FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
United Group Resources Pty Ltd ABN 17 114 888 201 v Calabro [2010] FCA 22
CORRIGENDUM
MCKERRACHER J
29 JANUARY 2010 (CORRIGENDUM 1 FEBRUARY 2010)
PERTH
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
FAIR WORK DIVISION
WAD 14 of 2010
BETWEEN: UNITED GROUP RESOURCES PTY LTD ABN 17 114 888 201
First ApplicantAGC INDUSTRIES PTY LTD ABN 57 079 939 898
Second ApplicantMODERN ACCESS SERVICES PTY LTD ABN 87 129 312 590
Third ApplicantDOWNER EDI ENGINEERING POWER PTY LTD ABN 53 000 983 700
Fourth ApplicantMONADELPHOUS ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES PTY LTD ABN 52 008 861 836
Fifth ApplicantCBI CONSTRUCTORS PTY LTD ABN 90 000 612 411
Sixth ApplicantDECMIL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 58 116 776 991
Seventh ApplicantFREO GROUP LIMITED ABN 64 009 325 124
Eighth ApplicantMAMMOET AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 77 075 483 644
Ninth ApplicantPCH GROUP LTD ABN 41 009 120 021
Tenth ApplicantRCR CONSTRUCTION & MAINTENANCE PTY LTD ABN 97 063 053 814
Eleventh ApplicantRCR POSITRON PTY LTD ABN 38 106 084 879
Twelfth ApplicantJOHN HOLLAND PTY LTD ABN 11 004 282 268
Thirteenth Applicant
AND: BRAEDEN CALABRO AND OTHERS LISTED IN THE RESPONDENTS’ SCHEDULE
Respondents
JUDGE:
MCKERRACHER J
DATE OF ORDER:
27 JANUARY 2010
WHERE MADE:
PERTH
CORRIGENDUM
1.The reasons for judgment were first published on 29 January 2010 with case citation ‘United Group Resources Pty Ltd ABN 17 114 888 201 v Decmil Australia Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 22’. On 1 February 2010, the case citation was amended to read ‘United Group Resources Pty Ltd ABN 17 114 888 201 v Calabro [2010] FCA 22’.
2.On 1 February 2010, the first-named respondent was also amended from ‘Decmil Australia Pty Ltd’ to ‘Braeden Calabro’.
I certify that the preceding two (2) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment herein of the Honourable Justice McKerracher. Associate:
Dated: 1 February 2010
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
United Group Resources Pty Ltd ABN 17 114 888 201 v Calabro [2010] FCA 22
Citation: United Group Resources Pty Ltd ABN 17 114 888 201 v Calabro [2010] FCA 22 Parties: UNITED GROUP RESOURCES PTY LTD ABN 17 114 888 201, AGC INDUSTRIES PTY LTD ABN 57 079 939 898, MODERN ACCESS SERVICES PTY LTD ABN 87 129 312 590, DOWNER EDI ENGINEERING POWER PTY LTD ABN 53 000 983 700, MONADELPHOUS ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES PTY LTD ABN 52 008 861 836, CBI CONSTRUCTORS PTY LTD ABN 90 000 612 411, DECMIL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 58 116 776 991, FREO GROUP LIMITED ABN 64 009 325 124, MAMMOET AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 77 075 483 644, PCH GROUP LTD ABN 41 009 120 021, RCR CONSTRUCTION & MAINTENANCE PTY LTD ABN 97 063 053 814, RCR POSITRON PTY LTD ABN 38 106 084 879 and JOHN HOLLAND PTY LTD ABN 11 004 282 268 v BRAEDEN CALABRO AND OTHERS LISTED IN THE RESPONDENTS’ SCHEDULE File number(s): WAD 14 of 2010 Judges: MCKERRACHER J Date of judgment: 29 January 2010 Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW - interim injunction - jurisdiction to grant injunction - unlawful industrial action - relevant considerations in exercising discretion - applicants’ undertakings as to damages Legislation: Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) s 3, s 3(2), s 39 , s 39(1), s 39(3), s 49, s 49(1), s 49(1)(c), s 49(3), s 49(3)(a), s 49(4), s 49(6)
Fair Work Act2009 (Cth) s 417(3)(b), s 421, s 421(1), s 545(2)
Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 (Cth)Cases cited: Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2006) 149 IR 299
Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2006) 149 IR 306Date of hearing: 27 January 2010 Place: Perth Division: FAIR WORK DIVISION Category: Catchwords Number of paragraphs: 41 Counsel for the Applicant: K De Kerloy with K Reid Solicitor for the Applicant: Freehills Counsel for the Intervener: SD Harben Solicitor for the Intervener: Clayton Utz
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
FAIR WORK DIVISION
WAD 14 of 2010
BETWEEN: UNITED GROUP RESOURCES PTY LTD ABN 17 114 888 201
First ApplicantAGC INDUSTRIES PTY LTD ABN 57 079 939 898
Second ApplicantMODERN ACCESS SERVICES PTY LTD ABN 87 129 312 590
Third ApplicantDOWNER EDI ENGINEERING POWER PTY LTD ABN 53 000 983 700
Fourth ApplicantMONADELPHOUS ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES PTY LTD ABN 52 008 861 836
Fifth ApplicantCBI CONSTRUCTORS PTY LTD ABN 90 000 612 411
Sixth ApplicantDECMIL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 58 116 776 991
Seventh ApplicantFREO GROUP LIMITED ABN 64 009 325 124
Eighth ApplicantMAMMOET AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 77 075 483 644
Ninth ApplicantPCH GROUP LTD ABN 41 009 120 021
Tenth ApplicantRCR CONSTRUCTION & MAINTENANCE PTY LTD ABN 97 063 053 814
Eleventh ApplicantRCR POSITRON PTY LTD ABN 38 106 084 879
Twelfth ApplicantJOHN HOLLAND PTY LTD ABN 11 004 282 268
Thirteenth Applicant
AND: BRAEDEN CALABRO AND OTHERS LISTED IN THE RESPONDENTS’ SCHEDULE
Respondents
JUDGE:
MCKERRACHER J
DATE OF ORDER:
27 JANUARY 2010
WHERE MADE:
PERTH
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1Upon the applicants giving the usual undertaking as to damages, until 5.00 pm on 5 February 2010, pursuant to s 39 and/or s 49(1)(c) of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) each respondent is restrained from:
(a)engaging in or being a party to or in any way associated with or otherwise involved in any of the following actions in relation to building work on the Pluto LNG Project at Burrup Peninsula (Project):
(i)failing or refusing to attend work on the Project or failing or refusing to accept or perform work on the Project at all;
(ii)performing work on the Project otherwise than in accordance with the terms of his employment contract;
(iii)performing work on the Project in a manner different from that in which it is customarily performed, or adopting any practice in relation to work on the project, the result of which is a restriction or limitation on, or a delay in, the performance of that work;
except where such actions:
(i)are authorised or agreed to by the respondent’s employer; or
(ii)are based upon the respondent’s reasonable concern about an imminent risk to the respondent’s health or safety and the respondent has not unreasonably failed to comply with the directions of the respondent’s employer to perform other available work, whether at the same or another workplace, that was safe and appropriate for the respondent to perform;
(b)interfering with or in any way disrupting the performance of work on the Project by any of the following means:
(i)imposing, maintaining or aiding, abetting, encouraging, directing, procuring, inducing, advising or otherwise being involved in any bans, limitations, restrictions or delays on the performance of work or the acceptance of work by any of the applicants’ other employees to be performed under their terms of employment or in a manner which work is customarily performed with the applicants; and
(ii)imposing, maintaining or aiding, abetting, encouraging, directing, procuring, inducing, advising or otherwise being involved in the taking of days off by any of the applicants’ other employees otherwise than in accordance with rosters specified by the industrial instruments and employment contracts regulating their employment with the applicants.
2Any person affected by the restraints imposed by the injunctive relief has liberty to apply on 48 hours written or electronic notice to the applicants or the Australian Building and Construction Commission.
Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
FAIR WORK DIVISION
WAD 14 of 2010
BETWEEN: UNITED GROUP RESOURCES PTY LTD ABN 17 114 888 201
First ApplicantAGC INDUSTRIES PTY LTD ABN 57 079 939 898
Second ApplicantMODERN ACCESS SERVICES PTY LTD ABN 87 129 312 590
Third ApplicantDOWNER EDI ENGINEERING POWER PTY LTD ABN 53 000 983 700
Fourth ApplicantMONADELPHOUS ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES PTY LTD ABN 52 008 861 836
Fifth ApplicantCBI CONSTRUCTORS PTY LTD ABN 90 000 612 411
Sixth ApplicantDECMIL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 58 116 776 991
Seventh ApplicantFREO GROUP LIMITED ABN 64 009 325 124
Eighth ApplicantMAMMOET AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 77 075 483 644
Ninth ApplicantPCH GROUP LTD ABN 41 009 120 021
Tenth ApplicantRCR CONSTRUCTION & MAINTENANCE PTY LTD ABN 97 063 053 814
Eleventh ApplicantRCR POSITRON PTY LTD ABN 38 106 084 879
Twelfth ApplicantJOHN HOLLAND PTY LTD ABN 11 004 282 268
Thirteenth ApplicantAND: BRAEDEN CALABRO AND OTHERS LISTED IN THE RESPONDENTS SCHEDULE
Respondents
JUDGE:
MCKERRACHER J
DATE:
29 JANUARY 2010
PLACE:
PERTH
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
On the applicants’ urgent application for interim injunctive relief, I made orders that are published herewith. These are my short reasons for doing so.
The applicants seek interim injunctive relief against the respondents as a result of the respondents’ allegedly unlawful industrial action. That action is said to be in contravention of the Woodside Pluto LNG Project 2009 No. 2 Order of Fair Work Australia dated 23 January 2010, the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) (BCII Act) and the Fair Work Act2009 (Cth). Fair Work Australia is the national workplace relations tribunal established under the Fair Work Act.
I gave the Australian Building and Construction Commissioner leave to intervene. Leave was unopposed. The Commissioner supported the case of the applicants.
The application is supported by undertakings as to damages filed by all applicants.
The application is also supported by affidavits. The evidence of Mr Colin Milne, Industrial Relations Consultant, discloses the following matters:
The applicants are building contractors. They are also 'constitutional corporations' and have been engaged to carry out the construction of the Pluto LNG Project at Burrup Peninsular (the Project), currently the biggest construction project in the North West of Western Australia.
The respondents are building workers employed by the applicants (or in the case of the thirteenth applicant, employed by its subcontractors) in connection with the construction of the Project.
Employees who work on the Project are required to work under rosters cycles which are 4 weeks on, 1 week off; 5 weeks on, 1 week off; or 6 weeks on, 1 week off. The employees generally work 10 hour days, Monday to Saturday, on two shifts;
·commencing at 6.30am and ending at 5.00pm each day; and
·commencing at 6.30pm and ending at 4.30am each day.
During the period employees are rostered to work on the Project site, they are accommodated at either Gap Ridge Village, Searipple Village or in their own accommodation.
The applicants engage their construction workforce on the Project site under industrial instruments pursuant to the Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 (Cth).
DECEMBER 2009 INDUSTRIAL ACTION
On or about 27 November 2009, according to Mr Milne, employees on the Project were advised that, effective 4 January 2010, all accommodation at Gap Ridge Village would be managed on a 'Motelling' basis (the Accommodation Changes). The Accommodation Changes resulted from an acute shortage of accommodation on the Project and were made at a Project level (that is, the decision affected all contractors who use the Gap Ridge Village accommodation).
On 1 December 2009 and 2 December 2009, almost all of the employees on the Project who were rostered to work failed to present for work in protest over the Accommodation Changes (the December 2009 Unlawful Industrial Action).
On 2 December 2009, orders were made in respect of the December 2009 Unlawful Industrial Action by Deputy President McCarthy of Fair Work Australia (FWAB) for the employees of the first applicant to return to work, such orders to remain in force until 18 January 2010.
JANUARY 2010 INDUSTRIAL ACTION
On 21 January 2010, further information was provided to workers by Foster Wheeler WorleyParsons on the ‘motelling’ basis of accommodation.
On 22 January 2010 and 23 January 2010, almost all of the employees on the Project who were rostered to work failed to present for work in protest over the Accommodation Changes (the January 2010 Unlawful Industrial Action).
On 23 January 2010, orders were made (effective midnight on 24 January 2010) in respect of the January 2010 Unlawful Industrial Action by Commissioner Cloghan of FWA for employees of the Applicants (other than the Thirteenth Applicant) who were union members to return to work, such orders to remain in force until 28 February 2010.
CURRENT INDUSTRIAL ACTION
On 25 January 2010, almost all of the employees on the Project who were rostered to work failed to present for work in protest over the Accommodation Changes (the Current Unlawful Industrial Action).
On 26 January 2010, there was scheduled work to be performed (despite the public holiday). Once again, most employees who were required to work failed to present for work.
On 26 January 2010, the local union organisers for the Project were contacted and advised of the proposed urgent application to this Court. The unions were also requested to inform their members of the applicants’ intention to seek the urgent relief. The unions requested they be kept informed but did not wish to be heard on the application.
On 27 January 2010, employees on the Project held a meeting in the car park at the Project site commencing at 6.30am and resolved to continue to take industrial action until at least 30 January 2010.
On 27 January 2010, almost all of the employees who were rostered to work failed to present for work.
EFFECT OF INDUSTRIAL ACTION
Mr Milne believes that further industrial action on the Project by the respondents is probable, given the on‑going implementation of the Accommodation Changes over the next 2 months.
He believes the alleged impact of the industrial action on the Project is significant, totalling well in excess of $500,000 per day. These losses arise from:
(a)delay to the current construction program, which ultimately could affect the completion date for the Project;
(b)the costs of having machinery, plant and equipment and general site infrastructure available but not being effectively utilised;
(c)the loss of a percentage of workers who resign due to the industrial action and have to be replaced. There is already a shortage of adequately qualified workers in certain positions and therefore some workers who choose to resign to avoid the industrial action will be very difficult to replace;
(d)significant accommodation costs while no productive work is being carried out (approximately $90 per night, per employee); and
(e)the costs of additional security on site.
There is also a risk that delay to the construction program resulting from industrial action will cause:
(a)extension of time claims by contractors;
(b)contractual penalties claims against contractors for non‑completion of contracted work within the contracted time; and
(c)the inability of WBPL to meet contracts for future gas sales.
Mr Milne has been informed that the situation in and around the accommodation camps, particularly at Gap Ridge Village, is volatile and could easily become violent. He is informed and believes that threats have been made against employees who are not participating in the industrial action, which has resulted in FWW significantly increasing the level of security personnel on site and around the accommodation.
The respondents are currently and have been since 22 January 2010, striking in protest over changes to their accommodation arrangements. There are over 1500 employees involved in this action. Their action is said to be disrupting the performance of the work on the Project and causing significant financial loss to the applicants.
On 23 January 2010, orders were made by Commissioner Cloghan of Fair Work Australia for employees of the applicants (other than the thirteenth applicant) who were union members to return to work, such orders to remain in force until 28 February 2010. The applicants say that most workers have not done so but those who have returned to work are said to be subject to threats from those who have not returned.
The applicants argue that the respondents are engaged in unlawful industrial action for the purposes of the BCII Act.
The Court has jurisdiction to grant an interim injunction to prevent the respondents from engaging in unlawful action under s 39 and s 48 of the BCII Act.
Section 39(1) of the BCII Act empowers the Court to grant an injunction if it is satisfied that unlawful industrial action is:
(a) occurring; or
(b) threatened, impending or probable.
Section 39(3) of the BCII Act provides that the power may be exercised whether or not it appears to the Court that:
(a)the defendant intends to engage again, or continue to engage, in conduct of that kind; and
(b)…
(c)there is an imminent danger of substantial damage to any person if the defendant engages in conduct of that kind.
Section 49(1)(c) and (3) of the BCII Act empower the Court to grant injunctions (including interim injunctions) in relation to a person who has contravened a civil penalty provision. Section 49(6) defines an eligible person to make an application under s 49(1) and (3) to include ‘a person affected by the contravention’. It follows that s 49(1) and s 49(3)(a) of the BCII empower the Court on the present application, to make an interim injunction in relation to a person who has contravened s 38 of the BCII.
Importantly, s 49(3) confers power to grant an interim injunction without reaching a final decision that a contravention has occurred: Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2006) 149 IR 299 at [7], [8]; Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2006) 149 IR 306 at [52].
The power to grant injunctive orders in circumstances where a breach or arguable breach of an Act has or is likely to occur is not uncommon in Federal statutes. The considerations to be taken into account are the strength of the case on that issue, the purpose and objectives of the statute and the balance of convenience. Except to the extent that the specific considerations of the Act in question require addressing, the determination as to whether or not to grant injunctive relief is a process which accords with the general approach in equity to the grant of injunctions.
