Urban Construct Pty Ltd v City of Holdfast Bay

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Civil)

URBAN CONSTRUCT PTY LTD v CITY OF HOLDFAST BAY

[2006] SASC 201

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Nyland, The Honourable Justice Sulan and The Honourable Justice Layton)

13 July 2006

LOCAL GOVERNMENT - TOWN PLANNING

Appeal from the Environment, Resources and Development Court of South Australia.  Application to demolish one of a pair of semi detached dwellings - refusal by Council confirmed by ERD Court - Residential (Foreshore) Zone - total demolition of a building complying development in the zone - whether demolition of one dwelling total demolition and therefore complying - nature and impact of proposed development on amenity considered - objectives for policy areas within zone - no evidence as to proposed replacement of building in the event of demolition - appeal dismissed - held application was for partial demolition of building and therefore non-complying.

Development Act 1993 s 4; Development Regulations 1993 Schedule 4, Part 1, s 1(1)(c), referred to.
Urban Construct P/L v City of Holdfast Bay [2005] SAERDC 55 (5 July 2005), discussed.
City of Mitcham v Freckmann & Ors (1999) 74 SASR 46; City of Mitcham v Freckmann (No 2) (2000) 76 SASR 145; Prostar v Petroleum Products (1998 - 1999) 72 SASR 383; Transfield v Adelaide Pty Ltd v Corporation of the City of Port Augusta (1982) 76 SASR 145, considered.

URBAN CONSTRUCT PTY LTD v CITY OF HOLDFAST BAY
[2006] SASC 201

Full Court:       Nyland, Sulan and Layton JJ

  1. THE COURT:   The appellant applied to the City of Holdfast Bay Council (“the Council”) to demolish one of a pair of semi-detached two-storey dwellings situated at No. 3 and No. 5 College Street, Glenelg.  The Council refused to grant provisional development planning consent for the demolition of No. 3.  The appellant appealed to the Environment, Resources and Development Court (“the ERD Court”) who confirmed the decision of the Council and dismissed the appeal.  The appellant now appeals to this Court against that order of dismissal.

  2. The premises at No. 3 College Street were vacant at the time of the hearing before the ERD Court but were formerly an occupied dwelling.  They are separately owned from the premises at No. 5 College Street (the remnant building) and the two premises are divided by a common wall and in the roof area by plasterboard.  The owner of No. 5 objected to the proposal to demolish No. 3.  There did not appear to be any structural reasons for the demolition of No. 3 but it is clear that the proposal was intended to make way for further development of the site.  No evidence was provided to the ERD Court as to what that future development might be, nor as to when it might occur.

  3. The land, upon which the premises are situated, is located in Policy Area 4 of the Residential (Foreshore) Zone (“the Zone”), as shown on Map HoB/5 of the Holdfast Bay (City) Development Plan (“the Development Plan”).  The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Urban Construct Pty Ltd v City of Holdfast Bay and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] SASC 201
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Urban Construct Pty Ltd sought approval from the City of Holdfast Bay Council to demolish one of a pair of semi-detached dwellings located within Policy Area 4 of the Residential (Foreshore) Zone. The Council, and subsequently the Environment, Resources and Development Court, refused the application. The applicant appealed to the Supreme Court. The appeal centred on whether the partial demolition of the building constituted a complying development under the Development Plan, and if not, whether the refusal to grant approval was unreasonable. The court had to determine whether the partial demolition of a building was a complying development under the Development Plan, and if the Council's refusal to approve the demolition was unreasonable.

The court held that the partial demolition of a building did not constitute complying development because it did not involve the total demolition and removal of a building, as required by the Development Plan. The court emphasised that the Development Regulations list the total demolition and removal of a building as a complying form of development. Since the applicant's proposal involved only a partial demolition, it did not meet the criteria for complying development. The court also noted that there was no evidence of a proposed replacement development, which would have been necessary to fully assess the impact of the proposed demolition. The court found that the Council's refusal to approve the application was not unreasonable given the lack of information regarding the replacement development and the potential impact on the neighbouring property.

The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal. The court concluded that the partial demolition of the building did not constitute complying development under the Development Plan, and the Council's refusal to approve the application was not unreasonable. The appeal was therefore dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The land, upon which the premises are situated, is located in Policy Area 4 of the Residential (Foreshore) Zone (“the Zone”), as shown on Map HoB/5 of the Holdfast Bay (City) Development Plan (“the Development Plan”). The total demolition and removal of a building is listed as a complying form of development. The Development Regulations provide that the total demolition and removal of a building is a complying development in respect of a Development Plan.[1][1] Development Regulations 1993, Schedule 4, Part 1, s 1(1)(c).The decision of the Council Upon initial consideration of the application, the Council concluded:·The partial demolition of a building did not satisfy the requirements of Table HoB/5 and therefore could not be considered as complying development in that it did not involve building works constituting “the total demolition and removal of a building” in accordance with 1(c); and·The partial demolition of a building was not a listed form of development in Table HoB/6 or under Schedule 9 of the Development Regulations. The Council referred the application to the Council’s Development Assessment Panel (“the Panel”). The applicant was requested to provide a survey by an accredited licensed surveyor to verify the location of the party wall and front veranda posts. The Panel resolved to refuse the application. In its reasons for refusal, the Council determined that the development was not in accordance with the intent of the Development Plan. The Council specifically referred to the lack of information about a replacement development, noting:·The partial demolition is a kind of development to be considered on its merits and assessed against all the relevant provisions of the Development Plan. No approval for a replacement development has been sought. It is unclear how long number 3 will remain vacant and the exposed end of number 5 will be visible. The demolition should be considered in conjunction with assessment of the replacement building.·While the zone anticipates more intensive development of suitable sites than a two storey building, it does not follow that a future application will be approved which increases return on the land. In the meantime, the site of the demolished portion of the building would have little or no return.·There is case law which supports looking at demolition only in conjunction with the replacement building or new use. In addition, the Council noted that the demolition of house No. 3 changed the use of the site, including the house at No. 5, which ceased to be a semi-detached dwelling. The Council noted that no approval had been sought for work that needed to be carried out at No. 5, and that the partial demolition proposal did not adequately address the implications for the front veranda post located partly on No. 3 and No. 5 College Street.Relevant statutory provisions Section 4 of the Development Act1993 (“the Act”) defines development to include “building work”. “Building work” is defined to include the “demolition of a building”. Section 4 also defines the word “building” to mean “a building or structure or portion of a building or structure …” unless the contrary intention appears. These definitions are also applicable to a Development Plan.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established