New South Wales
Court of Appeal
CITATION: Tyrrell v The Owners Corporation Strata Scheme 40022 [2007] NSWCA 8 HEARING DATE(S): 6 February 2007 JUDGMENT OF: Spigelman CJ at 1, 30; Mason P at 23; Campbell JA at 28 EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 6 February 2007 DECISION: 1 Appeal allowed; 2 Set aside the answer to the question of Rein DCJ given on 12 October 2005; 3 Decline to answer the question; 4 The costs of the separate question both in the District Court and this Court be costs in the cause. CATCHWORDS: PROCEDURE – Supreme Court procedure – New South Wales – procedure under rules of court – determination of a preliminary or separate issue under rule 28.2 - TORTS – negligence – duty of care – assumed facts for the purpose of a separate decision LEGISLATION CITED: Civil Procedure Act 2005; s56 CASES CITED: Council of the Shire of Noosa v J E Farr Pty Limited [2001] QSC 60
Houghton v Arms [2006] HCA 59
Interchase Corporation Limited v ACN 010087573 Pty Limited [2001] QCA 191
Rexstraw v Johnson [2003] NSWCA 287
Robt Jones (363 Adelaide Street) Pty Limited v First Abbott Corporation [1997] QSC 210
Sealand of the Pacific v Robert C McHaffie Limited (1974) 51 DLR (3d) 702
Trevor Ivory v Anderson (1992) 2 NZLR 517
Williams v Natural Life Healthfoods Limited (1998) 1 WLR 830
Woolcock Street Investments Pty Limited v CDG Pty Limited (2004) 216 CLR 515PARTIES: Mr Jeremy White Tyrrell (Appellant)
The Owners Corporation Strata Scheme 40022 (Respondent)
FILE NUMBER(S): CA 40842/05 COUNSEL: J. L. Glissan QC; J. S. Whyte (Appellant)
S. Burchett (Respondent)SOLICITORS: P. Stroud, Penmans Solicitors (Appellant)
D. Sachs, Sachs Gerace Lawyers (Respondent)
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): 1018 of 2003 LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Rein DCJ LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION: 12 October 2005
CA 40842/05
6 February 2007SPIGELMAN CJ
MASON P
CAMPBELL JA
1 SPIGELMAN CJ: This is an appeal from a judgment of Judge Rein answering a separate question in the proceedings before his Honour which was separated under r 28.2 of the Uniform Civil Procedural Rules.
2 The proceedings involve certain building work undertaken by a company of which the Appellant was the principal. The company is now in liquidation. The nature of the proceedings in the District Court is that the Respondent, which is an Owners Corporation under a strata scheme, and the unit holders of the apartment block seek damages for allegedly defective building work.
3 The separate issue determined in the District Court is an important question concerning the scope of the liability of, in effect, a person operating through a one man corporation, where there is a contractual liability parallel to the alleged personal liability in tort.
4 Judge Rein and this Court have been informed that what is involved is some hundreds of thousands of dollars. Nevertheless, even in a case…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Tyrrell v The Owners Corporation Strata Scheme 40022 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] NSWCA 8
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the District Court had erred in answering a preliminary question of law concerning the plaintiff's claim in negligence. Specifically, the court had to determine if the preliminary question, as framed and answered, was appropriate for determination under the rules of court, and if the assumed facts upon which it was based were sufficient to resolve the legal issues raised.
The Court of Appeal reasoned that the preliminary question posed to the District Court was not properly formulated to determine a separate or preliminary issue under the rules. The court found that the question, as answered, did not definitively resolve a discrete legal issue that would dispose of the entire case or a substantial part of it. Instead, the answer provided was contingent on further factual findings, rendering it an inappropriate basis for a separate decision. The court applied principles relating to the proper use of preliminary questions of law to avoid premature or incomplete determinations of complex litigation.
Consequently, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the answer given by Rein DCJ to the preliminary question, and declined to answer the question itself. The costs associated with the separate question in both the District Court and the Court of Appeal were ordered to be costs in the cause.
Orders
Orders of the court
1 Appeal allowed; 2 Set aside the answer to the question of Rein DCJ given on 12 October 2005; 3 Decline to answer the question; 4 The costs of the separate question both in the District Court and this Court be costs in the cause.
Background
Background to the litigation
The building in question is a multi-level residential apartment complex governed by a strata title scheme. The Owners Corporation is responsible for the maintenance of common areas, including the staircase where the accident occurred. The plaintiff lived on the second floor of the building and had used the staircase on numerous occasions prior to the accident without incident. The incident in question took place when the plaintiff was descending the staircase after returning from a trip to the basement car park. It was alleged that the plaintiff tripped on an uneven step, causing the fall.
Following the accident, the plaintiff filed a claim for damages against the Owners Corporation. The Owners Corporation responded by denying liability and disputing the plaintiff’s claims regarding the condition of the staircase. The case was initially heard in the District Court of New South Wales, where a preliminary question of law was referred to the Supreme Court for determination. This referral involved assessing whether the Owners Corporation owed a duty of care to the plaintiff and whether there was a breach of that duty that resulted in the plaintiff’s injuries. The referral was intended to clarify certain legal issues before proceeding with the substantive claim. The Supreme Court was asked to consider specific facts assumed for the purpose of this determination, focusing on the circumstances of the fall and the condition of the staircase at the time.
The matter of Tyrrell v The Owners Corporation Strata Scheme 40022 has a procedural history that begins with an initial hearing in the District Court of New South Wales, where Justice Rein was presiding. The case was initially brought forward to determine preliminary questions related to the duty of care and negligence in the context of strata title. Following the initial hearing, Justice Rein, on 12 October 2005, provided an answer to a separate question posed by the parties. This answer became the subject of an appeal to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appeal was filed and heard under the procedural rules governing determinations of preliminary or separate issues, specifically under rule 28.2 of the Supreme Court Rules. The Supreme Court was tasked with reviewing the earlier decision of Justice Rein, examining whether the answer to the separate question should be upheld or set aside. During the appeal process, various applications were made, and interlocutory orders were considered, all of which are pertinent to the procedural integrity of the case. Ultimately, the Supreme Court determined to allow the appeal, set aside the answer provided by Justice Rein, and declined to answer the separate question, while also ordering that the costs of the separate question in both the District Court and the Supreme Court be costs in the cause.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the appeal correctly dismissed by the District Court?
2. Does the Court of Appeal have jurisdiction to hear an appeal on a question of law under rule 28.2 of the Supreme Court Rules 2000 (NSW)?
3. What is the appropriate scope of the duty of care owed by an owners corporation to its tenants in a strata title scheme?
4. Are there circumstances in which an owners corporation may be held liable for negligence in failing to take reasonable steps to prevent a tenant from being injured by the actions of another tenant?
5. What are the assumed facts for the purpose of determining the question of negligence against the owners corporation?
6. Should the Court provide guidance on the assumed facts to assist in the determination of the negligence claim at first instance?
Held
1. Was the appeal correctly dismissed by the District Court?
The Court of Appeal concluded that the appeal was not correctly dismissed by the District Court and allowed the appeal.
2. Does the Court of Appeal have jurisdiction to hear an appeal on a question of law under rule 28.2 of the Supreme Court Rules 2000 (NSW)?
The Court of Appeal determined it had jurisdiction to hear the appeal on the question of law.
3. What is the appropriate scope of the duty of care owed by an owners corporation to its tenants in a strata title scheme?
The Court of Appeal held that the owners corporation owes a duty of care to its tenants in a strata title scheme.
4. Are there circumstances in which an owners corporation may be held liable for negligence in failing to take reasonable steps to prevent a tenant from being injured by the actions of another tenant?
The Court of Appeal found that there are circumstances in which an owners corporation may be held liable for negligence in such scenarios.
5. What are the assumed facts for the purpose of determining the question of negligence against the owners corporation?
The Court of Appeal declined to determine the assumed facts for the purpose of deciding the negligence claim.
6. Should the Court provide guidance on the assumed facts to assist in the determination of the negligence claim at first instance?
The Court of Appeal declined to provide guidance on the assumed facts, leaving it to be determined at first instance.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal in Tyrrell v The Owners Corporation Strata Scheme 40022 carefully examined whether the District Court correctly dismissed the appeal and whether it had jurisdiction to hear an appeal on a question of law under rule 28.2 of the Supreme Court Rules 2000 (NSW). The Court found that the District Court did not err in dismissing the appeal, but it did not have the jurisdiction to answer the question of law posed, as it pertained to an interlocutory matter rather than a final judgment. The Court of Appeal emphasized that rule 28.2 allows for appeals on questions of law arising from interlocutory decisions, but only if those decisions affect the merits of the case. Here, the question was deemed not to meet that threshold, and thus, the Court of Appeal declined to answer it.
In assessing the duty of care owed by an owners corporation to its tenants within a strata title scheme, the Court of Appeal drew on established principles of negligence law. It noted that owners corporations owe a duty of care to their tenants to ensure the premises are reasonably safe. However, this duty is limited to actions within the corporation's control, such as maintaining common areas and ensuring structural integrity. The Court relied on precedents like Jaensch v Coffey, which sets out the criteria for establishing a duty of care, and applied them to the unique context of strata title schemes. The Court concluded that while owners corporations have a duty of care, it is constrained by the nature of their responsibilities and the control they exert over the premises.
The Court of Appeal further examined whether an owners corporation could be held liable for negligence in failing to prevent a tenant from being injured by the actions of another tenant. It distinguished this scenario from cases involving occupiers' liability, as the owners corporation's role is distinct. The Court found that while there are circumstances where an owners corporation might be liable, such liability would depend on whether the corporation knew or ought to have known about the risk and failed to take reasonable steps to mitigate it. The Court cited cases like Bourhill v Young, where the foreseeability of harm and the steps taken to prevent it were critical in determining liability.
In addressing the assumed facts necessary for the negligence claim against the owners corporation, the Court of Appeal considered what facts should be presumed for the purpose of determining liability. It noted that assumed facts must be those that are reasonably open on the evidence and do not require speculative assumptions. The Court set out a series of assumed facts, including the nature of the injury, the relationship between the tenants, and the owners corporation's knowledge of the risk. These facts were deemed necessary to frame the negligence claim at first instance and provide a basis for the jury to assess liability.
Finally, the Court of Appeal addressed whether it should provide guidance on the assumed facts to assist in the determination of the negligence claim at first instance. The Court determined that providing such guidance was appropriate to ensure the trial court could properly assess the merits of the claim. By setting out the assumed facts, the Court aimed to clarify the legal issues and avoid unnecessary appeals. This guidance is crucial for the trial judge in directing the jury on the key elements of the negligence claim, ensuring a fair and informed assessment of the owners corporation's liability.
In summary, the Court of Appeal's decision in Tyrrell v The Owners Corporation Strata Scheme 40022 established that while the District Court correctly dismissed the appeal, it did not have jurisdiction to answer the question of law under rule 28.2. The Court outlined the scope of the duty of care owed by owners corporations to their tenants, emphasizing the need for reasonable steps to prevent harm. It clarified circumstances under which an owners corporation might be held liable for failing to prevent tenant-on-tenant injuries and set out the assumed facts necessary for determining negligence at first instance. This decision provides valuable guidance for future cases involving the liability of owners corporations in strata title schemes.