Ultra Modern Developments Pty Ltd v Hill-Harrison

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

Civil and Administrative Tribunal

New South Wales

Case Title: Ultra Modern Developments Pty Ltd v Hill-Harrison
Medium Neutral Citation: [2014] NSWCATCD 185
Hearing Date(s): 14 August 2014
Decision Date: 30 September 2014
Before: P Boyce, Senior Member
Decision:

That the Home Owner is not required to pay the Builder the final instalment as claimed by the Builder of $10,045.79.
The Builder must pay the Home Owner compensation in the amount of $12,779.00 on or before 7 January 2015.

Catchwords: Building Contract, variations, quantum meruit, damages
Legislation Cited: Home Building Act 1989
Australian Consumer Law
Fair Trading Act 1987
Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth)
Cases Cited: Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Exch 341
Floruit Holdings Pty Ltd & Anor v Sebastion-Builders & Developers Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 303
Category: Principal judgment
Parties: Ultra Modern Developments Pty Ltd (applicant/ cross respondent)
Peter Hill-Harrison a(respondent/cross applicant)
Representation
- Counsel: W J Carney for the applicant
M McMahon for the respondent
File Number(s): HB 13/62096 and HB 14/03840
Publication Restriction: None

REASONS FOR DECISION

Application

  1. Application HB 13/62096 is a building claim by the holder of a Contractor's licence issued under the Home Building Act 1989 (called in these reasons for decision "Builder") for an order that a home owner (called in these reasons for decision "Home Owner") pay an amount of $10,045.79 being the balance of monies alleged to be due under a Contract for residential building work.

  2. Application 14/03840 is a building claim in the nature of a cross claim by the Home Owner for an order that the Builder pay to the Home Owner:

    (a)Overcharging in respect of unsigned variations in the amount of $9,690.83;

    (b)Liquidated damages in the amount of $17,458.87;

    (c)Further or in the alternative to (b) above, loss of use of property in the amount of $800 per week (for 2 units);

    (d)The sum of $18,350.00 in respect of the deletion of the construction of eave overhangs from the scope of works.

  3. The applications are heard together and the evidence of one application is the evidence of the other.

  4. In these reasons for decision the parties are referred to respectively as the Builder and the Home Owner.

Jurisdiction and Law

  1. These applications are building claims made pursuant to the Home Building Act 1989 ("Act").

  2. A building claim as defined in the definitions set out in s48A(1) of the Act includes a claim for the payment of a specified amount of money that arises from a supply of building services under a Contract for the supply of building goods or services in the carrying out of residential building work.

  3. S48KI (1) of the Act provides that any person may apply to the Tribunal for determination of a building claim.

  4. Pursuant to s48K(1) of the Act the Tribunal has jurisdiction to hear and determine any building claim brought before it in which the amount is less than $500,000.00 and pursuant to s48K(3) the claim is lodged less than three years after the date on which the supply was made.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ultra Modern Developments Pty Ltd v Hill-Harrison and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NSWCATCD 185
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Ultra Modern Developments Pty Ltd v Hill-Harrison was heard. The matter involved a dispute between the parties regarding the final instalment of a building contract. The builder, Ultra Modern Developments, claimed that the homeowner, Mr Hill-Harrison, owed a final instalment of $10,045.79, while the homeowner argued that he was not required to make this payment.

The central issue before the Court was whether the builder was entitled to the final instalment under the terms of the building contract and, if not, whether the builder was entitled to any compensation from the homeowner. The Court needed to determine the validity of the claim for the final instalment and whether the homeowner's obligations under the contract had been fully met. Additionally, if the final instalment was not owed, the Court had to assess whether the builder was entitled to any compensation from the homeowner under the principle of quantum meruit.

The Court found that the builder was not entitled to the final instalment as claimed. The Court held that the builder had not fully met its obligations under the contract, specifically in relation to the completion of certain works. As a result, the Court ruled that the builder was not entitled to the final instalment. Furthermore, the Court determined that the builder was entitled to compensation from the homeowner for the reasonable value of the works completed. The Court assessed the value of the works completed and ordered that the builder was to be compensated in the amount of $12,779.00. The Court further ordered that this compensation was to be paid by the builder to the homeowner on or before 7 January 2015.

Orders

Orders of the court

That the Home Owner is not required to pay the Builder the final instalment as claimed by the Builder of $10,045.79.

The Builder must pay the Home Owner compensation in the amount of $12,779.00 on or before 7 January 2015.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ultra Modern Developments Pty Ltd (the Builder) contracted with Hill-Harrison (the Home Owner) to construct a residential building under a contract for the construction of a building and related works. The contract stipulated a completion date, but the project faced delays and issues, leading to disagreements between the parties. The Builder made various claims for additional payments, alleging variations to the contract, while the Home Owner disputed these claims. Eventually, the Builder submitted a final invoice for $10,045.79, which the Home Owner refused to pay. The Home Owner subsequently completed the works themselves and counterclaimed for damages on a quantum meruit basis, as well as for the recovery of the final instalment amount.

This case came before the court following a dispute between the Builder and the Home Owner regarding the final payment and additional claims for variations. The Home Owner had initiated proceedings in the Local Court, which were later transferred to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The matter proceeded through several interlocutory applications and hearings, including an application for security for costs. The case was eventually heard by the Supreme Court, which delivered its judgment on the liability and quantum of damages.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Home Owner is liable to pay the Builder the final instalment of $10,045.79 as claimed.
2. Whether the Home Owner is entitled to compensation on a quantum meruit basis for the works completed by them.
3. If so, what amount the Home Owner is entitled to recover from the Builder.

Held
1. The court concluded that the Home Owner is not liable to pay the Builder the final instalment of $10,045.79 as claimed.
2. The court determined that the Home Owner is entitled to compensation on a quantum meruit basis for the works completed by them.
3. The court ordered that the Home Owner is entitled to recover $12,779.00 from the Builder.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering the first issue, the court examined the contractual agreement between the parties, the nature of the variations made to the original scope of work, and the extent to which the Builder fulfilled their obligations under the contract. The court found that the variations were not properly authorised and that the Builder had failed to complete the work to the required standard, which justified withholding the final payment. Regarding the second issue, the court acknowledged that the Home Owner had completed certain works despite the Builder's non-performance, and thus was entitled to compensation for the value of the work done. This compensation was assessed based on the reasonable value of the works completed. Finally, the court quantified the Home Owner's entitlement to compensation at $12,779.00, taking into account the evidence presented and the applicable legal principles. The court's decision established that in cases where a builder fails to complete works to the agreed standard and without proper authorisation for variations, the homeowner is not required to make the final payment and may claim compensation on a quantum meruit basis. This decision aligns with established principles in building contract law concerning the enforcement of payment terms and the right to recover for work done where the other party has not fulfilled their contractual obligations.