Ul Haque and Minister for Immigration & Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

[2013] AATA  118

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/0529

Re

Abu Zafor Reza Ul Haque

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member A K Britton

Date 6 March 2013
Place Sydney

Decision Summary

The decision under review is affirmed.

......................[SGD]..................................................

Senior Member A K Britton

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP — Citizenship by conferral — Residence requirement — Ministerial discretion —Whether there was a close and continuing association with Australia — Application of Australian Citizenship Instructions — Decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) ss 21(2), 22, 22(1)(a), 22(1)(c), 22(1A), 22(1B), 22(9), 22A, 22B, 23

CASES

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Singh v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] FCA 685

Re Wolstenholme and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] AATA 315

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Australian Citizenship Instructions as at 1 July 2009

Australian Citizenship Instructions as at 1 January 2013

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member A K Britton

6 March 2013

  1. Mr Ul Haque was born in and is a citizen of Bangladesh. He has been a permanent resident of Australia since 1999. His wife and only child, a daughter, migrated to Australia from Bangladesh in 2004. Both are now Australian citizens. Mr Ul Haque seeks review of the decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration to refuse his application for Australian citizenship. The delegate found that Mr Ul Haque did not satisfy one of the criteria for the grant of Australian citizenship, namely the “residence requirement”, and, in addition decided not to exercise the discretion to count periods Mr Ul Haque spent overseas as periods he was present in Australia (s 22(9) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) (the Citizenship Act)).

  2. The primary issue to be determined is whether the discretion conferred by s 22(9) can and should be exercised. That power can only be exercised if the decision-maker is satisfied that Mr Ul Haque had “a close and continuing association with Australia”.

    THE RESIDENCE REQUIREMENT

  3. A person is eligible for conferral of Australian citizenship if, among other things, they satisfy the general residence requirement (s 22), the special residence requirement (ss 22A or 22B), or the defence service requirement (s 23), at the time the person made the application for citizenship (s 21(2)). There is no argument that Mr Ul Haque did not meet any of these requirements when he lodged his application for citizenship on 30 November 2011.    

  4. By s 22(1) of the Citizenship Act, a person will satisfy the general residence requirement if:

    (a) the person was present in Australia for the period of four years immediately before the day he or she made the application; and

    (b) the person was not present in Australia as an unlawful noncitizen at any time during that four year period; and

    (c) the person was present in Australia as a permanent resident for the period of 12 months immediately before the day he or she made the application.

  5. By s 22(1A),…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ul Haque and Minister for Immigration & Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 118
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Ul Haque and the Minister for Immigration & Citizenship, the court considered whether Mr Haque had a close and continuing association with Australia. This case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, where the primary issue was the interpretation and application of section 22(9)(d) of the Migration Act 1958, which pertains to the discretionary waiver of visa cancellation. Mr Haque, an Australian citizen by descent, was seeking a waiver of visa cancellation on the grounds of his association with Australia, despite spending most of his time overseas. The court had to determine whether Mr Haque's association with Australia was sufficiently close and continuing to warrant a discretionary waiver.

The court examined various factors to assess Mr Haque's association with Australia, including his family connections, business interests, and community involvement. The primary legal issue was whether Mr Haque had maintained a close and continuing association with Australia, as required by the policy instructions, despite his significant overseas commitments. The court considered definitions of "close" and "continuing" from authoritative dictionaries and evaluated the weight of Mr Haque's connections to Australia versus those to other countries, notably Bangladesh and Singapore. The court had to balance the discretionary policy, which suggested that the waiver would usually be exercised for applicants overseas with their Australian citizenship spouse, against the totality of Mr Haque's circumstances.

After a thorough analysis, the court concluded that while Mr Haque had some close and continuing associations with Australia, such as his family and certain business interests, his overall association with Australia was not predominant. The court found that Mr Haque had significant ties to Bangladesh and Singapore, where he spent most of his time, maintained residences, and managed the bulk of his business interests. The court determined that Mr Haque's association with Australia was not exclusive and that his overseas commitments significantly outweighed his Australian connections. Consequently, the court held that Mr Haque did not have a close and continuing association with Australia throughout the relevant period, and his application for a discretionary waiver of visa cancellation was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Ul Haque first arrived in Australia in 1999. Since then, he has had limited involvement in Australian community-based activities or organisations. He has a few friends in Australia, primarily business acquaintances. Mr Haque's Australian-based wife and daughter moved to Australia in 2004, but he has spent little time with them. However, he asserts a close and continuing association with them. Mr Haque has business and property interests in Australia, including involvement in a SEVEN-11 franchise. However, most of his time is spent managing significant foreign business interests and pursuing further overseas business opportunities, particularly in Singapore and Bangladesh. He maintains residences in these countries and they hold the bulk of his assets and income. He also has multiple property investments in various countries, but not predominantly in Australia.