The power to grant an injunction, including an interim injunction, under s 49 is additional to the Court’s power under s 39 and, unlike the power in s 39, is not predicated on the Court’s satisfaction that unlawful industrial action is occurring or is threatened, impending or probable. Rather, the Court may make any order ‘that it considers appropriate’.
As with s 39(3), s 49(4) also provides that:
(4)If the contravention is a contravention of section 38, then the power of the court to grant an injunction restraining a person (the defendant) from engaging in conduct may be exercised:
(a)whether or not it appears to the court that the defendant intends to engage again, or to continue to engage, in conduct of that kind; and
(b)whether or not the defendant has previously engaged in conduct of that kind; and
(c)whether or not there is an imminent danger of substantial damage to any person if the defendant engages in conduct of that kind.
The grant of interim relief under the BCII Act must also be considered in light of the objects of the Act. The main object of the BCII Act is set out in s 3. Relevantly, subs 2 provides that the main object is to be achieved by the following means:
…
(b)promoting respect for the rule of law;
(c)ensuring respect for the rights of building industry participants;
(d)ensuring that building industry participants are accountable for their unlawful conduct;
The Court is also empowered to grant interim injunctions under s 417(3)(b) and s 545(2) of the Fair Work Act in respect of industrial action and s 421 in respect of any contravention of an order of Fair Work Australia. There may well also be an arguable case on that ground. I am satisfied that there is an arguable case that the respondents are engaging in unlawful industrial action under the BCII Act and in industrial action under the Fair Work Act contrary to that Act in that they have not obeyed the order of Commissioner Cloghan in contravention of s 421(1) of that Act. For present purposes, however, given the urgency of the matter, s 39 and s 49 BCII provide sufficient a basis on which to frame the grant of interim short term relief.
As to the balance of convenience, the evidence at this stage discloses that the actions of the respondents have been and are disrupting the construction of the Project and are causing severe financial loss to the applicants. The daily costs is in hundreds of thousands of dollars. Damages would not be an adequate remedy in this matter because:
(a)the respondents are individuals and are unlikely to have the financial means to meet the level of damages awarded;
(b)the employees who are not participating in industrial action are being subjected to a serious risk of physical and/or psychological harm.
The balance of convenience, in my view, favours the grant of the relief on an interim basis.
An interim injunction in the terms sought in the first part of the applicants’ application for interlocutory relief will be granted. The relief will be short term relief which in substance, requires compliance with the order of Fair Work Australia, that is to say, a return to work. The orders also direct that others returning to work should not be prevented from doing so. However, I have also added liberty to any person affected by the restraints imposed by the orders to apply on short notice. I made the following orders:
1Upon the applicants giving the usual undertaking as to damages, until 5.00 pm on 5 February 2010, pursuant to s 39 and/or s 49(1)(c) of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) each respondent is restrained from:
(a)engaging in or being a party to or in any way associated with or otherwise involved in any of the following actions in relation to building work on the Pluto LNG Project at Burrup Peninsula (the Project):
(i)failing or refusing to attend work on the Project or failing or refusing to accept or perform work on the Project at all;
(ii)performing work on the Project otherwise than in accordance with the terms of his employment contract;
(iii)performing work on the Project in a manner different from that in which it is customarily performed, or adopting any practice in relation to work on the project, the result of which is a restriction or limitation on, or a delay in, the performance of that work;
except where such actions:
(iii)are authorised or agreed to by the respondent’s employer; or
(iv)are based upon the respondent’s reasonable concern about an imminent risk to the respondent’s health or safety and the respondent has not unreasonably failed to comply with the directions of the respondent’s employer to perform other available work, whether at the same or another workplace, that was safe and appropriate for the respondent to perform;
(b)interfering with or in any way disrupting the performance of work on the Project by any of the following means:
(iii)imposing, maintaining or aiding, abetting, encouraging, directing, procuring, inducing, advising or otherwise being involved in any bans, limitations, restrictions or delays on the performance of work or the acceptance of work by any of the applicants’ other employees to be performed under their terms of employment or in a manner which work is customarily performed with the applicants; and
(iv)imposing, maintaining or aiding, abetting, encouraging, directing, procuring, inducing, advising or otherwise being involved in the taking of days off by any of the applicants’ other employees otherwise than in accordance with rosters specified by the industrial instruments and employment contracts regulating their employment with the applicants.
2Any person affected by the restraints imposed by the injunctive relief has liberty to apply on 48 hours written or electronic notice to the applicants or the Australian Building and Construction Commission.
I certify that the preceding forty-one (41) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment herein of the Honourable Justice McKerracher. Associate:
Dated: 29 January 2010
SCHEDULE OF RESPONDENTS
Decmil Australia Pty Ltd 1 Calabro Braeden 2 Pearce Symeon 3 Lee Samuel 4 Johansson Michael 5 Connor John 6 Roberts Mitch 7 McCarty Grant 8 Grigarius Travis 9 Webb John 10 Kendall Simon 11 Scahill Adam 12 Watkins Lee 13 Gilmour Sam 14 Hales Rory 15 Brenton Michael 16 Henaway Caleb 17 Carman Steve 18 Hosking Peter 19 Day Paul 20 Peek Carl 21 Kohler Bradley 22 Smith Shannon 23 Clements Andrew AGC Industries Pty Ltd 1 AINSWORTH Michael 2 ALWAYS Peter 3 ARKEVELD Dirk 4 BAKBAK Bekir 5 BARCHAM Stephen 6 BARKER Georffrey 7 BARTON Richard 8 BARWISE Richard 9 BEILKEN Grant 10 BERMINGHAM Simon 11 BENKIRANE Abdellilah 12 BIGLIN Scott 13 BLACKBOURNE Eden 14 BLOOR Graeme 15 BODY Ross 16 BOGOEVSKI Tom 17 BOWERS Gerard 18 BRIAGAS Genaro 19 BRITCHER Colin 20 BROWN John 21 BROWN Mark 22 BROWN Matthew 23 BROWN Thomas 24 BROWNE Keith 25 BRUCE Robert 26 BUNNER Colin 27 BUNYAN Paul 28 BURGER David 29 BURGESS Derek 30 BURNS James 31 BYERS Shannon 32 CALLAGHAN Stephen 33 CAMPBELL Bevan 34 CAMPION John 35 CARANDANG Adrian 36 CARDOSO Joaquim 37 CARR William 38 CASAS Ramon 39 CASSIDY Chris 40 CATTLE Leslie 41 CHARDON Anthony 42 CHO Han Jeong 43 CHO Myoung Ho 44 CLAY Luke 45 CLAYBURN Richard 46 CLIFTON Dane 47 COLEMAN Allen 48 COLEY Keith 49 COMIA Irineo 50 COOK Geoffrey 51 COSMOS Maria 52 CREAM Kevin 53 CREASEY Grant 54 DANIELL Jared 55 DAVIS Faisal 56 DELLAGOSTINO Ray 57 DOLAR Angel 58 DOWDLE Greg 59 DOWNES Joshua 60 DUDA Brendon 61 ELLIOT Trevor 62 ELLIS Brendon 63 ELLIS Gavin 64 FABER Andrew 65 FINLAYSON Dean 66 FOLEY David 67 FRANCIS Steven 68 FRASER David 69 GARVIE Sean 70 GAZEY Liam 71 GEOGHEGAN Aaron 72 GIBBONS Jean 73 GIBBS Wayne 74 GODDEN Toby 75 GREENLAND Rewi 76 GREHAN Paul 77 HALLAM Neil 78 HANN Troy 79 HANSFORD Gordon 80 HARDINGHAM Victor 81 HARRIS Aiden 82 HARRIS Jack 83 HARRIS Paul 84 HEBBARD Quinton 85 HILL Rodney 86 HILLIER Dion 87 HOPA Boyd 88 HOWELL Dylan 89 HOY Dion 90 HUBBERT Zeke 91 JACK John 92 JAENSCH Corey 93 JAHN Brad 94 JEFFERIES Brad 95 JENKINS Mark 96 JONES Steven 97 JOSEPHS Anthony 98 JOVANOVIC George 99 KAMPMAN Michael 100 KERMODE William 101 KHOO Meow-Ling 102 KIM Hyong Joo 103 KIM Jae Uk 104 KIM Keumyul 105 KIM Tae Shir 106 KNOWLER Steven 107 KOLAR Slavko 108 KYUNG Kyuyel 109 LEDGER Todd 110 LEE Anthony 111 LEE Chongil 112 LEE Hyungkil 113 LEE Kyuyil 114 LOVE Ray 115 LUCKMAN Graham 116 LYNCH Brian 117 MACFARLAN Chris 118 MACKENZIE Alex 119 MAIN Craig 120 MAMUDI Mudzait 121 MARQUES Augusto 122 MARSDEN Warren 123 MARSHALL Roy 124 MARTIN Kean 125 MATIC Mirko 126 MATTHEWS Michael 127 MAXWELL Matthew 128 McBRIDE Neil 129 McCONNELL Terry 130 McDERMOTT Dermott 131 MCLEAN Graham 132 McMILLAN Ian 133 MITCHELL-NGAWAKA Bruno 134 MOON Lee 135 MOREIRA Manuel 136 MORTI Rosita 137 MULLIGAN Barrie 138 NA Myoung Ho 139 PAEHUA Charles 140 PAKU Albert 141 PALLIER Matthew 142 PALLIER Stephen 143 PAMVOUXOGOLOU Benjamin 144 PELOSI Steven 145 PEPPER Shane 146 PES James 147 PES Leslie 148 PIVA Bernard 149 POTTS Paul 150 POUYE Paul 151 PRATLEY Steven 152 PUKE Taare 153 QUINTO Arturo 154 RAMADANI Berat 155 RAO Keith 156 RAVEN Grant 157 RICHARDSON Andrew 158 RIGLEY Peter 159 ROBERTS Ricky 160 ROBINSON Brian 161 ROSALES Dennis 162 SABINE Tom 163 SARNADSKY Kenneth 164 SATUROS Perlito 165 SCHULTZ Drew 166 SEONG Ki Young 167 SEONG Lak 168 SEWELL John 169 SHAVE Anthony 170 SKIPINA Aleksandar 171 SKIPINA Vladmir 172 SMITH Jeff 173 SMITH Ryan 174 SOLOMON Trevor 175 SONG Dong Jin 176 SONG Kichul 177 SOUN Sareun 178 STIVALETTA Joey 179 STOJOSKI Zoran 180 SUYAT Bienvenido 181 SYGUWA Richard 182 TANNER Bradley 183 TAYLOR Raeminn 184 TENISELI Leo 185 THOMAS Gary 186 THOMPSON Tui 187 THOMSON Matthew 188 TURNER Paul 189 TURNER Anthony 190 VALENTINO Anthony 191 VAN TRAN Khanh 192 VENTURA Fabio 193 VOICAN Jacob 194 VOICAN Marian 195 WALKER Trevor 196 WALLACE Joe 197 WALSH Bruce 198 WARD Ches 199 WEBB Luke 200 WESTON Steve 201 WILLIAMS Neil 202 WILSON Peter 203 WOJTCZAK Natasha 204 YARRAN Ray 205 YATES Darrell 206 YEE Ah Meng (Sunny) 207 YOUNG Jamie 208 YOUNG Suk Park (Yong?) 209 ZABEL Ernest Freo Group Limited 1 BRAND Gregory 2 BROWN Keith 3 CASEY Michael 4 CHAPPEL Harold 5 CLINCH Fred 6 COUTTS Andrew 7 DEVINE Robert 8 FARIU Terry 9 FULLERTON Paul 10 GANTER Jake 11 GATHERCOLE SMITH Carl 12 HENRY Anthony 13 HOPPER Catherine 14 JOHNS Steven 15 KEDDELL, Mason 16 LUBRIG Alfred 17 MATHISON Warwick 18 MILES Blake 19 MITCHELL Euan 20 MORGAN Sherman 21 NGATAMARIKI Tangi 22 NOYES Paul 23 PASSMORE Brett 24 PAYNE Graham 25 PUERTA David 26 SARDELIC Antony 27 SIMS Luke 28 SMITH Malcolm 29 STEVENSON, Carl 30 STEPHENSON, Keith 31 STUBING Bradley 32 UPOKO Tuaere 33 VAUGHAN Michelle Modern Access Services 1 ANDERSON Joshua 2 AUGUST Anthony 3 BARBER Russell 4 Biddiscombe John 5 Blythin Kevin 6 Brinkley Kristian 7 Brooksby John 8 Burkhardt Ron 9 Capolicchio Brett 10 Cavallaro Domenico 11 Cooper Stephen 12 Cooper Tasman 13 Cornish Mark 14 Daly Jarrod 15 Dodd Adrian 16 Evans Simon 17 Finn Beryl 18 Freeman Steven 19 Glentworth Brooke 20 Godrei Pradeep 21 Goodson Matthew 22 Green Kori 23 Hartley Mark 24 Hayes Karim 25 Holland Antony 26 Hooton Nathan 27 Howard Ben 28 Hugill Christopher 29 Juras Frank 30 Kino Aaron 31 Lee Damien 32 Mam Nara 33 Mam Narak 34 Marshall Shane 35 Mathe Attila 36 Mcnamara David 37 Mcnulty Marin 38 Minifie Terry 39 Morrison Jon 40 Murray Mike 41 Namok Mark 42 Nunes Andrew 43 Osborn Christopher 44 Parker Troy 45 Peacock Michael 46 Peterson Trevor 47 Phillips Richard 48 Phillips-Mitchell Gavin 49 Pitt Stanley 50 Ratima Khimbo 51 Reuben Marvin 52 Revill Brent 53 Roberts James 54 Sant Troy 55 Sarson Jason 56 Smith Steve 57 Smith Shayne 58 Suter Julian 59 Thompson Brian 60 Tito David 61 Van Rooyen Kristy 62 Warahi Damian 63 Wells Brayden 64 Williams Adam 65 Willing Mark 66 Wrathall Shannon 67 Yates Scott 68 Yu Lida Mammoet Australia Pty Ltd 1 AINSWORTH Shaun 2 AUSTIN Grant 3 AXTON Shannen 4 BALL David 5 BATZLOFF Mark 6 BELLESINI Katie 7 BICKLER Adrian 8 BOLTON Lyall 9 CLIFFORD Tully 10 COHEN Andrew 11 COLEMAN Ronald 12 CRAVEN Matthew 13 DICKINSON Pauline 14 DIXON Shayne 15 DUNNE Maria 16 DRUMMOND Matthew 17 EDDINGTON Spencer 18 EMMOTT Rebecca 19 FITZGERALD Warren 20 FLETT Steve 21 FURLONG Katrina 22 GRAY Matthew 23 GRAY Richard 24 GREENWAY Darryl 25 HARDWICK James 26 HARRISON Brian 27 HINES Gregory 28 HOPKINS Gareth 29 HOW Adrian 30 LAMBERT Harold 31 LANDGREN Mick 32 LYE Warwick 33 McDONALD Ronald 34 McVINISH, Rosalee 34 MITCHELL Liam 35 NELSON Steven 36 OREILLY Richard 37 OTT Jonathan 38 REED Michael 39 RETTKE Robert 40 RICHARDSON Matthew 41 ROFF Andrew 42 ROGERS Malcolm 43 ROSS Adam 44 ROWE Greig 45 ROWE Raymond 46 SCHWARZ Peter 47 SEYMOUR Ashley 48 TAYLOR Nathan 49 TAYLOR John 50 THOMSON Gary 51 WALKER Ken 52 WAUGH Duncan 53 WELLS Brian 54 ZELINSKI Sonya Monadelphous Engineering
Associates Pty Ltd1 ABBOTT Ben 2 ALCIBAR Philip 3 ALEXANDER Raymond 4 ALI Paul 5 ALLSOP Simon 6 ANDERSON Steven 7 ANDERSON Stephen 8 ARMSTRONG Paul 9 ATKINS Daniel 10 ATKINSON Khan 11 BACHE Guy 12 BAKER Chris 13 Balazic Robert 14 BALLINGER Paul 15 BAMBERRY Russell 16 BARRON Dale 17 BARRY Peter 18 BATE Gordon 19 BELL Robert 20 BERRIDGE Helen 21 BOXALL Darren 22 BOZTEPE Serkan 23 BRODIE Peter 24 BRUEN Gerard (Ged) 25 BURCH Michelle 26 BURGETT James 27 BURTON Daniel 28 BUSHBY Douglas (Morris) 29 BUTLER John 30 BUTTACAVOLI Anthony 31 CABRILOVSKI George 32 CALBALA Deborah 33 CALCOTT David 34 CALLANAN Barry 35 CANAL Jose 36 CARRIES Louis 37 CARRUTHERS John 38 CARTER Chad 39 CARY Eric 40 CERVINI Marc 41 CHAPMAN Scott 42 CLAPHAM Wade 43 CLARKE Tony 44 CLAY Adam 45 COLEMAN Matthew 46 COLLARD Kelvin 47 COLLINS Wayne 48 COLLINS David 49 COOK Ben 50 COULTER Jesse 51 CRAWFORD Robert (Dave) 52 CRIBB Paul 53 CROSS Sidney 54 CUMMING Kenneth 55 CUNLIFFE Alastair 56 CURTIS Robert 57 DACOMBE John 58 DASTOL Ronald 59 DAVIES Jason 60 DAVIS Greg 61 DAW Robert 62 DAW Stephen 63 DAWES Shane 64 DAY Matthew 65 DEMAIO Sam 66 DERRICK Robert 67 DEVINE Scott 68 DOWLING Graham 69 DOWSETT Keith 70 DRACA Bogoljub (Bob) 71 DUNCAN Anthony 72 DUNN Deborah 73 DWYER Regan 74 ECCLES Lee 75 ELDERIDGE Ben 76 ELLIOTT Francis 77 ELPEZ Marijan 78 EMMANUEL Harry 79 EMMERSON Russell 80 EMSLIE John 81 ERCEG James 82 EVANS Zach 83 FARRUGIA Dennis 84 FERGUSON Margaret 85 FERGUSON Michael 86 FIELD Michael 87 FITZROY Corey 88 FLAHAVIN Joseph 89 FLETCHER Ryan 90 FORBES Adrian 91 FORREST Robert 92 FOWLES Tony 93 FRADL Robert 94 GARTON Steven 95 GILLESPIE Don 96 GIVNEY Shane 97 GLASS Tyson 98 GLASS Victor 99 GLYNN Martin 100 GODFREY Andrew 101 GOLUB Aleksander 102 GOODALL Adrian 103 GRILLS Dean 104 GRIVINS Justin 105 HAINES Danny 106 HARRIS Robert 107 HARRIS Patricia 108 HAYES Clint 109 HEBBARD Leith 110 HEBDEN Garth 111 HIKU Frank 112 HODDY Graeme 113 HOLLOWAY Rodney 114 HOLT Robert 115 HOOYBERG Eric 116 HOPPE Dennis 117 HOWARD Morgan 118 HUGHES Murray 119 HULL Kevin 120 ISAIA Ben 121 JANNEKER Clinton 122 JARRETT Grant 123 JONES Peter 124 JONES Rodney 125 JONES Richard 126 JONES Raymond 127 JUREWICZ Konrad 128 KAAKA Rima 129 KATSCHNER Lothar 130 KEEGAN Daniel 131 KEILY Shaun 132 KELLY Gavin 133 KELLY Shane 134 KELLY Mick 135 Kemp Michael 136 KING Joel 137 KING Mark 138 KORVER Glenn 139 KOUKA Boydie 140 KRAKOUER James 141 LAING Derek 142 LAMB Darren 143 LARSEN Leonard 144 LAWRENCE John 145 LAWRIE Lachlan 146 LEANING Jason 147 LEO Graham 148 LEONARD Troy 149 LEWIS Nerralie 150 LI Andrew 151 LIEBKE Steven 152 LIVINGSTON Anthony 153 LLOYD Martin 154 LORD Michael 155 LORTAN Gregory (Greg) 156 LOTZ Terrence 157 LOWE Darren 158 LUELING Freddi 159 LYONS Brock 160 MANN James 161 MATTHEWS Terry 162 MCCLUTCHIE Eugene 163 MCDONALD Malcolm 164 MCDONALD Cathy (Cate) 165 MCFARLANE Craig 166 MCGUIRE Alastair 167 MCLAREN Anne 168 MCLAREN Mark 169 MCMILLAN Brett 170 MELLOR Trevor 171 MILNE Andrew 172 MINNER Robert 173 MLEZIVA Sacha 174 MOONEY Matthew 175 MORRIS Patrick 176 MORTIMER Andrew 177 MURPHY Phillip 178 NAIDOO Manivasagan 179 NANKIVELL Mark 180 NELIS Joseph 181 NGAWHIKA Shane 182 NICHOLLS Andrew 183 NOCK Alan 184 NOVOSELL Erwin 185 O'MALLEY David 186 ORMEROD Jacqueline 187 OTTAWAY Kate 188 PAJONK Michael 189 PALEVNO Dennis 190 PATU Tuakaua 191 PATYI Richard 192 PAVLIK Robert 193 PAYNE Mark 194 PEDLER Robert 195 PETERSEN Malcolm 196 POOLE Michael 197 PRIDDETH Jake 198 PUATA Troy 199 PUATA Aaron 200 PURCEL Michael 201 QUALTROUGH Scott 202 QUINLESS Fred 203 RADDON Shannon 204 RANN Dylan 205 RAYMAN Carl 206 REGAN Les 207 REID Jethro 208 RIDDELL Jeffrey 209 RITCHIE Jason 210 RIVAS Anthony 211 ROBERTS Douglas 212 ROBERTSON James (Jim) 213 ROSANES Renie 214 ROSS Yancy-lee 215 RUDOLF Renee 216 SANDERS Michael 217 SAXBY Zallman 218 SCALES Simon 219 SCANTLEBURY Robin 220 SCHAECHE Eric 221 SCHOONER Raimona (Joe) 222 SCULLION Joseph 223 SCULLION Neil 224 SEMMENS Jai 225 SHAND Derick 226 SHELLY Ben 227 SIMPSON Tahi 228 SLOMAN Janet 229 SMITH Barry 230 SMITH Peter 231 SMITH Bruce 232 SPARKE Cassie 233 SPRAGUE Matthew 234 STARCEVIC Martin 235 STRANG Matthew 236 SWINDLEHURST Kevin 237 TAHI TAHI Antonio 238 TAMATEA Patrick 239 TANGIORA Clinton 240 TANNER Buwyn 241 TASKER Patricia 242 TE MIHA Deon 243 THEXTON Gary 244 TICEHURST Michael 245 TIMMERMANS James 246 TOAKLEY Matthew 247 TOMS Robin 248 TYSON Shane 249 VAAI Lasalosi 250 VAN EETEN Daniel 251 VARIAN Shane 252 VELLA Jesse 253 VOZAREVIC Bruno 254 WATSON Rebecka 255 WEARNE Adam 256 WEBB Paul 257 WEIR Kristian 258 WETERE Louis 259 WHELPDALE Eddie 260 WHITE Ramon 261 WHITE Brett 262 WILKINSON Norman 263 WILLIAMS Keetha 264 WILLSHIRE Andrew (Andy) 265 WILSON Troy 266 WINTLE Steven 267 WOODLAND Jamie 268 WOOLLASTON Simon 269 WRIGHT Colin 270 YEONG Kam RCR Positron Pty Ltd 1 Abelha D. E. 2 Biskup M. E. 3 Davey S. E. 4 Eggers S. TA. 5 Everitt J. E. 6 Gardener R. LE 7 Gouge J. LE. 8 Guyatt D. LE. 9 Harrison R. E. 10 Heard D. E. 11 Heywood S. LE. 12 Holmes P. E. 13 Howard T 14 Jordan A. TA. 15 Kennedy W. BM 16 Kimpton T. E. 17 Kirkpatrick K.TF 18 Leach A. TA. 19 Lette B. E. 20 Mccartney N. TA 21 Meardi A. TA. 22 Message S. TA 23 Mitchell L. E. 24 Mulvey P. E. 25 Perak A. TA. 26 Phillips D. E. 27 Priestly M. TA. 28 Sheasby R. TA. 29 Smith B. E. 30 Spangen S. E. 31 Watts S. E. 32 Webb B. E. 33 Wilks B. E. PCH Group Ltd 1 ASIATA Moses 2 ATKINS Te 3 BISHOP Matthew 4 BLAKE Sean 5 BRYAN Jason 6 BURNS Darryl 7 COLLINS Craig 8 COOMBES Michael 9 COOPER Layton 10 COOPER Aaron 11 DAVID Julian 12 DEVINE Cash 13 DIOSAN Radu 14 DROLLET Kayne 15 DUNN Nigel 16 EMERY Manny 17 FIAMANYA Dzifa 18 FINCARYK Oscar 19 FORBES Anthony 20 GABRIEL Iarere (Eddie) 21 GARNER Stephen 22 GATHERCOLE-SMITH Justin 23 GIBBS Jacob 24 GLASS Steven 25 HAPE Kahu 26 HARTLEY Dean 27 HAYES Craig 28 HINAKI Randal 29 HOWE Duane 30 IEREMIA Sipili 31 IND Matthew 32 JAYME Steven 33 JENSEN Ross 34 KAISER Michael 35 KEARNS Clinton 36 KELLY Stuart 37 KIRTLEY Jai 38 KLAPKO Andrew 39 KOMENE Robert 40 KOUKA Bennett 41 LANDMETER Harry 42 LODGE Dewayne 43 LULHAM Marc 44 MAEA John 45 MANU Harley 46 MANU Jeremia 47 MANU John 48 MANUEL Jardine 49 MASON Terence 50 MATENGA Huki 51 MCCRORY Bernard 52 McCRORY Jason 53 MEDLAND Dean 54 MILLS Stephen 55 MORRIS Joseph 56 MURPHY Wayne 57 NGAMOKI Pita 58 ORLOWSKI David 59 PAYNE Drew 60 PEMBERTON Paul 61 PIRIHI Jade 62 POTTER Leonard 63 RAHARUHI Kiha 64 RAINE Chris 65 REARDON Daniel 66 ROBINSON Michael 67 ROWSELL Jason 68 SHELFORD Angus 69 SMITH James 70 STONE Glenn 71 TEMAARI Ryan 72 TEPOHE Nathan 73 TEPU Patrick 74 THOMAS Jamie 75 THOMPSON Stacy 76 THURSTON Troy 77 TOGIA Sasa 78 TUPAEA Matthew 79 WALKER Stephen 80 WATENE Cory 81 WILLIAMSON Stephen 82 WIPERI Jason 83 DIEHL Armin 84 KELLY James John Holland Pty Ltd - Savcor Finn (subcontractors) 1 BROWNING Paul 2 DAWSON Samual 3 HOWELL Justin RCR Construction & Maintenance Pty Ltd 1 CAMPBELL Danny 2 DODSLEY Andrew 3 ELBOROUGH Kimley 4 FIELD Christopher 5 FRASER Laureen 6 FRASER Trevor 7 HAWKINS Stephen 8 LAMB Gregory 9 PARVIN Stephen 10 PLUNKETT Kevin 11 PORTER Mark 12 SEABURN Kevin 13 SOMERVILLE Ryan 14 SUTHERLAND Travis 15 TOKI Mitch 16 WALKER Wayne 17 WEBB Adrian Downer EDI Engineering Power Pty Ltd 1 ANDERSON David 2 AYRES Brett 3 BEETS Bryan 4 BENJAMIN Edmund 5 BENSON Scott 6 BOSCO Adrian 7 BOWER Peter 8 BUSINOSKI Ilija 9 CAMPBELL Rhys 10 CARR Bryne 11 CHEAL John 12 CHRISTENSEN, Ross 13 COBB Brett 14 COOPER Dwanie 15 DOCKERTY Michael 16 DOHERTY Paul 17 ESDALE Adam 18 GIBBS Ian 19 GOODALL Darren 20 GORDON-DAVISON Kayne 21 GRECI David 22 HANNAFORD Gareth 23 HARRIS Guy 24 HARVEY Brian 25 HOWE Ben 26 KENNING Darrell 27 LEACH Gareth 28 MACALE David 29 MARCINKOWSKI Laurie 30 OLDHAM Scott 31 PEGRUM Brad 32 POON Ryan 33 PRIMROSE Darren 34 ROACH Greg 35 ROBERTS Jenny 36 ROBERTS Mick 37 SANDERS Jason 38 SELLECK Syd 39 SHEATHER Luke 40 SMITH Nathan 41 SODEN Derek 42 STEPHENSON Tony 43 STONER Andrew 44 SULLIVAN Scott 45 SWAN David 46 TAYLOR John 47 THOMAS Jamie 48 TURNER Robert 49 TWYFORD James 50 VAN ROOYEN Kelly 51 VAN WANROOY Justin 52 WALTERS Steve 53 WILSON Jeff 54 ABBOTT, Bill 55 BLIOKAS, Rob 56 CAKE, Mathew 57 CORBETT, Adam 58 KERR, Brian 59 KOVACESKI, Angel 60 MARAS, John 61 WELSH, Gary 62 WILSON, Michael 63 MARSH, Tony CBI Constructors Pty Ltd 1 ADAMS Brendan 2 ALLMAN Robert 3 ARCARO Murray 4 ARCARO Nicholas 5 ATKINSON Stephen 6 BACON Kenneth 7 BAEZ Juan 8 BAEZ Sergio 9 BAIL Jason 10 BAILEY Troy 11 BARRETT Glen 12 BASIC Dragomir 13 BECKER Peter 14 BECKMAN Alan 15 BELL Murray 16 BEVAN Alan 17 BOBOS Carl 18 BRENNAN Stephen 19 BRITTAIN Timothy 20 BROOKS Raymond 21 BUTTARS Anton 22 CAMERON Alistair 23 CARMICHAEL James 24 CASTRO Dean 25 CHRISTENSEN Kenneth 26 CLARK Harley 27 CLARK Robert 28 CLEARY James 29 COELHO John 30 CONNELL Travis 31 CROSIER Andrew 32 CYPHER Justin 33 DODD Peter 34 DONDAS Michael 35 DONNELLY Brett 36 DUPLESSIS Johannes 37 EDWARDS David 38 ELPHICK Jeffrey 39 FAUSTINO Victor 40 FERREIRA Jose 41 FRONTE Salvatore 42 GARDINER Jason 43 GARNIER-BRADLEY Jason 44 GOGOLL Joel 45 GOODALL Tay 46 GROTH William 47 HAKIWAI Stirling 48 HARDINGHAM Adrian 49 HARRIS Ike 50 HEGARTY Steven 51 HOUSE Clayton 52 HUMPHREY David 53 HUNWICK Phillip 54 JARRETT Glenn 55 JOHNS Robert 56 JOHNSTON Anthony 57 KELLY Matthew 58 KINGHORN William 59 KOVACESKA Menka 60 KOVACESKI Donco 61 KRALJEVIC-KRUBIC Josip 62 KRUGER Rodney 63 LANE Darrin 64 LANNIN Bradley 65 LAROSA Agostino 66 LE CERF Garry 67 LEE Mu Yeun 68 LILLEY Joseph 69 LIM Nao 70 LUDLAM John 71 MABBOTT Bruce 72 MacKINNON Graeme 73 MANNERING Peter 74 MARLOW Michael 75 MARTIN James 76 MARTIN Trevor 77 MATEIU Gherge 78 MAXWELL Daniel 79 McCABE Mark 80 McINERNEY John 81 MCINERNEY Todd 82 MCKENNA Henry 83 MCKENZIE Alan 84 MCKINNON David 85 MILLER Bradley 86 MILROY Gary 87 MINNS Neil 88 MITCHELL Robert 89 MORLEY Robert 90 NEWSHAM Garry 91 NOBLE Brendan 92 O'SHEA Daniel 93 PAYNE Kenneth 94 PERRY Marcus 95 PESTANA Jose 96 PIRIHI Dylan 97 RAZI-PANAH Jarwad 98 RICE Mark 99 RYAN John 100 SANDERS Dean 101 SANSOM Gregory 102 SCHMITT Gregory 103 SCOTT Robert 104 SHIELD Keith 105 SMYTHE Jason 106 SNELLIN Ronald 107 STUURSTRAAT Shannan 108 SURRIDGE Daniel 109 SVILICICH Lee 110 SWINNEY Antony 111 TAMAPUA Allan 112 TAYLOR Kim 113 TUKUAFU Finau 114 VLUG Bruce 115 WAIARIKI Paul 116 WALSH John 117 WARNER Paul 118 WATTS Priscilla 119 WEAVER Blake 120 WEAVER Mark 121 WEIR Mitchell 122 WETERE Tirau 123 WOLSKI Daniel 124 WOOD Leon 125 WOODWARD Sam United Group Resources Pty Ltd 1 Ken Abrahams 2 Lional Abrahams 3 Lesley Ajaran 4 Shane Anderson 5 Nathan Arbery 6 Cody Arvidson 7 Mark Ashcroft 8 Adrian Baillie 9 Jonathan Barclay 10 Kenneth Barclay 11 Stephen Barnett 12 Rolando Bazaez 13 Louis Beaunoir 14 Jason Behncke 15 Jan Bennett 16 Troy Benton 17 Arjun Bhoi 18 Nitin Bhosale 19 Marcel Biggar 20 Francis Blampied 21 Tommy Bonke 22 Benjamin Boocock 23 Nathan Bosworth 24 Milorad Brakus 25 Christian Brekalo 26 Nick Brekalo 27 Andrew Brennan 28 Christopher Browne 29 Gabriel Bruno 30 Marcus Burke 31 Craig Cameron 32 Malcolm Carr 33 Dean Cassidy 34 Hasan Ceric 35 Tony Chipchase 36 Juho Choi 37 Clint Chrisp 38 Rob Cochrane 39 Gavin Coleman 40 Jye Coleman 41 Dean Collins 42 Andrew Collinson 43 Collis James 44 Michael Collyer 45 John Couts 46 Mark Coverly 47 Joshua Cruice 48 Alfredo Da Silva 49 Thomas Darling 50 Trevor Datson 51 Ian Davidson 52 Brian Davies 53 Jeffrey Davis 54 Brett Dawes 55 Gerrit De Blanken 56 James DeBruin 57 Beau Deverall 58 Claude Devos 59 Manuel Dias 60 Radwan Eltchelebi 61 Joao Felizardo 62 David Fergusson 63 George Ferreira 64 Terence Fisher 65 Mark Fleay 66 Craig Fleming 67 Katie Forbes 68 Terrence Fox 69 Jason Francis 70 Michael Franke 71 Damien Freeth 72 John Frino 73 Steven Gaby 74 Tim Gamble 75 David Gera 76 Richard Glass 77 Paul Gnech 78 Shaun Goldstone 79 Anthony Gostlow 80 Wayne Green 81 Phillip Grevell 82 Roger Griffiths 83 Michael Hagan 84 Adrian Hage 85 Peter Harper 86 Peter Harris 87 Terry Hay 88 Anthony Hayes 89 John Heckscher 90 Geoffrey Height 91 Todd Heron 92 Marcelene Heslop 93 Graeme Hocking 94 Peter Hoek 95 Andrew Holden 96 Mark Holley 97 Sean Hoskins 98 Steven Hossack 99 Harold Houghton 100 Mervyn Houghton 101 Brendan Howard 102 Tyron Hughes 103 David Hull 104 Joshua Humphries 105 Glenn Hutton 106 Youngman Hwang 107 Elias Israel 108 Mark Jackson 109 Sergio Jacobs 110 Paul Jean-Pierre 111 Craig Jeffs 112 John Jenkins 113 Kenneth Johnstone 114 Mark Jones 115 Ray Jones 116 Robert Jones 117 Fabian Joule 118 Edan Kennedy 119 Stuart (Alvin) Kerrigan 120 Nigel Kiedo 121 David Knyvett 122 Travis Ladhams 123 Mathew Lamb 124 Peter Law 125 Paul Leach 126 Chong-Won Lee 127 Kenneth Lewins 128 Mark Lindsay 129 Darren Lithgow 130 Shannon Livingstone 131 Jason Lockhart 132 Stephen Lowther 133 William Lyall 134 Donald MacKay 135 Brett Mackie 136 Gerarado Magtalas 137 Simeon Magtalas 138 Thomas Mahar 139 Matthew Manning 140 Juan Manriquez 141 Garry Mansfield 142 Felix Marriott 143 Calvin Martin 144 Andrew Mazlin 145 Adam McAnany 146 Darren McCamish 147 Gary McCarthy 148 Shane McClure 149 Ian McCracken 150 Matthew McGurgan 151 Wayne McMahon 152 Anthony Mead 153 Spencer Meade 154 Alan Middleton 155 Simon Mieschbuehler 156 Kane Mita 157 Charles Mitchell 158 Gary Mitchell 159 Erwin Montiere 160 Nicholas Morley 161 Steven Mott 162 Steven Moxon 163 Len Mudri 164 Ian Mullan 165 Kerron Muller 166 Christopher Murray 167 Michael Narbey 168 Rodney Nelson 169 Stuart Noakes 170 Gregory Norris 171 Stephen Novak 172 Thomas O'Brien 173 Luke O'Fee 174 Damien O'Kane 175 Russel Olsen 176 Martin Osborne 177 Robert Osbourne 178 Pavo Parad 179 Trevor Park 180 Anthony Pearce 181 Graeme Penglase 182 Mark Pertile 183 Robert Peters 184 Sotha Pheng 185 Aaron Phyland 186 David Pidgeon 187 Robert Pippia 188 Murray Porter 189 Howard Prosser 190 Matthew Ramage 191 Daniel Reddie 192 Ronald Robinson 193 Wayne Roelandts 194 Neville Roskruge 195 Phillip Rowell 196 Steven Sakic 197 Jin (Fred) Sang-Yoo 198 Ivan Sapina 199 Michael Schoeman 200 Dimitru Serban 201 Yong Shao 202 Denny Singleton 203 Gary Small 204 Charles Snyman 205 Kevin Squibb 206 Ralph Stapelfeldt 207 Gary Stramare 208 Clive Sucks 209 Steven Sulenta 210 Steven Tarran 211 Gary Taylor 212 Joseph Taylor 213 Allan Thompson 214 Bradley Thompson 215 Christopher Thornhill 216 Neil Tollison 217 Alberto Tome 218 Brett Tooby 219 Andre Turner 220 Mark Tutton 221 Brendan Tye 222 Colin Tyrer 223 Peter Ugle 224 Johnny Van Wyk 225 Arnoldus Van Wyke 226 Adrian Vandersluis 227 Darryl Vickers 228 Joel Von Nida 229 Noel Webster 230 Dean Weiss 231 Ihaia White 232 Drew Wickenden 233 Jason Wiggins 234 Mike Wildermott 235 Gabriel Williams 236 Gregory Williams 237 Henry Wynkwaardt 238 Noel Zanetti 239 Matthew Zonta 240 Pero Zuvela 241 Michael Abelha 242 Richard Alcott 243 David Ali 244 Noel Amari 245 Alan Arceo 246 Ryan Augustus 247 Mark Bailey 248 David Baines 249 Fred Baker 250 Reyon Band 251 Antony Barlow 252 Liam Barron 253 Todd Bartlett 254 Laurence Bascombe 255 John Basso 256 Mark Bateman 257 Richard Bauer 258 John Bernard 259 Craig Berry 260 John Berryman 261 Morgan Blake 262 Ellen Bolton 263 Slobodan Brakus 264 Benjamin Brand 265 Gavin Bratby 266 Tyrone Briffa 267 Darren Brown 268 Ivaso Buac 269 Ben Burns 270 Ian Byrne 271 Iain Calder 272 Aaron Calley 273 Ross Cameron 274 Les Camilleri 275 Patrick Carmody 276 Luke Cashman 277 Damien Chant 278 Michael Christensen 279 Andrew Clinton 280 Paul Cole 281 Derek Collins 282 Anthony Cooper 283 Jason Cornwell 284 Clyde Cowley 285 Bianca Coyne 286 Michael Crook 287 Darren Crowder 288 Kathleen Cunningham 289 Graeme Daniel 290 Mathias Dann 291 Andrew Darcy 292 Andrew Davies 293 Kevin Davis 294 Gary Davison 295 Joe De Faria 296 Matthew De Glanville 297 Chad De Rooy 298 Mark Delaney 299 Wade Den Ridder 300 Matthew Denton 301 Daniele Dimasi 302 Arnolda Do Carmo 303 Andrew Dobson 304 Tony Dobson 305 Blair Donnelly 306 Roland Edwards 307 Stephen Elliott 308 Cameron Ewart 309 Bud Feenstra 310 Miroslav Ferluga 311 Paulo Fernandes 312 Stuart Fletcher 313 Robert Fowler 314 Tristan Fuller 315 Andrew Gaffney 316 Graeme Geddes 317 Peter Geisner 318 Nicholas George 319 Guiseppe Giglia 320 Chris Gillen 321 Jose Gomes 322 Craig Goold 323 Wilfred Goss 324 Ian Grace 325 Joseph Green 326 Phillip Green 327 Andrew Greene 328 Paul Grgurovic 329 Mark Haak 330 David Hacking 331 Gabriel Halkyard 332 Steven Hall 333 Lyncon Halligan 334 Cy Hamilton 335 Chris Hancock 336 Jarrid Harrison 337 Greg Hatchett 338 Jarrad Hawkins 339 Kenneth Hayes 340 Luke Heaney 341 Martin Heath 342 Malcolm Herring 343 Julie Hicks 344 Nathan Hicks 345 Ben Hodkinson 346 Tim Holdsworth 347 Craig Holst 348 Wayne Homan 349 Karatehana Horo 350 Kevin Howat 351 Vince Howes 352 Tyrone Hoys 353 Gavin Hughes 354 Victor Hugo 355 Paul Hulbert 356 Mark Huyshe 357 Jamie Ingie 358 Norman Jamieson 359 Kim Jenkins 360 Quentin Jensen 361 Michelle Jeremiah 362 Ashley Jones 363 Bodhi Jones 364 Martin Jones 365 Steve (Slobodan) Jovevski 366 Savo Katic 367 Kosta Katsidis 368 James Keene 369 Paul Kelly 370 David Kemp 371 Joshua Klynsoon 372 Milan Krstanoski 373 Tonganu Kukutai 374 Nathan Lake 375 Daniel Lawrence 376 Jeffrey Lawson 377 Shane Leworthy 378 Robin Lilly 379 Charles Liness 380 William Logan 381 Christopher Luta 382 Jason MacDonald 383 Ivan Macukat 384 Callum Malloch-Smith 385 Victor Margarido 386 Cleopas Mashuta 387 Craig Maxwell 388 Coley Mayhew 389 Dean McBride 390 Craig McCartney 391 Charles McClellan 392 Duncan McDonald 393 Ian McDonald 394 Nicole McGinty 395 Allan McKinnon 396 Ross McMiles 397 Alan McMillan 398 William McShane 399 Kenneth Mendoza 400 Steven Mijailovic 401 Charles Miller 402 Phillip Millington 403 Benjamin Morcom 404 Matthew Morehu 405 Chris Murdock 406 Roy Murphy 407 Jeremi Musulin 408 Glen Neal 409 Brent Neill 410 Tim Nelson 411 Justin Noakes 412 Nowak Woyciech 413 Aurelio Nunes 414 Ashley O'Brien 415 Tim Ogden 416 Mao Ouk 417 David Ovens 418 Trent Pallier 419 Reece Paul 