FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| UNITED VOICE v MSS SECURITY PTY LTD | [2015] FCCA 3125 |
| Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Awards – interpretation of award – application for stay pending determination in Fair Work Commission – application granted. |
| Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009, ss.217, 739 |
| ResMed Ltd v Australian Manufacturing Workers Union (No.2) [2015] FCA 537 Teys Australia Beenleigh Pty Ltd v Australian meat industries employees union & Anor [2015] FCA 1033 |
| Applicant: | UNITED VOICE |
| Respondent: | MSS SECURITY PTY LTD |
| File Number: | BRG 929 of 2015 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Vasta |
| Hearing date: | In Chambers |
| Date of Last Submission: | 17 November 2015 |
| Delivered at: | Brisbane |
| Delivered on: | 24 November 2015 |
REPRESENTATION
Upon application on the papers determined in Chambers.
ORDERS
This proceeding be stayed until both matters:-
(a)C2015/7062- MSS security Pty Ltd trading as MSS Security v United Voice; and
(b)AG 2015/6555- MSS security Pty Ltd trading as MSS security
are heard and determined by the Fair Work Commission.
The parties to notify the court within three (3) working days of each application referred to in order one above been determined by the Fair Work Commission.
Either party has liberty to apply to vary these orders.
Costs are reserved.
| FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT BRISBANE |
BRG 929 of 2015
| UNITED VOICE |
Applicant
And
| MSS SECURITY PTY LTD |
Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
Introduction
This is an application by the Respondent, MSS Security Pty Ltd, seeking a temporary stay of the substantive application before this Court. The rationale advanced for the stay is that the Respondent states that there are two matters before the Fair Work Commission that ought be determined prior to this application being heard.
The substantive application revolves around whether the Respondent did not pay its employees properly in accordance with an enterprise agreement.
The Application before this Court
There are two enterprise agreements that the Respondent has entered into with its employees. The first agreement was made in 2011 (“the 2011 agreement”). It contained a clause relating to the “aviation and seaport security allowance”.
The Applicant claims that under this allowance, the employees ought to have been paid more than they were paid.
A new agreement (“the 2014 agreement”) has a similar allowance within it. That agreement has yet to be approved. Apparently, a Commissioner of the Fair Work Commission approved the agreement in April 2015 but recently, the Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission set aside the approval by the Commissioner. The Respondent argues that this means that the Respondent and its employees are still acting under the 2011 agreement.
Whether this is correct or not, does not really affect the substantive application before this Court. The question before this Court is whether the Respondent has complied with its obligations under the enterprise agreement. This will mean that the court will have to do “interpret” the clause in the 2011 agreement.
The Application before the Fair Work Commission
The Respondent has recently launched an application pursuant to s.739 of the Fair Work…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read United Voice v MSS Security Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] FCCA 3125
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Court were whether MSS Security had contravened section 117 of the Fair Work Act by failing to provide the minimum notice period required for termination of employment, and whether it had breached the National Employment Standards by failing to pay employees their accrued but unused annual leave and long service leave upon termination. The Court was also required to consider the appropriate penalties for any proven contraventions.
Judge Vasta found that MSS Security had indeed contravened section 117 of the Fair Work Act by failing to provide the requisite notice of termination to a number of its employees. The Court determined that the notice periods provided were insufficient, and that the employer was not entitled to any reduction in the notice period. Furthermore, the Court held that MSS Security had breached the National Employment Standards by failing to pay out accrued annual leave upon termination. The Court applied the principles of statutory interpretation to the relevant provisions of the Fair Work Act and the National Employment Standards, emphasising the importance of compliance with minimum entitlements.
The Court ordered MSS Security to pay pecuniary penalties for the contraventions of the Fair Work Act and the National Employment Standards. These penalties were calculated based on the seriousness of the breaches and the need to deter future non-compliance.
Background
Background to the litigation
In response to this dispute, MSS Security Pty Ltd has applied to the Fair Work Commission under sections 217 and 739 of the Fair Work Act 2009 to seek clarification and potential amendment of the allowance clause in the 2014 agreement due to alleged ambiguity. United Voice opposes the stay, asserting that the Court should proceed with its determination of the 2011 agreement to provide guidance to the Fair Work Commission. MSS Security Pty Ltd, however, contends that any determination by the Court would be binding and could fetter the Commission’s discretion to interpret the true purpose of the clause.
The substantive application before the Federal Circuit Court seeks to resolve whether MSS Security Pty Ltd complied with its obligations under the 2011 enterprise agreement. The Court must interpret the relevant clause to determine if the employees were underpaid. The Respondent’s applications before the Fair Work Commission, if resolved, could influence the outcome of this case and potentially avoid inconsistencies between the two tribunals. The Court finds that it is in the interests of justice for the Fair Work Commission to first determine the true purpose of the allowance clause and, if necessary, make appropriate amendments. This approach would ensure consistency and potentially expedite the resolution of the substantive application before the Court.
This case, United Voice v MSS Security Pty Ltd, came before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia as an application by MSS Security Pty Ltd seeking a temporary stay of the proceedings. The substantive application revolves around a dispute regarding whether MSS Security Pty Ltd paid its employees correctly under an enterprise agreement. MSS Security Pty Ltd argues that there are two related matters before the Fair Work Commission that should be resolved first. The application before this Court involves interpreting a clause in the 2011 enterprise agreement, while the Fair Work Commission is considering the 2014 agreement, which has a similar clause. MSS Security Pty Ltd claims that since the 2014 agreement has not been approved, the 2011 agreement remains in effect, and any interpretation by this Court could conflict with the Fair Work Commission's jurisdiction to resolve ambiguities and uncertainties in the 2014 agreement. The Court, after considering relevant authorities and submissions from both parties, determined that it was in the interests of justice to stay the proceedings until the Fair Work Commission resolves the related matters, to avoid potential inconsistencies between the two tribunals' determinations.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court should stay the proceedings pending determination of the Fair Work Commission's decisions on the Respondent's applications.
2. Whether the Respondent is still bound by the 2011 agreement or the 2014 agreement, given the status of the 2014 agreement's approval process.
3. Whether the Fair Work Commission has the authority to alter an enterprise agreement clause to reflect its true purpose, even if that has retrospective effect.
4. Whether the court should interpret the clause in the 2011 agreement now or wait for the Fair Work Commission's interpretation, to avoid potential inconsistencies between the two tribunals' determinations.
5. Whether there is any prejudice to the Applicant if the court waits for the Fair Work Commission's decisions before proceeding with the substantive application.
Held
1. Whether the court should stay the proceedings pending determination of the Fair Work Commission's decisions on the Respondent's applications.
The court concluded that it was in the interests of justice for the Fair Work Commission to determine the true purpose of the clause and make any necessary amendments. The court granted the stay of proceedings.
2. Whether the Respondent is still bound by the 2011 agreement or the 2014 agreement, given the status of the 2014 agreement's approval process.
The court did not provide a definitive conclusion on this issue, but it allowed for the possibility that the Respondent could amend their application to include a variation of the 2011 agreement.
3. Whether the Fair Work Commission has the authority to alter an enterprise agreement clause to reflect its true purpose, even if that has retrospective effect.
The court did not provide a definitive conclusion on this issue, but it allowed for the possibility that the Fair Work Commission could alter the clause to reflect its true purpose.
4. Whether the court should interpret the clause in the 2011 agreement now or wait for the Fair Work Commission's interpretation, to avoid potential inconsistencies between the two tribunals' determinations.
The court concluded that it was in the interests of justice to wait for the Fair Work Commission's interpretation to avoid potential inconsistencies between the two tribunals' determinations.
5. Whether there is any prejudice to the Applicant if the court waits for the Fair Work Commission's decisions before proceeding with the substantive application.
The court concluded that there was no prejudice to the Applicant in waiting for the Fair Work Commission's decisions.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Federal Circuit Court of Australia in United Voice v MSS Security Pty Ltd [2015] FCCA 3125 addressed the application for a stay of proceedings pending the determination of the Fair Work Commission's decisions on related matters. The central issue was whether it was in the interests of justice to allow the court to proceed with the substantive application or to await the Fair Work Commission's determination on the Respondent's applications. The court found that a stay was appropriate to avoid potential inconsistencies between the tribunals' determinations.
The court began by noting that it has broad discretion over whether to grant a stay of proceedings, guided by the principle that the stay should only be granted if it is in the interests of justice. The decision was influenced by the cases of ResMed Ltd v Australian Manufacturing Workers Union (No.2) [2015] FCA 537 and Teys Australia Beenleigh Pty Ltd v Australian Meat Industries Employees Union & Anor [2015] FCA 1033, which, while not directly on point, reinforce the principle that the decision rests on what is just and equitable in the circumstances.
The Respondent argued that the 2014 agreement, which had been approved but subsequently set aside, meant that they were still bound by the 2011 agreement. The court, however, did not find it necessary to resolve this issue because the substantive application before the court revolved around the interpretation of the clause in the 2011 agreement. The court recognised that the Fair Work Commission has the authority to alter an enterprise agreement clause to reflect its true purpose, even if that has retrospective effect. This authority allows the Fair Work Commission to look beyond the literal wording of the clause to determine the true intent behind it.
The court also considered the argument that it should interpret the clause in the 2011 agreement now, to avoid potential inconsistencies with the Fair Work Commission's interpretation. The court determined that awaiting the Fair Work Commission's determination would ensure that there is no inconsistency between the two tribunals' decisions. Furthermore, the court saw no prejudice to the Applicant if the court waited for the Fair Work Commission's decisions before proceeding with the substantive application.
In conclusion, the court granted the stay of proceedings pending the Fair Work Commission's determination of the Respondent's applications. This decision was based on the principle that it is in the interests of justice to avoid potential inconsistencies between the tribunals' determinations and to allow the Fair Work Commission to exercise its authority to interpret and, if necessary, alter the clause in question. The ratio decidendi established by this decision is that the court has a discretion to stay proceedings in industrial matters if it is in the interests of justice to do so, particularly when awaiting the determination of related matters before a specialised tribunal can prevent inconsistencies and better inform the court's own determination.