The case of Ul Haque and Minister for Immigration & Citizenship involves a determination regarding whether Mr Ul Haque had a "close and continuing association" with Australia during the relevant period. The matter was assessed based on various factors including Mr Haque's business and property interests, his family connections in Australia, and his association with other countries. The court was tasked with objectively evaluating these factors to determine if the criteria for a close and continuing association were met.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Evidence of active participation in Australian community-based activities or organisations: Mr Ul Haque has had no involvement in Australian community-based activities or organisations since first arriving Australia in 1999. He says he has a few friends in Australia, mainly business acquaintances. DID MR UL HAQUE HAVE A CLOSE AND CONTINUING ASSOCIATION WITH AUSTRALIA THROUGHOUT THE RELEVANT PERIOD? Whether Mr Ul Haque had “a close and continuing association” throughout the relevant period is a question of fact to be objectively assessed having regard to all relevant factors including those listed in the Instructions. The words that make up the phrase “close and continuing association” are ordinary English words and should be given their ordinary meaning in the context in which they appear. The Australian Oxford Dictionary defines “close” as “having a strong or immediate relation or connection”, “continuing” as meaning “to remain in existence or unchanged” and association as “the act or an instance of associating; fellowship or companionship”. The Macquarie Dictionary offers similar definitions, defining “close” as “near, or near together, in space, time, or relation”, “continuing” as “to last or endure” and “association” as “the act of associating … connection or combination”. I accept that notwithstanding the little time Mr Ul Haque has spent with his Australian‑based wife and daughter since they moved to Australia in 2004, his association with each is close and continuing. I also accept that while a small proportion of his total portfolio, Mr Ul Haque’s Australian business and property interests point to a continuing association with Australia. Further I accept that he has had an active involvement in the SEVEN‑11 franchise, particularly when the problems with his brother’s management were exposed. The reason Mr Ul Haque has spent most of the past decade overseas is because of the demands of his significant foreign business interests and the Singapore-based litigation. This is hardly surprising given their scale and apparent complexity. As he readily concedes the great bulk of his time is absorbed in the management of existing overseas interests and pursuing further overseas business opportunities. I accept as argued for Mr Ul Haque that the policy that the discretion “would usually only be exercised if the applicant was overseas with their Australian citizenship spouse” is not, by itself, determinative. I also accept that Mr Ul Haque’s business and property interests are not to be disregarded merely because they represent a fraction of his total business and property interests. Nonetheless the assessment as to whether Mr Ul Haque had a close association with Australia cannot be undertaken in a vacuum and his association with other countries must also be taken into account. This is not to suggest that to satisfy s 22(9)(d) a person’s association with Australia must be exclusive, but rather that the totality of their circumstances must be taken into account. Here Mr Ul Haque has a close and continuing association with both Bangladesh and Singapore: he spends most of his time and maintains residences in these countries and they generate and/or hold the bulk of his assets and income. In addition all but a handful of his 300 plus workforce are employed in these two countries. By comparison, he has a relatively low level of business investment in this country. He has multiple property investments in a number of countries but not predominantly in Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Mr Ul Haque had a close and continuing association with Australia throughout the relevant period.
2. Whether the policy that the discretion "would usually only be exercised if the applicant was overseas with their Australian citizenship spouse" is determinative.
3. Whether Mr Ul Haque’s business and property interests in Australia should be disregarded because they represent a small fraction of his total business and property interests.

Held
1. The court concluded that Mr Ul Haque did have a close and continuing association with Australia throughout the relevant period, despite spending most of his time overseas.
2. The court determined that the policy stating the discretion "would usually only be exercised if the applicant was overseas with their Australian citizenship spouse" is not determinative on its own.
3. The court found that Mr Ul Haque’s business and property interests in Australia should not be disregarded simply because they represent a small fraction of his total business and property interests.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the term "close and continuing association" as being defined by ordinary English meanings, emphasizing its objective assessment based on all relevant factors. The court acknowledged Mr Ul Haque’s close and continuing association with his Australian-based family and his involvement in the SEVEN-11 franchise, despite his limited time spent in Australia. However, the court also noted Mr Ul Haque’s significant associations with Bangladesh and Singapore, where he spends most of his time and maintains residences, and where the bulk of his assets and income are generated. The court highlighted that while Mr Ul Haque's business interests in Australia are not to be disregarded, his overall associations with other countries must be considered. Therefore, the court assessed that Mr Ul Haque's association with Australia, while present, is not exclusive or predominant when compared to his connections with other countries. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that the assessment of a "close and continuing association" with Australia must consider the totality of a person's circumstances, including their associations with other countries.