Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd v Miyamoto

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd v Miyamoto [2004] FCA 982

COPYRIGHT – Assessment of damages – Compilation compact discs of popular music created by disc jockeys for use at nightclubs, hotels, clubs etc – In each case, many copies were made and sold or distributed free to patrons – Respondents knew that their actions infringed applicants’ copyright – Licences to reproduce were unlikely to have been granted by applicants – Whether ordinary damages should be assessed pursuant to s 115(2) or s 116 of Copyright Act – Whether additional damages should be awarded under s 115(4) of that Act – Factors to be taken into account under s 115(4) – Determination of amounts of damages – Whether lump sum costs orders should be made – Whether respondents should be jointly and severally liable for costs – Amounts of costs orders.

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), ss 115, 116

Federal Court Rules, Order 62 rule 36A

UNIVERSAL MUSIC AUSTRALIA PTY LTD & ORS v JUN MIYAMOTO & ORS

N 1331 of 2002

WILCOX J
30 JULY 2004
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 1331 of 2002

BETWEEN:

UNIVERSAL MUSIC AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
FIRST APPLICANT

SONY MUSIC ENTERTAINMENT (AUSTRALIA) LIMITED
SECOND APPLICANT

WARNER MUSIC AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED
THIRD APPLICANT

MURDER INC RECORDS
FOURTH APPLICANT

MCA RECORDS
FIFTH APPLICANT

UNIVERSAL RECORDS
SIXTH APPLICANT

SONY MUSIC ENTERTAINMENT INC
SEVENTH APPLICANT

ATLANTIC RECORDING CORPORATION
EIGHTH APPLICANT

ELECTRA RECORDS
NINTH APPLICANT

ISLAND DEF JAM MUSIC GROUP
TENTH APPLICANT

AND:

JUN MIYAMOTO also known as DJ MOTO
FIRST RESPONDENT

DAVID PACHECO
SECOND RESPONDENT

PETER PAPALII
THIRD RESPONDENT

TAHI CROFT
FOURTH RESPONDENT

NICK GARCIA
FIFTH RESPONDENT

MINESTO PTY LIMITED
trading as ANTHEM RECORDS
SIXTH RESPONDENT

UNSOUND RECORDS PTY LIMITED
SEVENTH RESPONDENT

DANIEL MAXWELL NYAVOR
EIGHTH RESPONDENT

EDMOND NICHOLAS KALEEL trading as SOUL SENSE
NINTH RESPONDENT

CHRISTO PATSANTZOPOULOS trading as
PATSAN'S DANCE MUSIC SPECIALIST
TENTH RESPONDENT

GEORGE PATSANTZOPOULOS trading as
PATSAN'S DANCE MUSIC SPECIALIST
ELEVENTH RESPONDENT

JOE SOU ANAU SITOA
TWELFTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

WILCOX J

DATE OF ORDER:

30 JULY 2004

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Judgment be entered in favour of the first applicant, Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd, the second applicant, Sony Music Entertainment (Australia) Limited, and the third applicant, Warner Music Australia Pty Limited:

(a) in respect of ordinary damages, pursuant to s 116 of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) (‘the Act’), as follows:

(i)as against the first and second respondents, Jun Miyamoto and David Pacheco, jointly and severally, in the sum of nine thousand three hundred and fifty dollars ($9,350);

(ii)as against the third respondent, Peter Papalii, in the sum of four thousand two hundred and fifty dollars ($4,250);

(iii)as against the third, fourth and fifth respondents, Peter Papalii, Tahi Croft and Nick Garcia, jointly and severally, in the sum of four thousand two hundred and fifty dollars ($4,250); and

(iv)as against the sixth and twelfth respondents, Minesto Pty Limited trading as Anthem Records, and Joe Sou Anau Sitoa, jointly and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd v Miyamoto and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 982
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd v Miyamoto, the Federal Court of Australia was tasked with addressing copyright infringement claims brought by Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd, Sony Music Entertainment (Australia) Limited, and Warner Music Australia Pty Limited against several respondents who were involved in the production, distribution, and sale of unauthorised compilation CDs containing copyrighted sound recordings. The court was required to determine the extent of liability for each respondent and to quantify the damages owed by the respondents to the applicants. This involved assessing both ordinary and additional damages under the provisions of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth).

The court considered several key legal issues, including whether the respondents had knowingly infringed the applicants' copyright, and if so, the appropriate measure of damages. Given that none of the respondents disputed the infringement, the court did not need to address certain statutory provisions that would have been applicable if the respondents had claimed ignorance of the infringement. The primary focus was on calculating damages based on the unauthorised reproduction and distribution of the compilation CDs. The court concluded that the respondents' actions were commercial in nature, warranting the imposition of additional damages under section 115(4) of the Act. The court also determined the appropriate lump sum payments for costs against each respondent.

