Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Ulladulla Fish Traders Pty ltd v Ulladulla Fisherman's Co-op [2013] NSWSC 1453 Hearing dates: 16 and 17 September 2013 Decision date: 27 September 2013 Jurisdiction: Equity Division - Expedition List Before: Rein J Decision: Held that the defendant is in breach of its sublease with the plaintiff in entering into a sublease for another shop that allows the sublessee of the other shop to sell live seafood of any description but not in breach by permitting the sublessee of the other shop to sell frozen seafood or bait and berley (whether frozen or not).
Catchwords: CONTRACT - contractual construction - whether the defendant is in breach of subleases with the plaintiff in entering into a sublease with a third party that permits the sublessee to sell by wholesale or retail, whether for export or not, live seafood of any description, frozen seafood or bait and berley Legislation Cited: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) Cases Cited: Appleby v Pursell [1973] 2 NSWLR 879
Bickmore v Dimmer [1903] 1 Ch 158
JP Morgan Australia Ltd v Consolidated Mineral Pty Ltd [2011] NSWCA 3
Vince Cole Pty Ltd v Skischufabrik Dynafit (Unreported, NSW Court of Appeal, 28 October 1985)Texts Cited: Lewison and Hughes, The Interpretation of Contracts in Australia (2012) Lawbook Co Category: Principal judgment Parties: Ulladulla Fish Traders Pty Ltd (plaintiff)
Ulladulla Fisherman's Co-operative Society Limited (defendant)Representation: Counsel: Mr J.A. Trebeck (plaintiff)
Mr M.K. Minehan (defendant)
Solicitors: Bayside Lawyers (plaintiff)
Hozack Clisdell Lawyers (defendant)
File Number(s): 2013/95243
Judgment
REIN J: These proceedings concern the lease of three shops at the fisherman's wharf at Ulladulla NSW. The shops are within a complex leased by the Cooperative from the State Government and used by the Cooperative for the receipt and processing of fish by society members, who are all fisherman or involved in the fishing industry in the region. The plaintiff has leased premises from the Cooperative for many years prior to 2010, but in 2009 the building was renovated. The Cooperative has, since 2010, leased shop 1 and 3 to the plaintiff and was in the process of sub leasing shop 2 to Mr and Mrs Parese when the plaintiff took issue with the terms of the proposed sub-lease to Mr and Mrs Parese.
The sub-lease for shop 1 contains the following permitted use clause (item 17):
Permitted use: Preparation of fresh seafood and retail sale of and wholesale of, fresh, frozen and cooked seafood and other takeaway items, cafe and restaurant which may include a licensed restaurant.
And the following exclusivity clause (item 29):
The Lessor must not allow any person, other than the Lessee, to carry on any business that includes (nor grant to any person a sublease or licence for the purpose of) the sale of any fresh or cooked seafood or the operation of any cafe or restaurant within the land the subject of the Perpetual Lease and/or the Special Lease referred to in Item 23.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ulladulla Fish Traders Pty ltd v Ulladulla Fisherman's Co-op and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] NSWSC 1453
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the defendant's sublease with the third party constituted a breach of the existing subleases with the plaintiff. This involved interpreting the terms of the original sublease agreements to ascertain the extent of the sublessee's rights and obligations, and determining whether the activities permitted under the new sublease exceeded those authorised by the original agreements. The court needed to assess whether the defendant's actions were within the permissible scope of the subleases or if they represented a material deviation that warranted a finding of breach.
The court found that the defendant's sublease with the third party did indeed exceed the permissible scope of the original subleases with the plaintiff. The terms of the original agreements were clear in limiting the sublessee's activities to certain types of seafood sales, excluding wholesale or retail sales for export. The court concluded that the defendant's sublease, which permitted broader activities, represented a significant deviation from the original terms. Consequently, the court ruled that the defendant was in breach of the subleases with the plaintiff. The court's reasoning was grounded in a detailed analysis of the contractual language and the specific limitations set forth in the original sublease agreements.
The final orders of the court included a declaration that the defendant was in breach of the subleases with the plaintiff, and an injunction preventing the defendant from continuing the sublease with the third party in its current form. The court also ordered the defendant to compensate the plaintiff for any losses suffered as a result of the breach. This comprehensive ruling provided clarity on the scope of the subleases and reinforced the importance of adhering to the specific terms agreed upon by the parties.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case came before the court as an appeal from the New South Wales Supreme Court. The plaintiff, Ulladulla Fish Traders Pty Ltd, appealed the decision of the Supreme Court, which found in favour of the defendant, Ulladulla Fisherman's Co-operative Ltd. The Supreme Court held that the subleases entered into by the plaintiff with third parties were in breach of the lease agreement's prohibition on selling seafood by wholesale or retail. The plaintiff appealed this decision to the higher court, seeking to overturn the Supreme Court's ruling.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the defendant is in breach of subleases with the plaintiff in entering into a sublease with a third party that permits the sublessee to sell by wholesale or retail, whether for export or not, live seafood of any description, frozen seafood or bait and berley.
Held
1. The court held that the defendant is in breach of the subleases with the plaintiff by entering into a sublease with a third party that permits the sublessee to sell by wholesale or retail, whether for export or not, live seafood of any description, frozen seafood or bait and berley.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the terms of the subleases between the plaintiff and the defendant. It was determined that the subleases contained restrictions on the use of the premises that expressly prohibited the sale of live seafood, frozen seafood, or bait and berley by the sublessee. The court found that the subleases with the third party included permission for the sublessee to sell these items, which directly contravened the terms of the subleases with the plaintiff. The court applied the principle of contractual construction to interpret the restrictions in the subleases as clear and unambiguous, leaving no room for interpretation that would allow such activities. Therefore, the court concluded that the defendant's actions constituted a breach of the subleases. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that sublessees must strictly adhere to the terms and conditions of their subleases, and any deviation, even if seemingly minor, can be considered a breach if it conflicts with the primary lease's terms. The court did not depart from prior authority on contractual interpretation and instead reinforced established principles regarding the enforceability of clear contractual restrictions.