Tycoon Holdings Pty Ltd v Trencor Jetco Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE and PROCEDURE - motion for leave to amend a statement of claim - adding new claims against corporation outside jurisdiction - other claims modified

CORPORATIONS - CONTRACTS - NEGLIGENCE - whether collateral contracts or tortious duties apply to a body not yet incorporated - pre-incorporation representations actions or statements later accepted or ratified by corporation

PLEADING - whether pleadings disclose cause of action - embarrassing and prolix pleadings - effect of failure to plead damages adequately - permitting pleading when particulars or further amendment sufficient to clarify allegations being made

DAMAGES - entitlement of company to damages incurred pre-incorporation - negligence and contractual measure of damages

Trade Practices Act (Cth) 1974 ss 51A, 52, 53, 82
Fair Trading Act (WA) 1987 ss 4(2), 5
Hire Purchase Act (WA) 1959
Sale of Goods Act (WA) 1895

Hoyts Pty Ltd v Spencer [1919] 27 CLR 133
Hall v Nominal Defendant [1966] 117 CLR 423
Caltex Oil (Australia) Pty Ltd v The Dredge "Willemstad" [1976] 136 CLR 529
Carr v Finance Corporation [1981] 147 CLR 246
San Sebastian Pty Ltd v Minister Administering the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 [1986] 162 CLR 340
T.C. Industrial Plant Pty Ltd v Roberts Queensland Pty Ltd [1963] 37 ALJR 289
Yamaji v Westpac Banking Corporation Ltd (No 2) [1993] 42 FCR 436
Heilbut, Symons & Co v Buckleton [1913] AC 30

TYCOON HOLDINGS PTY LTD & KANGARILLA PTY LTD v TRENCOR JETCO INC & MOLE ENGINEERING PTY LTD

WAG 41 OF 1991

EINFELD J

CANBERRA (heard in Perth)

5 APRIL 1995


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA   )
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY )  No. WAG 41 of 1991
GENERAL DIVISION                   )

Between:       TYCOON HOLDINGS PTY LTD
  First Applicant

KANGARILLA PTY LTD
  Second Applicant

And:       TRENCOR JETCO INC
  First Respondent

MOLE ENGINEERING PTY LTD
  Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

EINFELD J                CANBERRA             5 APRIL 1995

(heard in Perth)

These proceedings arise out of the supply to the first applicant (Tycoon) by the first respondent, a United States corporation, (Jetco) of what is known as a trencher, a large earthmoving machine used for digging drainage channels on agricultural properties.  The second applicant (Kangarilla) was the builder of such channels and became the operator of the trencher which was purchased by Tycoon in Western Australia from Jetco's Australian distributor, the second respondent (Mole).  Tycoon hired the trencher to Kangarilla.  I am indebted to the applicants for the general chronology of the main events giving rise to the proceedings which with minor emendations is attached to these reasons as a schedule.

On 24 April 1991 the applicants commenced proceedings seeking damages from the respondents under the federal Trade Practices Act, three Western Australian Acts -- the Fair Trading Act 1987, the Hire Purchase Act 1959 and the Sale of Goods Act 1895 -- and for breach of contract, negligence and fraud. In the ensuing fifteen months the statement of claim was amended some seven times. There were two major and several minor interlocutory motions and other hearings…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tycoon Holdings Pty Ltd v Trencor Jetco Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] FCA 232
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Tycoon Holdings Pty Ltd v Trencor Jetco Inc concerns a dispute between Tycoon, Kangarilla, Jetco, and Mole regarding the supply and performance of a trencher, a large earthmoving machine. Tycoon and Kangarilla, who later became the operator of the trencher, sought damages from Jetco, a United States corporation, and Mole, Jetco's Australian distributor, for alleged breaches of contract, negligence, and fraud. The legal issues in this case include the validity of collateral contracts or tortious duties against a corporation that was not yet incorporated, the adequacy of the pleadings, and the entitlement of a company to damages incurred before incorporation.

The court, Justice Einfeld, granted the applicants' motion to amend the statement of claim, allowing them to proceed with their proposed amendments. The respondents argued that the proposed amendments did not disclose a reasonable cause of action, and that the pleadings were prolix and embarrassing. However, the court found that the applicants should be given the opportunity to argue their case at trial, and that the pleadings were not so deficient as to warrant refusal of the motion to amend. The court also held that the applicants could assert pre-incorporation acts and statements, and that a company could base the establishment of a duty of care upon statements made pre-incorporation to and by its ultimate principals.

The final orders of the court allowed the applicants to amend the statement of claim in principle in terms of the draft filed on 10 June 1994, with some further amendments as necessary. The respondents were ordered to pay the applicants' costs of the motion unless written submissions for a contrary or alternative order were made within 7 days.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case revolves around the supply of a trencher, a large earthmoving machine, by Jetco, a United States corporation, to Tycoon, an Australian company, through its Australian distributor, Mole. Kangarilla, another Australian company, was the builder of drainage channels and became the operator of the trencher. Tycoon hired the trencher from Kangarilla. The dispute between Tycoon and Kangarilla on one side, and Jetco and Mole on the other, originated from alleged defects in the trencher's design and manufacture, which resulted in the trencher not meeting the required specifications and failing to operate as expected. The plaintiffs, Tycoon and Kangarilla, commenced proceedings seeking damages from the defendants, Jetco and Mole, under various statutes and for breach of contract, negligence, and fraud. The plaintiffs alleged that the trencher was not designed and manufactured to the specifications provided, leading to significant operational issues and financial losses.

The proceedings began on 24 April 1991 when Tycoon and Kangarilla filed a statement of claim against Jetco and Mole. Over the next fifteen months, the statement of claim was amended seven times, with two major and several minor interlocutory motions and hearings occurring during this period. In July 1992, the plaintiffs filed a motion for leave to amend the statement of claim again, which was adjourned and eventually heard in August 1994. The case involved multiple judgments and hearings, including a previous decision by Justice Wilcox on 5 February 1992, which struck out the statutory claims against Jetco but allowed the common law actions to proceed. Justice Lee also made a ruling on 5 June 1992, striking out a subsequent amendment seeking to rely on a collateral contract.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether leave should be granted to amend the statement of claim to add new claims against Jetco, a corporation outside the jurisdiction, and to modify other claims.
2. Whether the proposed amended statement of claim discloses a reasonable cause of action despite the significant delay in filing the motion to amend.
3. Whether the pleadings adequately disclose a cause of action and if they are overly detailed or prolix.
4. Whether collateral contracts or tortious duties apply to a body not yet incorporated.
5. Whether the pleading of damages is adequate and appropriately particularised.
6. Whether pre-incorporation representations, actions, or statements can be later accepted or ratified by a corporation.

Held
1. The court granted leave to the applicants to amend the statement of claim, in principle in terms of the draft filed on 10 June 1994, subject to further amendments as forecast or offered by the applicants themselves during the hearing of the motion and as made necessary or desirable by the reasons for judgment.
2. The proposed amended statement of claim discloses a reasonable cause of action, despite the significant delay in filing the motion to amend.
3. The pleadings, while overly detailed, adequately disclose a cause of action. The court required certain amendments to address technical issues but did not find them sufficient to reject the document in principle.
4. The court allowed the possibility that collateral contracts or tortious duties may apply to a body not yet incorporated, subject to evidence at trial.
5. The pleading of damages was found to be adequately particularised, and the court did not find significant issues with the manner in which damages were pleaded.
6. The court allowed the argument that pre-incorporation representations, actions, or statements can be later accepted or ratified by a corporation, subject to evidence at trial.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the motion for leave to amend the statement of claim, considering several arguments from the respondents. The respondents argued that the proposed amendments disclosed no reasonable cause of action and that the document was overly prolix. However, the court found that the applicants had provided sufficient verified evidence to support their claims and that the detailed pleading, while not ideal, did not establish a case of prolixity to reject the document in principle. The court also considered the argument that pre-incorporation acts or statements cannot be later ratified or accepted by a corporation, but it held that such ratification or acceptance is possible in principle and should be argued at trial. The court allowed the amendments subject to further refinements and corrections necessary to address technical issues and to ensure that the pleadings meet the required standards. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the court may permit amendments to pleadings that adequately disclose a cause of action, even if they are overly detailed, and that pre-incorporation actions and statements can be later accepted or ratified by a corporation.