UNDERWOOD v GLACKEN
[2002] SADC 50Judge Allan
Civil
On 27 December 1997, the plaintiff was accidentally shot by the defendant; the bullet striking him in the left knee. As a result, the plaintiff suffered injury and loss for which he seeks damages. The defendant admits liability and the matter comes on for assessment of those damages.
The plaintiff was born on 28 December 1971. He was educated to matriculation standard, leaving school at the end of 1988. Since leaving school, he has worked as a clerk, process worker, landscaper, apprentice motor mechanic and general labourer. He hoped to join the police force, but his application was unsuccessful.
The plaintiff obtained work immediately after finishing school and, except for periods which I will mention later, has been constantly employed ever since.
In March 1996, the plaintiff commenced his own landscaping business. It included paving, irrigation and the construction of walls and lawns. The bulk of the work was paving. He was operating this business at the time of the accident. The business was developing and he took on casual workers as he required assistance. By the time of the accident, he had reached the stage where he was satisfied with the level of business he was doing. In the year ended 30 June 1997, the business made a profit of just over $15,000. There were sales of about $87,000 and expenses of about $72,000.
Prior to the accident, the plaintiff was actively involved in sport. At school, he had played mainly football and cricket, but had participated in any sporting activity that was available. After he left school, his sporting interests, so far as playing was concerned, revolved around football. He played competitively up until the accident. He earnt some money from playing football. In 1995 and 1996, while playing at Murray Bridge, he was paid $200 per game. In 1997, he received no payment for playing.
In the early days of his football career, the plaintiff experienced some pain in his right knee. At the age of 17, he had an arthroscopy performed on it and, later, developed bursitis in it. Shortly before the accident, the bursitis was surgically treated and the plaintiff was recovering from that procedure at the time of the accident. He recovered fully and does not have any lingering disability of that knee. He had some other football injuries, a chipped bone in an ankle and a broken thumb, but recovered from them.
The shooting accident occurred after the plaintiff and others, including the defendant, had returned from a spotlighting expedition near Ardrossan. Immediately after the accident, the plaintiff was taken to the Maitland Hospital where he was examined and received some initial treatment before being taken to the Ashford Hospital in Adelaide. Later, on the day of the accident, the plaintiff was operated on by Dr Krishnan; an orthopaedic surgeon. The bullet had lodged in his knee. It caused a compound intra-articular fracture of the lateral femoral condyle of the femur and there…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Underwood v Glacken No. DCCIV-00-1751 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] SADC 50
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered Underwood's pre-accident life, which included various jobs and active participation in sports, particularly football. Underwood had also started his own landscaping business, which was doing well at the time of the accident. Post-accident, Underwood experienced significant pain and limitations in his knee, affecting his ability to work and participate in sports. The court evaluated the impact of these injuries on Underwood's life, noting the changes in his work capabilities and lifestyle.
Regarding economic losses, the court assessed Underwood's past income loss based on his earnings from his landscaping business, adjusted for potential income from football and periods he might not have worked. For future economic losses, the court considered the likelihood of Underwood's working life being shortened and the possibility of his wife returning to work while he cared for their children. Special damages included agreed costs and the cost of re-training courses. Future medical expenses were estimated based on the likelihood of Underwood needing arthroscopic procedures.
The court awarded Underwood damages for past and future non-economic loss, past and future economic loss, special damages, future medical expenses, and gratuitous services. Interest on past non-economic loss, past economic loss, and past gratuitous services was also included. The total damages were assessed at $192,319.40, with judgment entered in Underwood's favour. The court also noted that counsel would be heard regarding costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi