FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Universal City Studios LLLP v Hoey trading as DVD Kingdom
[2006] FCA 727
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – proceedings for infringement of copyright - no appearance or defence filed by the respondent – orders sought pursuant to O 35A of the Federal Court Rules by reason of default – whether restraining orders and other relief should be granted
Held: Orders should be made.
Federal Court Rules O 35A
Luna Park Sydney Pty Limited v Bose [2006] FCA 94 cited
Wu v Avin Operations Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 36 cited
Arthur v Vaupotic Investments Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 433 cited
Chappell & Co Ltd v Associated Radio Co of Australia Ltd [1925] VLR 350 citedUNIVERSAL CITY STUDIOS LLLP v HOEY trading as DVD KINGDOM
NSD 252 OF 2006SACKVILLE J
9 JUNE 2006
SYDNEY
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
NSD 252 OF 2006
BETWEEN:
UNIVERSAL CITY STUDIOS LLLP
FIRST APPLICANTTWENTIETH CENTURY FOX FILM CORPORATION
SECOND APPLICANTCOLUMBIA PICTURES INDUSTRIES INC
THIRD APPLICANTPARAMOUNT PICTURES CORPORATION
FOURTH APPLICANTWARNER BROS PICTURES INTERNATIONAL [A DIVISION OF WARNER BROS PICTURES INC]
FIFTH APPLICANTDISNEY ENTERTAINMENT INC
SIXTH APPLICANTUNIVERSAL PICTURES (AUSTRALASIA) PTY LIMITED
(ACN 087 513 620)
SEVENTH APPLICANTTWENTIETH CENTURY FOX HOME ENTERTAINMENT SOUTH PACIFIC PTY LIMITED (ACN 002 412 679)
EIGHTH APPLICANTTWENTIETH CENTURY FOX HOME ENTERTAINMENT AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 076 486 470)
NINTH APPLICANTCOLUMBIA TRISTAR HOME ENTERTAINMENT PTY LTD (ACN 002 489 554)
TENTH APPLICANTPARAMOUNT HOME ENTERTAINMENT (AUSTRALASIA) PTY LTD (ACN 003 914 609)
ELEVENTH APPLICANTROADSHOW FILMS PTY LTD (ACN 100 746 870)
TWELFTH APPLICANTBUENA VISTA HOME ENTERTAINMENT, A DIVISION OF BUENA VISTA (AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED
(ACN 054 610 025)
THIRTEENTH APPLICANTAND:
SHANNAN JOHN HOEY trading as DVD KINGDOM
RESPONDENTJUDGE:
SACKVILLE J
DATE OF ORDER:
9 JUNE 2006
WHERE MADE:
SYDNEY
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The Respondent, whether by himself, his servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, be restrained from, without the licence of the First Applicant or the Seventh Applicant:
(a)selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any copy of a digital versatile disc (DVD) in non-region 4 DVD format embodying any Universal Film.
(b)importing for the purpose of selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any DVD in non-region 4 DVD format embodying any Universal Film.
2.The Respondent, whether by himself, his servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, be restrained from, without the licence of the Second Applicant, the Eighth Applicant or the Ninth Applicant:
(a)selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any copy of a DVD in non-region 4…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Universal City Studios LLLP v Hoey t/as DVD Kingdom and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] FCA 727
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue the court had to address was whether the respondent's actions constituted copyright infringement under the Copyright Act 1968. Specifically, the court needed to determine if the respondent's sale and distribution of non-region 4 DVDs of the applicants' films, without their permission, violated the applicants' exclusive rights to reproduce and communicate their films to the public. The court also had to consider whether the respondent's actions amounted to an infringement of the applicants' exclusive rights to authorise the sale, rental, and distribution of their films.
The court found that the respondent's activities did indeed constitute copyright infringement. The court reasoned that the exclusive rights of the applicants to control the reproduction and communication of their films extended to the distribution of non-region 4 DVDs. The unauthorised sale and distribution of these DVDs by the respondent amounted to an infringement of the applicants' rights. The court further held that the respondent's actions also infringed the applicants' rights to authorise the sale, rental, and distribution of their films. The court granted the applicants an injunction against the respondent, restraining them from selling, distributing, or exhibiting in public any non-region 4 DVDs of the applicants' films without the applicants' licence. Additionally, the court ordered the respondent to deliver up any such DVDs in their possession and scheduled an inquiry into damages. The matter was stood over for further directions regarding the damages inquiry. The respondent was also ordered to pay the applicants' costs as agreed or taxed.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The Respondent, whether by himself, his servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, be restrained from, without the licence of the First Applicant or the Seventh Applicant:
(a) selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any copy of a digital versatile disc (DVD) in non-region 4 DVD format embodying any Universal Film.
(b) importing for the purpose of selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any DVD in non-region 4 DVD format embodying any Universal Film.
2. The Respondent, whether by himself, his servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, be restrained from, without the licence of the Second Applicant, the Eighth Applicant or the Ninth Applicant:
(a) selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any copy of a DVD in non-region 4 DVD format embodying any Fox Film.
(b) importing for the purpose of selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any DVD in non-region 4 DVD format embodying any Fox Film.
3. The Respondent, whether by himself, his servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, be restrained from, without the licence of the Third Applicant or the Tenth Applicant:
(a) selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any copy of a DVD in non-region 4 DVD format embodying any film Columbia Film.
(b) importing for the purpose of selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any DVD in non-region 4 DVD format embodying any Columbia Film.
4. The Respondent, whether by himself, his servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, be restrained from, without the licence of the Fourth Applicant or the Eleventh Applicant:
(a) selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any copy of a DVD in non-region 4 DVD format embodying any Paramount Film.
(b) importing for the purpose of selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any DVD in non-region 4 DVD format embodying any Paramount Film.
5. The Respondent, whether by himself, his servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, be restrained from, without the licence of the Fifth or Twelfth Applicant:
(a) selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any copy of a DVD in non-region 4 DVD format embodying any Warner Film.
(b) importing for the purpose of selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any DVD in non-region 4 DVD format embodying any Warner Film.
6. The Respondent, whether by himself, his servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, be restrained from, without the licence of the Sixth Applicant or the Thirteenth Applicant:
(a) selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any copy of a DVD in non-region 4 DVD format embodying any Disney Film.
(b) importing for the purpose of selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any DVD in non-region 4 DVD format embodying any Disney Film.
7. The Respondent, whether by himself, his servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, be restrained from, without the licence of the Twelfth Applicant:
(a) selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any copy of a DVD in non-region 4 DVD format embodying any Roadshow Film.
(b) importing for the purpose of selling, letting for hire, or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale or hire, distributing for the purpose of trade or by way of trade exhibiting in public any DVD in non-region 4 DVD format embodying any Roadshow Film.
8. The Respondent deliver up on oath any copies in DVD format of the cinematograph films identified in paragraphs 1 to 7 above in the possession, power, custody or control of the Respondent.
9. There be an inquiry as to damages payable by the Respondent pursuant to sections 115 and 116 of the Copyright Act 1968 and additional damages payable pursuant to s115(4) of the Copyright Act 1968.
10. The matter be stood over for further directions relating to the inquiry in paragraph 9 above.
11. The Respondent pay the Applicants' costs as agreed or taxed.
GLOSSARY OF TERMS USED IN ORDER
Universal Film means any film:
(a) of which the First and/or Seventh Applicant is the:
(i) owner (whether because it made the film or has been assigned the copyright in the film); or
(ii) exclusive licensee in Australia of the copyright in the film, and
(b) in relation to which the First and/or Seventh Applicant has Notified the Respondent, or has caused the Respondent to be Notified, is a film of which it is the owner or exclusive licensee in Australia (where such notification includes a notice to the effect that if a film has a particular trade mark (specified in the notice) the First and/or Seventh Applicant is the owner or exclusive licensee in Australia),
including the films listed in the Schedule to this order under heading "Particular Universal Films".
Fox Film means any film:
(a) of which the Second and/or Eighth and/or Ninth Applicant is the:
(i) owner (whether because it made the film or has been assigned the copyright in the film); or
(ii) exclusive licensee in Australia of the copyright in the film, and
(b) in relation to which the Second and/or Eighth and/or Ninth Applicant has Notified the Respondent, or has caused the Respondent to be Notified, is a film of which it is the owner or exclusive licensee in Australia (where such notification includes a notice to the effect that if a film has a particular trade mark (specified in the notice) the Second and/or Eighth and/or Ninth Applicant is the owner or exclusive licensee in Australia),
including the films listed in the Schedule to this order under heading "Particular Fox Film".
