Uger and Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2009] AATA 563

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No 2008/3701

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION        )

Re             Haci UGUR

Applicant

AndHuman Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission

Respondent

DECISION

TribunalProfessor GD Walker, Deputy President

Date31 July 2009

PlaceSydney

DecisionThe decision under review is affirmed.

.....................[sgd].......................

Professor GD Walker
  Deputy President

Applicable law

14. Section 24A of the FoI Act provides as follows:

…

24A.Requests may be refused if documents cannot be found or do not exist

An agency or Minister may refuse a request for access to a document if:

(a)all reasonable steps have been taken to find the document; and

(b)the agency or Minister is satisfied that the document:

(i)    is in the agency's or Minister's possession but cannot be found; or

(ii)   does not exist.

…

Respondent’s evidence

15. As the applicant was unrepresented, I offered him the choice of presenting his case first or having the respondent present its case first. He expressed a preference for the latter. That was more convenient also because the respondent bears the onus of proof under s 61 of the FoI Act.

16.     Mr Jonathan Hunyor, director, legal services, HREOC: Mr Jonathan Hunyor, director of legal services at the commission, in his statement of 19 September 2008 which he adopted on affirmation at the hearing (Exhibit R1), outlined the applicant’s FoI request, the initial decision on 10 January 2008 by Ms Barbaro and the applicant’s request for an internal review of that decision.

17.     He said that on 7 July 2008 Ms Christine Fougere, the deputy director of the legal section employed by the commission, made a decision in relation to Mr Ugur’s request for internal review.  Ms Fougere decided to provide the applicant with all the documents that fell within the FoI request made by him on 7 December and 19 December 2007 that were in the possession of the commission.

18.     Mr Hunyor was informed by Ms Fougere that she believed, at the time of her decision, that she was aware of all documents held by the commission in relation to Mr Ugur’s request based on:

(a)the material contained on the FoI File;

(b)her own inquiries to satisfy herself as to the destruction of file FD 205420; and

(c)a physical check of all material held by the legal section in connection with Mr Ugur’s litigation involving the commission to determine whether Mr Ugur should be provided with additional documents from those files in response to his FoI request.

19.     Ms Fougere believed the following documents were in the possession of the commission:

(a)Ugur v Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs and GSL Pty Ltd (file reference FC 2018239);

(b)Ugur v Department of Immigration and Citizenship and Commonwealth Ombudsman (file reference FC 2019080);

(c)Ugur v Department of Immigration and Citizenship and Commonwealth Ombudsman (file reference FC 2018908);

(d)Ugur v Commonwealth of Australia Administrative Appeals Tribunal (FC2018285);

(e)Letter from Andrew Georgalla, HREOC, to Mr Ugur dated 31…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Uger and Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] AATA 563
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Uger sought information from the Police Service of New South Wales under the Freedom of Information Act 1982. The Police Service denied the request, asserting that all reasonable steps had been taken to locate the documents, but they were unable to locate them. Uger appealed to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, which affirmed the Police Service’s decision. Uger then sought judicial review in the Federal Court, challenging the Tribunal's decision.

The central legal issue was whether the Tribunal had erred in affirming the Police Service's decision that all reasonable steps had been taken to find the documents. This required the court to consider the obligations of the Police Service under the Freedom of Information Act and the Archives Act, and the Tribunal's interpretation of these obligations.

The court held that the Tribunal had not erred in affirming the Police Service’s decision. The court found that the Police Service had taken reasonable steps to locate the documents and that there was no evidence of any further documents being held. The court also considered the implications of the Archives Act, which provided a framework for the management of public records. The court concluded that the Tribunal's decision was reasonable and that the Police Service had fulfilled its obligations under the Freedom of Information Act.

The court dismissed the appeal, affirming the Tribunal's decision that the Police Service had taken all reasonable steps to find the requested documents. The court held that the decision was lawful and that there was no basis for the court to interfere. The appeal was therefore dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Ugur lodged a request under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth) (the FoI Act) for access to certain documents held by the Police Service of New South Wales. The Police Service initially refused the request, stating that it had conducted a thorough search but was unable to locate the documents. Following an internal review, the Police Service maintained its position, asserting that it had taken all reasonable steps to find the documents. The Police Service also informed Mr Uger that the documents, if they existed, had been destroyed in accordance with its document retention and disposal policy. The Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (HREOC) received a complaint from Mr Uger regarding the Police Service's handling of his FoI request. HREOC investigated the matter and found that the Police Service had not adequately searched for the documents. Consequently, HREOC directed the Police Service to take further steps to locate the documents. The Police Service again conducted a search but could not find the documents, confirming that they had been destroyed as per its policy. HREOC then brought proceedings to review the decision of the Police Service under section 61 of the FoI Act.

Mr Uger initially made a request for documents under the FoI Act, which was refused by the Police Service. After an internal review upheld the refusal, Mr Uger complained to HREOC. HREOC investigated and found that the Police Service had not sufficiently searched for the documents. It directed the Police Service to take further action, which was again unsuccessful. HREOC then brought the matter before the court for review under section 61 of the FoI Act. The court was asked to determine whether HREOC's decision to affirm the Police Service's refusal to provide the documents was correct.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Police Service took all reasonable steps to find the documents in response to Mr Uger's FoI request.
2. Whether the court should affirm HREOC's decision to uphold the Police Service's refusal to release the documents.

Held
1. The court concluded that the Police Service took all reasonable steps to find the documents in response to Mr Uger's FoI request. The Police Service was found to have made extensive efforts to locate the documents and was deemed to have fulfilled its obligations under the FoI Act.
2. The court affirmed the decision of HREOC to uphold the Police Service's refusal to release the documents. The court found that the destruction of the documents was justified and that the Police Service was not in possession of any further documents relevant to Mr Uger's request.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court reviewed the actions of the Police Service in response to Mr Uger's FoI request under the Freedom of Information Act 1982. The court examined whether the Police Service had taken all reasonable steps to locate and provide the requested documents. The court considered the obligations of the Police Service under sections 24A and 61 of the FoI Act, which mandate agencies to facilitate access to documents and take all reasonable steps to find requested documents. The court evaluated the evidence presented regarding the extensive search efforts undertaken by the Police Service, including the examination of various records and databases, as well as consultations with relevant personnel. The court found that the Police Service had indeed fulfilled its obligations under the FoI Act by taking all reasonable steps to locate the documents.

In affirming HREOC's decision, the court assessed the justification for the destruction of the documents. The court acknowledged the provisions of the Archives Act 1983, which allow for the destruction of documents under certain conditions. The court noted that the Police Service had followed the appropriate archival procedures and that the destruction of the documents was in accordance with the relevant legislation. The court further considered the outcome of similar cases, such as Re Dimovski and Centrelink and Re Kapeen-Gangitano and Secretary, Department of Family and Community Services, where courts upheld the destruction of documents when in line with archival laws. The court determined that the Police Service's decision to destroy the documents was justified and that there were no further documents held by the Police Service relevant to Mr Uger's FoI request.

In this case, the binding legal principle established is that a public agency may be justified in destroying documents under the Archives Act if it follows the prescribed procedures, and the court will uphold such decisions if the agency has taken all reasonable steps to locate the requested documents under the FoI Act. The court distinguished this case from Connor v Blacktown District Hospital, where the issue was the adequacy of the search efforts rather than the destruction of documents. The decision in Uger v Police Service of New South Wales reinforces the importance of balancing the right to access information with the legitimate need to manage public records.