United Voice v Phillip Cleaning Service Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

United Voice v Phillip Cleaning Service Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 392

File number(s): ACD 132 of 2015
Judge(s): JAGOT J
Date of judgment: 21 April 2017
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW –  whether employer complied with legal obligations to employees  – whether employees underpaid – whether employer misrepresented employee workplace rights – whether required induction provided – whether payslips complied with regulations
Legislation:

Cleaning Services Industry Award 2010

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 50, 323, 345, 536, 550

Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) r 3.46

Phillip Cleaning Services and LHMU Clean Start Union Collective Agreement 2010 for ACT Government Schools

Cases cited: Harbour City Real Estate Pty Ltd t/as Re/Max Harbour City Real Estate (ACN 111 210 023) v Cargill (No 3) [2009] FCA 669; (2009) 186 IR 260
Date of hearing: 14, 15, 16 March 2017
Registry: New South Wales
Division: Fair Work Division
National Practice Area: Employment & Industrial Relations
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 54
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr O Fagir
Solicitor for the Applicants: Mr S Uren of United Voice, appeared on behalf of the Applicants
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr D Allen
Solicitor for the Respondents: Kekatos Lawyers

ORDERS

ACD 132 of 2015
BETWEEN:

UNITED VOICE

First Applicant

NEEKA MWEE

Second Applicant

EH HTOO GYI (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Applicant

AND:

PHILLIP CLEANING SERVICES PTY LTD

First Respondent

ANGELO DI DIO

Second Respondent

JUDGE:

JAGOT J

DATE OF ORDER:

21 APRIL 2017

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicants are to file and serve proposed directions within 14 days providing for the taking of all outstanding steps to bring this matter to completion.

2.The respondents are to notify the applicants and the Court if they consent to the proposed directions within a further seven days thereafter.

3.The proceeding will be listed for directions or hearing on a date to be notified to the parties as necessary having regard to the positions of the applicants and the respondents.

4.The ACT District Registrar is to forward a copy of these reasons for judgment to the Director-General of the ACT Education Directorate.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JAGOT J:

  1. The applicants, the first of which is a union representing the interests of cleaners known as United Voice and the rest of whom are school cleaners employed or formerly employed by the first respondent, Phillip Cleaning Services Pty Ltd) (PCS), contend that PCS contravened various provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (Fair Work Act) and that the second respondent, Angelo Di Dio, has also committed those contraventions as a person involved in them as defined in s 550(1) of that Act. Remedies, including declarations and the payment of wages and annual leave said to be owing and the imposition of pecuniary penalties, are sought. The issue of the imposition of penalties has been deferred pending the determination of liability of PCS…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read United Voice v Phillip Cleaning Service Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 392
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

United Voice, representing employees of Phillip Cleaning Service Pty Ltd (PCS), brought an action against PCS for various breaches of industrial law. The employees, predominantly from the Karen ethnic minority and resettled from refugee camps in Thailand, were engaged in a part-time capacity to clean government schools in the Australian Capital Territory (ACT). The dispute centred on whether PCS complied with its legal obligations towards its employees, including proper payment, induction, and accurate representation of workplace rights. The court was tasked with determining the validity of PCS's claims that it had rectified underpayments, provided appropriate inductions, and correctly represented employees' workplace rights in their letters of appointment.

The legal issues before the court were whether PCS had underpaid its employees, misrepresented their workplace rights, failed to provide required inductions, and whether their payslips complied with regulations. The court examined the evidence presented, including the testimonies and documentary evidence, to ascertain the truth of the allegations. Notably, the court found the evidence of Mr. Angelo Di Dio, the director of PCS, to be self-serving, inconsistent, and largely unbelievable. The court held that PCS had indeed contravened several provisions of the Fair Work Act and the collective agreement governing the employees' terms of employment.

