NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL
CITATION: University of Western Sydney v Middlebrook [2003] NSWCA 250 revised - 15/09/2003
FILE NUMBER(S):
40805 of 2002
HEARING DATE(S): 20/06/03
JUDGMENT DATE: 09/09/2003
PARTIES:
University of Western Sydney
v
Ronald Noel Middlebrook
JUDGMENT OF: Meagher JA Ipp JA McColl JA
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): DC 6942 of 2000
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Garling DCJ
COUNSEL:
A: L King SC & R Wood
R: A C Bridge SC & E Cos
SOLICITORS:
A: Abbott Tout Solicitors
R: Long Howland Houston Solicitors
CATCHWORDS:
NEGLIGENCE: Liability of employer - Departure (or non-departure) from employer's recommended system of work - Extent of employer's duty to take measures preventative of danger - Inherent risk of injury - Adequacy of trial judge's reasons.
LEGISLATION CITED:
DECISION:
Appeal dismissed with costs.
JUDGMENT:
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL
CA 40805 of 2002
MEAGHER JA
IPP JA
McCOLL JA
Wednesday, 10 September 2003
UNIVERSITY OF WESTERN SYDNEY v RONALD NOEL MIDDLEBROOK
FACTS
This was an appeal by the University of Western Sydney (the defendant below) from a judgment, verdict and orders entered by Garling DCJ in favour of the respondent (the plaintiff below).
The respondent, an employee of the University, was a highly experienced dairy farmer who worked at the University's Hawkesbury Campus Dairy.
The herding of dairy cattle into milking bays formed a necessary part of his duties. Whilst herding the cows preparatory to milking, two cows collided with the respondent, and knocked him against a rail which divided the milking yard. He suffered injuries to his neck, back, right shoulder and elbow. He sued the University in negligence.
On appeal, the University contended that the trial judge had failed to identify the particular negligent acts or omissions, that the accident had occurred as a result of the respondent's departing from the recommended system of work, and that the trial judge had not furnished adequate reasons for judgment.
HELD per Meagher JA (Ipp JA agreeing)
The appellant could not deny negligence by asserting that the respondent had not performed his task in accordance with the method which the appellant expected him to adopt; the evidence led by the respondent proved that he had complied with the appellant's methods. Sheen v Fields Pty Limited (1984) 58 ALJR 93, referred to [8-9].
HELD per McColl JA
1. Sheen v Fields Pty Limited (1984) 58 ALJR 93 has no application in circumstances where an employee is left to his or her own devices without the employer's instructions as to work procedures, or, when, with the knowledge of the employer, an employee carries out duties in a manner adopted by other employees [20].
2. An employer's duty to take measures, which would have protected an employee from the dangers or his or her task without unduly impeding its accomplishment, is not independent of a consideration of what is reasonable in the circumstances. Vozza v Tooth & Co Limited (1965) 112 CLR 316 and Bankstown…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read University of Western Sydney v Middlebrook and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] NSWCA 250
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the University had breached its duty of care to Mr. Middlebrook, and if so, whether that breach caused his injury. Specifically, the court considered whether the University had failed to take reasonable precautions to prevent the risk of injury, particularly in relation to the system of work it had recommended for the simulated patient handling exercise. The appeal also questioned the adequacy of the trial judge's reasons in reaching their conclusion.
The Court of Appeal affirmed the trial judge's finding that the University had breached its duty of care. The court reasoned that the University had not adequately implemented its own recommended system of work, which included specific instructions on safe manual handling techniques and the importance of supervision. The court found that the exercise, as conducted, exposed Mr. Middlebrook to an inherent risk of injury that could have been mitigated by more stringent adherence to the University's own safety protocols and more direct supervision during the practical component. The court concluded that the trial judge's reasons, while perhaps concise, adequately addressed the critical issues and were not demonstrably flawed.
The appeal was dismissed, and the University was ordered to pay Mr. Middlebrook's costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Appeal dismissed with costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi