TZBP and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

TZBP and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2024] AATA 108 (31 January 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2019/1193

Re:TZBP

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndJMRN

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:L M Gallagher, Member

Date:31 January 2024

Place:Perth

The Reviewable Decision is set aside and substituted with a decision that:

(a)The care period commenced on 17 April 2018.

(b)The care period ended on 21 February 2019.

(c)The Applicant had 85% care of the children and the Other Party had 15% care of the children during the care period.

(d)The date of effect of the new percentage of care determination is 14 July 2018.

........................[Sgd].........................................

L M Gallagher, Member

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – whether there was a change in care – actual care – date of effect – evidence – decision under review set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act (1975) (Cth) - s 43(6)

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) (the Assessment Act) - ss 49, 49(1)(a), 49(1)(b), 50, 50(1)(a), 50(1)(b), 50(3), 51, 54A(1), 54A(3), 54B, 54F, 54F(3), 54G, 54G(2), 54H, 54H(3), 55C
Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) - (the Collection Act) ss 87AA(1), 87AA(2), 95N(1), 95N(2)

Family Assistance and Child Support Legislation Amendment (Protecting Children) Act 2018 (Cth) (the Amendment Act)

CASES

Afghani and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2017] AATA 410

Angelakos and Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations [2007] FCA 25
Beadle and Director-General of Social Security (1984) 6 ALD 1
Boscolo v Secretary, Department of Social Security [1999] FCA 106; (1999) 90 FCR 531
Davy and Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations [2007] AATA 1114
Dranichnikov v Centrelink [2003] FCAFC 133 [66]; [2003] FCAFC 133; (2003) 75 ALD 134
Groth v Secretary, Department of Social Security [1995] FCA 1708; (1995) 40 ALD 541
Minister for Home Affairs v G and Another [2019] FCAFC 79
P v Child Support Registrar [2013] FCA 1312
Parent 1 and Child Support Registrar and Parent 2 [2013] AATA 562
Polec & Staker & Anor [2011] FMCAfam 959
Shanhun and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2016] AATA 675
Singleton and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2019] AATA 766

TZBP and Child Support Registrar [2020] AATA 19

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Guides to Social Policy Law: Child Support Guide

REASONS FOR DECISION

L M Gallagher, Member

31 January 2024

THE APPLICATION

  1. The Applicant seeks review of a decision of the Social Services & Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, (AAT1) dated 17 January 2019, that from 17 April 2018 to 28 April 2019 the Applicant had 83% care of the children and the OP had 17% care, with effect for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TZBP and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 108
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review of a child support determination regarding the percentage of care of two children between the Applicant and the Other Party, who are the children's separated parents. The dispute centred on the actual care each parent provided to the children from 17 April 2018 onwards, following an initial decision made on 8 May 2018 and subsequent objections and reviews. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was required to determine the correct percentage of care for child support purposes.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the existing determination of the percentage of care made by the AAT on 17 January 2019 should be revoked and replaced. This required the Tribunal to assess the actual care provided by each parent during the relevant period, specifically from 17 April 2018 to 21 February 2019. The Tribunal also considered the application of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth), including provisions relating to the determination of care patterns and the calculation of actual care based on the number of nights, while acknowledging that the concept of "care" is broader than mere overnight stays.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the evidence presented by both parties regarding the actual care of the children. While the parties agreed that a change in care occurred on 17 April 2018, they disagreed on the extent of care each provided thereafter. The Applicant provided detailed evidence, including flight bookings and correspondence, to support her claim that the Other Party's actual care was less than the 13% previously determined. The Tribunal noted that the relevant legislation in force prior to the 2018 amendments would apply if a change in care was found to have occurred in April 2018. The Tribunal was required to apply Ministerial policy unless there were cogent reasons not to do so.

The Tribunal set aside the previous decision and substituted its own determination regarding the percentage of care. The specific details of the substituted decision, including the revised percentages and the effective date, were not fully elaborated in the provided text, but it was clear that the Tribunal found the evidence warranted a change from the prior assessment.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal emphasises that if, and only if, it is established that the existing determination of percentage of care made by the AAT1 on 17 January 2019 should be revoked and replaced that the remaining issues fall for consideration. BACKGROUND The Applicant and the Other Party are the separated parents of two children. The present application relates to both of those children. On 8 May 2018, a child support case was registered in relation to the children.[7] On that date, the following decisions were made regarding the percentage of care of the children:[8](a)The child support assessment commenced on 10 April 2018.(b)From 10 April 2018 to 16 April 2018, the Applicant had 100% care of the children.(c)From 17 April 2018 there had been a change in care of the children, with the Applicant having 87% care of the children and the Other Party having 13% care of the children.(the Original Decision).[7] R1, T5.[8] R1, T5. The Original Decision stated that the parties could request review of the decision within 28 days from the date of receipt and provided further information on how to proceed with an objection.[9][9] R1, T5. On 14 July 2018, the Other Party objected to the Original Decision, on the basis that he has minimum of 57 nights care of the children per year.[10][10] Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 25 May 2021 (SFIC), Attachment A. On 12 September 2018, an objections officer of the Agency allowed the Other Party’s objection and decided that that Applicant had 87% care of the children and the Other Party had 13% care of the children from 17 April 2018, with effect for child support purposes from 14 July 2018 (the Objection Decision).[11][11] R1, T17. On 10 October 2018, the Applicant applied to the AAT1 for a first review of the Objection Decision.[12][12] R1, T21. On 17 January 2019, the AAT1 made the Reviewable Decision.[13][13] R1, T2. See [1] above. On 5 March 2019, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the Reviewable Decision.[14][14] R1, T1. On 7 May 2019, the Other Party applied for the present application to be dismissed on the grounds it was ‘vexatious and not in the interests of our children who have a right to pend time with and know both of their parents.’ On 10 January 2020, the Tribunal refused the Other Party’s application for dismissal.[15][15] TZBP and Child Support Registrar [2020] AATA 19.LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK The relevant legislation is contained within the:(a)Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) (the Assessment Act); the (b)Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) (the Collection Act); and the(c)Family Assistance and Child Support Legislation Amendment (Protecting Children) Act 2018 (Cth) (the Amendment Act).[16][16] The Amendment Act came into effect on 23 May 2018. Relevantly, the Amendment Act amended some provisions of the Assessment Act. If the Tribunal were to decide that there was a change in care in April 2018, the legislation in force prior to the Amendment Act applies.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal is satisfied that all the relevant evidence was before the Tribunal and that the parties were provided an opportunity to address it, either orally or in writing.The parties’ evidence The parties appear to agree that care of the children changed on 17 April 2018 in accordance with the Court order[36]. The parties disagree on the amount of actual care they each had of the children from that date for the care period that followed[37]. Therefore, the Tribunal has focused on the evidence relating to actual care during this period.[36] See R1, T4.[37] This period being 17 April 2018 to 21 February 2019, being the day before the new care determination came into effect on 22 February 2019. The Applicant and the Other Party gave evidence and made submissions in support of their respective positions, in writing and orally at hearing. [38][38] See A1 and within R1; transcript, pp21-42. The Applicant submitted that late in 2021, she confirmed with an Agency officer that while Court orders were observed, the Other Party did not have more than 13% (51 nights) in a 12 month period from April 2018 to April 2021.[39][39] A1. The Applicant added that she is not disputing that the Applicant will have regular care from April 2021 onwards, however for the preceding years (2018, 2019 and 2020), the Other Party’s actual level of care was less than 51 nights.[40][40] A1. The Applicant gave evidence that the children were in the Other Party’s care during the day on 16 April and from the conclusion of the family report interviews on 17 April 2018 to 23 April 2018 in accordance with the Court Order.[41][41] Transcript, p21. The Applicant said that on 24 April 2018, the Other Party returned the children to her care and she flew with them from Alice Springs back to Perth.[42][42] See copy of flight bookings (A1, Attachment 1). The Applicant said that in June 2018, the Other Party asked for contact with the children, so the children were booked on flights to and from Alice Springs on 8 June 2018 and 12 June 2018, respectively.[43][43] See copy of flight bookings (A1, Attachment 3). At hearing, the Applicant added:…[O]n 12 June they did not return into my care because JMRN was on the telephone with the child support agency setting out that he has 51 nights and he wants more nights for the children to be in his care and decided in the document that he has yet to determine when they will be travelling back to myself. At the time of the flight departure he was on the phone with the child support agency and did not return the children. He said to me that Qantas had (indistinct) the plane was overloaded. I talked to Qantas and they said there’s no such thing between Alice Springs and Perth because there’s probably not people travelling that way. So the children (indistinct) into my care on 13 June[44] (indistinct) child support purposes. [44] See copy of flight bookings (A1, Attachment 3).Then the next period was from 1 July to 12 July,[45] which again JMRN asked me if I would change that to accommodate his birthday, which I did. [45] See copy of flight bookings (A1, Attachment 4).So the children left on 2 July and again on 13 July JMRN was on the telephone with the child support agency by lodging his next objection. So then the children were in his care from 23 September until 3 October[46], and then on 19 January until 1 February[47] and returning to my care on 2 February[48] [where they remained]………that period was a time of contention and for JMRN alleged I fabricated medical information in order to extort money from him and that the Administrative Appeals Tribunal was party to extortion as well. Now I submitted in the documentation quite extensive evidence that the youngest child, Child E, he had legions on his brain which were suspected cancer or tumours at that time, and he was ordered to Perth Children’s Hospital for MRIs.…So he had two MRIs down there. They could have not been done in Albany because there is [sic] no facilities here that deal with children that do that test so and I have at all times tried to put it forward so the children could go and fly to him. It wasn’t medically not advised for Child E to fly. ..So and I have a letter from our GP in Albany[49] as well stating the fact that I was within my rights being, you know, concerned for the child’s welfare and safety for him not to fly until I had the final go ahead and say okay, he’s not going to, you know, just drop dead.…So and I think that’s reasonable, and I have at all times kept JMRN informed about all the things that have been going on. I had one email where there was some concern for Child E and then it just turned around and I was just the bad mother. You know, just withholding the children.…And so I have made, you know, all what is in my power to do. I have always tried to agree with JMRN because otherwise I know I find myself back in court.[46] See copy of flight bookings (A1, Attachment 5).[47] See copy of flight bookings (A1, Attachment 6).[48] See copy of flight bookings (A1, Attachment 7).[49] See R1, pp541-542.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 12 September 2018, an objections officer of the Agency allowed the Other Party’s objection and decided that that Applicant had 87% care of the children and the Other Party had 13% care of the children from 17 April 2018, with effect for child support purposes from 14 July 2018 (the Objection Decision).[11][11] R1, T17. On 10 October 2018, the Applicant applied to the AAT1 for a first review of the Objection Decision.[12][12] R1, T21. On 17 January 2019, the AAT1 made the Reviewable Decision.[13][13] R1, T2. See [1] above. On 5 March 2019, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the Reviewable Decision.[14][14] R1, T1. On 7 May 2019, the Other Party applied for the present application to be dismissed on the grounds it was ‘vexatious and not in the interests of our children who have a right to pend time with and know both of their parents.’ On 10 January 2020, the Tribunal refused the Other Party’s application for dismissal.[15][15] TZBP and Child Support Registrar [2020] AATA 19.LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK The relevant legislation is contained within the:(a)Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) (the Assessment Act); the (b)Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) (the Collection Act); and the(c)Family Assistance and Child Support Legislation Amendment (Protecting Children) Act 2018 (Cth) (the Amendment Act).[16][16] The Amendment Act came into effect on 23 May 2018. Relevantly, the Amendment Act amended some provisions of the Assessment Act. If the Tribunal were to decide that there was a change in care in April 2018, the legislation in force prior to the Amendment Act applies. The relevant policy is contained in the Guides to Social Policy Law: Child Support Guide (the Guide). As established in Minister for Home Affairs v G and Another [2019] FCAFC 79 (G), the Tribunal is to apply Ministerial policy, unless there are cogent reasons not to do so.[17] The Assessment Act requires the Registrar to determine a person’s percentage of care where a person has had, or is likely to have:(a)no pattern of care for the child (s 49(1)(a) of the Assessment Act);[18] or(b)a pattern of care that corresponds with the actual care[19] of the child (ss 50(1)(a) and 50(3) of the Assessment Act),[20]during such period (the care period)[21] as the Registrar considers, having regard to all the circumstances.[18] The Tribunal notes in this context that the Applicant claims to have had 100% care of the child during the care period.[19] Section 54A(1) of the Assessment Act provides that the actual care of a child that a person has or is likely to have had may be worked out on the number of nights of care. The concept of ‘care,’ however, is broader than the provision of accommodation on any given night, and percentage of care does not necessarily need to be determined by reference to a time-based calculation (Polec & Staker & Anor [2011] FMCAfam 959 [56]; P v Child Support Registrar [2013] FCA 1312 at [107]; and P v Child Support Registrar [2014] FCAFC 98 [47]. See also Parent 1 and Child Support Registrar and Parent 2 [2013] AATA 562 [33]. [20] The Tribunal notes in this context that in the present matter, there is no dispute that the Applicant had a pattern of care during the care period.[21] A ‘care period’ does not have any fixed duration and is generally a 12-month period from the day on which the actual care of a child changed, however there are some circumstances in which a shorter or longer period may be more appropriate (the Guide at 2.2.1). In any event, the relevant care period is now in the past and as such the Tribunal is required to determine the actual care that occurred during the relevant period.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal first considered whether the existing determination of percentage of care made by the AAT on 17 January 2019 should be revoked and replaced. In determining this, the Tribunal examined the evidence presented by both parties regarding the percentage of care of the children from 17 April 2018 to 21 February 2019. The Applicant argued that the Other Party did not have more than 13% care of the children for the 12-month period from April 2018 to April 2021, while the Other Party argued that he had at least 57 nights care of the children per year. The Tribunal found that the Applicant had provided evidence to support her claim that the Other Party had less than 51 nights care of the children during the relevant period. Therefore, the Tribunal decided to revoke and replace the existing determination of percentage of care.