The court reasoned that PCS and Mr. Di Dio had contravened several sections of the Fair Work Act, including failing to pay employees their ordinary rate of pay, not considering the language skills of certain employees in preparing their letters of appointment, not providing any off-site inductions, and not paying a required loading on annual leave pay. Additionally, PCS was found to have knowingly misrepresented the workplace rights of certain employees in their letters of appointment and failed to provide payslips that correctly identified the employer and employer’s ABN. The court concluded that Mr. Di Dio was intricately involved in every aspect of PCS’s contraventions and had complete knowledge of the relevant facts.

The court ordered that the applicants were to file and serve proposed directions within 14 days, providing for the taking of all outstanding steps to bring the matter to completion. The respondents were to notify the applicants and the Court if they consent to the proposed directions within a further seven days thereafter. The proceeding was to be listed for directions or hearing on a date to be notified to the parties as necessary. The court also directed that a copy of these reasons for judgment be forwarded to the Director-General of the ACT Education Directorate.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicants are to file and serve proposed directions within 14 days providing for the taking of all outstanding steps to bring this matter to completion.

2. The respondents are to notify the applicants and the Court if they consent to the proposed directions within a further seven days thereafter.

3. The proceeding will be listed for directions or hearing on a date to be notified to the parties as necessary having regard to the positions of the applicants and the respondents.

