COPYRIGHT TRIBUNAL OF AUSTRALIA
Phonographic Performance Company of Australia Limited
under section 154(1) of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) [2009] ACopyT 1
Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ss 154, 163, 164, 166, 167
Copyright Tribunal (Procedure) Regulations 1969 (Cth) rr 47, 48Bank of New South Wales v Withers (1981) 35 ALR 21
Re John Dee (Export) Pty Limited (1990) ATPR 41-006
Charlick Trading Pty Ltd v Australian National Railways Commission & Anor (1997) 149 ALR 647
Fuelxpress Ltd v LM Ericsson Pty Ltd (1987) 75 ALR 284
Re Application by Seven Dimensions Pty Ltd (1996) 35 IPR 1REFERENCE BY: PHONOGRAPHIC PERFORMANCE COMPANY OF AUSTRALIA LIMITED (ACN 000 680 704) UNDER SECTION 154(1) OF THE COPYRIGHT ACT 1968 (CTH)
CT 2 of 2007
EMMETT J (PRESIDENT)
29 OCTOBER 2009
SYDNEYCOMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Copyright Act 1968
IN THE COPYRIGHT TRIBUNAL
CT 2 OF 2007
REFERENCE BY:
PHONOGRAPHIC PERFORMANCE COMPANY OF AUSTRALIA LIMITED (ACN 000 680 704) UNDER SECTION 154(1) OF THE COPYRIGHT ACT 1968 (CTH) PRESIDENT:
EMMETT J (PRESIDENT)
DATE OF ORDER:
29 OCTOBER 2009
WHERE MADE:
SYDNEY
THE TRIBUNAL ORDERS THAT:
1.The Applicant pay to Fremantlemedia Australia Pty Ltd and Fremantlemedia Australia Holdings Pty Ltd (together, the Addressees) issued by the Tribunal on 18 November 2008 at the request of the Applicant (Summonses) their reasonable costs reasonably incurred (which may be more than party/party costs but less than solicitor/client costs) in complying with the Summonses, including (without limitation) costs in relation to the following categories of work:
(a)narrowing the categories of documents required by the Summonses;
(b)obtaining advice regarding the Addressees' obligations under the Summonses;
(c)reviewing documents potentially captured by the Summonses for relevance, privilege and confidentiality;
(d)preparing documents for production (including masking privileged documents and marking confidential documents).
2.Failing agreement between the Applicant and any Addressee regarding the amount of costs payable pursuant to order 1 above, the Registrar of the Tribunal or a person specified by the Registrar may settle the amount of the costs to be so paid. In settling the amount of the costs, the Registrar or the person shall allow so much only of the amount as in their opinion is recoverable pursuant to order 1 above.
3.The question of whether, and if so, to what extent, Seven Network Limited, Ten Network Holdings Limited, Nine Network Australia Holdings Pty Limited, WIN Corporation Pty Ltd, Southern Cross Broadcasting (Australia) Pty Limited and Prime Media Group Limited, (the “Summonsed FTA Broadcasters”), should be awarded costs in relation to the Summonses issued to them on 18 and 24 November 2008 be stood over to the occasion when consideration is given to costs of the proceeding generally, whether at or after the final hearing.
4.Pursuant to the Copyright Tribunal (Procedure) Regulations reg. 48, PPCA be exempted from compliance with any requirement of reg. 47 of those regulations to make payment of fees or expenses to the Addressees or the Summonsed FTA Broadcasters in respect of the Summonses.
5.Until further order, access to Confidential Exhibit…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read under section 154(1) of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] ACopyT 1
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were the determination of the costs to be borne by the Applicant in relation to the summonses served on the Addressees and the potential costs to be borne by the Summonsed FTA Broadcasters. The Applicant argued that the Addressees should bear their own costs, while the Addressees contended that the costs should be borne by the Applicant. Regarding the Summonsed FTA Broadcasters, the Tribunal needed to decide whether they should be liable for costs at that stage of the proceedings or if their potential liability should be deferred until the general consideration of costs. The Tribunal had to balance the provisions of section 154(1) of the Copyright Act with the procedural regulations to arrive at a just outcome.
In its reasoning, the Tribunal first considered the costs to be borne by the Addressees, holding that the Applicant was liable for the reasonable costs incurred by the Addressees in complying with the summonses. This decision was based on the Tribunal's understanding that the summonses were issued by the Applicant and, therefore, the Applicant should bear the costs associated with their service. The Tribunal also decided to stand over the question of the Summonsed FTA Broadcasters' potential liability for costs until the general consideration of costs at the conclusion of the proceedings. This decision was based on the Tribunal's view that it was premature to decide on the Summonsed FTA Broadcasters' potential liability for costs before the final outcome of the proceedings. Finally, the Tribunal exempted PPCA from making payments to the Addressees and the Summonsed FTA Broadcasters under the Copyright Tribunal (Procedure) Regulations, considering it appropriate to do so in the circumstances of the case.
In conclusion, the Tribunal ordered the Applicant to pay the Addressees their reasonable costs incurred in complying with the summonses, while deferring the decision on the Summonsed FTA Broadcasters' potential liability for costs until the general consideration of costs at the conclusion of the proceedings. The Tribunal also exempted PPCA from making payments to the Addressees and the Summonsed FTA Broadcasters under the Copyright Tribunal (Procedure) Regulations. Finally, the Tribunal limited access to a confidential exhibit to external solicitors, counsel, and experts for the parties involved in the reference and the addressees of the summonses.
Orders
Orders of the court
THE TRIBUNAL ORDERS THAT:
1. The Applicant pay to Fremantlemedia Australia Pty Ltd and Fremantlemedia Australia Holdings Pty Ltd (together, the Addressees) issued by the Tribunal on 18 November 2008 at the request of the Applicant (Summonses) their reasonable costs reasonably incurred (which may be more than party/party costs but less than solicitor/client costs) in complying with the Summonses, including (without limitation) costs in relation to the following categories of work:
(a) narrowing the categories of documents required by the Summonses;
(b) obtaining advice regarding the Addressees' obligations under the Summonses;
(c) reviewing documents potentially captured by the Summonses for relevance, privilege and confidentiality;
(d) preparing documents for production (including masking privileged documents and marking confidential documents).
2. Failing agreement between the Applicant and any Addressee regarding the amount of costs payable pursuant to order 1 above, the Registrar of the Tribunal or a person specified by the Registrar may settle the amount of the costs to be so paid. In settling the amount of the costs, the Registrar or the person shall allow so much only of the amount as in their opinion is recoverable pursuant to order 1 above.
3. The question of whether, and if so, to what extent, Seven Network Limited, Ten Network Holdings Limited, Nine Network Australia Holdings Pty Limited, WIN Corporation Pty Ltd, Southern Cross Broadcasting (Australia) Pty Limited and Prime Media Group Limited, (the “Summonsed FTA Broadcasters”), should be awarded costs in relation to the Summonses issued to them on 18 and 24 November 2008 be stood over to the occasion when consideration is given to costs of the proceeding generally, whether at or after the final hearing.
4. Pursuant to the Copyright Tribunal (Procedure) Regulations reg. 48, PPCA be exempted from compliance with any requirement of reg. 47 of those regulations to make payment of fees or expenses to the Addressees or the Summonsed FTA Broadcasters in respect of the Summonses.
5. Until further order, access to Confidential Exhibit JIF-1 be limited to external solicitors, counsel and external experts for:
1. the parties to the reference; and
2. the addressees of the summonses issued on 18 and 24 November 2008.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi