United Energy Distribution Pty Ltd v Australian Energy Regulator

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

United Energy Distribution Pty Ltd v Australian Energy Regulator

[2012] FCA 405

Citation: United Energy Distribution Pty Ltd v Australian Energy Regulator [2012] FCA 405
Parties: UNITED ENERGY DISTRIBUTION PTY LIMITED (ACN 064 651 029) v AUSTRALIAN ENERGY REGULATOR
File number: VID 989 of 2010
Judge: FOSTER J
Date of judgment: 20 April 2012
Legislation: Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth), ss 5(1)(d), 5(1)(e) and 5(1)(f)
National Electricity Law, Pt 6, Div 3A, subdivs 1 and 2, s 71B  
Cases cited: Application by United Energy Distribution Pty Limited [2012] ACompT 1 related
Application by United Energy Distribution Pty Limited (No 2) [2012] ACompT 8 related
Dates of hearing: 20, 21, 22, 23 and 27 June 2011; 4, 5, 6, 7, 12, 22 and 25 July 2011; and 27 March 2012
Date of last submissions: 22 March 2012
Place: Sydney (via video link to Melbourne)
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: No Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 20
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr AC Archibald QC and Mr SR Horgan SC
Solicitor for the Applicant: Johnson Winter & Slattery
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr C Scerri SC, Ms M Sloss SC, Mr S Lloyd SC, Mr P Gray, Mr D Star, Dr V Priskich, Mr T Clarke and Mr L Merrick
Solicitor for the Respondent: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the Minister for Energy and Resources for the State of Victoria (Intervener): Mr P Hanks QC and Mr G McCormick
Solicitor for the Minister for Energy and Resources for the State of Victoria (Intervener): Minter Ellison

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 989 of 2010

BETWEEN:

UNITED ENERGY DISTRIBUTION PTY LIMITED (ACN 064 651 029)
Applicant

AND:

AUSTRALIAN ENERGY REGULATOR
Respondent

JUDGE:

FOSTER J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 APRIL 2012

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY (VIA VIDEO LINK TO MELBOURNE)

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The whole of this proceeding be dismissed.

2.There be no order as to costs.  

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 989 of 2010

BETWEEN:

UNITED ENERGY DISTRIBUTION PTY LIMITED (ACN 064 651 029)
Applicant

AND:

AUSTRALIAN ENERGY REGULATOR
Respondent

JUDGE:

FOSTER J

DATE:

20 APRIL 2012

PLACE:

SYDNEY (VIA VIDEO LINK TO MELBOURNE)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The applicant, United Energy Distribution Pty Limited (UED), is one of five registered electricity distribution network service providers in the State of Victoria.

  2. On 29 October 2010, the Australian Energy Regulator (the AER) published its final determination as to the basis upon which electricity distribution services will be provided by UED in Victoria for the regulatory period 2011–2015.

  3. There are four other registered electricity distribution network service providers in Victoria.  At the same time as it published its final determination in respect of UED, the AER published a separate final determination in respect of each of the other four distribution network service providers.  The AER supported and explained…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read United Energy Distribution Pty Ltd v Australian Energy Regul... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 405
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter under consideration was between United Energy Distribution Pty Ltd and the Australian Energy Regulator. The dispute centred on the interpretation of certain clauses within the National Electricity Rules (NER) and the application of these clauses to the Energy Services and Commerce Variable (ESCV) S Factor Scheme. Specifically, the Tribunal examined whether the ESCV S Factor Scheme could be carried forward into the regulatory control period 2011–2015. The Federal Court was tasked with determining the validity of the Australian Energy Regulator's (AER) decision to implement a methodology to close out the ESCV S Factor Scheme.

The primary legal issue the court had to address was whether clauses 6.4.3(a)(6) and 6.4.3(b)(6) of the NER permitted the continuation of the ESCV S Factor Scheme into the 2011–2015 regulatory control period. The court also needed to determine whether the AER's interpretation of these clauses was correct and whether it was within their authority to implement the close-out methodology. The court examined the ordinary meaning of the relevant clauses and the intention of the draftsman of the NER, considering whether the extrinsic material provided any assistance in interpreting the clauses. The court further assessed whether the Interpretation of Legislation Act 1984 (Vic) applied to the interpretation of the NER and if it provided any support to the AER's position.

The Tribunal concluded that the relevant clauses of the NER did not permit the continuation of the ESCV S Factor Scheme into the 2011–2015 regulatory control period. The court held that the draftsman intended to start with a clean slate in respect of incentive schemes as at 1 January 2011. The Tribunal found that the AER was not authorised to rewrite the relevant subclauses and that the close-out methodology was not an amendment of the ESCV S Factor Scheme but rather an engrafted methodology designed to mimic the effects of the scheme while ending it. The court also determined that sections 27 and 28(2) of the Interpretation of Legislation Act 1984 (Vic) did not assist the AER's position.

As a result of the Tribunal's findings, the AER did not have the power to include the close-out methodology within its final decision, and the year-by-year penalty sought to be imposed on United Energy Distribution Pty Ltd could not be enforced. The court dismissed the proceeding in its entirety and made no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The whole of this proceeding be dismissed.

2. There be no order as to costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In its Reasons for Decision published on 6 January 2012, at [241]–[247], the Tribunal summarised its conclusions in respect of the AER’s ESCV S Factor closeout decision in the following way: Decision 241The essence of the issue confronting the Tribunal in respect of the AER’s decision to implement a methodology to close out the ESCV S Factor Scheme is one of interpretation. The critical question is whether cl 6.4.3(a)(6) and cl 6.4.3(b)(6) of the NER, upon their true interpretation, permit the carrying forward into the current regulatory control period 2011–2015 of the ESCV S Factor Scheme being a scheme which was in operation only in respect of the State-based last ESCV price determination up to 31 December 2010. That question is answered favourably to the position of the AER and the Minister if the subclauses to which we have referred contemplate the carrying over of such a State-based regulatory regime.242In our view, however, the subclauses referred to do not permit such a course. This is essentially for the reasons advanced by UED. The draftsman of the NER intended, in our view, to start with a clean slate in respect of incentive schemes as at 1 January 2011. This is no accident. Had the draftsman wished to authorise that which the AER has in fact done in the present case, he or she could have done so by prescribing appropriate transitional provisions, as was done in the case of South Australia. This was not done. Instead, the AER was required to propound its own incentive scheme (STPIS) and to do so in respect of the first regulatory control period for which it was charged with the responsibility of making the relevant determination. 243At [56]–[61] above, we have discussed the governing principles and provisions for the interpretation of the NEL and the NER. Applying those principles to the present problem, it seems to us that:(a)The extrinsic material to which our attention was drawn does not assist, one way or the other, in the interpretation of cl 6.4.3(a)(6) and cl 6.4.3(b)(6).(b)Despite the fact that cl 7 requires that the interpretation that will best achieve the purpose or object of the NEL is to be preferred to any other interpretation, that notion is not a mandate for a wholesale redrafting of the relevant provision.244The language deployed in the relevant subclauses is clear enough. Interpreting the language according to its ordinary meaning and in accordance with the relevant definitions contained in the Glossary for the NER and in s 2 of the NEL does not produce absurd results. It may produce results with which the AER and the Minister disagree – disagreement which may, in the circumstances of the present case, even be supportable by reasoned argument. However, in our view, this is quite beside the point. We are not authorised to rewrite the relevant subclauses. 245Even if the Interpretation of Legislation Act 1984 (Vic) applies to the interpretation of the NER (and we think that it does not), we do not accept that s 27 of that Act is of any assistance to the AER in the circumstances of the present case. As UED has pointed out in its Reply Submissions, the power to amend the ESCV S Factor Scheme is constrained very substantially by the terms of cl 2.3.9(i) of the last ESCV price determination. Neither the ESCV nor the AER had a general right to vary the implementation mechanisms. The closeout methodology is not, in any event, an amendment of the ESCV S Factor Scheme. It is an engrafted methodology designed to mimic the effects of that scheme while, at the same time, bringing it to an end. 246Similarly, we do not think that s 28(2) of the Interpretation of Legislation Act 1984 (Vic) is of any assistance to the AER and the Minister. Subsection (2)(e) and subs (2)(f) of s 28 are relied upon in support of the proposition that both the rewards and penalties that would have been imposed in the 2011–2015 regulatory control period had the scheme continued into that period should, in effect, be preserved. But, the scheme expired on 31 December 2010. At that time, no price adjustments in respect of the 2011-2015 regulatory control period had been made or had accrued. The most that can be said is that the financial impacts of the scheme were notionally or contingently in place, subject to the scheme continuing beyond 31 December 2010 (which, of course, did not happen). Section 28(2) does not assist. Conclusion247For these reasons, the Tribunal is of the opinion that the AER did not have power to include within its final decision the methodology and consequential decision directed to the closing out of the ESCV S Factor Scheme. The year-by-year penalty sought to be imposed on UED by the AER’s adoption of its close-out methodology cannot be imposed on UED. We propose to deal with UED’s position now. The consequences of this conclusion on other DNSPs are reserved for further consideration in light of further submissions which we will invite the parties to make.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established