Columbia Film means any film:
(a) of which the Third Applicant or the Tenth Applicant is the:
(i) owner (whether because it made the film or has been assigned the copyright in the film); or
(ii) exclusive licensee in Australia of the copyright in the film, and
(b) in relation to which the Third Applicant or the Tenth Applicant has Notified the Respondent, or has caused the Respondent to be Notified, is a film of which it is the owner or exclusive licensee in Australia (where such notification includes a notice to the effect that if a film has a particular trade mark (specified in the notice) the Third Applicant or the Tenth Applicant is the owner or exclusive licensee in Australia),
including the films listed in the Schedule to this order under heading "Particular Columbia Film".
Paramount Film means any film:
(a) of which the Fourth and/or Eleventh Applicant is the:
(i) owner (whether because it made the film or has been assigned the copyright in the film); or
(ii) exclusive licensee in Australia of the copyright in the film, and
(b) in relation to which the Fourth and/or Eleventh Applicant has Notified the Respondent, or has caused the Respondent to be Notified, is a film of which it is the owner or exclusive licensee in Australia (where such notification includes a notice to the effect that if a film has a particular trade mark (specified in the notice) the Fourth and/or Eleventh Applicant is the owner or exclusive licensee in Australia),
including the films listed in the Schedule to this order under heading "Particular Paramount Film".
Warner Film means any film:
(a) of which the Fifth or Twelfth Applicant is the:
(i) owner (whether because it made the film or has been assigned the copyright in the film); or
(ii) exclusive licensee in Australia of the copyright in the film, and
(b) in relation to which the Fifth or Twelfth Applicant has Notified the Respondent, or has caused the Respondent to be Notified, t is a film of which it is the owner or exclusive licensee in Australia (where such notification includes a notice to the effect that if a film has a particular trade mark (specified in the notice) the Fifth or Twelfth Applicant is the owner or exclusive licensee in Australia),
including the films listed in the Schedule to this order under heading "Particular Warner Film".
Disney Film means any film:
(a) of which the Sixth Applicant or the Thirteenth Applicant is the:
(i) owner (whether because it made the film or has been assigned the copyright in the film); or
(ii) exclusive licensee in Australia of the copyright in the film, and
(b) in relation to which the Sixth Applicant or the Thirteenth Applicant has Notified the Respondent, or has caused the Respondent to be Notified, is a film of which it is the owner or exclusive licensee in Australia (where such notification includes a notice to the effect that if a film has a particular trade mark (specified in the notice) the Sixth Applicant or the Thirteenth Applicant is the owner or exclusive licensee in Australia),
including the films listed in the Schedule to this order under heading "Particular Disney Film".
Roadshow Film means any film:
(a) of which the Twelfth Applicant is the:
(i) owner (whether because it made the film or has been assigned the copyright in the film); or
(ii) exclusive licensee in Australia of the copyright in the film, and
(b) in relation to which the Twelfth Applicant has Notified the Respondent, or has caused the Respondent to be Notified, is a film of which it is the owner or exclusive licensee in Australia (where such notification includes a notice to the effect that if a film has a particular trade mark (specified in the notice) the Twelfth Applicant is the owner or exclusive licensee in Australia),
including the films listed in the Schedule to this order under heading "Particular Roadshow Film".
Notified means sending a notice by registered post or delivering a notice by hand to the Respondent's place of business.
SCHEDULE OF PARTICULAR TITLES
PARTICULAR UNIVERSAL FILMS YEAR FIRST PUBLISHED
Meet the Fockers 2004
White Noise 2005
PARTICULAR FOX FILM
Elektra 2005
PARTICULAR COLUMBIA FILM
Spanglish 2004
PARTICULAR PARAMOUNT FILM
Alfie 2004
PARTICULAR WARNER FILM
Ocean's Twelve 2004
PARTICULAR DISNEY FILM
National Treasure 2004
PARTICULAR ROADSHOW FILM
Racing Stripes 2005
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: SACKVILLE J
Full text does not contain this section.