Tytler v Corbett & GSL Custodial Services (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Applications Under Various Acts or Rules)

TYTLER v CORBETT & GSL CUSTODIAL SERVICES (NO 2)

Judgment of The Honourable Justice White

11 April 2006

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - EXTENSION OF TIME FOR APPEAL

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PROCEDURE UNDER RULES OF COURT

Applications to strike out outline of submissions of second respondent, for a "disjoinder" of proceedings in order to have matters heard and determined separately, multiple applications for discovery, and an application for an extension of time to institute an appeal against a decision of the Equal Opportunity Tribunal ("EOT") - where Supreme Court has a discretionary power to extend the time within which an appeal from the EOT may be instituted - consideration of matters relevant to the exercise of the discretion to extend time - discussion of relevant events that occasioned the delay in instituting the appeal.

Held:  application to strike out outline of submissions inappropriate - application for "disjoinder" unwarranted - rules pertaining to discovery in proceedings at first instance and prior to commencement of proceedings have no direct application to appeal proceedings - no basis shown to require discovery where complaint on appeal involves questions of law - applicant not responsible for much of the lapse of time before an institution of appeal - appropriate to grant extension - applications to strike out outline of submissions, for "disjoinder" and for discovery dismissed - application for an extension of time is granted.

Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (SA), s 86, s 87, s 96, s 98; Supreme Court Rules 1987 r 28.05, r 58, r 60, r 95.01, r 95.11, r 96.04, r 102.09, referred to.
Tytler v Corbett [2005] SASC 27; Lovett v Le Gall (1975) 10 SASR 479; Smith v St John Ambulance - SA Inc (Unreported, Supreme Court of South Australia, Matheson J, 10 December 1991); Smith v St John Ambulance Australia - SA Inc (1992) 166 LSJS 231; Sutton v State of South Australia [1998] SASC 6630, considered.

TYTLER v CORBETT & GSL CUSTODIAL SERVICES (NO 2)
[2006] SASC 100

  1. WHITE J: The appellant is seeking to appeal against a decision of the Equal Opportunity Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) delivered on 10 November 2004 dismissing his claims of sexual harassment and victimisation by the first and second respondents respectively. 

  2. The appellant seeks an extension of time in which to institute the appeal.  It should have been instituted no later than 10 December 2004, but in circumstances which I will detail below, it was not instituted until 6 December 2005.  As well as an extension of time, the appellant seeks a number of other orders.  This decision concerns various of his applications.

  3. In this Court, as in the Tribunal, the appellant has been unrepresented.  In addition, at all relevant times, the appellant has been in custody in the Port Lincoln gaol. 

  4. The proceedings in this Court have had a tortuous history.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tytler v Corbett & GSL Custodial Services (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] SASC 100
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Tytler v Corbett & GSL Custodial Services (No 2) involved the appellant, who was an incarcerated individual, appealing against a decision made by the Equal Opportunity Tribunal (EOT). The appellant alleged that he had been subjected to sexual harassment, verbal abuse, threats, and intimidation by the first respondent, who was employed as a catering manager at the Mount Gambier gaol. The appellant also claimed that the second respondent, GSL Custodial Services, was vicariously liable for the actions of the first respondent and had engaged in acts of victimisation. The EOT dismissed the appellant's complaint in its entirety, finding it to be frivolous, vexatious, misconceived, and lacking in substance.

The legal issues in this case primarily revolved around the appellant's right to appeal the decision of the EOT, the applicability of certain procedural rules, and the granting of an extension of time for the appeal. The court had to consider the relevant events that had caused the delay in instituting the appeal and whether the appellant was responsible for the delay. Additionally, the court needed to determine if the appellant was entitled to discovery in the appeal proceedings and if the application to strike out the outline of submissions of the second respondent and the application for disjoinder were appropriate.