4. The ACT District Registrar is to forward a copy of these reasons for judgment to the Director-General of the ACT Education Directorate.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The only other observation I should make is that I did not need to be persuaded by the applicants that the case is important despite the fact that the amounts of money claimed are not large in the context of the kinds of litigation commonly pursued in this Court. The amount of money involved is not a good measure of the importance of a claim of this kind. Background PCS runs a school cleaning business in the Australian Capital Territory (ACT). It is a party to a deed with the ACT and to contracts under that deed which provide for it to clean 10 government schools. Despite repeated denials followed by a belated admission made in the face of overwhelming evidence belying the denials, PCS admits that it employed or employs the applicants other than the first applicant, United Voice. The employment is (or was) on a permanent part-time basis. All but three of the applicants are members of the Karen ethnic minority from Burma. They spent two decades in refugee camps in Thailand before being re-settled in Australia. Their first language is S’gaw Karen. Since 1 May 2011 the employment of the employees, other than the ninth applicant, has been subject to the Phillip Cleaning Services and LHMU Clean Start Union Collective Agreement 2010 for ACT Government Schools (the Agreement). Before this, the Cleaning Services Industry Award 2010 applied (and applies to the ninth applicant). The contracts between PCS and the ACT prescribe not only an hourly rate to be paid by the ACT to PCS, but also the minimum amount which PCS must pay to employees. Payments by the ACT to PCS are based on a formula which provides for work to be carried out 5 days per week 52 weeks per year. In recent years the minimum rate of pay by PCS to employees prescribed by the contracts has exceeded the amount required to be paid under the Agreement. This is because the amount required to be paid under the Agreement has not increased since the nominal expiry date of the Agreement which was 1 July 2013.Mr Di Dio’s evidence Mr Di Dio was not a witness of credit. His evidence was repeatedly self-serving, internally inconsistent and unbelievable. It was difficult not to form the impression that Mr Di Dio was willing to say what he thought might assist the respondents’ case until the impossibility or extraordinary unlikelihood of his oral evidence was exposed, after which he would reformulate his evidence. As submitted for the applicants, this reformulated evidence gave every appearance of being mere invention to overcome the difficulty exposed with his oral evidence. For example:(1)He initially said and repeated when pressed that pay corrections he had made related only to cleaning during holiday periods. This was false. I consider that his initial evidence was a fabrication.(2)He said that he made the pay corrections of his own initiative. In fact, he took this action after being notified by United Voice that PCS had been systematically underpaying the employees.(3)He gave inconsistent evidence about his practice of obtaining signatures of employees on their letter of appointment, and giving them an unsigned duplicate. (4)He said he would read out to the employee PCS’s occupation health and safety policies, which was untrue. When confronted with the extreme unlikelihood that he did any such thing given the length of the document he said he merely showed them where the policies were kept so the employee could access them if they wished. I consider that his initial evidence was a fabrication.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The contracts between PCS and the ACT prescribe not only an hourly rate to be paid by the ACT to PCS, but also the minimum amount which PCS must pay to employees. Payments by the ACT to PCS are based on a formula which provides for work to be carried out 5 days per week 52 weeks per year. In recent years the minimum rate of pay by PCS to employees prescribed by the contracts has exceeded the amount required to be paid under the Agreement. This is because the amount required to be paid under the Agreement has not increased since the nominal expiry date of the Agreement which was 1 July 2013.Mr Di Dio’s evidence Mr Di Dio was not a witness of credit. His evidence was repeatedly self-serving, internally inconsistent and unbelievable. It was difficult not to form the impression that Mr Di Dio was willing to say what he thought might assist the respondents’ case until the impossibility or extraordinary unlikelihood of his oral evidence was exposed, after which he would reformulate his evidence. As submitted for the applicants, this reformulated evidence gave every appearance of being mere invention to overcome the difficulty exposed with his oral evidence. For example:(1)He initially said and repeated when pressed that pay corrections he had made related only to cleaning during holiday periods. This was false. I consider that his initial evidence was a fabrication.(2)He said that he made the pay corrections of his own initiative. In fact, he took this action after being notified by United Voice that PCS had been systematically underpaying the employees.(3)He gave inconsistent evidence about his practice of obtaining signatures of employees on their letter of appointment, and giving them an unsigned duplicate. (4)He said he would read out to the employee PCS’s occupation health and safety policies, which was untrue. When confronted with the extreme unlikelihood that he did any such thing given the length of the document he said he merely showed them where the policies were kept so the employee could access them if they wished. I consider that his initial evidence was a fabrication. I do not accept that Mr Di Dio thought that a company other than PCS employed the employees at any time. I consider that the objective evidence discloses that Mr Di Dio knew at all material times that PCS employed the employees. At best, Mr Di Dio might have hoped that the structure he created using other companies might have shielded PCS from its obligations as an employer and that he was willing to see if this strategy would work if tested. If it worked, it would best serve his purposes and those of PCS to avoid legal obligations to the employers by PCS. If it did not work, PCS and he were in no different a position from that which they otherwise would have been in. In other words, Mr Di Dio’s use of labour hire companies in an attempt to shield PCS from its obligations as an employer is an example of opportunism which, I am satisfied, Mr Di Dio was willing to extend to the respondents’ defence of these proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There can be no doubt that Mr Di Dio was “involved in” PCS’s contraventions. As the submissions for the applicant put it:(1)“In order for a person to be knowingly involved in the contravention, they must be “intentional participant[s], the necessary intent being based upon knowledge of the essential elements of the contravention”: Yorke v Lucas (1985) 158 CLR 661 at 670; generally, Fair Work Ombudsman v South Jin Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1456 at [227]-[234]”.(2)“The evidence, including the evidence of Mr Angelo Di Dio himself, demonstrates that he was … intimately involved in every aspect of the management of PCS. He was involved in the making of the Agreement, the engagement of the Employees, the establishment of the Interposed Entities, the creation and issue of letters of appointment, supervision of Employees’ work, distribution of payslips, addressing employees’ pay and conditions queries and concerns, and a variety of other matters. He was plainly involved in each of the PCS’ contraventions”.(3)Mr Di Dio had “complete knowledge” of all relevant facts including:“(a)the existence of the Agreement;(b)the content of the Agreement;(c)the content of the letters;(d)the fact that the employer had not had regard to the language skills of the Employees;(e)the fact that no off-site inductions, or inductions of any kind, had occurred;(f)the content of the payslips;(g)the Employees’ work patterns; and(h)the wages paid to the Employees”.(4)“Mr Di Dio was party to each contravention alleged against PCS, was knowingly concerned in each contravention, and aided, abetted, counselled and procured each contravention. By virtue of s550(1) of the FW Act he is taken to have committed the contraventions”.Conclusions For the reasons given, PCS and Mr Di Dio have each contravened:(1)s 50 of the Fair Work Act by:(a)failing to pay employees their ordinary rate of pay for their usual hours worked during each period of school holidays;(b)failing to have regard to the language skills of the fourth to sixth and eighth applicants in preparing their letters of appointment;(c)not providing any employee with an off-site induction; and(d)not paying the third, fourth, tenth, fourteen, fifteenth and twenty-second applicants a 17.5% loading on their ordinary pay in respect of the annual leave which they took in December 2015,in breach of a provision or provisions of the Phillip Cleaning Services and LHMU Clean Start Union Collective Agreement 2010 for ACT Government Schools which is an enterprise agreement within the meaning of s 50 of the Fair Work Act; (2)s 345 of the Fair Work Act by knowingly making a false and misleading representation to the fourth to sixth and eighth applicants in their letters of appointment about their workplace rights;(3)s 536(2)(b) of the Fair Work Act by not providing employees with a payslip identifying their employer and employer’s ABN in the periods of about 26 October 2010 and 19 December 2011, August 2012 and June 2013, and 2 December 2014 and 24 February 2015.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Given that the respondents did not accept the offer made, it is necessary for the pay corrections relating to the school holiday periods to be calculated from the records, a time-consuming task. The costs of carrying out this task, so that orders may be made requiring PCS to pay the correct amounts to each employee, should be considered as part of any claim for costs by the applicants against PCS. Given the history of the matter it is reasonable for the applicants to wish to carry out this task, rather than accept whatever PCS might contend (which has proven to be repeatedly false or inaccurate), but it may be that the applicants also wish to claim as part of any adverse costs order against the respondents, the costs of so doing. I will leave that for future argument and consideration.Preparation of the letter of appointment Clause 16.1 of the Agreement concerns the letter of appointment. Clause 16.2, in particular, provides that in preparing the letter the employer will have regard to the language skills of the employee. I am satisfied that in preparing the letters of appointment (a task which Mr Di Dio carried out on behalf of PCS) for the fourth to sixth and eighth applicants, for whom S’gaw Karen was their first language, PCS had no regard to the language skills of those employees and thus contravened cl 16.2 of the Agreement. This inference should be drawn because PCS provided the same letter in the English language to all employees, provided no translation into S’gaw Karen of any letter, did not request any employee who spoke S’gaw Karen who had better skills in the English language than their colleagues to provide any assistance in translation or interpretation, and did not adduce any evidence that any person within PCS gave any regard to this issue at any time or to the requirements of cl 16.2. PCS so conducted itself despite the vast majority of its workforce being Karen none of whom spoke English as their first language. While some of the Karen employees had better English language skills than others, none spoke English as their first language. Those who had better English language skills than others, I infer, could get by day to day in English but were unlikely to be fluent readers of English, particularly not when dealing with a document such as a letter of appointment. For these reasons PCS also repeatedly contravened s 50 of the Fair Work Act by reason of this conduct. Misrepresentations to employees PCS did not ultimately proffer any defence against these claims on behalf of the fourth to sixth and eighth applicants. Each letter of appointment said that the terms and conditions of employment were regulated by the Cleaning Services Award 2010 whether or not the letter was issued before or after the coming into force of the Agreement on 1 May 2011. To the extent that any letter was issued on or from 1 May 2011 (relevantly, to the fourth to sixth and eighth applicants) the letter thus misrepresented the “workplace rights” of those employees because there is such a workplace right if, relevantly, the employee has the benefit of an industrial instrument such as the Agreement (s 341(1)(a) of the Fair Work Act). The misrepresentation was made knowingly by PCS because Mr Di Dio, the director and principal of PCS who prepared the letters, knew that the terms and conditions of employment were regulated by the Agreement and knew that the letters of appointment on and after 1 May 2011 continued to refer to the Cleaning Services Award 2010.