UnitingCare NSW.ACT v Hancock

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

UnitingCare NSW.ACT v Hancock [2014] FCA 391

Citation: UnitingCare NSW.ACT v Hancock [2014] FCA 391
Appeal from: Chief Industrial Magistrate’s Court of New South Wales
Parties: UNITINGCARE NSW.ACT v ELIZABETH HANCOCK, HILARY KILLEN, LEEANNE WATSFORD, GABRIELLE COPELAND, ROBYN CHAPMAN, DEBORAH CAINE, JILLIAN ARCHER, JULIEANN SMITH, KERRIE KNOX, LINDA GILMORE, NENITA GATES and BERNADETTE MCGUINNES
File number(s): NSD 1852 of 2013
Judge(s): BUCHANAN J
Date of judgment: 22 April 2014
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Appeal from Chief Industrial Magistrate’s Court of New South Wales – matter brought as a “small claim” – payment of “in charge” allowance to nurses for undertaking supervisory duties in relation to an aged care facility – whether designation by management of being in charge was necessary – nurses told they were in charge and performed the relevant duties – no error by the Chief Industrial Magistrate’s Court – appeal dismissed
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), ss 548, 548(3)
Local Court Act 2007 (NSW)
Nursing Homes, &C., Nurses’ (State) Award (NSW), cl 10

Local Court of New South Wales, Practice Note Civ 1, reissued 7 January 2013, cl 23

UnitingCare Ageing Enterprise Agreement 2007-2009
UnitingCare Ageing Enterprise Agreement 2009-2011
UnitingCare Aged Care Residential & Community Services Agreement (NSW) 2011-2013, cl 30.1

Cases cited: Allied Pastoral Holdings Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [1983] 1 NSWLR 1
Ashby v Slipper [2014] FCAFC 15
Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 R 67
Bulstrode v Trimble [1970] VR 840
Ellis v Wallsend District Hospital (1989) 17 NSWLR 553
Poricanin v Australian Consolidated Industries Ltd [1979] 2 NSWLR 419
Date of hearing: 5 March 2014
Place: Sydney
Division: FAIR WORK DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 31
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr M P Cleary
Solicitor for the Appellant: Hilliard and Berry Solicitors
Solicitor for the Respondents: Mr N Dawson, NEW Law Pty Ltd

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

FAIR WORK DIVISION

NSD 1852 of 2013

ON APPEAL FROM THE LOCAL COURT OF NEW SOUTH WALES
BETWEEN:

UNITINGCARE NSW.ACT
Appellant

AND:

ELIZABETH HANCOCK
First Respondent

HILARY KILLEN
Second Respondent

LEEANNE WATSFORD
Third Respondent

GABRIELLE COPELAND
Fourth Respondent

ROBYN CHAPMAN
Fifth Respondent

DEBORAH CAINE
Sixth Respondent

JILLIAN ARCHER
Seventh Respondent

JULIEANN SMITH
Eighth Respondent

KERRIE KNOX
Ninth Respondent

LINDA GILMORE
Tenth Respondent

NENITA GATES
Eleventh Respondent

BERNADETTE MCGUINNES
Twelfth Respondent

JUDGE:

BUCHANAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 APRIL 2014

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

FAIR WORK DIVISION

NSD 1852 of 2013

ON APPEAL FROM THE LOCAL COURT OF NEW SOUTH WALES
BETWEEN:

UNITINGCARE NSW.ACT
Appellant

AND:

ELIZABETH HANCOCK
First Respondent

HILARY KILLEN
Second Respondent

LEEANNE WATSFORD
Third Respondent

GABRIELLE COPELAND
Fourth Respondent

ROBYN CHAPMAN
Fifth Respondent

DEBORAH CAINE
Sixth Respondent

JILLIAN ARCHER
Seventh Respondent

JULIEANN SMITH
Eighth Respondent

KERRIE KNOX
Ninth Respondent

LINDA GILMORE
Tenth Respondent

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read UnitingCare NSW.ACT v Hancock and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 391
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In UnitingCare NSW.ACT v Hancock, the dispute centered around the payment of an "in charge" allowance to nurses for performing supervisory duties at an aged care facility. The nurses, represented by the respondents, argued that they were entitled to the allowance based on their designation as being "in charge" of the facility. The appellant, UnitingCare NSW.ACT, contested this, arguing that formal designation by management was necessary for such payment. The case was brought as a small claim before the Chief Industrial Magistrate’s Court of New South Wales, and an appeal was subsequently lodged by the appellant.