The court found that the respondents' actions were deliberate and commercial in nature, leading to the imposition of additional damages. The total damages awarded were calculated based on the number of unauthorised copies distributed and the commercial benefit derived by the respondents from their actions. The court ordered various respondents to pay specific amounts in ordinary and additional damages, and also directed lump sum payments for costs. These orders were tailored to reflect the respective roles and contributions of each respondent to the infringement activities.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Judgment be entered in favour of the first applicant, Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd, the second applicant, Sony Music Entertainment (Australia) Limited, and the third applicant, Warner Music Australia Pty Limited:

(a) in respect of ordinary damages, pursuant to s 116 of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) (‘the Act’), as follows:

(i) as against the first and second respondents, Jun Miyamoto and David Pacheco, jointly and severally, in the sum of nine thousand three hundred and fifty dollars ($9,350);

(ii) as against the third respondent, Peter Papalii, in the sum of four thousand two hundred and fifty dollars ($4,250);

(iii) as against the third, fourth and fifth respondents, Peter Papalii, Tahi Croft and Nick Garcia, jointly and severally, in the sum of four thousand two hundred and fifty dollars ($4,250); and

(iv) as against the sixth and twelfth respondents, Minesto Pty Limited trading as Anthem Records, and Joe Sou Anau Sitoa, jointly and severally, in the sum of two hundred and sixteen dollars ($216);

(b) in respect of additional damages, pursuant to s 115(4) of the Act, as follows:

(i) as against each of the first and second respondents, Jun Miyamoto and David Pacheco, in the sum of ten thousand dollars ($10,000);

(ii) as against the third respondent, Peter Papalii, in the sum of nine thousand dollars ($9,000);

(iii) as against the fourth respondent, Tahi Croft, in the sum of two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500);

(iv) as against the fifth respondent, Nick Garcia, in the sum of five thousand dollars ($5,000); and

(v) as against the twelfth respondent, Joe Sou Anau Sitoa, in the sum of four thousand dollars ($4,000).

2. Each of the respondents make a lump sum payment to Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd, by way of satisfaction of the applicants’ claim for costs against that respondent, as follows:

(i) Jun Miyamoto – twenty thousand dollars ($20,000);

(ii) David Pacheco – twenty thousand dollars ($20,000);

(iii) Peter Papalii – twenty thousand dollars ($20,000);

(iv) Tahi Croft – ten thousand dollars ($10,000);

(v) Nick Garcia – ten thousand dollars ($10,000);

(vi) Minesto Pty Limited trading as Anthem Records, and Joe Sou Anau Sitoa, jointly and severally – ten thousand dollars ($10,000).

Background

Background to the litigation

It has not been suggested that any of the respondents were unaware that their acts constituted infringement of the applicants’ copyright. Consequently, neither s 115(3) or s 116(2) applies to this case.The essential facts The findings of Lindgren J relate to six CDs compiled and manufactured by one or more of Mr Miyamoto, Mr Pacheco, Mr Papalii, Mr Croft and Mr Garcia from sound recordings in which one or another of the applicants owns the copyright (‘the compilation CDs’). These five respondents all work as disc jockeys providing popular music in venues such as nightclubs, hotels and clubs. The compilation CDs were each given a title. Details of the respondents who made and manufactured copies of the compilation CDs, and the approximate number of copies distributed in each case, are as follows:(i) Bizarre Ride – Miyamoto and Pacheco (150 copies);(ii) Black Label Limited – Miyamoto and Pacheco (150 copies);(iii) Black Label II – Miyamoto and Pacheco (650 copies);(iv) Black Label Vol 3 – Miyamoto and Pacheco (150 copies);(v) Summer Jamz 2002 – Papalii (500 copies); and(vi) Most Wanted Allstars Showtime – Papalii, Croft and Garcia (500 copies). In each case, the compilation CDs were made to enable the maker or makers to use them in musical presentations by the maker, or one of the makers, acting as a disc jockey. However, it would not have been necessary to make so many copies of the compilation CDs for this purpose. The purpose of making many copies was to enable them to be given to audience members, thereby assisting the popularity of the disc jockey, or to be sold to members of the public at prices between $10 and $15 each. Some of the compilation CDs were further reproduced, and copies sold to members of the public, by other unknown persons. The number of further reproduced CDs is not known. There is no evidence that Mr Sitoa was involved in the creation or copying of any of the compilation CDs. He was included as a respondent because he was, and is, a director of Minesto and the manager of the retail business it conducts under the name ‘Anthem Records’. Anthem Records maintains a website upon which it offered for sale three of the compilation CDs: Bizarre Ride, Black Label Limited and Most Wanted Allstars Showtime. The website quoted a price of $18 per copy. According to Mr Sitoa, and there is no other evidence on the point, only about 12 copies of the compilation CDs were sold in this way. Mr Sitoa asserts, and again there is no contrary evidence, that none of the compilation CDs was ever sold at Anthem Records’ shop.Ordinary damages Evidence adduced on behalf of the applicants satisfies me it is unlikely that any of the applicants would have granted a licence to any of the respondents to reproduce its copyright sound recordings on a compilation CD. For this to happen, it would have been necessary for the particular applicant to have obtained the approval of the relevant performing artists. The evidence establishes that approval is frequently denied and that it is particularly likely that approval would be denied for reproduction in a disc jockey compilation. It follows that it would be inappropriate for me to assess damages, under s 115(2) of the Act, on the basis of assumed licences.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

WILCOX J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: WILCOX J

Full text does not contain this section.