Up in Smoke Assets Pty Ltd v Zervas Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Up In Smoke Assets Pty Ltd v Zervas Pty Ltd [2023] NSWSC 1227
Hearing dates: On the papers; final submission received 12 October 2023
Date of orders: 16 October 2023
Decision date: 16 October 2023
Jurisdiction:Equity - Expedition List
Before: Parker J
Decision:

See [27]

Catchwords:

COSTS – party/party costs – freezing orders made on interim basis – plaintiff obtains judgment on the pleadings – residual dispute about whether freezing orders should be made on a final basis – costs of and occasioned by application for freezing orders reserved

COSTS – party/party costs – plaintiff obtains judgment on the pleadings – judgment could have been obtained in District Court – alternative claims not determined – plaintiff entitled to costs of proceedings to date of judgment

Legislation Cited:

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, rr 25.10, 25.14, 42.1, 42.34

Cases Cited:

Herron v McGregor (1986) 6 NSWLR 246

Texts Cited:

Nil

Category:Costs
Parties: Up in Smoke Pty Limited (Plaintiff)
Zervas Pty Limited (Defendant)
Representation: Solicitors:
Darby Jones Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Dib & Associates Lawyers (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2023/268614
Publication restriction: Nil

JUDGMENT

  1. This is a costs judgment. The plaintiff has succeeded in the proceedings. But the defendant submits that I should, in the exercise of my discretion, make no order as to costs.

  2. The plaintiff obtained judgment for $653,000. This amount corresponded to amounts which it had paid pursuant to a contract for the purchase of Lamborghini motor vehicles, which have not been delivered. $523,000 of the judgment sum concerned the purchase of one vehicle. The remainder concerned deposits paid under a further contract for the purchase of two further vehicles (of a common model, but distinct from that of the first vehicle). Judgment was entered after the defendant filed a defence admitting liability in restitution for these sums.

  3. The proceedings were commenced by summons, in the Duty List, on 23 August. The plaintiff’s prayers for relief included judgment for $653,000. Further or alternatively, claims were advanced pursuant to the Australian Consumer Law based on allegedly false representations. In aid of its claim, the plaintiff sought the making of freezing orders.

  4. Freezing orders were made on 23 August and then extended. They remain in place until further order and the plaintiff has indicated that it wishes for them to continue until the judgment is satisfied. For its part, the defendant has indicated that it will seek to have the freezing orders discharged. The issue is to be the subject of a hearing in the Applications List on 20 October.

  5. On 8 September, the proceedings came before me in the Expedition List, on the plaintiff’s application for expedition. Although counsel for the plaintiff pressed for me to order expedition, I deferred dealing with the application. Instead, I ordered that the matter continue on pleadings and be adjourned for further mention once the pleadings had been filed and the shape of the contest (if any) had become clear.

  6. The plaintiff filed its statement of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Up in Smoke Assets Pty Ltd v Zervas Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWSC 1227
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Up in Smoke Assets Pty Ltd sued Zervas Pty Ltd over a dispute related to property transactions and contractual obligations. The plaintiff sought relief in the form of damages and sought interim freezing orders to prevent the defendant from disposing of assets. The case eventually reached a stage where the plaintiff obtained a judgment on the pleadings, effectively deciding the dispute in its favour. However, a residual issue remained regarding whether the freezing orders should be made on a final basis.

The court was required to address two primary legal issues. Firstly, whether the freezing orders should continue in effect on a final basis, and secondly, what the appropriate costs order should be given the unique circumstances of the case. The court considered the nature of the relief sought, the stage at which the judgment was obtained, and the implications for both parties. The court also needed to determine the appropriate forum for the proceedings, given that the judgment could have been obtained in the District Court.

The court held that the freezing orders should not be made on a final basis as the relief was no longer necessary. Regarding costs, the court found that the plaintiff was entitled to costs of the proceedings up to the date of judgment, but not beyond. The court reasoned that the plaintiff could have obtained the judgment in the District Court, which would have resulted in lower costs. The court also noted that the alternative claims made by the plaintiff had not been determined, which impacted the final costs order. The court's decision balanced the need for a just outcome with the principle that the costs of litigation should reflect the actual proceedings and outcomes achieved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Up in Smoke Assets Pty Ltd initiated proceedings against Zervas Pty Ltd seeking a declaration and injunctive relief, including freezing orders. The plaintiff alleged that the defendants had engaged in fraudulent and wrongful conduct in relation to certain assets. The plaintiff applied for interim freezing orders to prevent the defendants from dealing with the assets in question. The interim freezing orders were granted by the court. The case proceeded to judgment on the pleadings where the plaintiff was successful in obtaining the declarations and injunctive relief sought. A residual dispute remained regarding whether the freezing orders should be made on a final basis. The plaintiff sought costs of and occasioned by the application for the interim freezing orders, as well as the costs of the proceedings up to the date of judgment.

Up in Smoke Assets Pty Ltd filed a statement of claim against Zervas Pty Ltd, seeking declarations, injunctive relief, and freezing orders. The defendants filed a statement of defence. The plaintiff subsequently applied for interim freezing orders to prevent the defendants from dealing with the assets in question. The interim freezing orders were granted. The case proceeded to judgment on the pleadings where the plaintiff was successful. The plaintiff applied for costs of and occasioned by the application for interim freezing orders, as well as the costs of the proceedings up to the date of judgment.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the freezing orders made on an interim basis should be made on a final basis.
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the costs of and occasioned by the application for interim freezing orders.
3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the costs of the proceedings up to the date of judgment.

Held
1. The court decided that the freezing orders made on an interim basis should not be made on a final basis.
2. The court determined that the plaintiff was not entitled to the costs of and occasioned by the application for interim freezing orders.
3. The court ruled that the plaintiff was entitled to the costs of the proceedings up to the date of judgment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the application of freezing orders in the context of the broader proceedings. The court found that the plaintiff had obtained judgment on the pleadings, which indicated that the substantive claims of the case could be resolved without the need for the freezing orders to be made final. However, since there remained a residual dispute about whether the freezing orders should be made final, the court decided against making them final. The court noted that the application for interim freezing orders was a procedural step that did not necessarily lead to a final outcome on the merits of the case, and therefore the plaintiff was not entitled to the costs associated with this application. Regarding the costs of the proceedings up to the date of judgment, the court considered the plaintiff's success in obtaining a judgment on the pleadings. Despite the unresolved dispute about the freezing orders, the plaintiff's overall success in the proceedings justified awarding costs up to the date of judgment. The court's decision highlighted the distinction between costs associated with specific applications and those related to the overall proceedings, aligning with the principle that a party who succeeds on the merits of their claims is entitled to costs.