The central legal issue for the court was whether the designation by management of being "in charge" was necessary for the nurses to be entitled to the "in charge" allowance. The court examined the evidence provided by the respondents, which included testimonies from various nurses who stated they were told they were in charge during their orientation and had performed supervisory duties for years. The court also considered the appellant's argument that the nurses' memories were unreliable and that there was no formal act of appointment or designation. The court dismissed the appeal, finding that the nurses' testimonies were credible and that they had indeed been told they were in charge and had performed the relevant duties, which was reinforced by the appellant's payment of the allowance.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the evidence presented, emphasizing that the nurses' testimonies were consistent and credible, supported by their long-term performance of supervisory duties. The court found no error in the Chief Industrial Magistrate's decision and dismissed the appeal. The final orders were that the appeal be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There was no suggestion in argument on the appeal that the appellant sought any liberty to cross-examine any witness of the respondents . Rather, the appellant chose to base its evidentiary case on the affidavit of its own witness. It was, therefore, in that way that any relevant challenge was to be made (if at all) to the evidence called by the respondents. The respondents’ evidence at trial There was no challenge on the appeal to the following summary by the respondents of some of the evidence: 9.All of the respondents had been told that the registered nurse in charge was in charge of the facility. Eight of the respondents had been told this during orientation by the registered nurse providing the orientation. Two of the respondents had been told that the registered nurses was [sic] in charge of the facility by the then Director of Nursing, Margaret McMillan; one was told by Anne Calvert, who also was the Director of Nursing at the relevant time; and another on commencement by the Facility Manager, Christine Petersen. 10.The evidence was that, prior to around August 2008, there were two registered nurses on shift. An asterisk was placed next to the nurse-in-charge’s name on the roster and that nurse was paid the allowance for less than 100 beds. After around August 2008, only one registered nurse was rostered for the shift and was paid the in charge allowance for less than 100 beds. 11.Nemita Gates, one of the respondents, gave evidence that, prior to being employed as a registered nurses [sic], she had worked in the hostel as an endorsed enrolled nurse. At that time, she had been told by the then hostel manager, Marilyn Heneicke, that she should contact the in charge registered nurse when she needed advice or assistance. 12.Joylyn Marshall, an endorsed enrolled nurse employed in the hostel gave evidence that, on commencement of employment, she had been told by either her supervisor, Sharon Lockard or the Facility Manager, Christine Peterson, that the registered nurse in charge of the nursing home was also in charge of the hostel and that she was to contact the registered nurses in charge if she needed advice or assistance. Her evidence was also that she was referred to a memorandum on a noticeboard at the hostel which advised that this was to occur. 13.Janet Strodder, an assistant-in-nursing employed in the hostel, gave similar evidence to that of Ms Marshall. 14.Joanne Kelly, an endorsed enrolled nurse employed in the hostel, gave evidence that when she commenced, she was told by the Director of Nursing, Pauline Miller and the Hostel Supervisor, Marilyn Heneicke that the registered nurse in-charge of the nursing home was also in charge [of] the hostel. 15.Both Ms Kelly and Ms Marshall gave evidence that, as endorsed enrolled nurses, they are required to work under the supervision of a registered nurse. (Footnotes omitted.) In an amended notice of appeal, the appellant contended that the evidence given by the respondents and their other witnesses was unreliable because it was based on memories of conversations long ago and because it was “identical in material respects”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The respondents did not suggest that the increased payment could fairly be regarded as an admission. However, payment of the increased allowance by the appellant is relevant in at least one respect. It is relevant that (so far as the evidence showed) the appellant began paying the higher allowance without any change in duties and without any formal or overt act of appointment or designation as “in charge” with respect to the Hostel. It is relevant at least, therefore, to the argument that some such overt or formal act was necessary. The judgment under appeal Judgment was given orally. The Industrial Magistrate identified each of the award and the industrial agreements. Her Honour identified the provisions relied upon. Her Honour identified the central question which the parties have agitated on the appeal. Her Honour summarised the evidence. Her Honour identified the arguments of the parties. In particular, the Industrial Magistrate considered and rejected the proposition that the memories of the respondents were unreliable. The Industrial Magistrate said: In relation to all of these matters, I find for each of the claimants, where the [appellant] says that their memories are not to be relied on, that they are not supported by any senior management, only each other, that not only were they told at the time of their employment what they said was required of them as the registered nurse in charge, but it was duties that they undertook all those years. So they just were not told something, and then given years to forget about it, they were actually employed in those duties. They undertook those duties, that is the evidence of the claimants, that they were not only told something, that they did something, and they worked there for years. They may not be supported in their claims by senior management but Jocelyn Marshall, Janet Strodda and Joanne Kelly all worked under the registered nurses, were all told that the registered nurses were going to be in charge of the facility, not simply the nursing home, and that they could rely on the registered nurses to undertake the duties that the registered nurse would have to undertake, that is the sch 8 drugs, and other duties required of them, and that they called on those registered nurses to undertake those duties. So I do not agree with the [appellant’s] position that they have to have exceptional memories. If they did not do anything, they would, but not only were they told something, but they did something, and that reinforces their memories. In relation to designated, that it is not being defined, but I am satisfied that - and of course the [appellant] says that it needs more than a longstanding delegation that there needs to be something more in terms of something positive being visited on the registered nurses to say that they were actually in charge and were designated that way for the whole facility. Each one of them gives evidence of them being part of an orientation. They were told that they were in charge. It was the way they worked. Nothing was ever done to counter that. There was no contradictory evidence brought by the [appellant]. I know the principle, he who asserts must prove, but there was nothing from the [appellant] to say that on their orientation, and all the names were given, each one of them named who it was that they got the instruction from, none of those were part of the [appellant’s] counter-position to say that that never happened.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.