The court held that the application to strike out the outline of submissions of the second respondent was inappropriate as it did not meet the necessary criteria. The court also found that the application for disjoinder was unwarranted, as the rules pertaining to discovery in proceedings at first instance and prior to the commencement of proceedings did not directly apply to appeal proceedings. Regarding the discovery, the court noted that the complaint on appeal involved questions of law, and there was no basis shown to require discovery. The court further held that the appellant was not responsible for much of the lapse of time before the institution of the appeal. Considering these factors, the court exercised its discretion and granted the application for an extension of time.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the applications to strike out the outline of submissions, for disjoinder, and for discovery. However, the application for an extension of time was granted, allowing the appellant to proceed with the appeal against the decision of the EOT. This decision recognises the difficulties faced by the appellant as an unrepresented and incarcerated litigant while also considering the responsibility for the delay in instituting the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The proceedings in this Court have had a tortuous history. Some of that has resulted from actions taken by the appellant. Some of it has resulted from actions for which the appellant is not responsible and over which he had no control. It is going to be necessary for some of that tortuous history to be recounted in this judgment in order that the applications made by the appellant, and the lapse of time, may be understood. Appropriate allowance has to be made for the difficulties experienced by the appellant as an unrepresented and incarcerated litigant in attending, in a timely way, to all matters associated with the institution and prosecution of the appeal. At the same time, it is to be remembered that the appellant has evidently had an education which many unrepresented litigants have lacked. The appellant describes himself as having the Degree of Bachelor of Education, and Bachelor of Social Work and, in addition, as holding a Diploma of Teaching.Background Circumstances The sexual harassment alleged by the appellant was said to have occurred in the period between October 2002 and July 2003 when the appellant was in custody in Mount Gambier gaol. During that time, the first respondent was employed as a catering manager at the gaol by the second respondent (“GSL”). GSL managed the gaol pursuant to a contract with the South Australian government. The appellant worked in the gaol kitchen and had come into contact with the first respondent. As to the complaint of sexual harassment by the first respondent, it is sufficient, for the purposes of this decision, to say that the appellant alleges that the first respondent had, whilst carrying out her duties as catering manager in the Mount Gambier gaol over a period of approximately nine months, made lewd comments and engaged in sexually provocative behaviour towards him, all of which was unwanted, resented and resisted by him. The appellant alleged a contravention by the first respondent of ss 87(2), 87(6)(b), and 87(8) of the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (“EOA”). The first respondent denied each of the appellant’s allegations and alleged that she had been harassed and threatened by the appellant whilst carrying out her daily duties, and that the harassment and threats had caused stress and anxiety which resulted in her resigning her employment with GSL. The appellant alleged that GSL (as the employer of the first respondent) was vicariously liable for her conduct or, in the alternative that it had, by her conduct, subjected him, as its employee, to sexual harassment in contravention of s 87(1) of the EOA. In addition, the appellant alleged that GSL had engaged in acts of victimisation, contravening s 86 of the EOA. The victimisation was said to have consisted of GSL treating him unfavourably on account of his assertion of a right to complain about the alleged sexual harassment by the first respondent; in GSL having failed itself to investigate his complaint about the conduct of the first respondent; in his having been refused permission to make a telephone call to the Commissioner of Equal Opportunity so as to lodge a harassment complaint; and because correspondence written by him had been taken by the Department for Correctional Services officers at Yatala Labour Prison and not returned to him.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The second respondent denied wholly the allegations of the appellant. By its answer filed in the Tribunal, it alleged that in about September 2003 it had received a complaint from the first respondent that the appellant was “stalking” her and that on 2 October 2003, it had received other evidence indicating that the appellant had developed an “unhealthy interest” in the first respondent. It was decided then that the appellant should be transferred to the Port Lincoln prison. After being told that decision, the appellant made allegations that he had been the victim of sexual harassment, verbal abuse, threats and intimidation at the hands of the first respondent.The Decision of the Tribunal By s 96(2) of the EOA, the Tribunal is empowered to make, at any stage of the proceedings before it, an order dismissing the proceedings. On 13 July 2004, GSL applied for an order dismissing the whole of the appellant’s proceedings before the Tribunal on the grounds that they were “frivolous, vexatious, misconceived and lacking in substance”. The Tribunal upheld that application, holding that the appellant’s complaints were trivial and lacking in substance. Although it considered that there is some doubt as to whether prisoners are entitled to the benefit of the provisions in the EOA, it did not decide that question. The Tribunal held that none of the appellant’s complaints against the first respondent alleged conduct to which s 87 of the EOA referred. In relation to the complaints against GSL, the Tribunal held that none alleged conduct to which s 86 of the EOA referred and, even if that conclusion was wrong, that the complaints were trivial and lacking in substance. Hence the appellant’s complaint was dismissed in its entirety. It is from that decision that the appellant wishes to appeal.Initial Steps in the Institution of the Appeal By s 98(1)(b) of the EOA, the appellant had a right of appeal to this Court from the decision of the Tribunal. Section 98(2) provides that such an appeal “must be instituted within one month” of the making of the decision or order appealed against. The Tribunal decision was delivered on 10 November 2004. The Tribunal subsequently dealt with the issues of costs and delivered its decision on those issues on 10 December 2004. There are no rules of this Court which provide specifically for appeals from the Tribunal. But as the Tribunal was presided over by a judge of the District Court, SCR 96.04 is applicable. That rule provides:Where any Act:(a) vests jurisdiction in a Tribunal over which a Judge of the District Court presides; and(b) provides a right of appeal from a decision of that Tribunal to the Supreme Court; and(c) does not specify whether the right of appeal is to the Full Court or to a single Judge,the appeal shall be to the Full Court unless a Judge, on an application made within seven days of the filing and service of the notice of appeal by any party to the appeal, decides that the subject matter of the appeal is of such a nature as not to warrant the attention of the Full Court in which case the appeal shall be heard and determined by a single Judge.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.