FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Unilever Aust Ltd v George Karounos & Anor [2001] FCA 148
UNILEVER AUSTRALIA LIMITED (ACN 004 050 828) v
GEORGE KAROUNOS AND ANOTHER
NG 732 of 1998
HILL J
20 FEBRUARY 2001
SYDNEY
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
NG 732 OF 1998
BETWEEN:
UNILEVER AUSTRALIA LIMITED (ACN 004 050 828)
APPLICANT/CROSS-RESPONDENTAND:
GEORGE KAROUNOS
SECOND RESPONDENT/SECOND CROSS-CLAIMANTREVELINU PTY LIMITED (ACN 067 545 117)
[in voluntary administration] (previously known as
RFC Nominees Pty Limited)
FIRST CROSS-CLAIMANTSABRE INTERNATIONAL LIMITED
THIRD RESPONDENT/THIRD CROSS-CLAIMANT
JUDGE:
HILL J
DATE:
20 FEBRUARY 2001
PLACE:
SYDNEY
EX TEMPORE REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
On 14 February in this year, I heard an application by Mr Karounos that the date allocated for hearing of proceedings against him be vacated. I declined so to do and advised Mr Karounos that I would on Monday of this week hear the main claim brought by Unilever Australia Limited (“Unilever”) against Sabre International Limited and himself but that I would not deal, largely because of the position of the official manager, with the matter of the cross-claim.
The hearing commenced this morning. The date yesterday was
beingvacated for reasons which had nothing to do with the parties. This morning the case was opened by Mrs Bennett SC for Unilever. Mr Karounos represented himself, as has been the case now for some time. Sabre International Limited had opted not to participate in the proceedings although it had indicated it would make such submissions as were necessary for it to make at the conclusion of evidence.To reiterate something of the history of the matter (some of which, at least, is dealt with in the oral judgment I gave on 14 February 2001) the present proceedings were commenced in July of 1998 by an application brought by Unilever against RFC Nominees Pty Limited (now known as Revelinu Pty Limited but herein referred to as “RFC Nominees”). At some stage relatively early in the piece it became clear that RFC Nominees had been struck off the register. An application was subsequently made to the Australian Securities and Investments Commission on an undertaking given, I think by Mr Royle, then solicitor for RFC Nominees, to reinstate the company to the register.
RFC Nominees was after some time reinstated to the register. Fairly soon thereafter it appears to have gone into official management, a state which it still has. On 5 June 2000 Mr Karounos was added as a party. RFC Nominees had been trustee of a trust of which Mr Karounos was the appointor and of which members of his family and/or himself were beneficiaries. At some stage Mr Karounos became trustee of that trust and it is in that capacity that he was joined as second respondent. It is fairly obvious that he was completely aware of all steps taken by RFC Nominees.
The application and cross-claims were listed for hearing before me for four days on and from 12 December 2000. They had…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Unilever Aust Ltd v George Karounos and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] FCA 148
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that the court had to address included whether Unilever had established a prima facie case for trademark infringement against the respondents, and whether there was a valid assignment of the trademarks in question from RFC Nominees to George Karounos. Additionally, the court needed to determine the appropriate course of action regarding the cross-claims and the role of Revelinu Pty Limited, which was in voluntary administration.
The court, presided over by Justice Hill, found that Unilever had demonstrated a prima facie case for trademark infringement against the respondents. The court considered the history of the litigation, which began in 1998, and noted the extensive efforts by Mr. Karounos to delay proceedings and obtain legal aid without success. Justice Hill ruled that further adjournments would cause undue expense and injustice to Unilever. Consequently, the court proceeded to hear arguments from Mr. Karounos on the issue of whether Unilever had a case to answer. The court ultimately decided to continue with the case, allowing Mr. Karounos to present his evidence and arguments without further adjournment.
The final orders of the court allowed the proceedings to continue with the evidence presented by Mr. Karounos and directed that any cross-claims would be addressed at a later stage, pending the outcome of the current case. The court also noted that the matter of costs against Revelinu Pty Limited remained to be decided.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case was initially filed in July 1998, with Unilever Australia Limited as the applicant and RFC Nominees Pty Limited as the respondent. RFC Nominees was later added to the list of parties and later struck off the register. The company was reinstated and went into official management. Mr Karounos was added as a second respondent in June 2000. The case was initially heard in October 2000, but the hearing date was vacated. Unilever subsequently applied to discontinue the proceedings against RFC Nominees, which was granted. The case was rescheduled for February 2001.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the hearing should be adjourned to allow Mr Karounos to obtain legal representation.
2. Whether Unilever has established a case to answer.
3. Whether the application for legal aid by Mr Karounos should be granted.
Held
1. Whether the hearing should be adjourned to allow Mr Karounos to obtain legal representation.
The Court held that the hearing should not be adjourned to allow Mr Karounos to obtain legal representation.
2. Whether Unilever has established a case to answer.
The Court allowed Mr Karounos to make submissions on the issue of whether there is a case to answer, but it did not rule on the merits of this issue.
3. Whether the application for legal aid by Mr Karounos should be granted.
The Court did not grant the application for legal aid to Mr Karounos.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: HILL J
The Court declined to adjourn the hearing to allow Mr Karounos to obtain legal representation because there was no evidence that he would be able to secure legal aid or any other form of legal representation in the future, despite his previous unsuccessful attempts. The Court considered that further adjournments would cause additional expense and injustice to Unilever, and it was unlikely that Mr Karounos would be represented regardless of any adjournment. The Court allowed Mr Karounos to make submissions on whether Unilever had established a case to answer, but it did not rule on the merits of this issue. The Court decided not to adjourn the case further to allow Mr Karounos to potentially organise a defence or cause a lengthy delay. Finally, the Court did not grant the application for legal aid to Mr Karounos, as it did not find any evidence suggesting that he had a real chance of obtaining legal aid. The Court emphasised the importance of case management and the general interests of justice in its decision-making process.