420 Graham Pearce 421 Ben Penglase 422 Joel Penglase 423 Ashley Pickles 424 Darryl Pickles 425 Ryan Pickles 426 John Pratt 427 John Preston 428 Colin Price 429 Curtis Ransfield 430 Gerald Ransfield 431 Steven Reid 432 Glen Robinson 433 Paul Roche 434 Kerry Rossiter-McClaren 435 Rodrigo Ruiz 436 Joseph Ryder 437 Grgo Saric 438 Moreno Serramono 439 Jose Simoes 440 Kenneth Simon 441 Todd Sitnikoski 442 Shelby Skinner 443 Hamish Smith 444 Mark Smith 445 Paul St John 446 Kurt Stellenburg 447 Andrew Stevens 448 Kathy Stiberc 449 Selina Stolp 450 Reginald Styles 451 Wayne Sutherland 452 James Taylor 453 Jeremy Teaia 454 Shane Thomas 455 Leslie Thompson 456 Paul Todd 457 Karl Travers 458 Joshua Trunfio 459 Herbert Tucker 460 Angela Tumney 461 Keith Turnbull 462 Matthew Uepa 463 Raul Uriona 464 Ugur Uysaler 465 Andrea Vaega 466 Christopher Van Arkel 467 Liam Wakefield 468 Michael Walker 469 Bryan Walker 470 Alan Walker 471 Simon Wallace 472 Steve Waltl 473 Michael Webb 474 Paul Webb 475
476 Michael Whiteley 477 Rodney Williams 478 Jason Wilson 479 Daryl Wood 480 John Wyllie 481 Tyron Youlden 482 Leslie Young 483 Matthew Young 484 Roman Zasun 485 James Zauch 486 Charles Bell 487 Richard D'Costa 488 Jarrad Garrick 489 James Odiam 490 Colin Searle 491 Joe Silk 492 David Attrill 493 Vincenzo Bonavita 494 Chris Burgess 495 Corrie Bush 496 Ben Cattalini 497 Daniel Cattalini 498 Daniel Christian 499 Lance Cockayne 500 Kaine Coleman 501 Gavin Curley 502 Darren Evans 503 Timothy Fowler 504 Gerard Fullen 505 Kurt Fuller 506 Kelvin Gibbon 507 Michael Hancock 508 Stephen Hancock 509 Andrew Henshaw 510 Damian Hodder 511 Ahmad Intekheb 512 Mark Jenkinson 513 Chris Jones 514 George LeFebre 515 Edward Light 516 Clifford Logan 517 Ken Logan 518 Cameron Maughan 519 Gene Molloy 520 Robert Movick 521 David Murray 522 Richard Parker 523 Paulose Kulavelil 524 Matthew Pearson 525 Adam Sayle 526 David Sproule 527 Colin Swasbrook 528 Reece Tacey 529 Alex Varga 530 Martin Wells 531 Richard White 532 John Winter 533 Glenn Withers 534 Paul Young 535 Tim Young 536 Nicholas Hurst 537 Vicky Leefe 538 Charles Lowe 539 Lesley Sermon
- AGLC
- United Group Resources Pty Ltd ABN 17 114 888 201 v Calabro [2010] FCA 22
- Case
- [2010] FCA 22
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court needed to determine whether it had the jurisdiction to grant an interim injunction, considering the relevant statutory provisions and the nature of the alleged unlawful industrial action. Additionally, the court had to consider the factors it should take into account in exercising its discretion to grant an injunction, such as the applicants' undertakings as to damages and the balance of convenience.
The court found that it had jurisdiction to grant the injunction under sections 39 and 49(1)(c) of the Act. It held that the applicants had demonstrated a serious question to be tried regarding the unlawful nature of the respondents' industrial action. The court also considered the applicants' undertakings as to damages, which satisfied the court of the need to protect the applicants from irreparable harm. The court exercised its discretion to grant the injunction, subject to the usual undertaking as to damages.
The court ordered that, upon the applicants providing the usual undertaking as to damages, the respondents were to be restrained from engaging in specified actions related to the Pluto LNG Project until a specified date. The order also provided that any person affected by the restraints could apply for relief within 48 hours' notice.
Orders
Orders of the court
1 Upon the applicants giving the usual undertaking as to damages, until 5.00 pm on 5 February 2010, pursuant to s 39 and/or s 49(1)(c) of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) each respondent is restrained from:
(a) engaging in or being a party to or in any way associated with or otherwise involved in any of the following actions in relation to building work on the Pluto LNG Project at Burrup Peninsula (Project):
(i) failing or refusing to attend work on the Project or failing or refusing to accept or perform work on the Project at all;
(ii) performing work on the Project otherwise than in accordance with the terms of his employment contract;
(iii) performing work on the Project in a manner different from that in which it is customarily performed, or adopting any practice in relation to work on the project, the result of which is a restriction or limitation on, or a delay in, the performance of that work;
except where such actions:
(i) are authorised or agreed to by the respondent’s employer; or
(ii) are based upon the respondent’s reasonable concern about an imminent risk to the respondent’s health or safety and the respondent has not unreasonably failed to comply with the directions of the respondent’s employer to perform other available work, whether at the same or another workplace, that was safe and appropriate for the respondent to perform;
(b) interfering with or in any way disrupting the performance of work on the Project by any of the following means:
(i) imposing, maintaining or aiding, abetting, encouraging, directing, procuring, inducing, advising or otherwise being involved in any bans, limitations, restrictions or delays on the performance of work or the acceptance of work by any of the applicants’ other employees to be performed under their terms of employment or in a manner which work is customarily performed with the applicants; and
(ii) imposing, maintaining or aiding, abetting, encouraging, directing, procuring, inducing, advising or otherwise being involved in the taking of days off by any of the applicants’ other employees otherwise than in accordance with rosters specified by the industrial instruments and employment contracts regulating their employment with the applicants.
2 Any person affected by the restraints imposed by the injunctive relief has liberty to apply on 48 hours written or electronic notice to the applicants or the Australian Building and Construction Commission.
Note:
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: MCKERRACHER J
Full text does not contain this section.