report from Archicentre. In a report dated 17 April 1999 the highly reactive soil and trees growing in close proximity to the house on her property were identified as contributing to structural damage. The report advised Ms Valherie to maintain constant soil moisture balance all year round and to consider removing a number of trees, including the lemon scented gum. She was advised to maintain a consistent garden watering regime:On reactive soils adequate watering during dry-spells is important to prevent excessive drying out which could lead to excessive soil movement. A good soaking once a week would be required rather than a little watering each day. Observe that there is a reasonable water penetration into the soil. Some soils may need treatment, such as coring, in order to assist with this. Consult with a gardening or landscaping centre.With large trees and shrubs in the vicinity, try to install post-holes around the perimeter of the plant’s drip-line. Fill these holes with coarse sand or gravel and use these holes for direct watering in order to keep water of general watering to a minimum. By November 1999, Ms Valherie became increasingly distressed about the condition of the house and sought to rescind the contract for the purchase of the property. In July 2000 she commenced proceedings in the District Court against Ms Mitchell and Ms Arnott. During this time Ms Valherie suffered from a depressive mental condition. In October 2000 Ms Valherie abandoned the property, claiming that it was no longer fit for occupation. She continued to pursue legal action to rescind the contract.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

PERRY J BLEBY J GRAY J
In January 2003 Ms Valherie joined Ms Mitchell and Ms Arnott as third parties claiming an indemnity. The trial was conducted by a magistrate in April 2003.The Decision of the Magistrate On 6 May 2003 the magistrate delivered judgment. The magistrate accepted the expert evidence from Mr Liney, the engineer who provided the Kourkourou report to the corporation. He found that the damage to the units was brought about by excessive soil movement caused by the withdrawal of moisture from the soil by the lemon scented gum. He concluded that Ms Valherie was liable for the cost of repairs because, knowing of the risk of damage to the units, she failed to remove the tree or take alternative remedial action. He found Ms Valherie liable in nuisance and assessed damages at $23,962.00. He found that Ms Mitchell and Ms Arnott were liable to indemnify Ms Valherie in the amount of $2,500.00.Issues on AppealLiability for Damage The central issue relating to liability for damage was whether Ms Valherie ‘adopted the nuisance’ caused by the lemon scented gum when she purchased the property. Nuisance can be public or private. Private nuisance is the infringement of rights related the ownership or occupation of land. Private nuisance can occur by unreasonable interference with use and enjoyment of property rights or by material damage to land. Material damage caused to property by encroaching roots of a tree located in a neighbouring property can constitute private nuisance and can amount to actionable nuisance. In Morgan v Khyatt the court observed that[2]:… [I]t has … long been established as a general proposition that an owner of land may make any natural use of it; but also (and by way of qualification of the general rule) that if an owner of land grows or permits the growth on his land in the natural way of trees whose roots penetrate into adjoining property and thereby cause and continue to cause damage to buildings upon that property, he is liable for the tort of nuisance to the owner of that adjoining property.[2] Morgan v Khyatt (1964) 1 WLR 475 at 477 The occupier of premises from which a nuisance emanates may be liable for nuisance, even if the occupier did not create the nuisance.[3] This liability arises if the occupier adopts or continues the nuisance. The remarks of Viscount Maughan in Sedleigh Denfield v O’Calloghan are apposite:[4]…[A]n occupier of land ‘continues’ a nuisance if with knowledge or presumed knowledge of its existence he fails to take any reasonable means to bring it to an end though with ample time to do so.[3] Sedleigh-Denfield v O’Callaghan [1940] AC 880[4] Sedleigh Denfield v O’Calloghan [1940] AC 880 at 894 Although negligence is not an essential element in nuisance, fault is a necessary element in ‘continuing’ or ‘adopting’ a nuisance.[5] This element requires that an occupier of the premises from which a nuisance emanates was aware, or ought to have been aware, of the existence of the nuisance and fails to take any reasonable means to bring it to an end.[6] It follows that an occupier who did not create a nuisance and neither knew or ought to have known of it, cannot be liable for that nuisance.[7][5] Sedleigh-Denfield v O’Callaghan [1940] AC 880[6] Sedleigh Denfield v O’Calloghan [1940] AC 880 at 894[7]Torette House Pty Ltd v Berkman (1940) 62 CLR 637; Richard City Council v Scantelbury [1991] 2 VR 38 and Hargrave and Others v Goldman (1963) 110 CLR 40

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: PERRY J, BLEBY J, GRAY J

Relevantly the judge then concluded:If the Magistrate intended to find Ms Valherie liable for damage occurring before that date, to that extent only he was in error. My impression from his reasons is that he did so intend, but his reasons are not clear on the point.It follows from this that Ms Valherie should not be liable for the cost of repairing damage done to the Corporation units before the end of the year 2000. She is liable to pay damages only for the consequences of her wrongful conduct, and in my view, her liability is for the loss caused by her continuance of the nuisance. That loss as a matter of law, begins from the year 2001, because that is when she is treated as continuing the nuisance. I note that the same approach was taken by Hodgson J in Proprietors of Strata Plan No 14198 v Cowell (1991-1992) 24 NSWLR 478.The Conduct of Strata Corporation 1841 The question of compensable loss was complicated by the conduct of Strata Corporation 1841. As earlier observed Strata Corporation 1841 did not provide a copy of the Kourkourou report to Ms Valherie and failed to disclose the ‘strong recommendation’ of Kourkourou that the lemon scented gum be removed immediately. Strata Corporation 1841 deliberately ignored Ms Valherie’s request that it communicate with her at her Paris address. Strata Corporation 1841 misled the court when obtaining an order for substituted service. This conduct led to a delay in the removal of the lemon scented gum and also denied Ms Valherie the opportunity to consider the immediate removal of the gum.The Burden of Proof There is a further difficulty. As the judge correctly concluded, the magistrate failed to consider that the units were already damaged before Ms Valherie adopted or continued the nuisance and became liable for ongoing damage. The burden of proving the extent of loss was on Strata Corporation 1841. The measure of compensable loss necessarily involved a comparison of the extent of the damage to the units as at the end of the year 2000 with the extent of the damage at the time of the removal of the tree. What was the further damage? Did the further damage lead to a greater repair expense? What was the extra expense? Strata Corporation was in a position to lead evidence addressing these issues. An estimate of the cost of repairs at the two dates could have been made. The difference between the two would represent the primary loss of the Corporation. However this evidence was not placed before the magistrate. As a result the court has been left to make the best assessment it could on inadequate evidence.The Extent of Damage All the neighbouring units suffered some structural damage prior to Ms Valherie becoming aware that the units were being damaged by the roots of the lemon scented gum. Strata Corporation 1841 was in a position at the time it commissioned the engineer’s report in late 2000 to obtain an estimate of the cost of repairs. Its advisers Kourkourou had examined the units in late 2000 as well as at the time of the removal of the tree. The extent of the damage could be assessed and an estimate of the cost of repairs undertaken. The existing damage to unit 8 was significant as evidenced by the Housing Trust order.