TWIN CREEK HOLDINGS PTY LTD and BB APPLECROSS PTY LTD

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: COMMERCIAL TENANCIES (COVID-19 RESPONSE) ACT 2020 (WA)

CITATION:   TWIN CREEK HOLDINGS PTY LTD and BB APPLECROSS PTY LTD [2021] WASAT 93

MEMBER:   MS N OWEN-CONWAY, MEMBER

HEARD:   2 DECEMBER 2020, 15 APRIL 2021 AND 7 JULY 2021

DELIVERED          :   7 JULY 2021

FILE NO/S:   CC 1156 of 2020

BETWEEN:   TWIN CREEK HOLDINGS PTY LTD

Applicant

AND

BB APPLECROSS PTY LTD

Respondent


Catchwords:

Small commercial lease - Pandemic response - Restrictions - Related body corporate - Group - Entity - Eligible tenant - Interest claimed - Prohibited action - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Commercial Tenancies (COVID-19 Response) Act 2020 (WA), s 8, s 9, s 16
Commercial Tenancies (COVID-19 Response) Regulations 2020 (WA), Sch 1, cl 2, cl 2(2)
Coronavirus Economic Response Package (Payments and Benefits) Rules 2020 (WA), r 7, r 8
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 9, s 46, s 46(a)(ii), s 50
Emergency Management Act 2005 (WA)
Public Health Act 2016 (WA)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 9, s 13, s 16, s 17

Result:

Partially successful

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : Mr G O'Brien (Director)
Respondent : Mr J Robertson

Solicitors:

Applicant : N/A
Respondent : Williams & Hughes

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Pham and Bao [2021] WASAT 29

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

These reasons, in part, were delivered orally on 15 April 2021.  For the reasons explained below the hearing was reopened and further affidavit evidence was led.  These reasons are, in part based upon the transcript of the orally delivered reasons on 15 April 2021, with corrections to the transcribed reasons, amendments and adjustments to the transcribed reasons for syntax, grammar, formatting necessary for publication and addition of formal citations.  In addition, the list of exhibited documents is also included in these reasons for completeness.

The application

  1. On 14 September 2020, Mr O'Brien, the director of the applicant, applied to the Tribunal, pursuant to s 16 of the Commercial Tenancies (COVID­19 Response) Act 2020 (WA) (Act), for the Tribunal to determine a dispute between the applicant and BB Applecross Pty Ltd, the respondent.  By order dated 17 September 2020, the name of the applicant was amended to Twin Creek Holdings Pty Ltd, being the intended applicant in this proceeding.

The orders sought by the applicant

  1. The applicant seeks an order that the respondent pay to the applicant money that the applicant says is due, owing and payable pursuant to the terms of a lease between the parties.  The applicant claims all monies due, owing and payable pursuant to a lease, as rent for the months of April to December 2020 with no rent relief pursuant to the Act.  The applicant also claims interest, pursuant to the terms of a lease, on unpaid rent, variable outgoings and electricity charges.

  2. The applicant further seeks an order compelling the respondent to 'provide meaningful financial information' in order to determine any rent relief as referred to in the Act, the Code of Conduct…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TWIN CREEK HOLDINGS PTY LTD and BB APPLECROSS PTY LTD and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] WASAT 93
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Twin Creek Holdings Pty Ltd and BB Applecross Pty Ltd were involved in a legal dispute that was determined by a tribunal. The primary issue before the tribunal was whether BB Applecross Pty Ltd was part of a corporate group, as defined by relevant sections of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The applicant argued that BB Applecross Pty Ltd, along with other companies, formed part of a group controlled by BB Online and BB Group. This argument was based on the premise that these entities held significant control over the composition of BB Applecross Pty Ltd’s board and voting rights.