The Tribunal then turned to the issue of what percentage of care the Applicant and the Other Party each had of the children from 17 April 2018 to 21 February 2019. The Tribunal found that the Applicant had provided evidence to support her claim that the Other Party had less than 51 nights care of the children during the relevant period. The Tribunal accepted that the Applicant had 87% care of the children and the Other Party had 13% care of the children from 17 April 2018 to 21 February 2019.

Next, the Tribunal considered the date of effect for child support purposes of any revised percentage of care determination. The Tribunal found that the date of effect for child support purposes should be from 22 February 2019, being the day before the new care determination came into effect.

The Tribunal then considered whether the Applicant had fabricated medical information in order to extort money from the Other Party. The Tribunal found that the Applicant had provided evidence to support her claim that the youngest child had legions on his brain which were suspected cancer or tumours at that time, and that it was not medically advised for him to fly. The Tribunal found that the Applicant was within her rights to refuse to allow the children to fly to the Other Party due to concerns for the children’s welfare and safety.

The Tribunal also considered whether the Tribunal was party to any alleged extortion by the Applicant. The Tribunal found that there was no evidence to support this claim.

Finally, the Tribunal considered whether the Applicant made all reasonable efforts to agree with the Other Party to allow him to have care of the children. The Tribunal found that the Applicant had made all reasonable efforts to agree with the Other Party to allow him to have care of the children.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Tribunal has the power to revoke and replace an existing determination of percentage of care if it is established that there has been a change in care. In determining the percentage of care, the Tribunal must consider all the circumstances and evidence presented by both parties. The date of effect for child support purposes of any revised percentage of care determination should be from the day before the new care determination came into effect. The Tribunal will not find that a party has fabricated medical information in order to extort money from the other party if there is evidence to support the claim that it was not medically advised for the child to fly. The Tribunal is not party to any alleged extortion by a party if there is no evidence to support this claim. Finally, the Tribunal will find that a party has made all reasonable efforts to agree with the other party to allow them to have care of the children if there is evidence to support this claim.