The tribunal was tasked with examining the evidence presented to determine if BB Applecross Pty Ltd met the statutory criteria for being a subsidiary or related body corporate under the Corporations Act. The applicant's argument hinged on a search of the ASIC register, which the tribunal found to be neither accurate nor sufficient to establish the necessary connections. The tribunal found that there was no cogent evidence to support the claim that BB Applecross Pty Ltd was controlled by BB Online and BB Group in the manner prescribed by the Act. Additionally, the tribunal noted that while there were some relationships between the entities, such as short-term loans, these did not constitute the level of control required to establish a corporate group.

The tribunal concluded that there was insufficient evidence to persuade them on the balance of probabilities that BB Applecross Pty Ltd was part of a corporate group as defined. This conclusion was based on the lack of historical evidence of control by BB Online and BB Group over BB Applecross Pty Ltd. The tribunal rejected the applicant's reliance on the search of the ASIC register, finding it inadequate for the purposes of the case. Consequently, the tribunal found in favour of BB Applecross Pty Ltd, affirming that it was not part of a corporate group under the definitions provided in the relevant sections of the Corporations Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 9 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) provides that the phrase 'related body corporate':in relation to a body corporate, means a body corporate that is related to the first-mentioned body by virtue of section 50.Section 50 of the Corporations Act provides, relevantly:Where a body corporate is:…(b)a subsidiary of another body corporate; ……the first-mentioned body and the other body are related to each other. Section 46 of the Corporations Act provides:A body corporate (in this section called the first body) is a subsidiary of another body corporate if, and only if:(a)the other body:(i)controls the composition of the first body's board; or(ii)is in a position to cast, or control the casting of, more than one-half of the maximum number of votes that might be cast at a general meeting of the first body; or(iii)holds more than one-half of the issued share capital of the first body (excluding any part of that issued share capital that carries no right to participate beyond a specified amount in a distribution of either profits or capital); or(b)the first body is a subsidiary of a subsidiary of the other body. There is no evidence before the Tribunal that the respondent is a related body corporate, as that phrase is defined and referred to above by the Code, to the additional 20 companies the applicant refers to in the search relied upon by the applicant, or any of them, or to BB Online or BB Group. In order to be satisfied as submitted by the applicant, the Tribunal would likely require cogent and possibly historical evidence of conduct by BB Group and/or BB Online or other companies within the 20 identified by the applicant to establish control of the respondent in the manner described by s 46(a)(ii) of the Corporations Act. In addition, the Tribunal does not have sufficient evidence to establish that the respondent as a corporate trustee of the Applecross Unit Trust, is in a position to be controlled by BB Online and/or BB Group, albeit that's Messrs Scott Wescombe's respective family trusts, have an interest in the Applecross Unit Trust; BB Group has an interest in the Applecross Unit Trust and Joel and Scott Wescombe are shareholders of the respondent. Mr Renton, who is a shareholder of the respondent, a director of the respondent and has an association with a corporate trustee for his family trust, that has an interest in the Applecross Unit Trust is not, on the evidence, in a position to 'control' any of the companies to which the applicant refers. The search relied on by the applicant is not one of the ASIC register but is said to be based upon the ASIC register. The Tribunal does not accept that the search provided and relied on by the applicant provides accurate or sufficient information for the purposes of ascertaining whether any of the companies referred to therein are 'related bodies corporate' to the respondent in any case. Therefore, there is no cogent evidence before the Tribunal to persuade the Tribunal on the balance of probabilities, that the respondent forms part of a 'group' as defined by cl 2(2) of the Code and s 9, s 46 and s 50 of the Corporations Act, albeit that there are some factors that suggest there is a relationship between BB Online and BB Hillarys Pty Ltd as both of those companies provided short-term loans to the respondent during April, May and June of 2020, as disclosed in Exhibit 4 (a progressive balance sheet). The respondent's witness explained these short-term loans in evidence. This represents the first flaw in the applicant's argument that the respondent is part of a 'group' for the purposes of cl 2(2) of the Code.